Input monk edition >What language(s) are you learning?>Ask questions about your target language!>Help people who want to learn a new language!>Participate in translation challenges or make your own!>Make frens!Read the wiki:https://4chanint.miraheze.org/wiki/The_Official_/int/_How_to_Learn_A_Foreign_Language_Guide_Wiki**Comprehensible Input Wiki**https://comprehensibleinputwiki.org/wiki/Main_PageUseful links:>Free language‐learning book archive:https://mega.nz/folder/INlRkAQC#CthKI9-_kmDNyrOx12Ojbw>Books on linguistics and language courses:https://mega.nz/#F!Ad8DkLoI!jj_mdUDX_ay-8D9l3-DbnQ>Assorted language resources and some nice visual guides:https://pastebin.com/ACEmVqua>Torrents with more resources than you’ll ever need for 30 plus languages:https://archive(dot)ph/x0dFH>Russianon’s list of comprehensible input resources:https://docs.google.com/document/d/1wXd0V32TjCFsr1-F_en_lA4MI-i7JtyYf26cWLtPRec>Massive collection of textbooks on various languages, sorted by familyhttps://theswissbay.ch/pdf/Books/Linguistics/>/lang/ inpoot torrentshttps://rentry.org/inpoot>Refold Anki deckshttps://rentry.org/refold>Non-English piracy siteshttps://fmhy.net/non-englishPrevious Thread:>>226086675
I feel like I can't consume any media in English anymore, it has to be my TL. Anything consumed in English is just another opportunity lost I could be practicing
>>226152212TRVKE...
>>226152212why not use the autodub feature on youtube?
Pro tip: study your prepositions
>>226155410what happened?
>>226154453What language are you studying?
>>226152212same here, i just turn on the subtitles and auto translate it to my TL whenever possible
>>226156429I'm that anon:>>226150400 >>226152746 Gave up on French, tried German, I most often return to Italian (like A2 or something, openess of Italian ppl really helps with talking), recently I've been dabbling in Spanish. And Japanese and various Germanic languages fascinates me but it wasn't nothing serious. I'm the eternal dabbler
>>226156400Nothing, I'm just saying. People focus so much on verbs and nouns, but prepositions make up so much of the language, that knowing them really is the difference of if you can comprehend a sentence.
is there any possible way to find the old duolingo courses from before they raped everything with AI
>>226159059Oh my gosh nigga just get a dictionary, a grammar, and a reader you fucking pussy.
>>226159274no, i know what works for me. duolingo helped me learn spanish by feeding me a steady supply of vocab and grammar tips for 286 days and i'd like to use their french course since it was of a similar length and quality. it's gotta be archived somewhere.
How long does it take to reactivate the knowledge of a language you used to be able to hold conversations in 17 years ago?
the muchacho in striped pajamas
>>226159059DuoItalian dot something, I don't remember
>>226151267I think this is a good approach, but 100 example sentences sounds like way too many, most of them are just going to be the same shit with different nouns or something.
>>226159992that one's too old and only in italian i want to know if i can get the last edition of the human made course before the big AI update about a year ago that replaced and artificially lengthened everything
Someone should make visual mutual intelligibility maps for languages.
>>226164318I've seen one posted here before but I didn't save it
NEW CHALLENGELevel 1: Beginner (A1)>I have two brothers and one sister.>What time do you wake up in the morning?>I like coffee, but I prefer tea.>My house is near the train station.>It's cold outside today.Level 2: Intermediate (A2-B1)>When I was younger, I used to visit my grandparents every summer.>If the weather is nice tomorrow, we might go hiking.>I've been studying this language for six months, but I still make mistakes.>She told me that she had never traveled outside her country.>Even though I was tired, I decided to finish reading the book.Level 3: Advanced (B2)>Had I known how difficult the journey would be, I might have prepared differently.>Despite having lived abroad for several years, he still struggles to express himself naturally.>It's often the things we take for granted that we miss the most once they're gone.>No matter how convincing his explanation sounded, I couldn't shake the feeling that something was wrong.>The more I learn about other cultures, the more I realize how much my own upbringing has shaped my perspective.Level 4: Expert (C1)>He has a knack for making a mountain out of a molehill, yet somehow manages to overlook the elephant in the room.>Were it not for the benefit of hindsight, I doubt anyone would have questioned the wisdom of the decision at the time.>There's a fine line between standing by your principles and stubbornly refusing to acknowledge when you're wrong.>What began as a seemingly inconsequential misunderstanding gradually snowballed into a dispute that neither party was willing to let go.>For all his apparent indifference, it was painfully obvious that the criticism had struck a nerve.Optional: Tell us, in your TL, about a time when you experienced an unexpected act of kindness from a stranger. What happened? Where were you? How did it make you feel? Did the experience change how you think about other people?
>>226163665sorry anon, it's the only thing I know
>language's orthography doesn't indicate fundamental part of its phonologyi hate hate this>inb4 flag
>>226166112My TL's orthography is nothing but little pictures
>>226166414that genuinely bugs me less.
TestPlz work
>>226166581Your vpn works
>>226166581>>226166728Are you sure it's from VPN?
>>226166112Can I do this challenge in the conlang I'm building?
>>226166728>>226166796Brit learning russian (poorly) langer here. For some reason 4chan gave me a temp IP ban for some reason and I missed this thread dearly.I think it's cause I have to use a vpn on other websites while a tab on 4chan is still active which I think blocked me from posting annoyingly. Never used a vpn to post on 4chan because that's gay. If I did, why would I pick the shithole that is the UK.
>>226156910stop dabblingI will grind Latin to an upper intermediate level, start German and grind it to C1 (or at least B2) before I start FrenchI'll allow myself to start German then, because the only real way to get better at Latin at that point is through reading and writing, so I will just read 10-15 pages per day and write a little and it won't get in the way of my German
>>226167162As a Lithuanian speaker do you find Latin to be relatively simple? It seems like Latin has simpler grammar than Lithuanian, given how conservative the latter has been over the years coming from Proto-Indo-European.
It's been an extremely long time since I last used this thread. I'm a Spainfag that is quite advanced in Korean. I just wanted to share that I've finally started to invest time into learning hanja (the Chinese characters behind Korean sinitic vocabulary), just learning to recognize them and memorizing their 'names'For example: 學 = 배울 학. 배울 is the descriptive name of the sinogram, 'to learn', and 학 is the way that sinogram sounds/it's written in hangeul.That was going ok, but now that I've created a deck to test myself reading full words written on it, it's so satisfying and I'm noticing many things. Unironically this has revitalized my interest in the language.This is further proof that I should've been learning Japanese and kanji this whole time though
>>226167347the most difficult parts of Latin grammar for me were those that don't exist in Lithuanian, for example:>tensesLithuanian doesn't have pluperfect, imperfect, perfect, future perfect and only has a past tense, past iterative (occurring many times) and a future tense>participles (gerunds and gerundives, etc.)Lithuanian does have a rich participle system, but to be honest, it's not used much>passive voiceit's very simple and analytical in Lithuanian, so wrapping my head around this concept wasn't easy>numbersLatin has a very awkward system, Lithuanian is much more similar to English here>casesI had no difficulties with thesesome cases are used differently than in Lithuanian, but I understood, for example, the ablative absolute very quickly as it's similar to the instrumental casethere were some other things, like the est/sunt distinction (there's only one word for this in Lithuanian, yra)overall, I don't really know. I think one would have to try learning both from scratch to be able to judge
>>226167431Do hanja have inconsistent pronunciations like Japanese kanji? I've found that memorizing hanzi is really much easier than kanji becuase they make only one sound and represent only one syllable each
Check out this wonderful, free App called Verbum. Read the Holy Bible in Latin, English, Spanish, German, French, and Italian - all translations of the Latin Vulgate - with up to 3 of those languages displayed at once.
>>226168083A Dutch option is also underway.
>>226167514한자 generally have consistent pronunciations. korean would also be much easier if they still used them.
>>226167431how did you learn korean?
>MögenMeans ‚to like‘>MöglichDoes lt mean ‚likely?‘ No, it means ‚possible‘. How tricky is German?
>>226166112if you hate your TL don't learn it
>>226168083My dear sir, what do you think of the Gnostic interpretation of the Bible?https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1RE5l3T7Dqk
>>226168083the built in parser/dictionary is what makes it a really solid app>>226169678pseud crap
>>226169793>pseud crapIt makes much more sense than the "traditional" interpretation. I always felt like Bible stories were incomplete and just bad stories in general, and turns out it's because you're missing a ton of context that the early church fathers decided was "heresy" and just killed off everyone that believed the opposite. There are still imprints in the story, things that are just hand waved or left unexplained, like what the "tree of knowledge" is supposed to be and why it was such a grave sin to disobey god and what the tree of knowledge did to humans. Who was the snake and why did god create the snake in the first place? Then you have the entirety of the Old Testament where this merciful god just goes berserk mode on humanity, then suddenly turns the leaf and becomes "love your neighbor". Even the story of Jesus makes more sense through a gnostic lens, he came to wake us up, tell us that we are of the divine spark and explain how the escape the material prison i.e. how to reach gnosis. There was even a Gospel of Judas which tells his perspective that was destroyed until we discovered an old translation in some random cave. In the traditional interpretation, god just sends his son to die on a cross because symbolically it's like he dies for our sins o algo, humanity is saved, go spread the "good word". What is the good word? It's actually really funny when you think about it, all the meat was stripped from the bones and you just have this empty structure that is rendered completely inert.Christianity never rang true to me until I discovered gnosticism. At the very least, it turns it into a complete mythology that unfortunately flips the entire thing on its head. It solves a lot of inconsistencies, it solves the problem of evil, it solves the problem of why we are here in the first place and why it seems like we're in literal hell and why material reality feels so foreign to someone with a divine soul.
>>226152212I still watch English YouTube videos, but I try to consume all my books, movies, series, anime, manga, games etc. in German, when there's a translation/dub available, which happens to be very often.
