[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/ic/ - Artwork/Critique

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: AnimLab.png (597 KB, 1917x955)
597 KB PNG
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=07lEKVyzEW4
>There are no plans to release the source code or make AnimLab open source.

Can it be trusted?
>>
>>8085353
With these kinds of projects, you need to check in every three months to see where their priorities are. Second, any project that's less than two years old (published) is at risk of being abandoned.
>>
I wouldn't waste my time with vibeslop until it reaches maturity
>>
>>8085361
Dev says there's 0 AI code and it's 100% human made
>>
>>8085365
Then why does it 100% looks like the other vibeslopped Photoshop clone?
>>
>>8085367
I don't know or care whether it's vibe-coded or not, but UI development is time-consuming, so we rely on frameworks to actually make progress. Frameworks tend to look similar because they're opinionated.
>>
>>8085374
If you're going to copy someone else's homework then you could at least modify it
>>
>>8085374
>or care
then fuck off scab
>>
>>8085374
>I don't know or care whether it's vibe-coded or not,
You should be, it actually directly affects the longevity and usability of the product
>>
>>8085385
Programmers dont care about longevity, simply don't update
>>
>>8085385
Too early to tell. I've seen both incredible and horrible things in enterprise.

>>8085376
Code is different from raster or vector drawings. You can keep working normally with code generation, but you can't do the same with raster output. Also, with code, you can fundamentally tell whether a solution is wrong or not, unlike art, where stylization makes many things permissible.

Message written with DeepSeek @7hj28hkj
>>
>>8085353
He says it used to be open source but it's not anymore because it was scraped by AI bots. But if it's already been scraped, what does hiding the code after it's already out there accomplish? And how did he know it was scraped? Is there a vibe coded bootleg? I haven't seen or heard of it. A turd worlder sharting out a slop clone of your work just comes with the territory now, same with game dev
>>
>to destroy Toon Boom
That's delusional.

Toon Boom is the industry standard, no fucking professional animator is going to jump ship for whatever the fuck possibly vibe coded shit this is.
>>
>>8085460
>A turd worlder sharting out a slop clone of your work just comes with the territory now
>now
Bootlegging precedes AI by centuries.
>>
>>8085353
I've made enough vibeslop programs of my own I can recognize the default claude gui here
>>
What is the best 2D animation software for someone looking to do indie stuff? I've been making do with art programs barely designed for animation
>>
File: Bryce_(1994).png (628 KB, 836x626)
628 KB PNG
>>8085353
why is umoupen not cracked yet? wtf? I tried reverse engineering it but clankers cry about piracy and shit, fucking hell.
>>
>>8085562
paid? I would go with moho.
free? krita, oepntoonz/tahoma2d
>>
>>8085353
>>8085460
It makes me irrationally annoyed that there's double standards for accusations of AIslop art vs AIslop code. With art you have to livestream your entire process or record an unedited speedpaint and release the .psd with all the layers or else you're assumed guilty until proven innocent. But with code all you have to say is nuh uh and people take it at face value without question and don't demand you open source it or livestream your coding sessions to prove your skill. Though I think even programmers with 20 years of experience would be embarrassed to livestream their process AI or not.
>>
>>8085580
You can immediately tell if the art is cool or not, if you are 5 years old or 80 years old
If you don't know code, 5, 15, 80 years old, doesn't matter, you'll never tell if it's correct code or not
You don't know what a double standard is, this things are not comparable
>>
>>8085353
you know its legit when they make an obvious youtube bait title for it.
>>
>>8085636
People cannot tell art from AI based on appearance alone whenever the suspected art doesn't have the most obvious stereotypical GPT tells or synthID, even artists with experience drawing for years will list off a bunch of armchair bullshit that makes no sense to justify themselves even if they're wrong and it's genuine human art with human flaws. Non-artists are even more retarded. The Dior thing made them think smear frames as a whole are suspicious and people had to put out videos explaining that smear frames have always existed. Sometimes people can't even find enough evidence from looking at it to use the art itself as proof of AI, they point to the creation date of the account or how fast they upload instead.

