What was living in Italy like during the Medieval era?
>>18794630Peak comfy
>>18794630Tony Soprano plus famines and plagues
Which part of Italy? It matters a lot
>>18794630Literally no different than today.>Wagecuck until you die>Loud obnoxious wife>Your kids are always up to something>The POPE>Corrupt governments that take way too much of your moneyBeing an Italian was effectively being a paypig to mafiosos in armor
Moors were raiding as far north as Rome for slaves.Meanwhile, travel outside fortified settlements carried serious risks of bandits, rape and murder.Peasants were around 90 percent of population and rented land from the nobles. In order to pay their rent, peasants gave the land lord crops or livestock as well as working the nobles fields a few days a week
>>18794818>Peasants were around 90 percent of populationI remember reading a similar fact about Ottoman Life and this is the shit that always get me about Medieval/Early Modern Europe. Why did no one in Europe form a more egalitarian society, instead of having chunks of their work handed off to rich nobles and bishops. They had monasteries as an example for a society that didn't operate under the strictly hierarchical rules and there were holidays were society literally swapped roles for a day (feast of fools I think its called).
>>18794630It depends on when.Things were the same until the gothic war. That's when things got bad. Italy was a battleground between Constantinople and whatever barbarian tribe was squatting in the peninsula at the time. Although most barbarians were wise enough not to mess with the locals that much beyond standard raiding and left them in place for taxes and legitimacy, there was still economic collapse, plague and a refugee crisis that brought the population way down. That's when your pic is set. The old Italian Roman culture kind of continued on in the semi-independent Byzantine allied cities Rome, Naples, Venice, Capua, and the Pentopolis (five cities including Ravenna) in Romagna which is why it's called that. The others mostly started identifying as Lombards for more legal rights although they retained Vulgar Latin and the Roman Chalcedonian Faith. After Charlemagne defeated the Lombards who were pressuring the Roman Ecclesiastical elite the church became the center of Italian life and there was a growing conflict between the pope and his supporters (Guelphs) and the supporters of the German Emperor (Ghibblelines). This essentially led to gang warfare in the territories that were nominally part of the Holy Roman Empire. This was also the rise north Italian cities which unlike the rest of Europe were somewhat independent from fuedal lordship and somewhat Republican. They got rich by restarting Mediterranean trade after the socio-economic collapse stemming from the collapse of Western Rome. At this time Sicily got conquered by North African Arabs and southern Italy became a battleground between Byzantines, surviving Lombards, the HRE and Muslims. This is a poorly documented but actually quite eventful period. Most southern Italians didn't really have a stake in the fighting although sometimes they would chase conquering lords out if they were pushed too far like in Naples.
>>18794948The high middle ages resolved some of these conflicts. In the 1100s French Norman mercenaries slowly took all of Southern Italy ending the chaos there. The Sicilians converted back to Catholicism basically overnight. They actually did pretty well under Muslim rule and benefitted from being connected to a wider trade network land reform and new irrigation technology. The Normans continued with this and Norman Sicily was considered to be one of the richest kingdoms in Europe. Meanwhile in the North the pope-aligned Guelphs defeated the HRE at the battle of legnano in 1176 which essentially cemented the independence of the North Italian city states who became very rich from banking. Now people would think this was a good thing and times were good but in reality from here through the Renaissance it was chaos. Constant warfare between city states meant italy became the center of the Medieval European mercenary industry. Bankers and Mercenaries became the rulers of Italy and Bankers and Mercenaries don't exactly have the best interests of commoners in mind. Because of this the Ghibblilines actually persisted and even Dante at one point became one since he believed Italy needed a strong central authority. I think it was either Boccaccio or Petrarch who said that one of the reasons they wrote was to show future generations how bad things were.
>>18794854I think it's important to realize that being a peasant doesn't automatically mean your a serf. Being a freeholding peasant in the middle ages was not by any means a bad thing and it was somewhat common. Peasant just means farmer. In italy too you had more options than a lot of other places since it was the most urbanized place in europe and you had pathways through clergy, merchant, and mercenary work.
>>18794854In the early 1530s, an evangelical preacher named Bernhard Rothmann began publishing pamphlets throughout northern Germany arguing that the Bible demanded the absolute equality of man, including the total redistribution of wealth. This message deeply resonated with impoverished peasants, craftsmen, and trade guilds who felt oppressed by the ruling Catholic hierarchy
>>18794630Just don't live near swamps or waterlogged areas.Be lucky enough to have a way to avoid plague heavy areas when they strike and be able to recoup quickly
>>18795038Venice was the safest place to live
>>18794746not really. today you have decent health care and won't die of plague/famine every couple of years or have Saracen raid your village and take half the inhabitants into slavery in North Africa.
Better than anywhere else in Western Europe but still difficult in some ways. It was still a fairly wealthy place and a lot of the Roman infrastructure remained intact. That being said it still suffered from war, famine, and population collapse just as the rest of medieval Europe did. The physical cities remained largely Roman until about 1000. They were only torn down because Italy was rapidly gaining in population by this point and all of those ancient ruins needed to be cleared out of the way to build more houses. If you were stuck in the Middle Ages Italy wasn’t a bad place to be
>>18794854People tried and they got BTFO. The German peasant revolt for instance. Feudalism wasn’t always a bad system though. It just depended on the time and place.
