[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: Lasagna.png (106 KB, 347x367)
106 KB PNG
As a non-Marxist I've always found it interesting that many Marxists call the soviet union "State Capitalist"; because from an outside perspective this doesn't really make sense. Since the Soviet Union didn't have private property and production was dictated by the bureaucracy rather then by profitability.

But the Marxists who subscribe to State Capitalist theory would say that Capitalism isn't private control of the means of production; but a whole host of certain "social relations". They would say that Marx and Engels talked about a Collective Capitalism; in which production was centralized by one entity. They would say the Soviet Union was Capitalist because it had:
-Wage labor (since workers were given pay based on their work, with pay scales and which limited their consumption)
-Commodity production (since workers produced products that other workers bought)
-Surplus extraction (workers produced surplus value by working more then what was necessary to sustain themselves)
-Production based on Capital accumulation (production was governed on meeting certain targets for accumulation)
-Separation of workers from control over production (workers didn't collectively determine the conditions and purposes of production)
-Independent firms (each workplace had their own accounting and limited who could use the workplace)
(1/2)
>>
>>18798555
Now I would say these are interesting points; but I find this explanation to be lacking. I find the idea that the Soviet Union based their production on capital accumulation/profitability to be wrong. The Soviet Union based production on the perceived needs of its population and the needs of preserving the state apparatus. It used bureaucratic quotas to achieve this rather then the price system. Many Marxists (who don't follow State Capitalist theory) have pointed out that any type of surplus extraction doesn't mean it's Capitalist. Many non-Capitalist modes like feudalism use direct political force to extract surplus rather then the autonomous price system.

Also as a non-Marxist, I find the commodity production point to be moot. I know that it is important for Marxists; since according to them the commodity-form is central for Marx's theory of surplus value extraction, alienation, law of value, etc... But I would say that every society has had commodity production. Marx operated on 19th century anthropology where they thought that "primitive peoples" never traded regularly. Which we know to be false today, Hunter Gatherers (even immediate return ones) regularly trade items and services with each other and outsiders and have a concept of debt. We even know that Animals engage in trade and production for exchange. So, I don't find it to be a point worth considering; since every society has it.

Anyway, Marxists have a non-standard use of social relation where they don't include social norms. Private ownership by most sociological frameworks is a social relation. Private ownership actually meaningfully changes the incentives on how people used things and isn't just a "juridical fiction" as Marxists say. Having administrative control isn't the same as private ownership.
(2/3)
>>
>>18798557
But that's my analysis. Even though I'm not a Marxist or Socialist; I find State Capitalism theory worth engaging with. Even though I disagree with it.

So, what are your thoughts? Was the Soviet Union State Capitalist or not?
(3/3)
>>
>>18798559
Nice to see an effort post here as this board is mostly filled with retards.
Overall I agree but I think the USSR was fairly self evidently non capitalist basically nothing in the economy was done for profit. Any arguments beyond that aren't really needed.
>>
>>18798557
The Soviet Union used prices from western markets and the local black market to determine where to allocate capital investment for industries. And we know that workplaces had an unofficial role called a "fixer" who would coordinate trade with other workplaces to get materials. So I would say the Soviet Union definitely had some capitalistic elements; but importantly these elements weren't state sanctioned.
>>
The Soviet Union derived basically its entire budget after WW2 from dollar-denominated oil exports to capitalist countries

An actual communist country would not need to engage in profit seeking trade with capitalists

With your argument you could say that China is communist too, which it obviously isn't
>>
>>18798555
Right. You get into this value-form theory stuff with Marxist theorists, and about how the Soviet Union had wage labor and exploitation for decades (and actually more of it over time). But then a bunch of other people just say yeah, there are differences between a state ruled by a Marxist-Leninist party-state that controls most politics and investment decisions in the economy and a state in which that doesn't happen, hence there are differences between "capitalism" and "socialism" in 20th century comparative economics. The fundamental problem of Marxism is that markets just won over the board in almost everything and to a far larger degree than anyone expected in the past.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.