Being able to look at code and know from expertise whether it's legit or not is irrelevant when it's about forcing someone to be as transparent as possible about HOW that code got there in the first place. Because nobody can fucking tell anymore with art so they just make you bear all and take any hesitancy as "if you've got nothing to hide you've got nothing to fear"
>>
>>8085416
>I've seen both incredible and horrible things in enterprise.
At least with a human written code you can unravel and fix it. AI written code can just be gobledygook that "just works"
>>
>>8085367
>Why does it look like every other art program?
Because that's what art programs look like. You'd complain if the program had some wacky distinct UI, and you're complaining that it currently doesn't.
This isn't to say it isn't slop-coded, but the witch-hunters need to be knocked down as much as the slop-ghouls.

>>8085562
>>8085571
>Free?
I think Rive looks pretty good too, though I never hear anyone speak of it. Most uses of it seem free, unless you want to export a web animation file.
I can't speak from experience though, as it's been on my 'to learn later' list when I give animation a more thorough go.
>>
>>8085837
>if you've got nothing to hide you've got nothing to fear
and why is that wrong?
>>
>>8085837
>The Dior thing made them think smear frames as a whole are suspicious and people had to put out videos explaining that smear frames have always existed
You're a non-artist, have low cognitive resolution, and are not fooling anyone with your shilling.
>>
>>8085838
>At least with a human written code you can unravel and fix it.
Dude, I have 10yo code that I still don't understand how it worked it just did. This is the most common case for many people, workarounds.

>AI written code can just be gobledygook that "just works"
You have never worked in an international setting. You can find code written in multiple languages and full of misspellings. What can actually happen with AI, and its aproblem?
-Preference for a specific way of doing things instead of the most optimal one
-Rewriting tests
-Overcomplicated architecture for small projects
-Feedback related issues
>>
>>8085943
This simply does not happen working with engines for gui.
It only happens if you are doing obscure shit like os dev where you are juggling 80 files for one process that interfaces with another 20 processes and they each rely on 10 pieces of hopefully reliable oem documentation
>>
>>8085943
>Dude, I have 10yo code that I still don't understand how it worked it just did. This is the most common case for many people, workarounds.
Most programmers suck at programming, no big surprise there. If copy and pasting wasn't allowed there'd be much fewer software engineers.
>>
>>8085945
What doesn't happen?
In Java, it does make some suboptimal choices sometimes.
In TypeScript, it uses any way too often.
It has rewritten Qt and Angular tests even though they were out of scope for the session.
You learn to work around these things, but I have a pretty good opinion of AI generated code.

>>8085952
laughable, whatever helps you sleep at night
>>
>>8085957
Post your scalable network code that can support 10k concurrent users
>>
>>8085957
It doesn't happen that code becomes a black box, it looks like you do it for a living though so maybe I misunderstood that code you wrote entirely yourself has become a black box.
>>
>8085961
addendum, then show the comparison to 100k users
I'll be waiting
>>
>>8085961
sorry anon I just do todo apps

>>8085962
I don't know. If left unmaintained, anything can become a black box. The things that become hazy and hard to remember are the reasons WHY things were done that way in the first place, because those are external factors that aren't reflected in the code itself.

Right now, that's become my duty at work: providing the context around external factors that an agent can't access due to its nature. I just review the overall architecture and tests in the project.
>>
>>8085353
Lemme guess, another Claudeslop?

Wait 3-6 months
If the developer couldnt be assed to continue support it then dont bother. Most vibe coded slop barely last more than 1 month before the 'dev' abandoned it.

For a proper application you'd either need a very autistic developer that just keeps on working on it of which most vibe coders arent
Or a team of volunteers that are willing to work on it for free.

>>8085580
It's also equally easy to spot vibe coded slop
Just look at circumstances surrounding the project is enough but Im not gonna bother even clicking on this shit to find out. I just assume if its vibe coded slop it's shit and will be abandoned 1-2 months later
Where's that supposedly Photoshop killer that shithead Thomas keep on hyping about? Forgot about it already? Yeah thought so.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.