[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/ic/ - Artwork/Critique

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


Janitor applications are now open. Apply here!


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1756185499919537.png (475 KB, 725x635)
475 KB PNG
FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUCK
>>
>>7940514
left has more soul
>>
>>7940514
From SOVL to SLOPPA
>>
>>7940514
Yeah, knowing what you actually want to draw instead of some vague "I wanna draw" goal yields results, who knew.
>>
>>7940514
left is better
>>
I don't necessarily like the direction he went, but it was clear he had a direction. This is a great demonstration of what you can accomplish when you set out with concrete objectives.

Every artist should begin their journey by trying to figure out what they want to accomplish with their art and what steps are needed to do so. Everyone can make it.
>>
It looks like he knew what he was doing but didn't know how to really use digital. He didn't even try to detail the one on the left and his hands are still small and shit. I wouldn't be surprised if he used a 3d model, hopefully he didn't
>>
>anime girl in white void
i do not care
>>
>>7940514
>he started tracing sloppa
>>
>>7940526
>his hands are still small
You are aware that that's a girl he's drawing, anon?
>>
the cope on this board is so funny
>>
>>7940514
>pinup
>vs
>pinup with better rendermonkeying
Yawn
I might like the left better honestly
>>
Two types of people: the ones that get mad and the ones that get inspired

But this is /ic/ in 2026 and there's only the first type of person here
>>
>>7940552
They're mad because they don't have a shred of this guys innate talent even at the start of his journey.
>>
>TRANIME garbage
Just prompt it
>>
>>7940514
Right one looks boring because everyone did it using the same exact method of multiply layer, add/color dodge/softlight, erase stuff, blend using blending tools,
yawn
>>
>>7940514
bro did not learn anatomy
>>
>>7940514
The one on the left already is a good drawing, but the artist didn't know how to utilize his skill. If you can't tell you're a beglet with an untrained eye.
>>
>>7940514
i hate these because how do we know left isn't just the worst thing he had drawn in that time period and he was on average doing close to right?
>>
>>7940514
Do not treat this as a demotivator. He fell into the trap of focusing too much on rendering that he neglected draftmanship.

The artwork on the left is far from ideal (he needs more work on perspective and forms) but has a noteworthy amount of passion and individuality. Decent composition and gesture.

The example on the right feels emptier by comparison. Pretty on the outside but not much going on inside. Somehow it feels like it has less weight and gesture.
>>
>>7940514
yeah Coronavirus lockdowns unironically produced several professional illustrators. I wonder which /ic/ poster became good since 2020 lockdowns
>>
>>7940662
None
>>
File: ic.jpg (413 KB, 1020x1162)
413 KB JPG
>>7940514
The only thing marginally improved here is the rendering, which i checked the actual tweet and the the artist said he actually said he practiced 8-10 hours per day
Don't get me wrong there's still a notable improvement but rendering is only a single aspect of drawing you /beg/s are just easily enamoured by eye candy
Do you want it enough to practice 8-10 hours a day with no guaranteed results anon?
>>
>>7940691
8-10 hours sounds about right. Industry professionals usually spend 6+ hours drawing and it's what they recommend for beginners once they get comfortable with the process.

I don't really understand why so many digital artists fall into the rendering trap, though. Learning how to color and paint is surprisingly easy but it means jack shit if you don't have the fundamentals down outside of values.

It's better to spend 6 hours a day nailing down drawing for a whole year and then focusing on color and paint.
>>
>>7940691
your first mistake is believing his claim of 8-10 hours per day of practice. Statistically speaking, half of the world is below average IQ. So there is a 50% chance he is below average. Below average people tend to not understand what "practicing" really means. Does he consider drawing for fun to be practice? Or only studying? Does he consider the fact that towards the end of the day he's probably suffering from burnout or lack of focus?

I'm tired of people acting like art is an exceptional skill. It's not. It's just that there are many different aspects. But if your only goal is drawing anime girls, 8-10 hours for 10 months is easily over 2000 hours minimum. You can become an expert at anything with 2000 hours of study time. But I'm supposed to believe this claim? This guy is a liar or doesn't know what "practice" means. If you practiced math for 2000 hours, you know how many formulas, concepts, and problems you would be able to solve? But no, uh art is different because... IT JUST IS OKAY!
>>
>>7940703
Too many people use "practice" when they really mean to say studying/training.

Indeed, art is not an exceptional skill or some kind of magical unique thing. Like any other kind of craft, it is something you must put intentional work into. It is something that requires actual planning with concrete goals.

Drawing is just making something 3D on a 2D space. You make lines, then you connect those lines to make shapes, then make those shapes into forms, then connect those forms with a strong sense of gesture/flow/energy/direction. Then it's just a matter of composition.

