https://www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/S0092-8674(26)01334-6What's the next mystery to solve?
>>18793431>nooooo>The "Proto-Indo-Anatolian" comes from the CLV cline east of Turkey.>There is no steppe ancestry in Anatolia. >Homeland in the southern Caucasus. Trash. Everything to the trash. Southern arc obliterated once and for all.
>>18793598>>18793431Honestly, what's the surprise? Did anyone really expect otherwise? There was already a clear archaeological, genetic, and uniparental link between early Indo-European (or "Sredni Stog," if you prefer) and Anatolia. Not to mention that the culture and sites like Berezhnovka, Khvalynsk, Remontnoye, among others, have their origins in Ukraine.
>>18793604>>18793598>>18793431>eurocentric slop>TomLol no. CLV is not steppe it’s in the Caucasus. papers refers the EHG elements as “Steppe” not whole “CLV” part in central Anatolians.>MuH Indo-European warriors in Anatolia Genes don't speak linghus nor use pots. This SINGLE low-quality sample is quite irrelevant. It possesses the haplogroup G2a. Its mtDNA is common in the steppe. Do you know what that means??? That the steppe ancestry was mediated by women in both India and Anatolia lol the steppe theory lost lol steppe female was mediated through the ***Caucasus** into Anatolia.
>>18793431Early sredny stog had much I, which means the whg component was probably linguistically important, brutally over.
Our answer?
>>18793611No. See>>18793612you do not expect female mediated ancestry to be considered as conclusive evidence against South of Caucusus hypothesis.
>>18793606There is sredny I in anatolia and high steppe samples form the balkans
>>18793431...duh? You literally have to go through a steppe to reach Europe by land.
>>18793614>high steppe30% sure. Yamnaya majority ancestry is CLV and it still supports the proposed model rather than challenging it. IE languages born south of caucasus. Also, female mediation
>>18793606>>18793612>>18793613>CLV clineBerezhnovka, Khvalynsk, Remontnoye, among others, have their origins in Ukraine. The CLV groups are not majority ancestry "South Caucasus," this does not prove that the language originated in the south.You are changing the discourse. The premise was that there was no steppe ancestry in Anatolia and therefore this would be a flaw in the steppe theory, but this preprint categorically proves that: 1) there is gene flow from the steppe and, regardless of his Y haplogroup 2) he was buried according to the classic funerary customs of the steppe and Sredny Stog, with funerary objects similar to those found in the steppe. The burial customs for this are clearly steppe in origin and and it is different from the customs of farmers in the Caucasus.3)this specific burial style originated in the steppe Eneolithic. Yamnaya got it from late Sredny Stog. 4) I2a-L699 is clearly a steppe lineage, also found among Hittite samples. I2a-L699 also share a subclade with a Yamnaya sample.Alongside that retarded Brazilian, you are undoubtedly one of the most irritating, ignorant, and ideologically motivated posters here.
>>18793631>you are undoubtedly one of the most irritating, ignorant, and ideologically motivated posters here.now the troll is giggling like a little girl after being complimented so much
>>18793631Meanwhile when Oldest Kurgan burials are in South region, not steppe.genetic itself isn't matchable Archeological evidence is 0. This isn't the situation for South ancestry in CLVI can tell Indian R1a L657 isn't seen in most of Steppe MBlA despite large sampling. Then wouldn't accept it, why? These local CHG populations maintained a relatively similar autosomal genetic continuity and branching of local haplogroups since the Mesolithic, also preserving the same local Proto-Indo-European languages in the Neolithic and Bronze Age. this is a sample with little Steppe and with a native paternal haplogroup. Steppe was mediated by retarded women, and Andronovo was not Indo-Iranian, and nobody called themselves Aryan besides Indic and Iranian.
Troll obliterated
>18793637
>>18793637Everything in your post is incorrect and retard. what is this model supposed to prove? The homeland of PIE is in the Ukrainian steppes.
>>18793643>>18793652>>18793635>>18793635Samefagg
>>18793659you lost
p. 48 of David Anthony's 2007 book, The Horse the Wheel and Language:>The millennium or so around 4000 BCE, say 4500 - 3500 BCE, constitutes the latest window within which Pre-Anatolian is likely to have separated.If anyone here is versed in historical linguistics, feel free to chime in.
>>18793431confirms Lazaridis assumption that the Caucasus-Lower-Volga region is the Urheimat of PIE. Not in Europe
>>18793665>not in Europe Are you retard?
>>18793666Thanks for proving my point, I bet you're American. This is too far east for Ukrainian and too far south for Russian. It's outside the "European" borders. Europe then has forest steppe. Besides, if this region is so European then why do all the CLV peoples have ancestry from the South Caucasus?
>>18793666It's the same indian here>>18793637>>18793606
>>18793664The division between pre-Hittite and pre-Luwo-Lydian languages is dated to 3100-2600 BC as far as I know, and Proto-Anatolian was still a single language around 3100 BC. My problem with the 4500 BC dates is that if speakers of Proto-Anatolic were already in Anatolia in 4500 BC, we would observe a much deeper linguistic divergence, right? I theorize that if Cernavoda is in fact pre- or proto-Anatolian, as many speculate, then it is plausible that it remained restricted to southeastern Europe until at least 3200 BC, if not later. I am considering the Balkan route, naturally
>>18793664What is there to chime in about? I don't know how linguistics by itself is supposed to give you a magic year in which a language was spoken. That's been tried before. It's wildly inaccurate. You have to correlate linguistics with archaeology and genetics to keep any estimation sane.Notice how Anthony says 4500 - 3500. 1000 years huh? You may as well say I dunno when anything happened but we have a lot of wiggle room to imagine whatever we want.
>>18793676I am an expert in the analysis of female feet, including Anatolian female feet, and I think I can answer. The question is not so much "when Proto-Anatolian separated from the main Indo-European branch," but rather when its speakers arrived in Anatolia. PIA is a gay semantic game and they probably spent a millennium in southeastern Europe before migrating, or from the Caucasus if the OP's article is helpful.
>4500 BCToo early >3500Too late
>>18793680Thanks for nothing, idiot.>>18793682>>18793676I think I understand your point. But I still believe that the 4500 BC date for the split aligns well with linguistics and some YTMRCAs for the entry of Proto-Anatolian into Anatolia, 4500-4300 BC seems a bit too early? Maybe.
>>18793689>4500-4300 BC seems a bit too early? Maybe.Yes, I think it's too early. This is generally due to the fact that Sredny Stog necessarily needs to be the vector of the "pre-proto-Anatolian" languages. I see that there are still doubts about which route was taken, whether "eastern" or "western," considering that both have their strengths, the first with some genetic support as seen in this new sample and the second with archaeological and funerary support in Marmaria, for example. I presume that the steppe ancestry probably migrated to Anatolia via both routes at different times or in a short period. Yediay et al. may help clarify the issue and show us some additional evidence when the study is finally published.
>>18793431>What's the next mystery to solve?Indo-aryans
>>18793693they went by boat. sredny stog were the first vikings. they stormed the coasts of anatolia with horses on board. anatolians never saw it coming.
>>18793705Sources?
>>18793693early but definitely not impossible
>>18793727a dream