Explain Limbo and Purgatory to me. What are they supposed to be like?
>>18793769>Explain Limbo and Purgatory to me.Purgatory could be thought of as the realm of "good, but wasn't part of the church". You weren't baptized, you didn't accept Jesus as your lord as savior, or something otherwise prevented you from embracing Christianity, but beyond that you otherwise lived a god-fearing life and displayed all the virtues in your own right. People commonly believe purgatory is a realm for pagans and other people who predate salvation (cavemen for example), but there's a catholic idea where Jesus briefly goes to Hell after he's crucified and retroactively saves everyone who'll accept him. Preventing such an issue. >What are they supposed to be like?More or less like Earth/mortal life, with several exceptions:-You still possess all your physical inputs (touch, hunger, thirst, smell, etc), but you can't die, and there's no reproduction/children, etc. -There's plants, animals, but also non-humans (humanoids supposedly went to purgatory: elves, centaurs, satyrs, dwarves), and demons & angels can come and go as they please. -The mood is dour: people know they're dead, and that they were wrong, and while salvation (as well as damnation) is still possible in purgatory it will take significantly longer and in the mean time you must work and toil. -In Judaism and Mormonism: everyone who was condemned to purgatory is treated as a 2nd class citizen in perpetuity. Particularly, in Judaism, if memory serves; after revelation everyone in purgatory becomes a slave to a Jewish person.
>>18793791What about Limbo? Same thing as Purgatory?
>>18793769>explainlimbo and purgatory are where almost all people go after they die (assuming xnity is the 1 true religion) because humans sin during their mortal lives and must be cleansed before entering heaven the kingdom of goddoes that help?
>>18794794I'm more curious about what Limbo and Purgatory are supposed to actually be like. Like I vaguely recall an episode of The Simpsons in which they end up in Limbo or Purgatory and it's just a white empty room that's "so-so", but other explanations have suggested that Limbo is perhaps indistinguishable from the world of the living.
>>18794719>What about Limbo? Same thing as Purgatory?Functionally, materially, spiritually, essentially the same thing. The canonical justification, and some of the specifics (Limbo is seen as more permanent, purgatory is seen as like a washing machine) differ, but they both fundamentally exist as a processing center/cope for the people who are "good and/or innocent, but not Christian". The differences can be reduced to semantics and "time you'll spend there". I should clarify that while I said there's no "reproduction": infants that die in childhood before they can be baptized are supposed to automatically reside in purgatory/limbo. So that could be thought of as a "functioning" form of reproduction since while sex wouldn't produce offspring, there would no doubt be a steady supply of babies for souls to care for as their own sourced from abortion, miscarriage, etc.
>>18793791Souls in Purgatory are already saved, they can't be sent to hell. They must stay for a predetermined time which gets shortened by God's Grace via prayer
>>18795181>>18795201So are both Limbo and/or Purgatory supposed to be located within the "outermost layer" of Hell, or are they planes of existence entirely separate from Heaven, Earth, and Hell?
>>18795181>>18795201Also where do suicides go? Like where did the wife of Robin Williams in What Dreams May Come go? Do they end up in the same place as murderers, or those guilty of greed, pride, sloth, etc.?
>>18793769The two are often confused but they're very distinct things. Purgatory is where saved souls go to have their vices purged after death to become worthy of heaven. Like in hell, people are punished, but unlike hell it's for the purpose of reforming them, not eternal torment. It's still very unpleasant though, you want to minimize your time in purgatory as much as possible. This can be done by being a better person in this life, having faithful Christians praying for you after death, or, infamously, indulgences. Limbo is a part of hell that doesn't include any torture. It's for people who never really had the chance to be Christian and weren't terrible people, like virtuous pagans. The only downside of being there is just the fact you'll never get into heaven.
>>18796230Do people in Limbo know that they are dead?
>>18795201Sounds like something the church would come up with to sell seats
>>18793791In Mormonism: are Purgatory and Limbo both supposed to be located in the telestial kingdom or terrestrial kingdom?
>>18796284It's not called purgatory in the Gospel but the concept is there.
>>18796302Where?
>>18796067My understanding is that limbo and purgatory are different from each other. Limbo is called Abraham's Bosom in the Gospel and purgatory is called a prison whence you get out after paying your dues (sermon of the Mount). In the letters purgarory is called purifying fire.
>>18796098That's a more complicated answer. Suicide is considered a mortal sin but ultimately it's God's decision. I don't believe all suicides go to hell, nor is it the current Catholic teaching.
>>18796304Sermon of the Mount (the prison), 1 Corinthians 3:15 (the purifying fire) and the blasphemy against the Holy Spirit (the unforgivable sin).
Threads still up.>>18796067Takes vary: some denominations belief they're all completely separate realms, older belief systems believe that purgatory and/or limbo are either the most lenient realm of Hell, or at the very least border it. This "geography" might be a carry over from the pagan belief of how a river separates and segregates the various nether realms from one another. I vaguely remember reading ?somewhere? that Evangelicals believe they'll be able to see/hear people in Hell, which is supposed to "enhance" the experience for them (very telling of their character if true), and Jews are similarly supposed to have "leisurely access" to purgatory/sheol in advance for picking out servants. >>18796098>Also where do suicides go?The popular census seems to be Hell to the extent that even the Near Death Experiencers report this. But like this Anon says: >>18796308 it's not 100% cut and dry either, and there's exceptions and circumstances.>>18796289>In Mormonism: are Purgatory and Limbo both supposed to be located in the telestial kingdom or terrestrial kingdom?I'm not super familiar with all the nuances of Mormonism, but to paraphrase: the afterlives in Mormonism are dictated by ones access, or relationship, to the trinity (the father, the holy spirit, and the son). If you have all three you get into heaven proper, if you have the father and the holy spirit you get into the terrestrial kingdom, and if you only have the holy spirit you're stuck in the telestial kingdom. The terrestrial kingdom is the secondary ?purgatory/limbo? realm of the Mormons: good people, but who otherwise aren't Mormons, get sent here upon death, and live moderate lives and are second-class citizens and servants to Mormons (Mormons are servants to God). The telestial kingdom is a temporary hell-adjacent realm of processessing: most people serve a term of like 1,000 years before being elevated to the terrestrial kingdom.