ngl I can't think of a more retarded mistake made by a /his/ figure
I mean his timing was perfect, it worked really well because he caught them pants down, but he ignored Paulus' war sims and his request for winter clothing which is what is really dumb. Also treating some civilian pockets like trash despite betting on a civil-political win where the Russians overthrow Stalin...
>>18798576Retard his entire worldview was based around exterminating Slavs so he could settle Germans in the region. It's like saying Mao would have been better if he implemented capitalism.
>>18798461desu it went as well as it could have. Asking better for Germany than everything between 1933 and the end of 1941 is unrealistic green.
>>18798576>I mean his timing was perfect, it worked really well because he caught them pants down, but he ignored Paulus' war sims and his request for winter clothing which is what is really dumb.All military branches knew they had spy infiltrators & turncoats, and they knew that anything resembling orders & requisitioning of materiel that'd indicate a cold climate war would be a dead giveaway & signal imminent clash.
>>18798461He was out of juice and needed more. He had no choice.
>>18798626Unlike massing your entire army on the soviet border?
>>18798639Which army, theirs or the germans?
no evidence for stalingrad
Wasn't a mistake. It was a gambit
>>18798461Nothing wrong with wanting to physically push the Russians back to their home continent. Russians belong in Asia, not Europe.
>>18798576>treating some civilian pockets like trash despite betting on a civil-political winya this never made sense to me>>18798579i know that but still>hinge half your plan on Soviet satellites welcoming you as liberators>to kick down the "whole rotted edifice">alienate and abuse them all to the point you actually create a more unified East than it was when you attackedi thought germans were smart
>>18798648The soviets didn't even mobilize their army so the gemrans obviously. Read a book?
>>18798579I mean maybe, but the official propaganda from the German perspective was a bit more nuanced.
>>18798626There were literal German communists inside the Wehrmacht who changed sides and told that the Germs are invading yet Stalin ignored them.
>>18798461At the time it wasn't that unreasonable to think Germany could have prevailed. The German army was, on paper, the most powerful in the world in 1941 while the USSR had just humiliated itself in the Winter War where it got BTFO'd by a small neighboring country. A German-Soviet military confrontation was also inevitable so Hitler gambled and rushed it before the USSR could industrialize any further
>>18798461they done goofed
>>18799111Paulus did the war sims, they ignored him for no reason what so ever. I'm not saying Germany was the aggressor since the SU broke the MR pact first with further demands but Stil, a different approach would be better.