>>226169991>It makes much more sense than the "traditional" interpretation. I always felt like Bible stories were incomplete and just bad stories in general, and turns out it's because you're missing a ton of context that the early church fathers decided was "heresy" and just killed off everyone that believed the opposite. There are still imprints in the story, things that are just hand waved or left unexplained, like what the "tree of knowledge" is supposed to be and why it was such a grave sin to disobey god and what the tree of knowledge did to humans. Who was the snake and why did god create the snake in the first place? Then you have the entirety of the Old Testament where this merciful god just goes berserk mode on humanity.Like I said, pseud crap. I think what makes it so appealing to pseuds is how intelligent it makes them feel. All your criticisms of the "traditional" interpretation, whatever you even believe that to be, have literally tens of thousands of pages of exegetical work on them. Do you have any idea how much ink has been spilled over the tree of knowledge, or the serpent? Do you grasp at all half the things written in the NT itself? Clearly not, to engage in dualism and claim Christ somehow worshiped a same God from the one of the OT.>Christianity never rang true to me until I discovered Gnosticism.Gnosticism isn't Christianity, it's a different religion that tried to skinsuit it, failed, and got obliterated in detail by early theologians, then occasionally cropped back up over the course of the middle ages, as people kept thinking (like you) that they'd discovered something new and profound, when in fact they were recycling the same old tired heresy that had largely been defeated by argument and reason before Christians ever had the backing of the state. This is why manicheanism was so similar to catharism, because it's manicheanism resurrected in a Christian skinsuit.>There was even a Gospel of JudasYeah, I've read it, it's bunk.
>>226170247*different god.Anyways, a couple worthwhile texts on this subject I've quite enjoyed reading which will help disprove Gnosticism to you are:1. The Bible (if you have questions about the common interpretation, look it up or use a Bible that has a commentary)2. Runciman, the Medieval Manichee https://archive.org/details/medievalmanichee0000runc_o0a63. Against Heresies by St. Iraneus (in his time Gnosticism was prevalent enough to argue with, and Christians were a persecuted minority religion, contrary to your understanding, Constantine actually became emperor in the mid 300s, NOT right after Christ died, gnostics came and went on the basis of their own incoherence. This book is our most detailed primary source on what Gnostics actually believed and how they interpreted scripture, especially since the Nag Hammadi library wasn't discovered until the 20th century, buried in a jar in the sand, rather than in a cave. You're mixing them up with the dead sea scrolls, which were found in a series of caves).Beyond that, try engaging more broadly with the 2000 year tradition of Christianity that contains an almost laughable amount of discussion on every last verse in scripture. We have detailed commentaries going back to the Roman period, I've read for example large chunks of St. Jerome's commentary on Genesis.In short, no, the gospel was meant to be a message people could be taught by a teaching priest class (the Apostles, if you've heard of them) rather than the select few egyptians that died out 1600 years ago, or rather the millions of internet pseuds that think they discovered the greatest religious secret of all time from a YOUTUBE documentary about a text they've never actually read themselves.
>>226170247>literally tens of thousands of pages of exegetical work on themWould they really need to write that much if it was clear and reasonable in the first place? At the very least it shows there are problems and that you can write ten thousand pages justifying any particular point of view that you want. Just because there happens to be a lot written on it, doesn't mean they managed to solve it. From what I understand from regular religion class, is that the tree of knowledge and the snake were just there to tempt Adam and Eve and that their sin was disobeying god. Of course god knew everything and set everything up in advance because he's all powerful and all good, right? The gnostic interpretation is very simple: Yaldabaoth is not the true god, there are beings that exist outside of his material reality, the snake was one of them, either Sophia or Jesus or even Satan if you want, but the point is that he did not want Adam and Eve to have this "knowledge" because it reveals their true nature and made them more difficult to control. From that perspective, it makes sense why god would be very angry and would want to curse humanity to labor and procreation ("go forth and multiply" so that you go from two souls to 8 billion, literally just divide and conquer, same shit with the tower of babylon, more languages, more division...). It also explains why he had to do multiple resets over the years until he got a population that was ignorant of their true nature. It explains the problem of evil i.e. why does god allow evil if he is all powerful and all good - because he isn't all powerful and all good.
>>226170327>From what I understand from regular religion classExpecting your sunday school to give you a detailed adult understanding on scripture is like expecting a traditional French grammar class in highschool with a teacher that can't speak it to produce fluent speakers who can discuss and interpret Hugo effortlessly.>Yaldabaoth is not the true god, there are beings that exist outside of his material reality, the snake was one of them, either Sophia or Jesus or even Satan if you want, but the point is that he did not want Adam and Eve to have this "knowledge" because it reveals their true nature and made them more difficult to control.Words words words with no real basis in tradition or scripture to justify them. The amount of numerology gnostics would engage in to justify the naming and numbering of their aeons is so silly for example. Ultimately it still leads to an incoherent answer to the problem of evil that is worse than Christianity since it doesn't at all answer why God in his almightiness doesn't just destroy the Demiurge. It also reduces Christ's suffering to nothing since he supposedly isn't a real man who really suffered and really died. It makes the entire thing into nonsense and then tries to do some woo-woo ancient new-wave mumbo jumbo to slap on top of it.>he did not want Adam and Eve to have this "knowledge" because it reveals their true nature and made them more difficult to control.It is the tree of knowledge of good and evil. That's what it is named in scripture. Have you even read the first couple chapters of Genesis? Knowledge of good and evil made man (Adam) capable of doing evil, since before his "evil" actions were innocent, such as being naked, as he had no knowledge and was just acting according to his nature as part of God's creation, thereby meaning he could not sin. He simply existed, not doing wrong because he had no concept of it. Knowledge of good and evil gave us the ability to sin.
>>226165302Tengo dos hermanos y una hermana.Cuando despertarte en la mañana?Me gusta cafe pero prefiero te.Mi casa esta cerca a la estacion de tren.Hace frio hoy.Not sure about "esta cera" or "es cerca,% but esta is my gut feeling.
>>226170327Your logic basically amounts to "I don't understand this, and I won't bother to look it up, so someone needs to perform a spontaneous exegesis of half of the bible on the spot to me at a level I can understand, lest I decide to follow the roman-period equivalent of mumbo jumbo new age crystal crap."Or, put another way>seeming plot-hole in a bronze age religious text>assume Christians have never bothered to look into it>embrace a bizarre fanfic interpretation with even more plot holesI honestly have no idea how to even begin to respond to you not because your ideas have any merit but because you're so fundamentally uneducated and it's just not my job to spoonfeed you something like this in a thread where it would be off-topic anyways.>curse humanity to labor and procreation Procreation is not a curse and your life is not a curse. Part of why gnostics always go extinct when they crop up is actually because of all the sexual degeneracy that comes with teaching that sodomy is good and normal sex between loving people is bad.
>>226170408>Expecting your sunday school to give you a detailed adult understanding on scripture is like expecting a traditional French grammar class in highschool with a teacher that can't speak it to produce fluent speakers who can discuss and interpret Hugo effortlessly.Yes, none of it makes sense without 10000 pages of interpretations by the "priest class" who knew what they were doing. It's very convenient that you are not allowed to think for yourself.>Knowledge of good and evil made man (Adam) capable of doing evil, since before his "evil" actions were innocent, such as being naked, as he had no knowledge and was just acting according to his nature as part of God's creation, thereby meaning he could not sin. He simply existed, not doing wrong because he had no concept of it. Knowledge of good and evil gave us the ability to sin.Right, to me that just seems like writing yourself into a circle for 10000 pages again. It just creates more question than it solves.Why did god put the tree in the garden? Who was the snake and why did it tempt Eve? Why did god create the snake? Did the snake have the knowledge already? If yes, why was the snake trusted with this knowledge and humans weren't? Why did having the knowledge ruin humanity? It's not like Adam ate the apple then proceeded to smash Eve's head with a rock, knowing full well it's wrong. Why was being naked a sin? Why didn't god give Adam and Eve clothes since he knew it was a sin? Why did he curse humanity to labor and procreation? Does it become necessary once you know the difference between good and evil? All the classic, traditional, orthodox, whatever you want to call it, explanations are like this, surface-level rationalizations that you can make up on the spot to fool the goys.The gnostic interpretation is superior because it's simple, reasonable without 100000000 pages of priestly fanfiction and it just makes sense. Maybe the details are iffy, but the overall structure of the myth is true.
>>226165302Cuando era mas joven, visitaba mis abuelos cada verano.Si la tiempo esta bueno mañana, podemos hacer trekking.Llevo seis meses estudiando esta idioma, pero todavia hago errores.Ella me cuento que nunca viajo fuera de su pais.Aunque estaba cansado, decidi a acabar con leyendo este libro.Less sure about these. Not sure if there is a better way to say "I used to."Not sure if "hacer trekking" is right, but I remember that "trekking" is definitely a Spanish word.Not sure if llevo is the right tense or if you use it with the gerund or if you use "en" with the gerund ("en estudiando") here or not."Viajó" is right or not?"Acabar" can mean finish or is it more like quit?
>>226167431Native Korean here. Hanjamaxxing is a meme. It doesn't get you faster. It gets you around the long road. I don't even know the very basics, except for some numbers or months. But I was good enough to hit the top 1% in Korean SAT in Korean language without any problem.It's gonna be a long ass road, but It's not worth it.Learning Chinese characters to improve your Korean gives you a worse return on investment (ROI) than learning Latin to improve your EnglishIt might be the biggest scam when it comes to learning Korean
>>226170563>none of it makes senseThe gnostic interpretations make even less sense and conflict wildly with scripture (see infra)>It's very convenient that you are not allowed to think for yourself.Your lack of intellectual independence and willingness to read about any of this shows that you have at least imbibed this maxim from Sunday school.>Why did god put the tree in the garden? Who was the snake and why did it tempt Eve? Why did god create the snake? Did the snake have the knowledge already?Have you tried googling it, retard? Or, idk, reading the Bible?Here's some assorted lines from the Gospel of John 1. I'll do a little exegesis for you, the bizarre technique of reading scripture directly and thinking about it. Famously such things are forbidden which is why the Bible is difficult to find and rarely published. I can read this in Greek and Latin for the record and can speak that the translation is uncontroversial.>1 In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.>3 All things were made by him; and without him was not any thing made that was made.>10 He was in the world, and the world was made by him>14 And the Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us, (and we beheld his glory, the glory as of the only begotten of the Father,) full of grace and truth.1. the Word (Jesus Christ) existed in the beginning, and was with God, and was God [πρὸς τὸν θεόν, καὶ θεὸς ἦν ὁ λόγος.] Trinitarianism exists to describe this verse and many others throughout Scripture3 + 10. Everything was made by him (Jesus Christ, the Word, God) Therefore, the world was made by God, not by the demiurge, and Jesus Christ was there in this. God came to the world THAT HE MADE, and not some second higher god coming from a higher realm to a world he did not make.14. The Word/God became FLESH (Jesus Christ) meaning he had a real physical body, he didn't fly through Mary's ear or act as a hologram at the crucifixion.
