>Be Rhineland in 1780s>No central government>No massive armies>No navies>No colonies>No slave plantations>No massive banking networks>Still rich and prosperous
>>18793430>MünsterWhy don't we have a movie on the anabaptist uprising and siege? Shit was so kino!
>>18793430It’s because of Jews
>>18793430Yeaaaaah.Lack of central government massively harmed it (i.e. didn't industrialize like britain). Lack of armies caused napoleon to come in and fuck shit up.And concerning wealth, it was developed (because you don't need colonies for that, contrary to what dirt world copers will say) but it certainly wasn't rich on the level of britain or other colonial powers.
>>18793430Me when I pretend to not know what a second order effect is.>>18793470You faggots have never engaged with the argument you are strawmanning.
>>18793461Why didn't they keep the bones in? It looks lame.
>>18793470Britain using their monstrous central government to destroy the lives of its own people and churn them up in factories is hardly a positive.
>>18793582Memes. You think the poor in agrarian, underdeveloped germany had better lives? They starved and worked themselves to death all the same, just maybe on fresh air, if that's any better.Germany saw a considerable economic boom when it unified, because suddenly trade across all germany was much simpler and legal conditions more similar.
>>18793591My concern is with Britain fueling their rapid industrialisation through the Inclosure Acts and clearances which destroyed traditional communities and left only a few extremely powerful landowners in the country. The dispossessed families had no choice but to accept urban poverty, being provided meager wages and suffering hellish conditions. This was also facilitated by the Colliers and Salters Act which bound Scottish miners to their employers forever. It's practically enslavement.
>>18793591there was a huge emigration of Germans to America seeking a better life
>>18793591Industrialization in the short term worsened the quality of life, only with the reforms of the 1890s did it finally start improving.
>>18793461Seconded. I''ll take take a trilogy on the 30 year war too starring Chris Hemsworth as Adolphus
>>18793603The Enclosure Act is the most talmudic piece of legislation ever written. The 1965 immigratiin act is second.
>>18793582Britain and current conditions is a weird case because it all starts there. Everything. All of it.>>18793812The bizarre and strained reasoning you see in the Talmud is not really seen there. Ngl the most Talmudic legal institution around is probably the U.S supreme court.
>>18793829I agree with you on the entire US jewdicial system, not just the supreme court. But I called the Enclosure Act talmudic because spiritually it poisoned England
>>18793837We are using the meaning of Talmudic in different senses then.
>>18793430I live in that broader region and it is true that those states were relatively rich for their size. The land in general is often rich in ressources as can be attested by the Topographia Ducatus Montani from 1715 (a geographic work meant for the Duke of Berg & Jülich) for example, which states that there were a plethora of waterpowered grinding mills, iron works and hammer works, various deep & pit mines (those aforementioned aspects lay the groundwork for the famous bladesmithing industry of Solingen) and more than enough livestock farming, orchards and fish ponds. But there were also regions that were desperately poor and remained so until the middle of the 19th century, like the Harz region for example (still relatively poor in modern Germany). And >>18793470 is right in the sense that all those various resources were never directed en masse and with an overarching goal. The industrial capacity remained at the level of cottage industries and agriculturally it remained at subsistence. And from the trade on the Rhine only every the riverine cities profited. Lastly the 17th and 18th century also saw a time period where large "foreign" investments were made into this region, as princes from other larger and powerful german states also held titles/land in the Rhineland. The Electorate of Cologne was ruled by bavarian Wittelsbachers, the brandenburger Hohenzollern held three duchies and Duke of Berg & Jülich was also the Elector of the Palatinate - this case is interesting because Elector Johann Wilhelm poured money into the region as he build himself a new residence there because hils old one in Heidelberg got destroyed by the french. Which brings us to the next point: war. Whenever there was a larger war in Europe this region suffered due to its strategic location and the fact that many european nobles either already had holdings there and wanted to conquer land.
>>18793565Bones don't last forever. The collagen has long since decomposed from exposure and the bones were reduced to dust and washed away.
>>18793603>the Inclosure Acts and clearances which destroyed traditional communities and left only a few extremely powerful landowners in the country. The dispossessed families had no choice but to accept urban povertySimilar developments occured in Germany too without any special legalisation besides the rising absolutist state. Already in the early 16th century did the requisition of common land and the cancellation of common usage privleges in favor for the exclusive usage and ownership of the higher nobility reach its boiling boint. The economic issues behind the Franconian Knights Revolt 1523 and the German Peasants War 1524 were specifically about the loss of those old common privileges and usage customs. Additionally in the Rhineland the practice of equal partible inheritance led to multitudes of farms and their associated land plots becoming successively smaller and increasingly unable to support the inhabitants. Thus day labourers, who were employed in the many small cottage industries, became the norm in order to support ones family. And the working conditions weren't great there either - especially the grinders suffer from silicosis due to the airborne abrasions of the grinding stones.