All you have to do is pick ONE aspect to focus on and commit to (with a corresponding subject), then switch to another fundie when you've made enough gains. Easy peasy.
>>
File: 1761560848116708.png (66 KB, 259x194)
66 KB PNG
>>7940514
>drawing
>look inside
>painting
>>
>>7940703
I don't believe he did 8-10 hours of pure focused "practice" as well, I also don't think he said the words and meant for them to be taken literally
No matter how dedicated you are you can't pull that shit off and not lose some productivity along the way

You are right about art not being an exceptional skill, but you can't deny that some people are able to grasp the concepts of drawing better than others. That's why certain /beg/s get discouraged easily. I really hate the phrase "art progression isn't linear" but to some degree there's truth in that
>>
>>7940714
I sincerely believe that online communities should bully artists into focusing on draftsmanship and collectively crap on examples of renderfags.

No amount of paint and color and lighting will cover up dogshit composition and dogshit form and dogshit gesture and dogshit line quality. And of course, not drawing from life.
>>
this thread is hilarious and it gets only better when you remember you are on ic
>>
>>7940514
the forms are almost identical in complexity, only thing that changed is rendering
>>
>>7940699
>Learning how to color and paint is surprisingly easy but it means jack shit if you don't have the fundamentals down outside of values.

You don't know what you're talking about, bud. People go crazy for highly rendered slop and colors.
>>
Why are you expressing envy?
>>
>>7940691
Why did you give it troonshit lesbian lips
>>
>>7940777
Sorry nigga I don't dabble in weebshit
Am I supposed to ignore the lips
>>
>>7940691
Never really believe anyone that draws 8-10 hours a day.
>t. Used to draw 8-10 hours a day on weekend. You're really only productive on the morning and afternoon/evening. By night you're easily distracted.

It's more beneficial to draw in the morning or whichever is your most efficient time frame. You'd get a lot done in 2-4 hour window when your brain is still fresh.
>>
>>7940514
He really did improve a lot in those 10 months but you can clearly see where his focus went if you look at it for longer than 5 seconds
>>
>>7940780
Yes
>>
>>7940814
My bad sensei
>>
>>7940691
why did you fuck up her face
>>
>>7940514
left makes me feel warm
right makes me feel nothing
>>
>>7940514
The funny thing is that the main flaw of the left (the stiffness from not drawing joints) remains unchanged. The illusion of progress
>>
>>7940514
Great now it looks like 90% of twitter artstyles
>>
>>7940867
>>7940839
>>7940780
I usually draw my bitches with luscious lips
>>
>>7940901
The inbreeding is a real shame
>>
>>7940516
I was gonna ask why does the right suck, but then I figured it’s just because it’s generic as fuck.
>>
>>7940617
anime website kill yourself
>>
>>7940514
From trying to actually have fun drawing to tracing 3d models.
>some people call this progress
>>
>>7940691
HOLY SOVL
>>
>>7940514
The reason you're all begs is that you spend all of your time obsessing over random artists
>>
File: nkjluouo.png (764 KB, 1314x794)
764 KB PNG
>>7940773
anon, he's not wrong. It's just that normies have low standards and loves render monkey shit. They deem anyone who draws better than a stick figure "talented", the standards are lower or higher depending on the platform you're in.
>>
>>7940714
>>7940718
Anon, that won't happen because normies don't give a fuck about draftsmanship. It's "boring" and doesn't activate their dopamine sensors like colors and light do. It doesn't matter how shit the drawing is, as long the colors are good, they will flock to it. It's like those bugs/flies buzzing around bright lights.
>>
>>7940547
>>7940733
the left is good and the right is bad bitch
>>
>>7940526
Your ugly yaoi hands style is not appealing, roastoid.
>>
>>7940714
Painting is just drawing with a bigger mark. You lack the critical knowledge.
>>
>>7940514
A good deal of improvement, but likely a result of model usage, better references/influences, ambition for polish, and familiarity with the software.
The most telling aspect, as it often is, are the hands. They have a traced feeling, but ironically have poorer sense of flow. The left hand especially seems to flail and has ambiguous intent. These are common traits of traced 3D model hands - even volume in the individual digits, but poor spacing between them.
The hair bun is distracting. I'm not a stickler for rendering, but in this case it's the disparity in quality that is jarring.
I'm not one to say silly things like "the left has SOuL!", but I think what people are noticing is that the left has a congruent style, every aspect is done with a consistent level of skill, and it possesses a certain kind of naive daring. That foreshortened hand says "I don't know what I'm doing, but that's what I want!" We can all appreciate that can-do spirit.
The right says "this is what people like. This is what I'm supposed to do." It's formal. It's formulaic.
>>
File: drawing.jpg (315 KB, 1350x2048)
315 KB JPG
>>7940514
This fucking narcissist probably chose one of the worst drawings from 2025.07 and one of the best drawings from 2026.05.
Picrel is also the newest drawing he posted, it looks like he still doesn’t understand the fundamentals and probably 80% of time only practices rendering because it takes less effort to learn and makes his "digital" art look better than it actually is.
>>
>>7940514
anime is easy to draw and you are focused on a singular style. Western art has so many styles it's way harder to learn
>>
>>7940514
every single one of his drawings has the same cheap sunlight shading that makes his art look good
he doesn’t even try anymore he just keeps using the same trick to make his art look good
>>
>>7941127
>muh fundies
Put this drawing in front of any normalfag consoomer and they'll say it's good.
>>
>>7941127
man, you can see the 3D model they traced over.
>>
>>7941151
This is not traced, the anatomy is fucked up.
If you think it looks 3D it’s probably the fake ass rendering on face that just looks good but wrong
>>
File: 1777126925120946.jpg (36 KB, 346x436)
36 KB JPG
>>7940514
>>
>>7941127
Yeah, it's really obvious that bro did not improve much in the drawing department. Ironically he might have been better at feeling the form before. Also that ear is atrocious
>>
>>7940545
>>7941118
it makes no physical sense with the hair retards
>>
This thread makes certain particular people SEETHE not because of his improvement (he improved*) but because being a render monkey improved his art without improving other areas that need work. On the surface that’s fine, and perfectly okay for social media. But why does this thread sting these anons in particular? It’s because they put talent points in rendering, too, realizing anyone can be like OP image (and the seethers) if they skill up in rendering.
>>
File: werwerwerwer.png (1.44 MB, 2014x2014)
1.44 MB PNG
Been doing value studies and tried to do this one from imagination. Went to color and spent like an hour to realize I had no idea what I was doing. Am I at the point I could try to dabble in color or do I need to just keep grinding value
>>
>>7941248
Wait I thought I was posting in the beg thread, FUCK
>>
>>7941248
I think values are good, you could try watching some marco bucci videos to get a quick grasp on color from this stage you are in
>>7940514
for how everything else is rendered, the hand got zero effort, I'd bet this lost guy from the /beg/ thread would do a better job with that hand and have it make sense
>>
File: 1635963680371.jpg (8 KB, 256x289)
8 KB JPG
All of the shit talk about render monkeys is made infinitely funnier when there hasn't been any truly standout draftsman on /ic/ in YEARS.
>>
>>7941159
>the myopic doppelganger
>>
File: 1717484887282374.png (132 KB, 700x700)
132 KB PNG
>>7942142
>>
>>7941159
lmfao
>>
>>7940691
>practiced 8-10 hours per day
How the FUCK do you people even do this shit?
I go to work
Go to the gym or go running depending on the day
Make myself a dinner
Do various house chores
Where the FUCK do you get that kind of time to do 8 let alone 10 fucking hours to draw?
>>
>>7942699
>I go to work
part-time
>gym
don't
>dinner
microwave slop
>chores
bare minimum, if even that