>>>226170519>Your logic basically amounts to "I don't understand this, and I won't bother to look it up, so someone needs to perform a spontaneous exegesis of half of the bible on the spot to me at a level I can understand, lest I decide to follow the roman-period equivalent of mumbo jumbo new age crystal crap."My logic is: this doesn't make any sense and it never made any sense. Here's an interpretation that fills in the gaps in the original text and gives a reasonable myth that rings true to what we actually experience. The priest class doesn't even give a fuck that you are confused by their desert myths, it's part of the humiliation ritual that you just blindly accept everything and rely on "faith". And if you are so inclined to question it, you can be referred to 10000 pages of misdirection. If any of those books contained truth, they would be burned and destroyed.>Procreation is not a curse and your life is not a curse. Part of why gnostics always go extinct when they crop up is actually because of all the sexual degeneracy that comes with teaching that sodomy is good and normal sex between loving people is bad.Kek, but why did Yaldabaoth make anal sex feel good if he didn't want us to do sodomy? Please tell me there is a 500 page treatise by St. Whatever that goes over why peepee does not go into poopoo.Procreation is a curse and specifically a punishment. Or do you not think that having a melon-sized object come out of your vagina is not a curse? Face it, none of the bible stuff makes any sense if god is not evil.
>>226170649>dude, just read the bible!!>aka the collected texts that we shaped through centuries, carefully removing all the relevant context so that it's rendered completely meaningless and a bunch of extra fluff like "how many angels can dance on the head of pin" that's extremely important to understanding why we live in a literal hell dimension
>>226170563>Who was the snake and why did it tempt Eve?before i go to bed i wanted to respond and tell you that the snake is literally da debil
>>226170653>Here's an interpretation that fills in the gaps in the original text*the gaps in your own knowledge>gives a reasonable myth >mythSo you don't even believe it.>The priest class doesn't even give a fuckThey're the magisterium (teaching order) and the reason there are so many pages of theology is because 2000 years of people have had to re explain the same things over and over to people. There are many summaries much shorter than 10,000 pages and I'm sure you could find some at your level quite easily if you just bothered to look.>Kek, but why did Yaldabaoth make anal sex feel good if he didn't want us to do sodomy?I mean, so does doing heroin.>Procreation is a curse and specifically a punishment.You are a nihilist.>Or do you not think that having a melon-sized object come out of your vagina is not a curse? The pain of childbirth is a punishment, yes.>none of the bible stuff makes any sense if god is not evil.That's the root of your beliefs. You're not even a gnostic you're just some kind of agnostic or atheist who is attracted to 'forbidden knowledge' (that anyone can easily find in a youtube documentary by some blithering semi-literate baboon).>>dude, just read the bible!!That's what I thought we were discussing but again I should have realized that a pseud gnostic would have some justification for not reading the 2 page selection of scripture they base their entire belief system on (Gen 2-3).>>aka the collected texts that we shaped through centuries, carefully removing all the relevant context so that it's rendered completely meaningless and a bunch of extra fluff like "how many angels can dance on the head of pin" that's extremely important to understanding why we live in a literal hell dimensionThe Summa Theologiae is a dense gargantuan encyclopedia meant for theology students so of course it handles a lot of issues, the point is that angels don't have corporeal mass.
>>226170653You need the Creator to be evil because you've already decided that life is not worth living. Maybe that's why you post walls of text 100x per thread about how horrible it is that you'll never be native in your second language, because you mental issues that make you focus on everything bad and completely disregard the good. I hope you get out of this state of being since I fully sympathize with you and understand how difficult life can become when your head's not in the right space. Your life is worth living.However, I think your beliefs about religion are retarded pseud crap. Good night.
>>226170712Sure, but why did he create the Devil, a literal embodiment of evil and just let it run around in his garden? Let me guess, the cope is "without evil, good can't exist"? I'm sure there's a way to reason yourself out of every plothole with enough pages of drivel.>>226170753>So you don't even believe it.I do believe it, I think the details are iffy, but the overall structure of the gnostic myth is True and mirrored in reality. You can also see the exact same structure in other religions. I am more and more convinced each day that we are living in material prison created by an evil deity that does not want us to know our true nature. The very structure of life itself is evil, procreation, eating of the flesh of other living beings, endless competition, hierarchy, driven by bodies and its impulses that overpower the soul. How can you look at this world and think that it was created out love? >I mean, so does doing heroin.We created heroin, but we didn't engineer the prostate to be in that position. Just sayin'.>The Summa Theologiae is a dense gargantuan encyclopedia meant for theology students so of course it handles a lot of issues, the point is that angels don't have corporeal mass.Uhh, glad we cleared that up, that was one of my burning questions.
>>226170802I didn't decide, I observed it, gnosticism or the structure of its myth explains it. Also, believe me, not being able to learn a language to fluency after 25+ sucks, but it's not even in the Top 100 reasons I think we're living in the hell dimension.Good night, I hope you don't fall for the demiurge's tricks in your next life.
>>226170843serbro, we wouldn't have a story if we didn't have an antagonist to push the narrative along. nobody wants to read a big old fat tome where it's just two jobless homos (sapiens) bumming it around a tree cutting genital-shaped fig leaves to adhere to their wibbly bits
>>226170653>anal sex feel goodHow did you discover this?>>226170843>eating of the flesh of other living beings>anon spent this much time arguing with a gay veganHe must really care.>we didn't engineer the prostate to be in that positionStill gotta engineer some other dude’s dick into your asshole
Translated the WotLK cinematic to Latin as an exercise. Accents are to mark long vowels, not stress. Feedback appreciated."My son, the day you were born, the very forests of Lordaeron whispered the name Arthas.My child, I watched with pride as you grew into a weapon of righteousness.Remember, our line has always ruled with wisdom and strength. And I know you will show restraint when exercising your great power.But the truest victory, my son, is stirring the hearts of your people. I tell you this, for when my days have come to an end, you shall be King."“Filí mí, dié quo nátus fuistí, ipsae silvae Lórdaeróní nómen susurrábant: Arthas.Puer mí, cum superbiá observábam, dum in arma iustitiae crescebas.Mementó: stirps nostra semper cum sapientiá et fortitúdine réxit. Et sció te abstinentiam praestáberis cum exercés magnam opem tuam. Sed victória vérissima, filí mí, est commovére corda populí tuí. Hoc tibi dicó: cum diés meí ad fínem pervénerint, tú eris réx.”
>>226170609being a native korean, you already have an intuitive understanding of hanja roots, even if you've never learned a single hanja character, just as an english native intuitively understands latin roots without knowing latin. I have no such intuition, so learning the roots really helps me remember and make sense of sino-korean words. otherwise its just an impenetrable wall of two syllable words that all sound the same. they also don't roll off the tongue like native korean words they all just sound like ching chang chong
>>226171008>How did you discover this?You never put a fingey up there just to see what it's like? Might change your life.I eat meat because it tastes good and because I'm completely detached from how its produced, maybe it would be different if I had to slaughter my own piggies for bacon, who knows. The world is full of suffering and being a vegan is largely just dumb virtue signaling that does fuck all to decrease it, same as being a Christian.>>226170978It's just a bad story, is what I'm saying. I like when the magic system and cosmology of the worldbuilding actually make sense.
first time back on /int/ since like 2016, what happened to the interpals thread? do any of you guys use interpals still?
>>226167347Latin is easier than French for a native Romance speaker
>>226169991>Then you have the entirety of the Old Testament where this merciful god just goes berserk mode on humanity, then suddenly turns the leaf and becomes "love your neighbor".you realise the "love your neighbour" is literally in the "old testament" (leviticus 19:18)? the false testament is the real problem, it's complete nonsense. christians are completely loston the fruit:https://youtu.be/JAvsy8ZOc_0
>>226169991>It solves a lot of inconsistencies, it solves the problem of evil, it solves the problem of why we are here in the first place Judaism already did that thousands of years before gnosticism was even a thing https://youtu.be/zy8OLzy-Zyc?t=16>and why it seems like we're in literal hell and why material reality feels so foreign to someone with a divine soul.you feel you're in literally hell because you have zero trust in God, so of course your life is horrible https://youtu.be/BWOlX-loZFk?t=2material reality is supposed to be enjoyed, but there is a right way and a wrong way to do everything. this is not something a christian or an atheist would have any idea about though. in fact the sages themselves teach how a person can become wealthy in this world while christians hate wealth (and children, hence why their priests are forbidden from marrying and having children while in Judaism polygeny is allowed)https://youtu.be/nV8-Wc0b6PMhttps://youtu.be/2S5mkE7lXOY
>>226171078Makes sense to me at least, one of the trickiest parts about advanced level spoken Japanese is basically the same thing and it would be a pain to learn without that extra reference to anchor what kou #263 means in a specific context. Hearing some new two syllable Chinese word basically has me flipping through a mental kanji dictionary to figure out what it means. Besides it's not like Chinese characters are that difficult to learn anyway after the initial hump, especially if Korean was less retarded with how it used them.
>>226171828Confusing with all the hebrew/yiddish words, but the point, self-control? Then the question arises, why would god give you desires that you can't control or need willpower to control?The Jews are quite amusing. Did you know they wrap a string around their entire neighborhood so that they're technically inside their house on the Sabbat? They built a whole discipline out of tricking god. Yaldabaoth's chosen people.
>>226171979>why would god give you desires that you can't control or need willpower to control?did you not watch the video? the whole point is to make heaven feel deserved to the soul
>>226172192Yeah, I stopped watching. What's the point of it being in English if he's throwing random gibberish in every 5 seconds that isn't even picked up by the auto-transcription?>the whole point is to make heaven feel deserved to the soulWell, I'm convinced. This world is so dogshit so that when we go to heaven, the contrast will feel like pure bliss.
>>226171979>They built a whole discipline out of tricking god.they're not tricking anything, they've strictly applied their legal codehttps://www.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/700456/jewish/What-Is-an-Eruv.htmthat nonsense about tricking God is something people like christians and nazis (same thing), who don't even attempt to keep anything from the Torah, have the chutzpah to say. it's unbelievable how hypocritical and retarded the antisemites are
>>226172240>What's the point of it being in English if he's throwing random gibberish in every 5 seconds that isn't even picked up by the auto-transcription?don't worry, there's the German channel too thenhttps://youtube.com/@rabbiyaronreuvendeenjoy
>>226172247Are you actually Jewish or just a wannabe? You can't just start using Yiddish slang and think you're one of them, bud. Oy vey, can you believe the chutzpah on this schmuck? It ain't kosher, is all I'm gonna say.>>226172288Lol, the AI voiceover is actually much clearer unironically.