>>18793430were those real borders?
>>18794318Very likely. On a related note: has anybody ever checked any of those vector maps that are featured on Wikipedia?
>>18794520they're traced over older paper maps
you would think lolberts would finally get a clue from these meme states allowed to exist by the great powers, like gulf sheikhdoms, formosa, even the european cuckion right now. but you do need to be that dumb to buy into the lolbert koolaid I suppose.
>>18795520Libertarians are such a non-issue in the political sphere of the western western world. What's their supposed relation to the HRE?
>>18793603Life in the countryside was rarely a Tolkienisque idyll, there's a reason the millions of Ellis Islanders that flooded the US chose to work in factories over retvrning to agrarian tradvtion in the Idaho or Oklahoma countryside
>>18793430
>>18796469
>>18793430Naturally. Read Hoppe. Read von Kuehnelt-Leddihn.
>>18793430>gets conquered an integrated into large central governments on either side of them with their massive armies
>>18793565look at the size of the gaps in that cage, Einstein. The bones would have fallen out lmao >>18793582Britain's central government was actually incredibly "weak" and pretty hands off for the majority of its Industrialized age, they didn't even have a proper police force when France already had one running in the Bourbon dynasty. German petty states were also hilariously despotic, shit like Hessians being used as bargaining goods to be rented out to other states, feudalism still existing, political clergy ruling over peasantry, etc... the fact that fucking PRUSSIA (under Fredrick II) was seen as a beacon of liberty gives you an idea of Elbian German life.
>>18793430Prussia getting a huge part of Westernmost Germany after the Napoleonic Wars was a disgusting shame and appalling
>>18795858Tbf it could be idyllic in the right place, e.g. New Zealand, Midwestern America (once the Native Americans were killed and the risk of getting scalped was nullified), etc...But yeah being a rural peasant in mainland Europe was utter fucking misery, holy shit imagine being Ukrainian or Polish or a Serbian farmer, might as well be born a slave
>>18793470>>18793582>>18797447Britain's government was centralized, but it also granted an exceptional level of liberty to the population, especially after the glorious revolution and as far back as Magna Carta during "merry old England". They could even draw caricatures of the King and not face that sort of punishment.The Netherlands and Italy were the wealthiest places in Europe composed of mercantile cities. The Rhineland of course benefited being along the Rhine close to this trade center where prices were higher. However in these places it was still routine to torture people who had criticized leading political figures.This drove many to England, because a scientist, engineer or inventor trying to put their ideas into practice needs to travel and talk to many people, which would leave them suspected of colluding with this or that enemy of their prince, in England there was little of this. There was a period of paranoia over Catholics, but this had subsided by the 18th century except in Scotland with Bonnie Prince Charles and that whole debacle. After that though lowland Scotland was more peaceful.
>>18793603The enclosure acts are blown wildly out of proportion by Karl Marx (which is how the meme spread into pophistory, even if you didn't draw it from him directly). It is unlikely if Denmark or Portugal or somewhere had done the same that they would enter the industrial revolution before the rest of Europe. If anything serfdom was the default on the continent and when similar practices emerged in England, like the Colliers and Salters Act, it became widely reported despite affecting only a tiny proportion of the population.
>>18797383
>>18797438Well it took until 1797 for that to occur. >>18797447>the fact that fucking PRUSSIA (under Fredrick II) was seen as a beacon of liberty gives you an idea of Elbian German life.Abolishment of serfom on royal domains in 1799. Three decades before most other german states did so. >>18797453The Hohenzollern already held three duchies in the west prior to the Napoleonic Wars.
>>18797924new whiteness map just dropped
>>18797981Preach, the bluer the area on that map is, the less white it is.
>>18797984Today migrants are attracted to the wealthy areas, but it was white people who built those wealthy areas. If your ancestors do not hail from these places then I'm afraid to say you are not actually white though you may appear to be.
>>18797986Who said anything about migrants? The true autochtonous inhabitants of those areas are Jivaro Indians.
>>18795520>w-we can actually c-conquer you anytime!!huge cope, meme states have and will always exist