[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: images (1).jpg (23 KB, 504x396)
23 KB JPG
Why is it so hard for Americans to accept the bombing of Hiroshima was actually a war crime? It's so weird, they can accept they genocided native americans or that slavery was fucked up. They can even realise that bombing civilians in the Vietnam war was wrong.
But whenever the morality of bombing two cities with atom bombs, americans will fiercely defend that it was indeed the right choice. Why is that?
>>
>>18793458
What should the Allies have done instead, that wouldn't be considered a war crime, to get Japan to negotiate? Conventional means/blockade/strategic bombing?
>>
>>18793458
Nukes are fake. Americans just dropped atomic waste on civilians and pretended a big bomb did it
>>
>>18793463
Do not remove Stimson's part in the Postdam declaration about keeping the emperor. Wait for the Soviet to attack, since it was the most likely bigger event that led the Japanese to surrender.
>>
Because WW2 is framed as a war between pure good and pure evil, so any action by team good to defeat team evil was the right decision
>>
>>18793458
The kids in Hiroshima were running Unit 731 o algo
>>
>>18793471
It’s not actually that black and white. For example, no one in their right mind thinks that Stalin was a good guy except tankies.
>>
>>18793458
>realise that bombing civilians in the Vietnam war was wrong
Do they? They only regret Vietnam because they lost
>>
the only people who believe that are the most liberal of libs and they DO think hiroshima was wrong as well
nobody cares what they think
>>
>>18793488
You know, there are other people in the world than just Americans.
>>
To nations like the Germans, or the Japanese, or even to some extent the British, war is a means of securing one's national survival through the forceful obtaining of land or resources. It isn't about good or evil, but simply about "us" and "them."
To Americans or Canadians or Australians, who already have more land and resources than they could ever need, war is more akin to a sport that is engaged in from time to time to solidify their own status as the 'righteous' nation. This is why the moral supremacy of the Allied Powers is such an important narrative to these nations, that can never be questioned or scrutinized without blowback.
The reason Americans will offer tepid criticisms of later conflicts, like Vietnam or Iraq, is mostly because they felt humiliated by the outcome of the conflicts in question, and they already lost the moral argument for them. Actually the fact they've been the 'bad guys' in the eyes of the world since 1945 makes it all the more necessary that they defend their actions in WW2. But even the European front of WW2 is now controversial since German-Americans and Italian-Americans bemoan the scorched earth firebombing of their homelands. So really the Pacific front is the only thing Americans have left to be proud of.
>>
>>18793458
Other than being scary and requiring only one bomb, how is this functionally different than firebombing? They’re both massively lethal, they both horribly maim people. They both render an area uninhabitable until cleanup. The firebombing of Tokyo was way worse.
>>
>>18793514
damn
>>
>>18793785
>The firebombing of Tokyo was way worse.
What? Hiroshima's death toll was significantly greater than Tokyo's, by some estimates twice as high if you count long term deaths from cancer
>>
>>18793785
>Tokyo and Hiroshima are the same thing
>Tokyo was way worse
Imagine contradicting your own argument in three sentences
>>
>>18793458
Why is it so hard for people to understand the notion of precedents?

The Japanese established a precedent of massive acts of large-scale and wanton destruction.

Within this context, the Americans were not only justified in nuking Hiroshima, but also in being far more sadistic and cruel in return.
>>
>>18793785
Both are crimes, but the case of Hiroshima is even worse. The death toll was higher, and the means of killing and injury were more inhumane. Perishing in a firestorm—even if it happens in an instant—is an agonizing experience. Yet, having one’s body deformed by radiation is a far crueler fate, like something out of a lovecraft novel.
>>
>>18793873
Japan killed less American civilians than Osama Bin Laden did
>>
>>18793873
Pearl harbor was a legitimate military target btw
>>
>>18793880
That's not how precedents work. Japan conducted the war with extreme savagery. Complaining at the end because you suffered in return 1% of your own cruelty is laughable.