>>226169678How could a loving god create beings in human form without souls (hylics) just for them to suffer and never find redemption?
>>226172395spoiler: he's not very loving
i wonder when people will realise that any perceived contradiction in popular belief has already been argued to death for centuries or millennia and logically explained, maybe they just don't think that far ahead or assume anything that conforms to their preconceived opinion is ultimately correct
>>226171078I'm gonna debunk this take but I should go to work for a part time job
what's some rare or niche languages you guys want to learn or are learning and why
>>226172858is Hebrew niche or rare?
>>226171546I thought it was dead
>>226172858I'll get around to old norse some day, I want to read the eddas and poetry in their original form since they are heavy on word play and rhyme that is mostly lost in a modernized version. Being able to read the rune stones you find standing along roads or in towns would be really cool as well.
>>226172858Cherokee. I'm not native American but it sounds cool as fuck and the writing system is neat.
>>226173765why not Navajo?
>>226171546everyone moved on to apps hellotalk, italki, tandem
>>226173399An interesting thing about runic inscriptions is how irregular the spelling is. For example, an Old Norse sentence like>Haraldr konungr bað gøra kuml þessiwould be written as>ᚼᛅᚱᛅᚾᛏᚱ ᛬ ᚴᚢᚾᚢᚴᚱ ᛬ ᛒᛅᚦ ᛬ ᚴᛅᚢᚱᚢᛅ ᛬ ᚴᚢᛘᛚ ᛬ ᚦᛅᚢᛋᛁwhich would be transliterated as>haraltr : kunukr : baþ : kaurua : kubl : þausiYou can see that a lot of nasals are dropped; that there's often no distinction between voiced and voiceless stops; and that the vowels are all confused
>>226173989https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherokee,_North_CarolinaI'm only a couple of hours away from this place where they actually use the language
>>226167162Yeah, but why German, not Swedish or Spanish
>>226172858Tigrinya
Crede mihi, non est Veneris properanda voluptas,Sed sensim tarda prolicienda mora.Ad metam properate simul: tum plena voluptas,Cum pariter victi femina virque iacent.
>>226177273>Ad metam properate simulSimul? Equidem properabo; utrum illa me sequatur necne, non flocci facio
>ser translates to "be">soy isn't "i am" it's "i be"
>>226169991there were also some forgeries in the manuscripts (of the Bible) that were copied, for example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_16#Longer_ending_3
>>226178548and literal fanfictions quoted by christians to this day as if they really happened https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jesus_and_the_woman_taken_in_adultery
>>226178524Nigga wat ?
>always read that B D G in Chinese pinyin are actually unaspirated voiceless stops, not voiced stops>they sound exactly like B D G in English>turns out word-initial B D G in English are not true voiced stops; they're the same as Mandarin's unaspirated voiceless stops>English B D G are only truly voiced in the middle of wordsDamn, I've been pulling my hair out trying to hear a difference that doesn't actually exist
>>226178661Ser means "to be"Sou means "i be"
>>226178720nigga that's not how conjugation works
>>226178746Says who?Other words don't change from be to am
>>226178774Sou = 1st person present singular indicative active form of ser in PortugueseI am = 1st person present singular indicative active form of to be in EnglishIf you want to speak broken Portuguese like "I be" it would be "Eu ser" something equivalent
why is cure dolly so recommended?
I would never learn spanish
since we were talking about the Bible, what I don't like is that I can't really find the New Vulgate (the slightly corrected Latin translation of the Bible) that the Vatican published, it seems like no one has it for salethere's the Stuttgart Vulgate, but I'd be more interested in an edition that would stay more true to the earliest OT/NT Greek, Hebrew etc. manuscripts rather than manuscripts of Jerome's Vulgateit also has punctuation
>>226179519Go to the Vatican and as for it
>>226179903it's a little far away from Lithuania
>>226179966You got $47 right?
>>226179519I got a pretty good deal on an edition based on the Codex Amiatinus
>>226180032>flyingwe don't do that in lithuaniahttps://www.lrt.lt/en/news-in-english/19/3111025/drone-incursions-trigger-air-alerts-across-lithuania-nato-jets-scrambled
>>226172631>any perceived contradiction in popular belief has already been argued to death for centuries or millennia and logically explained,Some people do realize this. Some people don’t. The people who don’t are pseuds because they make zero effort to engage with the great debate before forming their opinions.>assume anything that conforms to their preconceived opinion is ultimately correctYes this is largely the case with gnostics. But I suppose it’s largely the case with most people so who cares. However, my main problem is that in, say, Judaism, Catholicism, Orthodoxy, and some Protestants, I can easily find fairly large contingents online who at least know their own traditions fairly well and often other traditions too and can be argued with. I have yet to meet a Gnostic who falls into the latter category, they’re overwhelmingly idiots of the former. Ironically if my memory doesn’t deceive me this is basically why St. Augustine ultimately became disillusioned with Manicheanism, eventually helping lead to his conversion to Christianity, since he realized behind all the mumbo jumbo there were no real answers or intellectual rigor or depth.
>>226178548Even taking the theory that it was added in the 100s, which is not itself established IMO, that’s still long before the Church recognized the canonical version of the text which included it. And the text itself is not particularly important considering Mark probably was just left somewhat unfinished since it was possibly an early translation of Matthew into Greek initially. That’s not a forgery, you’re just using loaded vocabulary to express scorn, bias, and a lack of serious examination of the subject matter.
The exact relation of the synoptic gospels to each other is fascinating. One of the benefits of studying classical langs is that it exposes you to textual criticism and the process of transmission
>>226180032Ryanair and Easyjet are truly a blessing for the european language learner
>>226180316Yeah I never thought I’d be a bible guy it just sort of happened through the course of studying the langs. Or I should say that I’m distinctly NOT a bible guy, just a guy that reads the bible a lot.The core of the debate, which people usually fail to identify, instead bringing up a lot of irrelevant side stuff, can be split into two parts. The first is whether you believe He came back from the dead. Gnostics and Muslims technically don’t believe this at all, and believe all the scripture to that effect is lying, but let’s say for the sake of argument hologram or body double death on the cross still count. If you take it that Jesus came back from the dead, well, then the debate moves to the second stage because only God can raise someone from the dead like that. The second stage is determining then what Jesus taught and what the implications of that are. In this debate is the real meat of the discussion. If people can’t argue about this second prong then their position is likely formed on something wholly unrelated to scripture, and their beliefs about God are often just statements about their own life/personality rather than the product of serious examination. For the Serb, his belief in God, as he said, has no basis in scripture or any miracles or anything at all, except that he is miserable, so reality is miserable, and so the gnostic take insofar as he even understands it simply fits his depressive personality better. In essence, when they talk about God, they’re really talking about themselves, and projecting their beliefs as a speck in the Universe onto its almighty creator.I actually once found gnosticism interesting although I never seriously believed it, when I was like 15, because I too was quite sad and couldn’t square the problem of evil, but that was before I came to the abiding conviction (faith) that Jesus came back from the dead. Once that came, Gnosticism went since the evidence goes against Jesus teaching that.
>>226179031Genius autist who gives lucid explanations quickly.
>>226180998On the question of the gospels' authenticity, I agree with you. I was referring more to the composition of the gospels, i. e. in what order the gospels were composed; what material informed the gospels; whether they were generic works; etc. Though this also touches on the question of authenticity because it matters whether you believe that the gospels were written or informed by eye-witnesses or whether you believe that they are purely the products of a literary tradition.
>>226181475Of course, I just felt like writing more about the central issue with debates about Christianity and related religions in general and didn't have any other particular post to respond to, so it makes it look like I'm responding to you.The main point of that wall of text being that religious debates, especially online, rarely get out of the initial fog of vague assertions and name calling. In part I feel it's because people don't state their opinions plainly, and shroud it in some appeal to some religious tradition, and instead turn it into a game where you have to whittle down what they're even trying to say into something intelligible. I.e. a bunch of stuff about le bible and about le dumb christians ultimately ends up not even being worth arguing because it can be whittled down to "I hate being alive."
>>226180998>For the Serb, his belief in God, as he said, has no basis in scripture or any miracles or anything at all, except that he is miserable, so reality is miserableMaterial reality is miserable for everyone. There is something fundamentally wrong with having a soul attached to a meat-skeleton that has to devour other meat-things and needs to shut down for 8 hours regularly to hallucinate otherwise it goes crazy or dies. When the meat-skeleton is not hungry, it seeks out other meat-skeletons to rape and create more meat-skeletons to repeat the cycle. Because there is not enough for everyone to eat and rape, one must fight other meat-skeletons and take their stuff, of course, remembering to sacrifice some for Yaldabaoth and only him, not the other gods (he gets jealous).>I actually once found gnosticism interesting although I never seriously believed it, when I was like 15, because I too was quite sad and couldn’t square the problem of evil, but that was before I came to the abiding conviction (faith) that Jesus came back from the dead. Once that came, Gnosticism went since the evidence goes against Jesus teaching that.I guess I'm still stuck "being 15 and sad" but I don't know how believing Jesus rose from the dead suddenly cures any of that. You don't know his true message, it could've been obfuscated or simply erased. You have nothing but blind faith that god is good and he wouldn't deceive you like that, and you have to ignore his entire creation to believe that. Of course you can rationalize all of it, life is suffering so that the soul can feel like it has earned heaven. Yes, heaven is waiting for you, not endless death and re-birth, cuz that would make you feel sad and god wouldn't do that.
>>226182295I don't see why Catholicism (or Protestantism, Orthodox Christianity) are any worse at making people feel better about their conditionsremember, the 'opium of the people' was a term applied to modern Christianity
>>226182295>There is something fundamentally wrong Yes, we disagree on the what and the why but we can't meaningfully debate that for the reasons I articulated above.>one must fight other meat-skeletons and take their stuff, of courseYeah but that's epic and based and redpilled.>I don't know how believing Jesus rose from the dead suddenly cures any of thatBecause then it means he obviously has power over life and death as God or God supports what he's saying, either way, it demonstrates his teaching authority.>You don't know his true messageI do know it definitely wasn't Gnosticism.>You have nothing but blind faith that god is good and he wouldn't deceive you like that.See you don't know what Gnostics believe, or you can't remember it when arguing. Christ in Gnosticism was sent by the good God to tell the truth. Both our faiths claim Christ was a truth-teller we just disagree on what he said. I think the evidence far more strongly favors Christianity than the obviously later Manicheanism skinsuiting Christianity.>life is suffering so that the soul can feel like it has earned heaven. You're mixing up the brazillian's posts with mine. This isn't the Christian position, I articulated it roughly in prior posts.>Yes, heaven is waiting for you, not endless death and re-birth, cuz that would make you feel sad and god wouldn't do that.Don't gnostics believe they're gonna escape death and rebirth anyways? You literally believe this. The high God in his outer dimension is where you're escaping to, and this has to be real because surely he wouldn't make a world where suffering happens, that would be mean :(Okay so let's get back to the core debate. Do you believe Jesus had some kind of teaching authority, whether through coming back from the dead, or being a hologram who pretended to die who flew into Mary's ear; whether as God incarnate, or a revealer sent by the high god to tell the epic ensouled wizard chuds how to escape the material world.