ez
>>
>>7942722
...Fuck...
>>
>>7940514
These comparison are always
>quick sketch with some coloring you did in 10 minutes on the edge of a random canvas
v/s
>full drawing you spent 2 full weeks on
Not to say he didn't learn and become better at drawing, but these improvement comparison memes are almost always handpicked with the only purpose of humblebragging
>>
>>7942699
>Go to the gym or go running depending on the day
>Make myself a dinner
if you didnt eat slop in the evening you wouldnt need to go to the gym fatass
>>
>>7942699
>I go to work
there you go you already failed at the first step
>>
>>7943011
Kek you fuckers will crab anything not even drawing related stuff
I bet you look like shit or a skeletor (shit)
>>
>>7943114
you dont need to be train in the GoYiM to be athletic, just lay down the spoon once in a while and do minor exercises at home, take the stairs instead of the escelator or elevator, walk/bike to work etc. you want more time to draw, find it. stop being retarded. youre wasting at least 3 hours ok gym and dinner. and you shouldnt eat in the evening if you want to retain your normal weight, why do you think its called break fast
>>
>>7943119
Post your body
>>
>>7943119
That might work if you're still in your early 20s but let me tell you you WILL regret not exercising.
>>
>>7942725
You think why health of Japanese mangakas so often goes to shit?
>>
>>7942699
they don't have jobs and/or they're young college/high school students