Japan would not even have the right to complain if the US massacred everyone in Okinawa. A nuke is absolutely nothing.
>>
>>18793883
What war? You mean the Chinese civil war, which Japan entered to oppose the Kuomintang gangsters?
>>
>>18793883
Japan killed less American civilians than Osama Bin Laden did
>>
>>18793885
Yes I mean the war in China, also in the Philippines, and the various savage deeds Japan conducted on Allied POWs and nurses.

Japan repeatedly demonstrated their approval of horrifying acts of barbarousness. They relinquished all right to complain or protest about treatment in return and deserved everything they received and far, far worse.

If a disgusting thug starts beating to death your neighbor and you blow his legs off, it's not for anybody to hum and haw and say "Well anon maybe you could have disabled him some other way!"
>>
>>18793887
Japan killed plenty of other civilians with whom the US was allied. They only failed to kill as many American civilians because they simply lacked access to them.

The US is justified in treating Japan more harshly based on the Japanese treatment of the Chinese in the same way that you are justified in using lethal force to defend your friend if someone attacks them.
>>
>>18793890
Japan and its allies did not start the Chinese civil war, nor do Japan and its allies bear responsibility for every alleged war crime that occurred during the Chinese civil war.
Americans know nothing about Asian affairs and we would be grateful if you butted out.
>>
>>18793895
Japan bears responsibility for numerous war crimes that happened throughout China as well as in the Philippines and in other Asian countries, not only to Asian people but also to Western people, and the fact that Asian states are still dissatisfied with Japan's apologies to this day demonstrates that.