>>226182295>When the meat-skeleton is not hungry, it seeks out other meat-skeletons to rapeyou think skeletons solely engage in rape? you think there's no consensual coming together to bone? this is just about as bad as that jew loving alg brazilian
>>226182672>Because then it means he obviously has power over life and death as God or God supports what he's saying, either way, it demonstrates his teaching authority.Not necessarily. Jesus was just another being that was powerful enough to enter our material reality and spread the word and perform some miracles and come back after death - but that doesn't make him the master of this realm. Yaldabaoth can obfuscate and destroy his message over time, he could build an institution called the Church that spreads his lies and kills all the "heretics". Maybe a couple scrolls here and there get found in a cave, but overall, gnosticism is an obscure, melodramatic quasi-religion for pseuds and sad teenage boys that haven't matured yet. He won in the end.>I do know it definitely wasn't Gnosticism.Obviously neither you or I know. You can trust in your goy fan fiction, but obviously you don't know and there's no way to verify it. You can observe reality and question why such a loving god would create it that way, but you will chalk it up to teenage angst, you're an adult now and adults are biased towards whatever helps them function in the world. If you believed that you were in hell, how could you show up to your stupid job and take your kids to school? It's best not to think about it.>Christ in Gnosticism was sent by the good God to tell the truth. Both our faiths claim Christ was a truth-teller we just disagree on what he said.Yes, but the message is lost. Believing in gnosticism doesn't save you, only gnosis saves you, and apparently this knowledge is either lost or only kept in secrecy. I'm going to die and get my memory wiped like every other soul and I won't be able to stop the archons from bringing me back.
>>226183027Theres no such thing as consent when every action we take is influenced by hormones
Observing a lot of off-topic posts
>>226182672>Don't gnostics believe they're gonna escape death and rebirth anyways? You literally believe this. The high God in his outer dimension is where you're escaping to, and this has to be real because surely he wouldn't make a world where suffering happens, that would be mean :(No, that's the part that sucks, I don't have the actual steps to achieve gnosis. Yaldabaoth can't stop you from noticing the fundamental evil of material reality, but it's not like that's enough to stop you from reincarnating. "Just don't go towards the light" is the best advice we got based on near-death experiences. I don't think it's enough.>>226183027Rape was the norm throughout history. Men used to just jump over the river and kill all the males and take their children and wives as slaves to rape. Modern society obfuscates the animal within us, but it's still there. We are still just fighting over resources and pussy, and we will continue to do that until we escape the flesh prison.>>226183183Language learning has been solved, but salvation is still an open question.
Locking this thread due to off-topic posts. Only based atheists may reply now.
>>226183256>Language learning has been solved, but salvation is still an open question.Okay, but I need all of you to tell which language to learn
>>226183309When in doubt, pick a powerful language from the top of the Power Language Index.https://www.kailchan.ca/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Kai-Chan_Power-Language-Index-full-report_2016_v2.pdfAnd everything else being equal, it's just a matter of taste.
>>226183097>obviously you don't know and there's no way to verify itI think everyone needs a thorough education in critical examination of primary sources and approximating verisimilitude cause this is just anti-intellectual.>goy fan fictionGnostics are goys/gentiles. You are a goy. Jews believe Christ to be an illegitimate messiah so they believe Christians to be goys, but Christians are not goys, non-Christians and non-Jews are goyim. >I'm going to die and get my memory wiped like every other soulNo you’re not, if you don’t seek God in this lifetime you will go to hell forever. Seek God with an honest heart NOW. YOLO.>>226183256Bro doesn’t even read the literature on gnosis. Make sense since he hasn’t even read the 300 word section of scripture he bases his beliefs on.>>226183183>>226183291My only defense is that he brought up Gnosticism and my only response was essentially that we ought to ignore the topic as pseud crap. I believe the quality of his posts vindicate my original position that the gnostic position is pseud crap.>>226183309Latin. Latin and Greek to engage with Classics is great. Latin for religious studies is great. Greek for religious studies or philosophy requires purity of heart and sufficient background knowledge to not just turn it into a party trick about how “ackshually that word means XYZ because I ‘read’ da Bible in da ORIGINAL language.” Reading without understanding is worthless.
>>226183309Hindi, the fact that it's spoken by so many people and that India is a developing country means that eventually, everything you will ever want to read will be translated into Hindi, while you might struggle to find books translated into English sometimesreally, just go with Hindi
>>226183508>if you don’t seek God in this lifetime you will go to hell foreverI'm already in it, but I'm looking forward to being a two headed baby in India in my next cycle. You'll be a rich man with a big cock in your next life for defending the demiurge. You earned it, bud.
>>226182295>that has to devour other meat-thingsno one has to, they just choose to. it is in fact cheaper and healthier to devour plant-things
This has to be a troll right? That one Anon can't possibly believe what he's saying
>>226183309Hebrew so you don't become a christian
>>226183798Vegan diet is pretty bad for you, even if you make sure to take all your required vitamins and other shit you can't get from your diet. People think they can just substitute meat with protein from plants, but not all protein is equal and the one from meat is just much higher quality.But yeah, in this day and age, you have the luxury to eat a plant based diet if you so desire. It doesn't make a difference in the overall total of suffering in the world, but it's a nice gesture. It's like recycling your paper and plastics, some Indian is on the other side of the world will make sure he pollutes 100x more to even it all out in the end.
How can we be living in hell when we have so many languages to learn? And so much music to enjoy?https://youtu.be/QiXpDlcEE34
>>226184726We made a hobby out of it, but let's not forget the original purpose of languages was to divide humanity. There's a built in speed limit to how fast you can learn and how deeply as well. We've invented little games in our prison to entertain ourselves, but one day in pure soul form would be better than an entire lifetime of sense pleasure. Rather than experiencing a smidge of a fraction of a speck of beauty through little air vibrations, we could experience beauty directly as an emanation from the source.>>226185174Wish I had a view like that.
>>226185309Top two pics in your meme aren't even that grim, just a bit inconvenientBottom left only bothers you if you have some superiority complex and care what other people spend money onBottom right is a compromise and often far better than dying in the streets in old age, which many elderly with no family would otherwise be reduced to
>>226185309>the original purpose of languages was to divide humanityfeel free to learn Hebrew since that's the language everyone spoke back in Noah's times
Jesus spoke Aramaic and English
>>226183705Maybe the other head will be Jordie’s soul. I guess growing up affluent means I’ll know more languages.>>226184726If Babel didn’t fall Latin wouldn’t have existed. God created the nations. It’s sovl.>>226185309>purpose was to divide humanityIronically the purpose of antichrists is to confuse and muddle Christ’s quite clear teachings and delegitimize his church. You’re actually acting as an agent of the deceiver because the message you preach is nihilism and hopelessness.>>226185591Nuh uh it was Adamic, which John Dee had revealed to him as gramatically identical to English and had the same phonetic inventory.
Wait till you all hear about Reformed Egyptian
>>226185309BTW, do you have any more acoustic guitar songs in German that you recommend?
It's become clear that the learning methods we endorse here are directly tied to our general views on life
>>226185309there are literal miracles dropping just this week and you're an unironic gnostic?https://youtu.be/_byNqJDEYxs?t=3637https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/oct/01/hero-pilot-stabbed-flydubai-plane-flight-israel>>226185791>quite clear teachings like this one?https://www.reddit.com/r/Christianity/comments/21dthp/it_is_certainly_the_most_embarrassing_verse_in/
holy off topic, can you guys bring it to /his/ or /x/?
>>226185995https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DLwDfqxcl1Ihttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gs8Ni82S7k0https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6fB4cG5FDoMI have trouble finding good German music.My Swedish playlist has 174 tracks after a year while my German one only has 45 tracks after 4 years.
>>226184182>Vegan diet is pretty bad for you, even if you make sure to take all your required vitamins and other shit you can't get from your diet. People think they can just substitute meat with protein from plants, but not all protein is equal and the one from meat is just much higher quality.you have no idea what you're talking about
>>226186844https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hJNF2_dCWkgThis is the video I remember watching. Vegans usually look pretty skinny and sickly after a few years, some eventually realize they have nutritional deficiencies that can only be satisfied with actual meat.
>>226186251I suppose if your Greek sucks and you don't think about it or ask anyone it would certainly be confusing. γενεὰ and generation are not the same concepts, because the GNT is famously lexically narrow, ESPECIALLY the gospel of Mark and of John, John by it's clarity and repetition, Mark by it's relative plainness and paucity of theological matters. Picrel for an example from St. Jerome, who wrote the Vulgate, on how many meanings Λόγος has in Latin, for example (we have voluminous commentaries on the Bible and explanations of his translations by the way). Also, bringing up a C.S. Lewis line, when C.S. Lewis went from atheist to devout Christian, maybe should make you wonder if it's as important as you think. Besides why are you unironically posting reddit links, I ain't finna engage with that junk.
does this happen in your TL?
>>226187628I have grown heavily disillusioned with my idea of Japan and I'm thinking of dropping it as a language
>>226186251Also, the reason you can only communicate in sneering remarks is because you are doing the classic technique of bad-faith religious discussion where you endlessly nitpick your interlocutor's faith while having literally no critical examination of your own faith. The inquiry a Jew engages in should not be "Is Christianity false?" it rather ought to be "Why is Judaism true? And why is it more plainly true than Christianity?" All I can say in that regard is that, were I not a Christian, I certainly would find Judaism even less convincing. Any flat-earther UFO-truther can criticize pastor bob's articulation of Christianity, but can he advance his own faith and defend it from criticism? It's not my job to defend Christianity from your every criticism, but it is your job to explain why Judaism is closer to the Truth. But further off-topic posting at this point would just be silly so I'll leave it at that.>>226187833I did this, linguistically.>>226187628Japan is unironically like this doe
>>226186377TY Serbie.>I have trouble finding good German music.Me too, but if I find some that I like, I'll post it.
