[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/k/ - Weapons


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1780972832879808.png (982 KB, 1200x675)
982 KB PNG
Why not?
>>
>>65617740
GDI carryall from the C&C tiberium games.
>>
>>65617740
Mostly cost and complexity, a bigger Osprey would be cheaper to build and maintian than something with double the engines and rotors.
>>
>>65617740
Maybe in 60 years but not today.
>>
File: 1784085187498886.gif (11 KB, 255x154)
11 KB GIF
>>65617748
>carryall
>>
>>65617740
It would require too many sacrifices.
>>
>carryall
>>
>>65617748
That's a Tarantula from Nuclear Option.

And to answer OP... it's a four-engine tiltrotor. Such an aircraft would be spending 99% of its life in constant maintenance.
>>
When I first saw it I assumed the 76mm was a gimmick but it's flat out the best air to ground weapon in the game.
>>
MIC just doesn't have the 20th century wanderlust anymore
>>
File: tarantula.webm (1007 KB, 1024x576)
1007 KB
1007 KB WEBM
>>65617740
>Why not?
Way too cool to exist in our reality.
>>
>>65617740
Square cube law, all eggs in one basket bad.
>>
>>65618069
How do you use it? I find myself getting incredibly bored pinging guided shells from relative saftey
>>
>>65617740

It doesn’t look like the wings provide any lift so the rotors have to do all the lifting. It is more efficient to have one giant rotor (like the CH-53) than several smaller motors plus other benefits like lower complexity and cost. When you have a tiny vehicle like a multi copter that weighs a few pounds it isn’t that big a deal to add extra motors and rotors, but efficiency absolutely tanks when you try to scale that up. My estimate is above 500 lbs. it’s better to use a conventional layout. Now if you change those stubby little wings for ones that actually produce lift, that idea looks brighter.
>>
>>65618298
>lock up 20 targets on the map
>get into a firing position
>fire 2 shells
>unlock target
>fire 2 shells
>unlock target
>lock up 20 more targets while you wait for the gun to cool down
Boltstrikes usually need 5 shells and Aerosentries usually need 10, but everything except HELs go down eventually, and when everything is dead you can immediately drop a LAV25 to capture the base. The excitement comes from trying to survive enemy players while you do it.
>>
>>65618334
Ah yeah so pretty much what I do only a bit more efficient. I'm gonna continue trying to infiltrate enemy airspace in a chicane and dying repeatedly instead.
>>
>>65617740
Zero recovery from engine failure.
>>
>>65618380
But enough about the osprey
>>
File: carryall2.jpg (65 KB, 640x400)
65 KB JPG
>>65617740
>>
File: TiberianSun800.jpg (73 KB, 800x600)
73 KB JPG
>>65618496
>>
File: testc001.jpg (29 KB, 640x400)
29 KB JPG
>>65618497
>>
>>65617828
You don't have to mechanically connect all rotors together with a billion clutches and universal joints, at this point one could reasonably envision a hybrid electric system to provide redundancy; IIRC GE has developed such a system recently. Granted it would still be a four engine beast, but such an aircraft would be much better than an Osprey. Cooler too.
>>
File: MSV_LADS.png (1.22 MB, 1008x764)
1.22 MB PNG
>>65618069
>blocks your path
>>
>>65618507
Anduril's Thunder attack tiltrotor uses electric motors powered by a conventional engine/generator. Idk if it would be enough for a C130 size plane
>>
Why not? Because
>MISSILE [ARH] 12.6 km
>MISSILE [ARH] 12.4 km
>MISSILE [ARH] 10.5 km
>MISSILE [ARH] 9164 m
>MISSILE [ARH] 5261 m
>>
>INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING
WHZZZZ
>>
File: 2938452135.png (6 KB, 423x110)
6 KB PNG
>>65618765
I remember when ARH was duked by just hovering slowly in one spot
>>
>>65618507
If it relies on four engines and no interconnected drive then where is the redundancy?
>>
File: flow.png (85 KB, 271x279)
85 KB PNG
>>65618256
That thing is pure sex. Quadcopter AC130, basically. I am terrible at flying it in-game, though. You really have to plan your flight path out, fly below radar, stay close to friendly aircraft, and pray you don't have to manoeuvre it too much.
>>
>>65617740
why use props and not turbo fans? Why not use turbofans on the Osprey and eliminate the giant blender blades?
>>
>>65618514
>SIR GET DOWN
https://www.instagram.com/reel/De6CE8sqe1d/
>>
>>65619340
Turbofans and turbojets produce thrust, turboprops produce constant power. A turboprop is better suited to produce more thrust at lower speed. You can see variable pitch propellers like a CVT in a car.
>>
File: revoked.jpg (154 KB, 1004x529)
154 KB JPG
When is the Rafale-Gripen-Viper going to get a model update? It's clearly outdated compared to newer plens, and the pug nose has to go
>>
>>65618380
If you can CTOL on a runway even if you only have two engines left. Set rotors to 70 degree tilt to avoid a groundstrike, and just land it like a C-130
>>
>>65619456
The disc loading is going to be ridiculous even with all 4 props running. No way it stays airborne at landing speed with only 2.
>>
File: kamikaze4.webm (3.83 MB, 1024x576)
3.83 MB
3.83 MB WEBM
>>65619445
I reject that thing being Rafale anything, the intakes are ugly, it's a single engine and it really need that QoL-mod extra pylon.
The game definitely need a Rank 4 fighter based on the Rafale-Eurofighter.

