James Pavatt was the 133rd person executed by Oklahoma since 1976. He and Brenda Andrew murdered the latter's business executive husband in Oklahoma City in 2001 as part of a murder-for-hire plot when they were in the middle of divorce proceedings. She was convicted and sentenced to death along with her accomplice/lover James Pavatt after the pair fled to Mexico. Robert Dale Andrew was born September 19, 1962. Brenda Evers was born December 16, 1963. She grew up in Enid and was raised in the Lutheran church. Brenda was a smart, dutiful, and devoutly Christian girl who participated in church youth activities and a Christian evangelism program--she did baton-twirling and did not attend parties with her peers as she objected to their smoking and drinking. Rob was raised a Baptist and was of a similar background. The pair met in high school, attended college, married in 1984, and lived for some time in Texas before settling in Oklahoma City.
Rob became a successful and wealthy advertising executive while Brenda worked as a bank manager, a job she gave up after their children were born in 1990 and '94 so she could be a stay-at-home mom. They purchased a home in the upscale Lansbrook neighborhood of Oklahoma City and Brenda taught Sunday school at North Point Baptist Church although she had not been from a Baptist background. However, their marriage developed tensions. Brenda had preferred living in Texas and was unhappy at Rob's decision to move back to Oklahoma; he sought marital counseling.They separated in October 2001 and filed for divorce. Brenda began seeing James Pavatt, a 48 year old insurance salesman and fellow Sunday school teacher, and they began an affair. Pavatt was also a friend of Rob's and had sold him an $800,000 life insurance policy. Pavatt had recently divorced his wife Suk Hui.
Pavatt was born November 10, 1953. The details of his early live are obscure, but he'd served in the US military after high school and was a Military Police officer in South Vietnam. Pavatt had married Suk Hui in 1992 and was working at Prudential Insurance. Co-workers found him a rather off-putting and unlikable individual who had a strange obsession with wanting to shoot dogs; any time he saw one, he talked about shooting it. His former wife said he'd been a "great" husband and was shocked at his murder of Rob Andrews.In fact, Brenda had been cheating on her husband for some time; she had had two other lovers and was known to wear provocative, skintight clothing in public, even at the church. In the weeks leading up to the murder, her and Pavatt hatched a plan to kill Andrew and collect his insurance policy. On October 26, Pavatt cut the brake lines on Andrew's car in the hope he would be killed in a crash. He asked his daughter to call Andrew on a pay phone and claim Brenda was in a Norman, Oklahoma hospital and badly needed him. An unknown male made a similar call to Andrew, who however found out about his car's cut brake lines. He contacted police and told them he suspected his wife and Pavatt were having an affair. On November 2, Andrew, who by now was beginning to realize that his wife and Pavatt were trying to kill him, reported his suspicions.
On November 20, Andrew went to Brenda's house to pick up the kids for the Thanksgiving holiday, but while he was there Brenda asked if he could help re-light the pilot light on a furnace in the garage. He went in there, and Brenda and Pavatt shot him twice with a shotgun blast, killing him instantly. Brenda also purposely shot herself in the arm and claimed afterward that her and her husband were attacked in their garage by two masked gunmen. On the 26th, Brenda and the kids got tourist visas along with Pavatt, who drove across the border to Mexico, not attending Rob's funeral. The same day, someone tried to use Rob's bank card to withdraw money from an ATM machine in Nuevo Laredo, Mexico.The couple were quickly suspected and an international manhunt for them started. Pavatt's adult daughter assisted law enforcement in helping track him down and admitted that she'd helped prepare his journey out of the country, and said that the murder plot was Brenda's idea. She was given a cell phone to help track him down and they made around 20 phone calls. Brenda and Pavatt were arrested in Hidalgo, Texas on February 27, 2002 while attempting to cross back into the United States. Her children were found alive and well and put in the custody of their grandparents. Oklahoma County DAs announced that they would seek the death penalty for both Brenda and Pavatt.
Pavatt was found guilty of first degree murder and sentenced to death in September 2003. A tentative execution date of January 12, 2004 was set, although the case would be automatically reviewed by the state supreme court first. Brenda was found guilty in July 2004 and a tentative execution date set for December 10. She maintained her innocence throughout.The insurance payout from Rob's death was awarded to the couple's children, their three uncles being made trustees of the fund.Pavatt appealed his conviction in 2007, 2017, 2019, and 2020. In 2022, he was part of a joint lawsuit filed by twenty-seven Oklahoma death row inmates charging that the state's lethal injection method violated the 8th Amendment. The suit was dismissed by a court that summer. Pavatt's execution date was set for July 11, 2024, but the state court of appeals postponed it. A new execution date was set for November 12, 2026 and Governor Kevit Stitt announced that he would not offer him clemency per the state board of pardons's recommendations.
Pavatt was executed on time by lethal injection. He had no final words and for a last meal requested a three-meat barbecue dinner and a strawberry milkshake.Brenda was placed in Mabel Bassett Correctional Center as the only woman on Oklahoma's death row. In the state's entire history, it had executed only four women, one of them in 1903, prior to statehood, and three in 2001. The main defense her attorneys made was that the prosecution had used inappropriate and irrelevant evidence at her trial about her sex life and infidelities, and attempted to depict her as a harlot and an unfit mother. One of the prosecutors had referred to Brenda as a "slut puppy" and a pair of her lingerie was shown in the courtroom to bolster their arguments. The courts however rejected her appeals in 2007, 2015, and 2023. In 2025, the Supreme Court agreed to grant her a re-hearing and ordered the case remanded to the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals, but they upheld her conviction.
>>18797263>>18797273wtf? she was hot!
>>18797273>>18797270>>18797267
>>18797288Couldn't help but notice that there are many more photos of her than there are of her Deputy Droop-a-Long accomplice.
>>18797267brothas, pay attention. this mf-er be spendin' way too much time at his high paying corporate job makin' dough. he don't have no time for his old lady so bitches being what they are she got frustrated and decided to cheat on him and eventually have him whacked. lesson learned: ignore your bitch at your own peril. he coulda taken her out to a fancy restaurant or shopping for overpriced shoes once in a while. seems like he could afford it.
>>18797273damn, that's a 38 year old woman with two kids!? she had amazing genetics.
>>18797263>>18797266>>18797267
>>18797327why are you talking like you're black?
>>18797335She improved. >>18797266Looked awkward and derpy in her 20s.
>>18797288>it's ok that she was a murdering cheating whore because she makes my pee-pee hardkys
>>18797266not much in the way of boobage tbqh
>>18797327granted. Rob, man, all you had to do was take her to dinner and a movie once in a while instead of spending all your time in the office. it didn't have to end this way.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bLr5cL0eG2wthread theme song
>>18797270exactly 25 years ago today
>>18797335i was shocked too