>>226187857>why Judaism is closer to the Truth.jesus himself said it's the truth>Then Jesus said to the crowds and to his disciples: 2 “The teachers of the law and the Pharisees sit in Moses’ seat. 3 So you must be careful to do everything they tell you. But do not do what they do, for they do not practice what they preach. 4 They tie up heavy, cumbersome loads and put them on other people’s shoulders, but they themselves are not willing to lift a finger to move them.>5 “Everything they do is done for people to see: They make their phylacteries[a] wide and the tassels on their garments long; 6 they love the place of honor at banquets and the most important seats in the synagogues; 7 they love to be greeted with respect in the marketplaces and to be called ‘Rabbi’ by others.phylacteries are all from the Oral Torah btw, there's no description of the little boxes in the Written Torah
>>226187397>le youtube essayThe vast majority of research supports more plant-based diets. Almost all of the people on the longevity leaderboard are on a plant-based or near plant-based diet. All of the blue zones with longest longevity are nearly plant based diets.The only nutrients you need to supplement on a vegan diet are b12 (which is not produced by animals it's produced by bacteria in dirt and natural bodies of water, and we don't get it because our food is cleaned and sterilized. even animals in factory farms get it supplemented) and DHA which is hard to get enough from meat anyways you need either fish or algae supplement. Everything else you can either get from plant foods or produce on your own most things like creatine humans self-produce. On the contrary there are millions of phytonutrients that you can only get from plants, including things that are good for the brain like anthocyanins and carotenoids that most people get hardly any of - or fiber, which 98% of people are statistically deficient in (compared to almost no one who is protein deficient). Also the 'meat = poor people food lol' argument is so retarded I can't believe anyone would mention it in good faith. Meat is literally like 5x more expensive per calorie than things like beans or whole grains and that's despite it being artificially cheaper than it should be because of industry subsidies
>>226188349>t.
>>226187857>bad-faith religious discussionthe rabbis already discussed christianity to death on multiple occasions and even today Tovia Singer continues to show how nonsensical christianity is (it's so easy to see how stupid christianity is, for example, how can jesus be the messiah, a descendant of David, and at the same time be the son of God? As far as I know God isn't from the tribe of Judah, and how was mary, a jewish woman, married to joseph, if she was a virgin and jews are legally required to have sex to get married?)https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disputation_of_Barcelona>All I can say in that regard is that, were I not a Christian, I certainly would find Judaism even less convincing.Your loss then because it's pretty clear the God of Israel is still helping Orthodox Judaism and their religious folks https://youtu.be/A04yz1EwNZw?t=2724
>>226188193Yeah, the law was brought through Moses from God because the Israelites WERE his chosen people. Jews were obligated to follow the law. Your conclusion is a non-sequitur from that that betrays a basic lack of knowledge of Christianity. Christ came and in his life lived the law in order that by his death its purpose would be fulfilled (that there be a holy people in the right time and place for God to send the Messiah). Elsewhere in scripture multiple times Christ speaks at length about how the old rotten branch will be cut off and how new branches will be grafted on from the nation. He founds a new priesthood (in the order of Melchizedek) when he washes the apostles, like Aaron did with his sons. 12 apostles for 12 tribes, this new covenant fulfills the old, as the many prophecies in the psalms and prophets are fulfilled that Israel (the Church) will through the Messiah bring all nations together in worship. The Old Testament is our book, man.>phylacteries are from the oral torahWhy does that matter.I feel kind of retarded for even engaging with this since it’s more off-topic, and you’re still really doing the same junk where you out of context snide and criticize Christianity instead of explaining why the universal truth of the universe is held by Rabbi Schmuley who sucks newborns you-know-what. Didn’t you guys hear? The messiah came! You don’t have to genitally mutilate newborns anymore!
>>226188534Oh yeah Titus came and obliterated everything because the Jews won. Maimonedes said to pray for the death of all Christians daily because he sure wasn’t bitter. Where is your temple, your sacrifices, your priesthood? Oh wait the Levites are gone and are never coming back, because the genealogies are all lost. Sounds like maybe a narrow ethnoreligion actually ISNT universal truth? Crazy I know.
>>226188602>Titus came and obliterated everything because the Jews won.where's rome again?oh, that's right. nowhere. where's Israel?oh right, it's still here.
>>226188775>where's rome again?This is like saying Israel didn’t exist during the time of the judges because they didn’t have a unified government. Rome is the capital of the Church, which has priests in every country on Earth. Rome politically fragmented. Even David’s kingdom didn’t make it 3 generations before fragmenting. Bro the West has ruled the world for hundreds of years and the only reason you guys even have any land to your own is because we gave it to you. Yeah it’s easy to blow up some farmers when Christians are giving you our F-35s.
>british women are beginning to copy american women who in turn copy hollywood actresses to try to become like the characters in their movies and showswhy? WHY?!
>>226189644i meant accent wisei hate the vocal fryi ahye vocal fry in English i hate the bitchy lewd accent young women put i hate their lack of vocalisation to larp as men with a deep voicei hate hollywood for ruining my TL (English)southern americans will be the last bastion of the English language it seems
>>226189678in fact even italian women are copying the american women and putting vocal fry in their voices, if you watch enough youtubers from Italy you'll notice in their Italian
when do i use what's your opinion on and what's your opinion of by the way? or are they interchangeable? i don't think i could find this in any grammar book
i hate this brazilian anon more than jordie
>>226190239Cool it with the anti-semitic remarks...
>>226190239If we could find a way to kill the Brazilian and doomer Serb this thread would be so much better
>>226189678Oh yeah I despise the spray tans and “sexy” vocal fry these britbong foids do
The Serb giveth, and the Serb taketh away... I simply follow the truth wherever it leads me, not my fault reality is grim.
in my country the native speakers are terrible in their own language and cant help code switching with english
>>226190284you don't have to bother, i know when I'm not welcome im sorry Serbian, but you probably won't be able to witness my German resultsso long, farewell
>>226190572See you tomorrow, Rabbi.
>>226190572110 threads
>>226190598He will be back tomorrow, having been BTFO’d, and will act like nothing even happened. Hitler wrote about this in Mein Kampf in the chapter describing his political arguments when he was a wagie.
I'll NEVER learn German. I'm just too fucking stupid. I'm literal human waste. I should just die.
>russian by the nature method is still lost media
>>226192204There's a Russian by the Nature Method?!
Is there no Greek/Hellene general on /int/ at all?!
>>226193087no, they're relegated to /med/
>>226192955yes, but only a few random chapters of it have been scanned. nobody's found the whole book (or if they have, they haven't digitized it).
I hate when I get obsessed with a random new word stuck in my head, then realize how little I'm likely to use it.First it was "épouvantail" (Scarecrow) which is rare and seasonal outside farmsNow it's "tandis que" (whereas), which in casual convo is too easy to default to just "mais" (but) What's your useless word obsession?
>>226179519Here: but it’s out of stock:https://www.vaticanum.com/en/bibliorum-sacrorum-nova-vulgata-editio-typica-minor?srsltid=AYCX9vLNdRrE3SoYuun19U4vUESQY_S8gBZIF3qBVFWHfroCo-EvF2YTYou could also have a custom book printed, but I’ve never done that before. https://www.vatican.va/archive/bible/nova_vulgata/documents/nova-vulgata_index_lt.html
>>226189678death to white women
>>226194215i like the superlative form of the adjective flagrans, flagrantissimus. have i even used this adjective yet? fuck no
>>226165302level 1jeg har to brødre og en søsterhvad klokken vågner du op om morgenen?jeg kan lide kaffe, men jeg fortrækker temit hus er i nærheden af togstationeni dag er det kold udenforlevel 2da jeg var yngre, plejede jeg at besøge mine bedsteforældre hver sommerhvis vejret er skønt i morgen, vandrer vi måskejeg har studeret dette sprog i seks måneder, men jeg begår stadig fejltagelser.hun fortalte mig at hun aldrig før har rejst uden for sit landselvom jeg var træt, besluttede jeg mig at færdiggøre bogenlevel 3hvis jeg vidste for svært rejsen ville blive, må jeg har forberedt mig anderledes.til trods for at han har boede bort i flere år, kæmper han stadigvæk at udtrykke sig naturligtdet er oft tingene at vi tager for givet som vi savner mest når de er vækunanset hvor overtalende hans forklaring lød, kunne jeg ikke ryste (???) følelsen at noget var galtjo mere jeg lære om andre kulturer, jo mere indser jeg hvor meget min opdragning har formet min perspektivbeen learning danish off/on for like 7 years or so. mostly i just watch or read like 2ish hours of media a week to maintain. not sure if that's enough? i can still understand most things, though my active vocabulary is definitely not as good as it once was.
>>226191414There, there. Learning a language is difficult so that fluency tastes even sweeter on your lips when you earn it.I wouldn't have it any other way.
>>226191414I WILL master Japanese, I'm already quite good and I put in my hours every day so it's only a matter of time.
>>226165302>When I was younger, I used to visit my grandparents every summer.小时候,我每夏天都去我爷爷和奶奶>If the weather is nice tomorrow, we might go hiking.如果明天的天气很好,我们可能在森林散步>I've been studying this language for six months, but I still make mistakes.我学了六个月这个语言了,但还是错>She told me that she had never traveled outside her country.她告诉了我她永远外国没旅游过>Even though I was tired, I decided to finish reading the book.虽然我很累,我决定看完这本书>Had I known how difficult the journey would be, I might have prepared differently..如果我知道这个路这么难, 我可能准备不一样>Despite having lived abroad for several years, he still struggles to express himself naturally.虽然他外国住几年,他还不说得自然
>mfs complain about german while im here learning hebrew german learners dont know how good they have it. they have a piece of cake of a language to learn and many comprehensible input channels to useeven this ai slop is tempting to me because of how lackluster the hebrew space ishttps://youtu.be/pPjDo8y1TAwbesides you already speak english for heavens sake. it's entirely your retarded method that's holding you back
>>226196516>I'm already quite goodyoure noti guarantee you're not
>>226197518People learn languages all the time. There are 2 million L2 Japanese speakers. What's so hard to believe?
>>226198282he's nowhere close to C1 let alone C2 and i don't consider C2 a "very good" level eithereven youtube polyglots who make their existence revolve around learning a language suck at Portuguese even after years studying it so for Japanese it's probably even worse
Got C1 level for English from my Cambridge English Placement test. Surprising for me, in school it was B2. But then, the test was mostly for listening and reading.
