Did he peak in Africa or was he just overrated?
>>18794603Both. He was a very competent officer overall to be sure but making him out as some kind of great military genius who only lost because of reasons out of his control is false. By late 1942 he didn’t have the talent to cope with the overall organizational/leadership qualities of the reformed British army and U.S. II Corps. He arguably isn’t even one of the very highest S-tier of Wehrmacht officers like Model or Von Manstein.
>>18794603>loses to a literal autist
>>18794603If he was commander in Stalingrad, he would have ordered a withdraw the second the encirclement happened.
>gotta go fast!>but herr general! all our supplies are being unloaded from one single dock 1000 miles away!>don't care, gotta go fast!