>and we would be grateful if you butted out
If you make a thread whining about your suffering, which you wholly deserved and then some, then Americans are naturally invited to respond. You deserved to be nuked and far worse. The Allies would have reached parity with Japan if we had unloaded 1 million Chinese soldiers in occupied Japan to terrorize the people for years.
We didn't do that, though. You're welcome.
>>
>>18793901
When Japan realigns with China, we will remember your words and your threats.
>>
>>18793901
>You deserved to be nuked and far worse.
Why are Americans psychopath when it comes to Japan?
>>
>>18793919
They hate all Asians except South Koreans. They talk the same way to Chinese and Vietnamese
>>
do people think that "war crime" just means "bad stuff in war"?
>>
>>18793861
>death tolls
This gets into some debate about what killed more people. The Tokyo firebombing caused something like a million injuries as well plus rendering about a million homeless. So I’m still in the camp of Tokyo was worse just because the harm to civilians was greater.
>>18793864
They’re functionally the same act. Using a weapon to destroy a city. One city was much larger and more people were harmed. Yet the Tokyo firebombing gets next to no attention, and everyone fixates on the nuclear weapons as if they were somehow special in their brutality outside of their novelty.
>>
>>18793941
Tokyo's death toll was 80,000. Hiroshima's death toll was 160,000
And both resulted in an entire city becoming homeless
>>
>>18793878
Depends. Some metrics had Tokyo quite a bit higher in deaths, injuries, and homelessness. As for radiation versus burns? What makes you think people died of burns quickly? The point is they’re both awful, they’re both functionally the same aside from novelty, but the novel weapon is considered somehow much worse than the same act with a more mundane weapon.
>>
>>18793941
He quoted the Gita bro you don’t get it
>>
>>18793931
It means killing prisoners or purposely targeting civilians, which is what the US did. And it's also why no one was condemned for aerial bombings at Nuremberg or Tokyo. The allies understood it would have made them look bad.
>>
>>18793944
Tokyo may have been upwards of 200,000 initially dead, a million injured, a million homeless. That’s worse than 160,000. Hiroshima was much smaller than Tokyo.
>>
>>18793950
Is your argument that the Allies ceded the moral high ground by resorting to morale bombing like the Axis powers did?
>>
>>18793945
Being burned won't necessarily destroy you psychologically while radiation poisoning will. Those who survived Hiroshima became vegetables
>>
>>18793957
If we’re considering psychological injury here, I’m still going to say Tokyo was worse. Again, radiation sickness is horrific. Radiation burns are disturbing. So are conventional burns. The novelty of one doesn’t make it worse. Yet it’s treated as some unique atrocity when a much larger scale atrocity is just sort of ignored.
>>18793947
That quote is pretty metal though lol
>>
>>18793959
Radiation literally causes psychological deterioration. I don't know why you're denying this.
If you're claiming the 'long term' death toll of Tokyo was 200,000 then I could easily claim the 'long term' death toll of Hiroshima was 400,000. The official death tolls are 80,000 and 160,000 respectively.
Or are you counting all Tokyo citizens who died, not just those who died specifically in the Tokyo firebombing? (which is what this conversation is about)
>>
>>18793968
You’re claiming the highest reasonable estimate of deaths in one bombing, and the lower estimate for the other. Are you trying to say that Hiroshima was a larger city? I know what radiation does to a person. I question if you know what body wide burns means for a person if you think they aren’t similar in the suffering caused. My question is that are the nuclear bombings given so much attention for any reason other than the novelty of the weapons used when compared to other morale bombing attacks? Since so far you haven’t given me a reason why they are beyond the novelty. Burning civilians alive is an atrocity. Why is one mass burning special and another isn’t? Keep in mind, all three of these attacks were done by the United States against Japan, so I am not trying to engage in apologetics about the topic. I just don’t see how they’re special.
>>
>>18793890
So true, the Palestin- I mean the Japanese civilians deserved to be punished because of Hama- I mean the Imperial Japanese Army
>>
File: 1787444431317500.jpg (65 KB, 403x395)
65 KB JPG
>tell somebody that they easily could have dropped the bombs in a deserted area or off the coast
>their brain shuts down
its like they have no comprehension of doing something that doesn't involve killing people
>>
>>18793977
Because nuclear weapons cause mutations that destroy the mind and body while conventional weapons generally only destroy the body.
Conventional weapons can kill you but they cannot damage your genetic code.
>so I am not trying to engage in apologetics about the topic.
Maybe not but it does appear to be your motive to obfuscate a rather simple matter.
>>
>>18793989
>mutations
Radiation sickness typically kills people so afflicted, if slowly, much like conventional burns. Damage to the genetic code is a moot point given we’re talking about a days or weeks long lifespan. If you’re talking about chronic illness though, a lot more people were injured in Tokyo. Which gets back to the point. If I wanted to get into apologetics, I’d be trying to justify morale bombing. I’m not. I just don’t think it’s a good idea to separate razed cities and broiled civilians based on the novelty of the gadget used to incinerate them. Especially since it is often used as a way to make conventional firebombing and the like appear less horrific when it just isn’t.
>>18793988
I still think if the nukes were only about forcing a surrender, they would have dropped one in like Tokyo harbor. Personally I think a big part of the motivation was to warn off the Soviets.
>>
>>18794008
Destroying people on a genetic and psychological level is obviously more horrifying than simple murder, and I do think it's your motive to downplay this despite your pretensions of unbiased neutrality.
>>
>>18793458
No one denies it was a war crime. The claim is just that the Japanese deserved it because they also committed war crimes
>>
>>18794032
>No one denies it was a war crime
Americans constantly do though. Arguing it was actually a good thing because it saved lives or something like that. This is obviously pretty old because that's the justification Stops used in the 60s. But Americans still believe it.
>>
>>18793968
So let's say the nukes didn't cause any radiation damage, would they be better than burning Tokyo and not a war crime?
>>
>>18794016
Genetic level? Anyone so destroyed doesn’t live long, and I’d add that if you’ve ever seen full body burns, you’d consider that the end experience for the victims is quite similar. My question is why are you trying to minimize the firebombing of Tokyo? Since that’s the only logical reason I can come up with for why one mass murder gadget is worse than another.
>>
>>18794046
>let's say nukes weren't nukes
Ok, that's a clever point. I may have no choice but to concede. If nukes weren't nukes, then you're correct, they wouldn't be nukes. All of the math adds up.
>>18794059
>My question is why are you trying to minimize the firebombing of Tokyo
I've been polite up till now but your simpering faux-empathy is getting on my nerves.
It's obviously in your interest to exaggerate firebombing as a crime and downplay nuclear bombing as a crime, since firebombing was something both sides of the war engaged in while nuclear bombing is an atrocity unique to America.
This is why you have lied multiple times to increase the death tolls from firebombing while downplaying and handwaving all of the elements unique to nuclear bombings from genetic damage to psychological decay.
The difference between me and you is I don't pretend to be unbiased. I will honestly state that my contempt for the United States is what guides me to oppose its moral arrogance and narcissistic hypocrisy.
>>
>>18794034
Yeah but they don't actually believe that, it's just professional bullshitting. Hence why they just flip to "the Japs deserved it" as soon as they're given evidence which contradicts the weapons being necessary
>>
>>18794084
>Ok, that's a clever point. I may have no choice but to concede. If nukes weren't nukes, then you're correct, they wouldn't be nukes. All of the math adds up.
You don't have to engage but what makes nukes nukes and so powerful as a weapon is the gigantic explosion, the radiation is a side effect
>>
>>18794089
>Yeah but they don't actually believe that, it's just professional bullshitting.
I dunno. They even have historians who keep using that argument.
>>
>>18793885
America only embargoed Japan AFTER Japan invaded French Indochina, which clearly signalled Japan's intent to invade the American held Philippines

