Caesar himself thought Pompey could have wiped him out at Dyrrachium >"Today the victory would have been the enemy's, had there been anyone among them to take it." Even still his strategy of starving Caesar's forces would have worked and yielded less Roman casualties if he wasn't shamed by Cato and the other senators into allowing a final battle for literally no reason.And also prior to the civil war Pompey's conquests and military victories were unarguably greater than Caesar's conquest of Gaul.Really I think the only reason people disrespect this guy is because his bust makes him look like a dopey fuck. We very easily could have been living in the Pompeian Rome timeline.
>>18795426>Caesar himself thought Pompey could have wiped him out at DyrrachiumBecause pompey had much more men than caesar
>>18795426I don't think he is disrespected. He is is generally considered a great general.
>>18795431...according to caesar
>>18795426>Was Pompey a better general than Caesar?No. Pharsalus settled that debate.>Caesar himself thought Pompey could have wiped him out at Dyrrachium>"Today the victory would have been the enemy's, had there been anyone among them to take it."Could have but didn't because he didn't press his advantage. A mistake Caesar would not have made had the roles been reversed.
>>18795426>And also prior to the civil war Pompey's conquests and military victories were unarguably greater than Caesar's conquest of Gaul.Bullshit. Other Roman generals like Lucullus had done 90% of the work but Pompey during his term as consul withheld all reinforcements. By the time Pompey was proconsul and dispatched to the east (as he had planned when withholding reinforcements), there was no serious opposition to Roman rule. Lucullus had already destroyed the bulk of Mithridates' army and any vaguely competent general could've finished the job. Which was basically just to occupy some territory, subdue some minor resistance and reorganize everything to Rome's benefit.Caesar's conquest of Gaul was phenomenally impressive and should be contrasted with the Roman conquest of Iberia, which took more than a century and was filled with catastrophic Roman blunders and defeats. But Caesar won battles like Alesia against pressure under which any lesser general would've collapsed, and managed to avoid falling into ambushes and the like. Sure the geography of Gaul was less defensible, but not to the extent that hundreds of years and multiple successive generals+armies becomes one guy's term as governor.As for the civil war itself, Pompey had substantially more men and resources but lost. He had absolutely every advantage but couldn't convert it. Much of that I'd say is due to Caesar being such a fantastic general, but still if Pompey had been anything more than a "solid and competent" Roman general he'd have won the civil war with ease. Caesar in Pompey's position would've easily won against Pompey, or himself for that matter, in Caesar's position.
>>18795426He's kinda underrated as an administrator though, his political settlements are what formed the basis for seven centuries of Roman rule in the levant while he also succeeded in mitigating street violence in Rome and it was he who devised the law which made it so magistrates had a five year gap between holding office and heading out to the provinces so that they could be held accountable for their actions in office before being unleashed on the provincials.
>>18795525And was it not from Caesar that we knew Pompey could've easily won had he chosen to starve Caesar out?
>>18795733Yeah that's actually mostly a point against Pompey. In the republic, and especially around this period, it was really in vogue to hype up your enemies in order to make your triumph over them seem all the more glorious.
>>18795426Yes. Even without his inflated reputation. He was given bad advice. He waged a war to look good. Caesar waged a war to win.
>>18795426>Caesar himself thought Pompey could have wiped him out at DyrrachiumYou don't think he was just saying that?
Yes, took a whole ass volcano to take him out
>>18795426>And also prior to the civil war Pompey's conquests and military victories were unarguably greater than Caesar's conquest of Gaul.Taking ALL of Gaul was crazy work, you're underestimating how much Caesar did thereCaesar's victories were so massive that they threatened the balance of the Republic
>>18795715Pompey would have made an excellent emperor if born a century or so later; he was very good at self-aggrandizing without coming off as arrogant or overbearing, leveraging military force to coerce political concessions without needing to resort to violence, and solving messy situations where he as the state has overwhelming resources (e.g. piracy). But he was outclassed as a general by Caesar and didn't have the education or intellect of Caesar and Augustus, which I think was necessary to establish a new, long lasting post-republican regime.
Ancient historians remembered Pompey more positively than modern popular memory does. Like he was still remembered and spoken about as Caesar's equal in the 3rd-4th centuries so he left quite the impact on the Romans.
>>18797972Gee I wonder why
Yes, he was a competent experienced general and about the same age as our own in the modern world. He would have won had he not been pressured to attack, that part of history isn't a meme. Why would Caesar admit "yeah actually it was incredibly stupid for me to cross the Adriatic"? Many of the patrician class were in Pompey's camp witnessing events so he couldn't deny it.Pompey reminds me of Sima Yi, they both used the Fabian strategy against an opponent who was on another level with troops that were far superior, except Sima Yi didn't have to bring the entire court with him on campaign.
>>18797972Emperor Anastasius claimed descent from Pompey and had a statue put of of pompey in Constantinople.
Julia Caesaris dies in the labour of a healthy daughter in august 31, 54bc. What would Pompey, Caesar and Octavian do about this child, in order?