[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


I'm reading through the Bible for the first time, cover to cover.

I'm at Leviticus 11:19, and Yahweh explicitly, without any room for confusion, refers to bats as a type of bird.
It doesn't refer to flying creatures in a general sense, specifically birds.
The creator God of the entire cosmos calls a bat a type of bird.

Is Yahweh retarded?

How do Abrahamicists explain this?
It seems to me like it was written by bronze age humans who didn't actually even know what a bat was.
>>
Also holy shit is the second half of Exodus and Leviticus dry and dull as fuck.

Do we really need to repeat 100 times how you slit the throats of animals and break the necks of birds and and sprinkle their blood all over the place like some Satanic blood ritual?

Do we need to repeat the specifications of the tabernacle and the priest outfits and how to burn the oil unleavened bread like 20 times over?
>>
Also in addition to all this why is Yahweh calling bird of prey, and all sea creatures, and insects "abominations" and "detestable"?

Saying not to eat them is one thing. But he doesn't call camels or pigs abominations like he does these creatures.
Why would God make creatures he considers to be "abominations"?
>>
>>18793967
>I'm at Leviticus 11:19, and Yahweh explicitly, without any room for confusion, refers to bats as a type of bird.
1. Yahweh doesn't refer to anything in the Bible, because Yahweh isn't a character in the Bible. Yahweh is a made up fake name of God.
2. Leviticus 11:19 does not refer to bats as a type of bird. It refers to them as a type of fowl, which is perfectly appropriate given this definition from Webster's dictionary from 1828.
>It doesn't refer to flying creatures in a general sense, specifically birds.
Again, you can't read. Or maybe you're reading a modern fake version. Either way, you're fucked.
>Is Yahweh retarded?
No, but you are.
>Abrahamicists
And you're brown. Tick tock.
>>
>>18793982
>It says fowl instead of bird in the KJV!!!
>Also I hate minorities!! Enjoy Hell!
Not a serious response
>>
File: burning in hell.gif (82 KB, 220x190)
82 KB GIF
>>18793984
>Not a serious response
I gave you a perfect response and you rejected it because you don't care for an explanation, you just want a reason to hate the God who shed his blood for you. I'm so glad I'm not you. Hell is unbearably hot, and it never ends. Ever! :D
>>
>>18794002
>Infernalism
This has been debunked
>>
>>18794010
>If I pretend Hell isn't real then I won't have to go!
Good luck with that! xD
>>
>>18794018
Do you believe millions of unbaptised babies who died of cancers are being roasted alive on a spit in the depths of Hell for literally infinite time?
Do you believe a perfectly good God would endorse that?
>>
>>18793967
You got through all of genesis and exodus and you are just now asking this question because god lists a number of birds that are unclean then adds bats too at the end? You weren't bothered by, idk lets go with God repeatedly mind controlling pharaoh to refuse Moses then horiffically punishing the Egyptians for it. Or how about the flood story where God wipes out humanity except for Noah's family then admits they too have evil in their nature as all of mankind does, making the whole global genocide rather pointless.
>>
>>18794027
>Do you believe millions of unbaptised babies who died of cancers are being roasted alive on a spit in the depths of Hell for literally infinite time?
No. Any more retarded questions?
>>
>>18794029
Those things are already well known and discussed. The part where God calls bats a type of bird was new to me.

>>18794031
How are they not in Hell? Your system seems extremely inconsistent
>>
>>18793982
vulgate says 'de avibus'. that's them birds.
you posted a definition that says 'fowl' is the old synonym for 'bird', and pretend this is somehow a gotcha. or maybe in your world bats walk on two legs (just read the quote, bot).
>>
>explicitly, without any room for confusion
You really, really gotta love when unbelievers are attacking the bible based on a misinterpretation and as part of their argument they declare themselves 100% correct and unquestionable. Also, notice how when butchering scripture they will make declarations of its sheer clarity, but in every other context they will insist there is something wrong with the scriptures in being hopelessly obscure and impossible to understand. Anyways: DAWW THAT BAT IS SO CUTE HE LOOKS LIKE A DOGGIE :3
>>
>>18794041
>The part where God calls bats a type of bird was new to me.
how about the part about only four-legged insects being kosher? then the text even lists a few.
>>
>>18794041
>Those things are already well known and discussed.
How about the premodern notions of animal husbandry in genesis 30, where Jacob is able to cheat his uncle Laban by saying he will take as his wages only the goats with striped or speckled coats, which would normally be a small amount. Then he cuts stripes and speckles into branches and puts those branches in front of the goats as they mate, resulting in their offspring having stripes or speckles.
>>
>>18793967
>Is Yahweh retarded?
God made humans, humans made AI.
Do we try to make AI shatter than us? As far as possible, yes. Also it's pretty sure of its answers, and often frustrating to speak with.
Shouldn't it be the same for us and God?
From our point of view, God IS retarded.
Also probably fed up with our shit.
>>
>>18793967
>written by bronze age humans
Technically Abrahamics are iron age cults. What do you expect? They are all allegorical tales to codify the social construct of their respective timelines - not to be taken literately. You have a higher tolerance for bullshit than myself, I couldn't even get through Genesis.
They hadn't even figured out how seashells got on mountainsides figuring all that flooding happened just before they got there or something.
I think I read Dostoevsky's The Idiot after I gave up on the bible and felt much better.
>>
>>18793967
Yahweh is limited through ‘instrumental reason’
>>
>>18793967
The actual reason behind is the fact that ancient people probably didn't get to look at bats closely very often at all, and when it's sunset time and all the small bats are flying around they look basically indistinguishable from birds of the same size. Same reason the romans called them "birds of the evening" too
>>
>>18793967
lmao i should really read that shit
>>
>>18793982
When was the last time you saw a bat with feathers?
>>
>>18794041
>How are they not in Hell?
Because they haven't sinned.
>Your system seems extremely inconsistent
It's not.
>>18794353
>When was the last time you saw a bat with feathers?
I haven't. I guess God was just throwing them in the list because they fly so close enough. Which is fine, he can order his law however he wants.
>>
>>18794375
>Because they haven't sinned
They have sinned since Adam has sinned. In the Christian paradigm and especially in your sola scriptura KJV only one, the baseline is hell, and a state of severance from God.
You need to believe in the Christian dogma to go to heaven.