America was supplying Japan with tons of oil and iron and copper and engines and machine tools when it started a full war with China in 1937

Japan also provoked the US multiple times before the embargo, even trying to start a race war in the US before embargo, while US supplied Japan

Japan also attacked US troops in the USS Panay and Standard oil tankers on 12 December 1937 near Nanjing on the Yangtze river and shot down US pilot Robert McCawley Short over Suzhou on 22 February 1932.

This is why Curtiss test pilot Bob Fausel shot down a Japanese Fiat BR.20 on 4 April 1939 over Chongqing, due to previous Japanese provocations

Japan sent Japanese spies to Canada and the US in the 1920s and 1930s who incited Black Nationalists like NOI to race war against white people


Naka Nakane (Satokata Takahashi) was the agent and spy

Japan also planned to support Black Nationalists and Black Supremacists like the cult Nation of Islam (NOI led by Wallace Fard Muhammad and Elijah Muhammad) in a race war against whites in the 1930s, sending spies like Naka Nakane (Satokata Takahashi) to rile up Blacks Americans to violence against whites.

The Japanese Black Dragon Society founded the anti-white Black group Pacific Movement of the Eastern World (PMEW).

Japanese spared Jews and protected them while the Japanese raped and tortured Nazi Germans, Italians and Phalangist Francoist Spanish in the Manila massacre in 1945 at the German club, Bayview hotel and Spanish consulate.

Nazi Germans tried showing their German passports while getting bayoneted to death. Hundreds of European white women including Italian and Spanish women were gang raped at the Bayview hotel.

White supremacists think these are their allies.
>>
>>18794588
>which clearly signalled Japan's intent to invade the American held Philippines
No? Why would the Japanese have cared about the Philippines?
>>
>>18794620
Japan signaled its intent to seize Philippines as early as WW1 asking to buy it from the US and sending ships there