>1 million years learning Spanish >began as a literal child, at 13 year old>still can't speak like a normal person (just compare how her English flows compared to her Spanish, it's almost like her brain is busy building each word in Spanish before she says it so there's a huge delay)https://youtu.be/l9YwjDkCGZkif this doesn't prove ALG is right i don't know what will
>>226198676>ALGWhat's that?But at the end of the day, to a lot of people languages is just a tool. So if they can get by with her level (or any else) in their life - it's fine.
>>226198763>What's that?a theory of how humans get languages inside their heads>But at the end of the day, to a lot of people languages is just a tool. So if they can get by with her level (or any else) in their life - it's fine.the problem is, they think they will be satisfied with whatever they think is good for the rest of the lifewhen they actually reach that level and start noticing their deficiencies they will push their goalpost even further the issue is, if they learned the language incorrectly they will NEVER be able to reach the level they're truly content, and then they either abandon the language for good or they just resign they will never reach whatever level they had in mind and try to ignore the issues that bother them on a daily basispeople don't learn with others do they?
>unitedstatesianos can't cross the road whenever they feel like it>in fact it's a crime called "j walking"why?
>>226198979Because we aren't a third world shithole that doesn't have traffic laws.
>>226198979Isn't it something you can do if you're sure no one is around? Or was it UK?
>>226198439Your negative words won't stop me ALGoid. Even your own prophet failed to learn Chinese through his own flawed and inferior method. Hard work enjoyers like myself can't be stopped, we will all make it eventually.
>>226199220>Vietnamese SOVL strikes fear in the USAtians hearthttps://youtube.com/shorts/K3XXMDKQaHU
>>226199252no, just the UK, I've learned about it today https://youtu.be/z0xjTZRHBiw?t=0brazilians cross whenever they feel like it too (we "J walk")
>>226199271>Your negative words won't stop me ALGoid. i know, reality will.>Even your own prophet failed to learn Chinese through his own flawed and inferior method. he couldn't do the method, the method didn't fail him. years and years of being a "hard worker" and a linguist made him unable to do ALG>Hard work enjoyers like myself can't be stopped, we will all make it eventually.you better work harder than he did then because he still failed when he worked hard to learn Japanese (ALG wasn't even an idea in his mind then)https://bradonomics.com/brown-autobiography/>Japanese classes always had speech contests. The winners from each class would come together at the end of the term for the finals. I was a natural. Every term I would compose a speech and have the teacher correct it and record it. Then I got to work. I practiced until I could deliver it with perfect pronunciation and without a single hesitation. Then I practiced up to double speed without a hesitation. The next step was to make sure I wasn’t just performing practiced sentences. I had to wire it up so that a flash of thought would elicit the practiced sentence. Then on to hierarchies of thought so that a wider thought would lead to subthoughts and thus build up a whole paragraph of the speech. Did it work? To observers, it looked unbelievable. I always won in my class but lost out to higher classes in the finals. But whatever it looked like on the outside, from the inside it didn’t feel like language at all. I remember one term something tripped up my performance in the finals. I had to start over from the beginning! It reminded me of doing the same thing in a piano performance as a kid. With this kind of practice, every act is triggered by the preceding act (even after all that time I spent wiring the performance up to meaning). After an interruption, where’s the trigger?
>>226199426>As I look back now, I can see the folly. Perfect performance isn’t the goal of language learning. It isn’t the means of learning languages. And it isn’t the proof of language learned. But if that’s true, just what is this ‘ perfect performance’ I had been aiming for all my life? Could it be nothing more than doing the wrong thing better than anybody else?I did this sort of thing with daily drills and quarterly speeches for three years. It didn’t work. And I could see that it never would. Not a single sentence was ever triggered by a thought. And this had been one of my requirements for success. I had set out to prove the success of practice. I proved, instead, its failure.>It’s surprising how good we get at changing goals to meet results. I had to admit that I couldn’t speak Japanese, so I changed my goal from speaking Japanese to practicing it. I could practice Japanese better than anyone else in the world! (It reminds me of a ‘Duffy’ cartoon. Duffy said, “I always followed the old adage, ‘practice makes perfect.’ And look at me today. Perfect at practicing.” (Copy of cartoon to be attached.) What could I do with this skill? Teach students to practice Japanese, of course. And why should I do this? Well they weren’t learning to speak Japanese anyway. With my help at least they would be able to deliver practiced sentences and get praise and grades—like I had done all my life. I teamed up with the head of the Japanese department to teach beginning Japanese the following quarter. I would orchestrate the practice. She would provide the talk.>>226199271welp, go ham on your practice champ. do the anki and shadowing and sentence mining and whatever other nonsense it is japanese learners do these days
>>226198439>and i don't consider C2 a "very good" level eitherWell, you're a drooling moron then because C2 is the highest achievable level in the CEFR.>even youtube polyglots who make their existence revolve around learning a language suck at PortugueseNobody asked. Nobody cares.>so for Japanese it's probably even worseJapanese is easy, you're just retarded.
>>226198439tbf brazilians suck at portuguese too, so what's the big deal?
>>226199469>C2 is the highest achievable level in the CEFR.here's the highest achievable level on the CEFR https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_Bx_x-gvLw0now here's the highest achievable level in ALGhttps://youtu.be/_co2aVR4F_I>Nobody asked. Nobody cares.you seem to be incapable of thinking >Japanese is easy, you're just retarded.see above>>226199517brazilians don't make gender mistakes in every other words or speak with a mix of 100 different accents like this girl does https://youtu.be/3fj5Y-gFE7E
>>226199581What point does the video prove?
>>226199581>gender mistakesno, just number and subject mistakes lmaooooo "os cara" "tu vai" xDDD some retards even created a whole new pronoun for the 1st person plural because they weren't mentally prepared enough to use "nos" properly
>>226199941>no, just number and subject mistakeseverys single sentence you spout in Portuguese is riddled with "mistakes" since they don't have the cases that Latin hasstop being retarded, native speakers dictate what is correct language
>>226199973>native speakers dictate what is correct languageabsolutely 100% not. Your sCiEntIFiC methods completely disregards aesthetics.>native speakers (that have a high understanding of their language and classical litterature) define what is correct languageFTFY
>>226200158you need to spend a night with a linguist, urgently
>>226200353I know the difference between descriptivism and prescriptivism, I just don't get the underlying populist assumptions as well as all the epistemological ones. Isolated in a vacuum, descriptivism is fine as a pure method, but the average descriptivist goes way beyond just the method in their beliefs. Furthermore, I still reject is for aesthetics.
>>226199973>native speakers dictate what is correct languageNo, they don't. If the goal of language is communication, the most precise way of communicating is the correct language. Butchering plural and pronouns are incorrect, and no filthy faggot with a degree will change that. The goycattle subhuman gets his view of right and wrong from people he never met, don't know what they are like, don't know if they are honest, and try to spread his slave nature to others. Go back to social media.
>>226200551>If the goal of language is communication, the most precise way of communicating is the correct languagethen learn thishttps://pt.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ithkuil
i just realised something synaptic pruning in an on-going process that happens independently from your will and it's co constantly trying to settle your neurological system into an homeostatically optimal state which means at any given point including very advanced stages you can experience language regression such that you're devolving into early stages of native speakers language development but that's actually a good sign because you're beginning to go back in time so to speak as if you were reborn as a native speaker and your brain was starting back clean into becoming a fully fledged adult native speaker I've also realised ALG is fundamentally an object-oriented ontology and has strange correspondences in Epicurean metaphysics I've come across which entails the empirically verifiability of ALG's superiority in producing consistent language speakers results in the certainty that correlated areas and ideas must be correct as well by association
>>226200605I think that making 0 value judgement in science is a mistake but I lack the foundations in humanities to explore this idea. It's crazy that people like you want as much objectivity as possible even though your senses and tastes scream otherwise; science is built on top of our culture, not the other way around. Only a nihilist that worships science would propose that their semi-illiterate contemporaries know more Portuguese than Camões just because the former are still alive alongside with the language.
that's it.today i will start latin and make my ancestors proud o algo.
>>226201332Latinam linguam discimus et hodiernam linguam nostram corrigamos
>>226201332Bonam fortunam tibi exopto
>>226201332 >>226201472how do you learn to read latin manuscripts and facsimiles in gothic script, or even blackletter? they're the one reason i don't learn Latin
>>226201643Search "Latin palaeography"There are lots of free resources
This thread used to be so comfy
>>226201707It's just a few retards ruining it. Just stop responding to them and they'll eventually go somewhere else, since all they want is attention.
>>226201472>>226201630thanks guys
The axis of evil
>>226201707it was, and it sometimes is, and it can be again. just don't interact with bad-faith flags as much as you can. pattern recognition should be able to help with that.>>226201332salutem et fortunam bonam tibi precor, amice italice! stude et disce
I just learned from my 'putting that the Chinese have a system for counting to 10 using only one hand
>>226201883you don't understand the point of these posts, they're all gatekeepers keeping normies from ruining this place and hobby
how much of this can Portuguese speakers understand?
>>226201332Euge! Macte virtute amice.
>>226203019It’s really humorous that there’s at least two regular Brazilian posters and one is seemingly normal while the other is a batshit jew who makes up half the posts in the thread.
Translation challenge>It seems today that all you see is violence in movies and sex on TV.>But where are those good old-fashioned values on which we used to rely?>Lucky there's a family guy.>Lucky there's a man who positively can do all the things that make us laugh and cry.>He's a family guy!
>>226202819So does ASL and like every sign language
>>226205633And they are both learning German
>>226205999That's expected. The Chinese system is interesting because it's one that the average Chinese person knows and uses regularly
>>226200353>remember when this guy attacked the last speaker of Thao because he was white but as it turns out he really did learn it from the last native speaker>remember when this guy said saying "native speaker" is problematic>remember when this guy defended the word latinx>remember that he doesn't have a degree in second language learning>remember that he literally has a degree in black people
>>226207323is it true that he's not even jewish and converted as an adult? I saw someone say that and have been wondering if it's true ever since.