Unless the King James explicitly says somewhere that babies don't inherit Adam's sin, until they become legally eligible to vote in the US elections, then it's a moot point to argue. Or does it say anywhere in the KJV that children go to heaven?
>>
>>18794420
>They have sinned since Adam has sinned.
They aren't Adam. Grow a brain.
>Unless the King James explicitly says somewhere that babies don't inherit Adam's sin,
Ezekiel 18:20
>The soul that sinneth, it shall die. The son shall not bear the iniquity of the father, neither shall the father bear the iniquity of the son: the righteousness of the righteous shall be upon him, and the wickedness of the wicked shall be upon him.
Enjoy burning.
>>
>>18794431
>They aren't
As /his/'s anabaptist church representive, your responses are, do you know why your King James Bible-Study group believes in "age of accountability" doctrine?
It's not a natural inference of Paul's Adam-Jesus soteriology, but a retrojection to avoid uncomfortable entailments. As sola scriptura, you can't rely on EO church dweebs. So you must establish "age of accountability" doctrine from the text.

If ezekiel is taken at face value, that son shall not inherit the burden of the father, then what did Jesus lay his life up for, and what did he redeem the world against? If human beings are not truly implicated in Adam, why do they need a second Adam (Jesus)?

Tl;dr? Enjoy hell. The flames are nice.
>>
>>18794320
>>18793967
The original Hebrew term ʿôp̱ (often rendered "birds" or "fowls")
>>
>>18794486
>this verse doesn't count because it interferes with my theology
You did nothing to address the meaning of Ezekiel 18:20
>>
>>18793967
>>18794041
I don't understand your argument. Are you viewing the Hebrew words and the English words as 1:1 equivalents?

This is like a Russian saying someone speaking in English is making an error when they call something light blue "blue" when it's clearly not blue, it's гoлyбoй.

(In Russian, what we would call dark blue and light blue are labeled two totally separate colors, as separate as blue and green are in English)

I would really like a detailed explanation of the linguistic logic here for anyone calling this an error because I find the claim simply baffling, and can't piece together the logic here.
>>
>>18793967
Categories like "bird" are just social constructs. Israelites considering bats birds is perfectly valid. Also you have to realize translation is often not one to one. If you're translating a Hebrew word that groups together all non-insect flying animals, the closest English word is "bird," even though it doesn't have exactly the same meaning.
>>
>>18794742
Facts. I really don't understand how someone interested enough in history to be on a history board would be thinking the English word "bird" and its requirements must be an exact match for the original Hebrew word. It's like saying texts from in early modern English are wrong when they call clams and oysters "fish" since in modern English a clam wouldn't count as a fish
>>
>>18793984
The only appropriate response. You're brown, therefore I discard your opinion
>>
>>18794587
>I would really like a detailed explanation of the linguistic logic here
There is none. He thinks of categories as ontologically objective because he has a twelve year old mind. Don't even bother trying to explain anything.
>>
i'm so sick and tired of abrahamic mega cope that it's unbelievable
the only reason this garbage religion made any impact on the world is because of superior european culture diluting it into something palatable
>>
>>18795045
>I hate minorities
"Love thy neighbour" is one of the most important lessons of the Bible. Enjoy hell.
>>
>>18795771
Hahahaha the Bible?? Enjoy being a fucking retard for the rest of your life
>>
>>18793971
>why is a book derivative from oral traditions repetitive?
Oh boy. Never get into Buddhism, you will suffer an anheurisn reading the Pali canon.
>>
>>18795772
Keep stoking those flames.
>>
>>18793967
Words are words
Categorizations are literally made up things, they don't really exist.
What you consider a bird and what another culture considers a bird is irrelevant really. For all I care, any thing that flies and is bigger than a beetle is a bird. Who made you the ultimate authority on semantics and categorization? Why did you suddenly decide that bats are not birds?
>because le science
Let me tell ya something about fatherless bipeds.
>>
>>18795894
>Why did you suddenly decide that bats are not birds?
Bats are not birds. You know this.
>>
>>18796197
NTA but see >>18794587
>>18794742
>>18794759
and >>18795054

your argument does not and cannot make sense



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.