Japanese settlers who were allowed into Mindanao on Abaca plantations in the 1920s were a fifth column.
>>
>>18793458
War crimes don't exist if you win
>>
>>18793458
>why
because nuking the nippers WAS NOT and NEVER WILL BE considered a war crime instead it was a technological advancement that allowed usa to conquer the nutty nippers - doing that with a land invasion would have cost millions of dead usa soldiers which was not acceptable
>tldr
op is a fattie shitskin jamboy poopjeet faggot ass trolling shit go kys thx kek
>>
>>18794780
>doing that with a land invasion would have cost millions of dead usa soldiers which was not acceptable
Oh no. Not the schoolgirls armed with bamboo spears.
No invasion was ever needed. Japan was going to surrender and it's debatable it did so because of the nukes.
>>
>>18793463
...the japs already wanted to negotiate
>>
>>18794828
Negotiate means accept our terms or else. America could easily have given Japan the Versailles treatment but chose not to because the explicitly wanted to kill civilians.
>>
>>18793981
Why didn't the civilians read the leaflets dropped and leave the cities to prevent themselves from being killed?
>>
>>18794084
See, Japan apologized for its many atrocities during the war. It acknowledged that the slaughter of civilians, the massacre of prisoners of war, the twisted medical experiments on innocent people, the use of biological weapons, the use of slavery and so many other things were wrong. That is the core point. Japan acknowledged that they did something morally repugnant. The United States on the other hand has never formally apologized for targeting civilians during its strategic bombing campaign. Not once. It hasn’t even acknowledged the times such bombings were done in retribution rather than for military purposes. Never. So while you’re caterwauling about the doohickey that made some people sick in a different but no less fatal or agonizing way while utterly ignoring the ACTUAL ETHICAL PROBLEM? It would be funny if it weren’t so sad. I never lied once. You point to symptoms of a weapon used against civilians as somehow being special while ignoring the same type of victims because the weapons used to brutalize them weren’t sexy and new. You let your emotional reactions drive a frankly insulting, insufferable, inaccurate, belittling, and dismissive narrative of the thousands killed, the million maimed and injured, the million left homeless because you’re so hyped up on disdain for America that you IGNORE THE ACTUAL PROBLEM! The United States does not acknowledge that what it did was wrong, and you’d rather muddy the waters by trying to invent something special about two crimes out of how many of the same misdeeds because you think it’ll get you some kind of stupid moral high ground. Yet you miss the whole goddamn point. It’s not that you’re unbiased. It’s that you’re myopic.
>>
>>18794915
America targeted military infrastructure. Why didn't the civilians leave the cities when America warned them to? Precision bombing didn't really exist at the time.
>>
>>18793463
>18793514
>>18793785
>18793873
>>18793883
>18793901
>>18794032
>>18794780
>doing that with a land invasion would have cost millions of dead usa soldiers which was not acceptable

Why did the US have to make Japan surrender to begin with? Couldn't the US simply have said "Alright, we're done, have fun Japan" and pulled out?

It's not like Japan is gonna invade California or anything. I don't even think they'd be tempted to strike Hawaii again, isn't the entire reason they attacked Pearl Harbor was because A: They wanted to scare the US off to prevent them from joining the war, and B: They thought the US joining the war was inevitable anyways and they'd at least get a surprise hit in first? If so, then why would Japan goad the US into re-joining it after it would have left the war?

>b-but then that would leave Japan unchecked in East Asia!

Yes, and? There's no US citizens there. Not their business. If you're trying to assert that leaving Japan alone undermines US geopolitical interests and that's why they had to nuke Japan, then that's just admitting it wasn't actually necessary and was done for the sake of US imperialism or at least external influence, not self-defense.
>>
>>18794828
No they wanted to set terms of surrender. We had already offered terms, all they had to do if they cared about their people was accept them.
They did not care about their people so they refused the terms.

Remember WW2 was seen as the third in a series of wars that needed to be stopped. It was not looked at as a singular event at the time. The goal wasnt just to stop japan it was not stop the next war, unconditional surrender was required.

>>18794941
Japan was killing every month more people in mainland china alone, than both nukes killed. And the number was increasing every week.
Also you are retarded, japan was an imperial force, so giving it uncontested room in asia, would long term create a threat to the US. Japans stated goal for WW2 was an empire to rival those of the west.
>>
>>18794915
So would a blockade have killed less people? No ok. An invasion? No ok. Continued fire bombing? No ok. So what was the US supposed to do to keep casualties to a minimum. And you can just count japanese, and these facts hold true, you can ingore US casualties, and the bombs were still the lowest loss of japanese life. But we know you dont actually care about human life.
>>
>>18793458
Have you tried not eating people alive and bayonetting babies?
>>
>>18794941
>There's no US citizens there. Not their business.
Irrelevant. You cannot just murder a guy on a street and walk into a store and be mad he isn't accepting your patronage because he witnessed something "not his business".