>>226206184I thought the ALGilian was learning Lithuanian
All this dooming about adult learning doesn't really apply to me because my primary focus is comprehension, not speaking. It's been shown that an adult can learn essentially native-like comprehension skills. The accent may always be fucked thoughever, but I'm not trying to be something I'm not
>>226207455The lore is that his maternal line was smuggled out of Europe in the 40s and the ancestry was kept secret and he discovered it as an adult.>>226207323The Thao thing is especially funny because he’s a steel-blue eyed rural guy who speaks AAVE natively and he’s only “jewish” because of arcane matrilineal succession laws adopted within the last few centuries and is genetically probably just a normal American with a sprinkle of Ashkenazi. And he specializes in AAVE. It’s like he thinks the yarmulke makes him immune from criticism. It’s unfortunate because some of his videos are really high quality but just the identification as one of the tribe means he has these glaring blind spots that make him become irrational. His video on Hebrew is exceptionally poorly done even from a pro-Israel point of view because he just regurgitates a bunch of talking points and at times outright lies and uses his credibility with the audience and authority as a PHD in linguistics (not middle eastern history, or political science, or ethics, or whatever) to come off automatically right about a bunch of sensitive political topics that have literally nothing to do with his specialty.
>>226208595>I'm not trying to be something I'm notMy fellow American. A lot of people learning a language have identity issues. Kind of like transgenders.
/7puBet Kak DeJla?
>>226208739> the year is 2006, I'm 13 years old> just got an internet connection at home and a PC> playing counter strike 1.6 over the internet> don't know English at all, they start teaching English only in 5 or 6 six grade, and for half of classes it's still German> our pirated game versions don't have a Russian translation and it doesn't even display cyrillic in the chat> no voice chat> we all typing text emulating cyrillic with latin letters like this: > DaBau /7o Mudy> Ku/7u MHe emky> /7uDopac 3ae6aJl KpblcuTb
>>226202819check these channels out too for your inputting https://youtu.be/FrUJEWCnOl0https://youtu.be/uHp53ChGFZYhttps://youtu.be/tInDYmT5Lpohttps://youtu.be/MeV60njj5XI
Who do you consider to be the most impressive L2 speaker you've ever met?Mine is an old professor of mine. He was a German, Oxford-educated classical scholar who wrote primarily on Plato. I'm not ashamed to admit that he probably knew more about English than me, certainly more English words, and he was extremely precise in his speech. He may be the single most knowledgeable person I've ever met. The funny thing is, he still had a distinctly German accent; he even used the uvular pronunciation of R sounds. But I never encountered him make a grammatical mistake, nor could I ever fault his style of expression
>>226209428Xiaomanyc he barely speaks 2 languages but somehow people think he speaks 72 languages fluently
I divided the languages that interest me into two groups:>overall professionally useful / close to Poland:German, Dutch, Swedish, Norwegian, Finnish, French>less useful / not so easy to utilize in everyday life:Italian, Spanish, Japanese, Portuguese, RussianIn the second group, Japanese wins, so I'll skip the rest of the languages in the group.In the first group, I don't know what to choose. I would reject Finnish, but that's because it's seems to be super time-consuming and I'll have to learn Japanese too. I would reject French too, because it filtered me already few times and I'm not a big fan of modern France. German has the biggest population and slightly easier pronunciation, but almost no good music. Swedish, Norwegian, Dutch are theoretically overall easier amd are quirky the way I like, but with more difficult pronunciation and they seems to be less avaliable, have less content etc. Has anyone recently started or are planning to start one of these languages? Jordanian has already made a decision?
>>226209614The only professionally useful language is english.
>>226209947in other words: it is quite easy to find a use for the language at some work here and / or it is easy to emigrate there while still be close to Poland.
>overall professionally usefulWon't happen unless you actually had concrete plans to move there and then you would already have started >In the second group, Japanese winsGood it's decided, you will learn Japanese. You're not allowed to think about any other language until you post your N1 certificate. Happy studying.
>>226211805How do you say "the hood" in japanese (without using katakana)?
>>226209947>>226210477Obviously depends on the profession.I've seen senior software developer listings that require fluent German (in Germany, obv), and also I've seen some here (or remote) that give you bonus points if you know French.So even in an industry that people universally think is "English-only" there are still opportunities to win among other candidates by knowing another language.
>>226212100>senior software developer listings that require fluent German >(in Germany, obv)Imagine learning a foreign language for an EU-tier software salary
>>226212469Learning a language uniquely for career prospects is retarded in most cases.I only talk about career benefits as bonus for learning languages that I'm already interested in.
Have you ever managed to convince someone else to learn languages too?>>226208595>It's been shown that an adult can learn essentially native-like comprehension skills.you'd have to do hvpt
>>226212777>you'd have to do hvptThat's a basic part of learning a language
Damn, but I'll dabble if I finally decide to emigrate or somethingPretty much this >>226212100I've also seen job postings for well-paying positions (by Polish standards) that require only a good level of Norwegian or Dutch, with the promise that they'll teach you the rest.There are more (a lot) job openings for German or French speakers, but the pay is a little lower (still good money), and the requirements are also usually slightly higher. On the other hand, I could probably learn to code or something during the time it would take me to self-learn a Scandinavian language>>226212469No one actually said that, but if you want to learn a foreign language and can't make up your mind, it's a good idea to choose a language from your list that you could use at work and thus use almost every day >>226211988Maybe Muhou Chitai or something like that? There's manga with that title
>watching random vlogs by natives for practice>90% of them are by females because only women do gay shit like vlogging>keep getting crushes on the girls>get sad they'll never be my gf>have to switch back to watching documentaries narrated by men
>>226213077Let the parasocial relationship fluorish to improve your language skills.
>>226213060>No one actually said thatI did. And I know someone IRL who learned German to be a software engineer in Germany.
I'm almost positive that this CI course I'm using is intentionally showing coombait pictures as a strategy to help with retention
>>226213513Uh, okay then. But still, I think he just like Germany
>>226213077Unfortunately since most of my input is random vloggers if im not careful i talk like an egirl
Silly question but what level of Japanese language would i need to learn to be able to make orders of stuff with japanese companies?My hobby autism must grow beyond the Baltics
https://vocaroo.com/18HvzSybKD3gHow do I make my accent more intelligible? I feel like my youtube account is suffering because of it. What I say in each video's intro is quick, inflammatory and concise. but my view retention rate is shit. I believe it's because it's hard to make out what I say without subtitles.
>>226214312perfectly understandable, but it sounds like you say "over lazy dog" instead of "over the lazy dog"
I am disappointed with the choice of Latin-Lithuanian dictionariesall you have are old prints, which are pretty expensive (I could buy a new Latin-English dictionary for such prices) and one more recently (like 15 years ago) published dictionary which doesn't contain that many words and lacks vowel lengths, which is unacceptable to meI could probably just buy an English one instead desu
>>226214312Like with most foreigners who have a good grasp on English but are hard to understand, you’re just mumbling and dropping where it’s not normal to do it, like how you dropped the. Otherwise your actual accent sounds really good. For youtube, just slow down, and pay more attention to your enunciation.A native talking quickly but intelligibly might say >over’th lazy dogWith a very short-to-inaudable -e- on theBut they wouldn’t drop the th and just go “n” like you did.>overn lazy dogIs just not saying “the” at all. Basically, if you’re gonna mumble words like the and an and a, you need to do it like we do for us not to just not hear the words at all.
>>226208595comprehension can be doomed too. depends on how hard the language is, how old you are exactly, and how much experience you already have. if you're 30 trying to learn korean and you've never learned a language before just give up
>>226215246>if you're 30 trying to learn korean and you've never learned a language before just give upwhy korean and why would learning any language in general before change your hearing skill?>>226191414check this channel https://youtu.be/Nc9G7LO5MGk
I for one love accents and wish for them to be preserved
I was hungry some time ago and I ate a language.
>>226216474you had a full english? yummy
>>226214312>What I say in each video's intro is quick, inflammatoryshow us the videos
>>226216588Language rhymes with sandwich in some German accents.
I bought a Lithuanian-English dictionary for my Kindle but like only half of the words I search have a look up translation. How do I fix this?
>>226217381Use wiktionary
>>226192204I need its Arabic version.
>>226208595This is a good cope, I might take it up myself. It's not like I really need to use any of my TLs, I'd just like to have the ability if the need arises and also because learning half a skill is just embarrassing.>My hobby is language learning, I spend like 2-3 hours daily on it.>Oh, how many languages do you speak?>Uhhh, just English. But I can understand like 3 of them, no it's actually true I'm not lying, shall we put on some Peppa Pig for me to translate? Stop laughing!!
>>226209614Yeah, I stuck with Arabic and German, simultaneously. Started with German again. But I won't post here until I can output some German (B1)
Would you be impressed if you saw my 3 C2 certificates on my kitchen wall?
>>226222548I think I've already seen them. English, Spanish and Japanese?I'd only be impressed if you started at 25.
>>226222548...yes
German is getting easier and easier
>>226214312I swear I heard your voice before, come on, drop us a link
Japanese learners, reccomend me some cute Japanese teachers and content creators. I think that's a good idea: >>226213077 >>226213230>>226214312You mogg me
>>226221308That's not what I said at all. You seriously don't see a difference between speaking a language with an accent and not speaking a language at all.
>>226229867You thought we were dooming about... accent? We're talking about producing correct, natural and fluent speech. Perfect accent is just extra fluff on top, no one really cares about that.
>>226230002Your greentext is a strawman about comprehending a language without being able to speak it. The point of my post was that I can learn to comprehend a language with native-like profficiency without speaking with a native accent. That's not the same as saying that I despair of learning a goreign language at all
>>226230002And yes, I did think that you were dooming about native-like accents. I in no way thought you were dooming about learning to speak a foreign langauge at all because I couldn't believe that anyone could be so retarded as to believe that
>watching random vlogs by native speakers>keep randomly breaking into English for random phrases >video is interspersed with random montages with American music playing in background Genuinely what's the point of learning a language if everyone loves English?
>>226230300Ah, to be young again. Just as you've settled for less than a perfect accent, you'll eventually realize you'll have to settle again and again. Okay, it doesn't have to be very fluent or automatic, I'll talk slowly to gather my thoughts, no big deal, maybe I don't even have to sound natural, a couple foreign sounding constructions here and there, they probably understand what I'm getting at, but at the very least it's grammatically correct, right? Fine, I can make errors here and there, it's charming in a way. At least I can understand them perfectly, I think.
>>226230744Moaning this much over a modern European Germanic language when you know English is so cringe my guy. Is there just something about German learners that makes them this way?
>>226230744You seem to have begun learning languages with unrealistic expectations. No one with half a brain expects to magically become a native speaker of a foreign language. Accented but fluent speech and strong comprehension are reasonable goals which are attainable by adults. My own grandfather didn't learn to speak English until middle age, and I consider him fluent
>tfw after 10 years of dedicated rigorous practice/study, you still can't parrot basic phrases in your TL without intensive, borderline-masochistic mental exercise.
>>226231188>No one with half a brain expects to magically become a native speaker of a foreign language.you ever heard of ALGchads?