>>7943119
>t. 21 year old
>>
>>7943642
And japs walk to get to places. And their health still goes to shit assuming they're not a full time neet
>>
File: file.png (465 KB, 733x658)
465 KB PNG
>>7940514
too slow
>>
>>7944908
did he have someone holding his hand or something
>>
>>7943123
i just told you that you can do exercises at home retard
>>
everything looks the same these days
>>
>>7940867
To get her permission to die.
>>
>>7941094
the funny thing is this isnt even renderslop eye candy its pillow shading and looks like shit
>>
>>7940703
>Statistically speaking, half of the world is below average IQ
No, you dumb fuck. Statistically speaking half of population is below the mean.
>>
how do I even begin to render/color/paint like these >>7940514
>>7944908
fuck arts so hard
>>
>>7940514
>>7940691
you will get results
rendering is fundamental to both art and the feeling that a piece is finished
practice doesn't feel like practice if you enjoy the work involved with the process, because you are just drawing/painting things you enjoy and learning through large stretches of experimentation that feel like play
>>7940714
splitting hairs doesn't improve your prospects
>>
From soul to AI
>>
>>7941248
If you fix the lips... also that ear placement....
>>
This obsession with the appearance of effortless progress. Everyone wants to be a prodigy. Everyone wants to think they're a genius, until you see an actual genius and are humbled, then you realize that most people on social media are just desperate for validation. Actual geniuses aren't on social media posting about it, they get jobs in the industry at 17. Lmao.
>>
>>7949611
a strong separation of light and shadow to show form and light direction
subtle halftones in the light, very subtle reflected light in the shadows to show even more of the form
edge control to show how the planes change from one to another (rounded or sharp)
ambient occlusion for the darkest darks, sparingly
highlights for focus points like the eyes or to show material variation (glossy/metallic)
>>
File: m2-res_360p.webm (627 KB, 640x360)
627 KB
627 KB WEBM
>>7949751
Anikari, the teenager who got a job working as an animator on ONE PIECE at 18 years old comes to mind.
>>
>>7949755
the 18 year old made that???
>>
>>7949757
Oh sorry he was 17 when he started as a key animator that was a typo. Look at this. Stay humble. Awe stricken even. Already this good at such a young age. When you want to talk about prodigies and geniuses, this is it. This is the 1 in 10 million talent everyone wants to pretend they are.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z1VvSM2B-Z4
>>
>>7949751
Yoshinori Kanada, aka the father of kanada, entered the industry at 17 years old. He literally invented the Kanada style that is seen everywhere nowadays with things like mob psycho or dan da dan. Anikari is incredibly gifted, but there are always bigger fish in the sea.

Naoko Yamada was only 24 when she was given full directive control of an entire anime, K-on!

And so on and so forth.

People on twitter care more about appearances than actual substance. The people with actual talent quickly get scooped up and placed into roles. I'd say the twitter people need to be humbled, but the facts are who gives a fuck? They're all irrelevant at the end of the day.
>>
>>7949760
this is impressive but he likely started drawing as a child and kept at it until adulthood, and after joining the industry got a mentor to help him out. it's very impressive but it's not "talent" just skill and luck
>>
>>7949880
I think it's unfair to say talent doesn't exist, talent is just your affinity for understanding things specific to a skill. However, I don't believe anything is pure talent. Talent is basically like a force multiplier, you still need to put in the time and work to realize the limits of your potential. I do think however that Anikari is more of a symptom of the current modern world, true geniuses are like Kanada who are genre defining in what they bring to the table. If talented individuals are the ones that can easily see how to play the game, geniuses are the ones that are changing the way we play the game.

I know it can kind of hurt the ego or feel unfair that some people are just born seeing the world differently, but that's the just reality of what a true genius is, which is why everyone wants to pretend they're one on twitter. This isn't all to demoralize or blackpill. Quite the contrary, MOST people are not geniuses nor in the top 0.001% of talent, yet they still reach incredible heights, sometimes achieving far more sustainable success than those who rely solely on natural inclination.

The industry runs on reliable, highly skilled professionals who mastered the game through discipline, adaptability, and emotional intelligence. Consistency and reliability almost always outlast raw, unguided talent in the long run. This was all just really to call out the fuckheads on twitter that are desperate for validation.
>>
>>7949903
Most people dramatically underestimate what 5-10 years of legitimate CONSISTENT INTELLIGENT EFFORT can do. Simple as. Most people would achieve an advanced level of skill within that timeframe. Period.

Pointing to either extreme of those who are abysmally untalented or those who are geniuses as rationalization for not trying, is just a cope by the intellectually lazy who have already given up on themselves because they saw the effort and dedication it'd take and said they rather not.

It's what sickens me about the crabs on this board. Legitimately about 90% of the people on this board can achieve an advanced level of skill within 10 years with just an average amount of talent.
>>
File: fasdfasdf.jpg (275 KB, 1702x1227)
275 KB JPG
>>7940514
the fun of pushing something until it breaks
>>
>>7940514
Chinese render slop, there's a reason if AI is extremely good at making drawings that look like the one on the right
>>
File: file.png (583 KB, 1227x624)
583 KB PNG
Never trust these "improve"tards, most of them are straight-up lying.
They just found one shitty low-effort doodle they made in the past and want people to believe it was their best work and that they’ve improved rapidly.
>>
>>7940514
stop blackpilling



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.