Just ingore it was everyone's business what atrocities you commit. There are no isolated incidents in a modern world. (This includes the world of ww2)
>>
>>18794941
>A: They wanted to scare the US off to prevent them from joining the war
Retards deserve getting punished for their retarded actions. You suckered punch a guy you are afraid of naturally they are going to kick your ass
>They thought the US joining the war was inevitable anyways and they'd at least get a surprise hit in first
1. All they had to do was not invade French Indochina. What right did Japan have to illegally invaded French Indochina?
2. Again doubling down on the sucker punch tactic. In order for it to work you hit them to knock them out not to piss them off which Japan failed to do.
>why would Japan goad the US into re-joining it after it would have left the war
By that point the only option was Japans complete capitulation. No compromise. Sorry not sorry shouldn't have picked a fight with someone you couldn't beat.
>>
>>18794949
>Japan was killing every month more people in mainland china alone, than both nukes killed. And the number was increasing every week.

So?

North Korea and Saudi Arabia kill a bunch of their own people all the time. Does that obligate people to invade them?

>>18795106
>Retards deserve getting punished for their retarded actions.

Sure, maybe, but the claim I'm trying to challenge isn't the idea that the US was justified using the nukes, it's the claim that the US had no other choice.
>>
>>18793458
>to accept the bombing of Hiroshima was actually a war crime
the army made extra a movie to explain why it was not a war crime
"a tale of the 2 cities"

https://youtu.be/HoJ1V9lG0xI
>>
>war crime
May I see the code?
>>
>>18793506
Unfortunately
>>
>You might as well appeal against the thunder-storm as against these terrible hardships of war. They are inevitable, and the only way the people of Atlanta can hope once more to live in peace and quiet at home, is to stop the war, which can only be done by admitting that it began in error and is perpetuated in pride. We don't want your negroes, or your horses, or your houses, or your hands, or any thing that you have, but we do want and will have a just obedience to the laws of the United States. That we will have, and, if it involves the destruction of your improvements, we cannot help it. You have heretofore read public sentiment in your newspapers, that live by falsehood and excitement; and the quicker you seek for truth in other quarters, the better.

- W. T. Sherman
>>
>>18794920
>America targeted military infrastructure
They really didn't. The killing of civilians was the purpose. Hence, why Hiroshima wasn't bombed too much before. It was needed for the atomic bomb to have a greater impact.
>>
>>18794951
Really easy actually:
-do not modify the Postdam declaration written by Stimson that would guarantee the safety of the emperor, which happened anyway.
-give it to the Soviet so they can also sign it. Given the soviet invasion had probably more impact on the japanese surrender than the atom bombs, it would have shortened the war by a few weeks.
>>
>>18793458
Because war crimes aren't real in general.
>>
>>18795303
you said probably, and even assuming that, then you accept the nukes did have an effect. And it also had an effect on the soviets.

How exactly was the US to know the soviets would certainly invade, and that Japan would then surrender?
>>
>>18795559
>How exactly was the US to know the soviets would certainly invade
Because they talked about it and even at Postdam, Stalin reaffirmed he was going to do it.
>and that Japan would then surrender?
Because the US had intercepted the communications between Sato and Togo and they knew Japan was trying to use the Soviets to negotiate. How did the US know for certain the Japanese were going to surrender after the atomic bombs? They had no idea and actually planned to use more than two.
>>
>>18793458
Was bombing cities actually a crime at that time?
Like what did international treaties actually say about it
>>
>>18793458
This probably wouldn't be the case if people didn't moralfag about it so much.
>>
>>18793458
Because. War. Crimes. Aren’t. Real.
>>
>>18793923
Fucking how when weebs exist?
>>
>>18793458
>they can accept they genocided native americans or that slavery was fucked up.