>>18794854>Why did no one in Europe form a more egalitarian society, instead of having chunks of their work handed off to rich nobles and bishopsCause those rich assholes had private armies. People did not choose to be peasants. They were born into it, and if they got any notions about disturbing the social order, the social order beat them into submission.
>>18795110Also the levellers in England.
>>18794854There were peasant communes from time to time, but the nobility weren't fond of them and worked to undermine them, or simply attacked them. The simple fact that the nobility were also the military made it hard for anybody to object too strongly to the way they ran society. Even the clergy knew there was a limit to how far they could push their temporal meddling before the nobility decided the church was more trouble than it was worth. Power was a lot more nakedly about violence in the medieval period. There was a social contract, of sorts, and laws, it wasn't just might makes right. But the people in charge were warriors first, everything else second, so if you pushed them into a difficult position, politically, violence was usually one of the first things they resorted to.
>>18795116Or the Jaquerie in France, during the Hundred Years War. There's examples from basically every major medieval kingdom in Europe. Usually goes the same: big uprising, local authorities killed or forced to flee, the nobles regroup, cocky peasants try to meet them in battle, get utterly destroyed in the field, then it's wholesale peasant genocide until the nobles decide they've had enough.
>>18795094also you don't get burned at the stake for having a religious opinion the Pope doesn't like
>>18795094additionally Italy is a single nation nowadays with uniform laws, currency, tax codes, etc instead of the laws and currency being different in every other city.
>>18795145Those plucky peasants. Maybe it was they who truly possessed the Faustian spirit commonly associated with Europe. Perhaps we should be trying to regain a peasant mindset rather than a noble one.
>>18795151>additionally Italy is a single nation nowadays with uniform lawsi would take today where there's no death penalty whereas in medieval ages there were dozens of crimes that carried death or mutilation
>>18795151every city was its own little country and there were frequent wars between city states next to occasional outside invasions by the HRE, Normans, or Saracen raids
Italy wasn't that bad because the climate is so nice. Northern Europe had all the other downsides of the Middle Ages (wars, slave raids, brutal punishments for crimes, being taxed and exploited by nobles, plagues, famines, etc) on top of cold, shitty weather and less crops you could grow.
>>18795155Peasant revolts were not the norm. While they happened in every country at some point, the norm was generations of peasants toiling quietly and more or less contentedly. Even if life was hard, they didn't try to upend the social order cause it was all they knew, really. It's only when things got really, really bad that the peasants threw a revolt. And often the objective of those revolts wasn't a total overhaul of society, just a desperate means to alleviate the most immediate concerns they have (usually a recent tax being too steep). Most of them were perfectly fine being peasants, mostly cause they didn't know any other way of life.You wouldn't see real dissatisfaction with the inequality of society until literacy spread with the help of the printing press.
>>18795165True but nothing is more comfy than sitting inside with your bae when it's all rainy and cold outside hehe.
>>18795165Scotland or Scandinavia would have really sucked back then.
>>18795156Justice was difficult to carry out in the medieval world, though. There were no police, to investigate crimes and arrest criminals. The laws and how they were enforced also varied a lot from place to place because legal authorities had virtually no oversight in the countryside. When you see lists of medieval laws with gruesome punishments, you have to pay attention to how this list of laws was compiled. Do they all apply to the same place? At the same time? Or are they aggregated from many places, existing concurrently in different jurisdictions? Even if a law existed which prescribed a terrible punishment for a particular crime, actually catching the offender was a matter of local will to prosecute the criminal. The usual way criminals were apprehended back then was for a posse of concerned locals to round up the ne'er-do-well and put him in stocks to await trial. In the case of a complaint of one person against his neighbor, usually it was the responsibility of the aggrieved party to apprehend the man he accused, if he did not deign to show up at court to answer his accusation.
>nobody in this thread knows the difference between peasants and serfs
>>18795179it will depend. there were no organized police in the modern sense although guards and militia could enforce law and order, suppress rioters, etc. for ordinary crimes you were expected to solve them and catch the criminal yourself.
>>18795179England had a county sheriff who would catch individuals who committed crimes against the state or king, but ordinary crimes you were expected to solve yourself. Also England had the right to a jury trial and a lawyer from the Middle Ages and torture for ordinary crimes had ceased being used by the 13th century. This did not apply to crimes against the state where you got no right to a trial or lawyer and were allowed to be tortured.
>>18795179In Foucault's book he points out a lot of these people were freed either by the authorities or a local uprising prior the punishment actually being handed out. >>18795198Sometimes guards/militia are better. I think we've all lived somewhere with a shitload of stinking disruptive violent vagrants that the police basically protect. With a militia you just throw them out. With a police force, you can be compelled to tolerate totally asymmetric violence.
>>18795200France still allowed torture all the way to the Revolution. Voltaire after the horrific execution of Robert Damiens for attempted regicide in 1757 remarked "For some reason people like to call us a civilized country."
>>18795207conversely, the English penal code of the 18th century had over 200 capital crimes including white collar ones such as fraud or counterfeiting, although in practice the death penalty was seldom actually imposed for them. while they did have jury trials, judges were notoriously corrupt and any man of means could bribe his way out of a case. the French did not have jury trials, they had trial by judge but the judges took their job seriously and were pretty incorruptible. also France in the 18th century only had a small number of capital crimes compared to the vast amount prescribed in the English "Bloody Code."