None of that is true either.
>>
File: 1716881829058830.png (195 KB, 785x675)
195 KB PNG
>>18793466
yeah!
and maybe the ancient aliens forced us cool americans to do it!
>>
>>18795576
Just ignore how Postdam also decried nothing less than unconditional surrender should be allowed yes?
>>
>>18795164
Key word "their own people". Nobody cares if you do shit within your own borders. Starting an aggressive war over land grabbing and murdering hundreds of thousands of people of a different nation is wrong.
>the claim I'm trying to challenge isn't the idea that the US was justified using the nukes
Yes it was because it made Japan unconditionally surrender to the US
>>
File: 1715198381308226.png (939 KB, 1080x1139)
939 KB PNG
>People ITT don't realize that the chernobyl disaster was a secret attack planned by opposing forces


lol
>>
File: SDJ-026.jpg (67 KB, 345x500)
67 KB JPG
YEEEEHAWWW WE ALL GONNA RIDE THE NUKES TO THE GLORY LAND GOD MADE FOR US
>>
>>18795296
>The killing of civilians was the purpose
You have proof this was a deliberate attack that the bombers were ordered to specifically target civilian infrastructure and civilians? There were also other cities untouched by bombs yet America never bombed them. Kind of strange if they were deliberately wanting to kill civilians.
>>
File: GWqn5RmXsAAXO6H.png (429 KB, 1862x1320)
429 KB PNG
>>18795658
What do you think they meant when they said "there are no civilians in Japan"?
>>
>>18795821
So they were killing enemy combatants. Is killing enemy combatants wrong?
>>
>>18795821
Why did Japan intentionally intertwine military infrastructure with civilian infrastructure? Seems no different than terrorists hiding in a crowd or using human shields
>>
>>18793471
its framed like that because the alternative is
this side hates SATURN worshiping kikes
this side has a crown the loves saturn worshipping kikes
two heads of state argue over occult star gazing jewish tricks
wars ensure between two saturnalian cults. That is literally what happened

each egg in the face case for both parties is related to reading or misreading occult beliefs of the other party. What til fucking figure out how USA got the uranium before the germans
>>
>>18795864
>Why did Japan intentionally intertwine military infrastructure with civilian infrastructure?
It's what happened in every country that took part in that war. According to that logic, the Japanese would have been justified in bombing every american city. They knew it by the way, Lemay admitted he would have been found guilty of war crimes had he lost the war.
>>
>>18795576
Unconditional surrender. I am well aware japan was trying to play mommy daddy games with the soviets after EVERYONE, at potsdam agreed on unconditional. Again the wheel had to be broken.
>>
>>18795949
correct, on both counts.
>>
>>18793463
How about waging a normal war according to the laws
>>
>>18795963
>EVERYONE
The Soviets didn't sign it. Which gave hopes to the Japanese there might be some dissent among the allies. Besides, it was ultimately Byrnes and Truman who went with the radical approach of the "unconditional surrender" when many among their team tried to get something mentioning the fate of the imperial institution.
>>
>>18793458
>realise
How many times are you going to make this thread, leaf?
>>
>>18795994
agreed.
And history proves they agreed. Because they did the thing.
unconditional surrender was not radical, and was widely called for. Hence Potsdam.

Also at the end of the day why is its the US's responsbility to take care of the japanese people? Why dont japanese leadership do that. They can surrender and end the war at any moment they want to. Putting the onus for surrender on the US is absurd.
>>
>>18795592
Probably something after WW2 in UN gibberish but those courts are all rigged for the winners obviously.
Hiroshima and Nagasaki were specifically targeted for transgressions well before WW2 - the banishment of the pilfering Jesuits from those ports by the Samurai who at one point would lop the head off priests on sight. There was also the American paddle wheeler that sailed into Jap waters and pretty much exterminated them with muskets but never forgive, never forget. It wouldn't be surprising if something awful happened there again in the future.
>>
They were fascists so deserved it.
Or does being non-white outweigh someone's fascism?



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.