That said I'm impressed how this game don't limit itself to fighter fighter fighter fighter and let you use aircraft with very specific job in a complete battlefield.
https://nuclearoption.wiki.gg/wiki/CargoJet1
>>
>>65619340
Thrust is proportional to exhaust velocity squared whereas power consumption is proportional to exhaust velocity cubed, so for maximum fuel efficiency you want to expel the largest mass of air at the lowest speed possible. The caveat to that is that engines don't produce any thrust if the exhaust velocity is lower than the airspeed, which is why fast jets use turbofans instead of props and why even faster jets use turbojets instead of turbofans.
>>
Reminder that if you compare the size of a hexhound to the size of a GPO-500, an Ibis should be able to fit six of them in the rear cargo bay in addition to the twelve AGM-48s in the front cargo bay.
>>
>>65620096
I'm sittin' here strokin' mah dick right now
>>
>>65620101
You could, but it sure would suck to suddenly have to take evasive action with that load.
>>
>>65617740
the v-22 is shit
you'll notice all the next chen chopper designs are looking at hybrid autogyros not tilt rotors, dead end technology
>>
>>65618256
>shooting right into your engine and rotors
great plan
notice the v22 has no side guns?
>>
>>65620362
Can you rotate an apple in your head?
>>
>>65621100
Ruined that retards life with this one
>>
>>65620349
I want the Ibis Trigger to take a fat load on my face
>>
File: file.png (896 KB, 980x551)
896 KB PNG
>>65620362
While the game take liberties, did you somehow manage to forget the number of engines?
>>
File: reference.mp4 (47 KB, 498x282)
47 KB
47 KB MP4
>>65617759
>>
>>65617740
Useless in an ion storm.
>>
>>65618765
Optical. I don't fear ARH or IR in a Tula.
>>
>>65622238
I have taught numerous Tulas to fear the AGM-99. Shit as an anti-ship missile, hilariously competent in anti-air. They will not stop chasing you
>>
>>65622251
AGM-99s are bugged at the moment and don't trigger MAWS. Even pilots that know to evade them can just get randomly collected.
>>
File: nuclear aesthetic.webm (626 KB, 480x496)
626 KB
626 KB WEBM
I do think Nuclear Option unironically shows how a future mechanized force would actually be.

>EW up the ass
>High altitude flight is suicide due to SAM's up the ass
>Lasers defending key points
>Lasers that are mobile
>Lasers on tanks
>Lasers everywhere
>Mixture of extremely high tech, super expensive shit with the majority going Cold war tier purposefully cheap but still useable airframes for mass and economy

And of course if there was every a time where MAD doctrine ever gets replaced by strategic level active defensive systems rendering strategic level nuclear exchanges useless than I can definitely see a drunk pilot flinging a 1.5kt nuclear dummy bomb with a fucking trainer jet at enemy positions.
>>
File: 1778907094963.jpg (983 KB, 1920x1080)
983 KB JPG
I love the FS-3 Ternion. Let's just throw all the super F-15 projects (Silent Eagle, Strike Eagle, EX, MTD) into one plane and give it EOTS to boot.
>>
>>65623290
>finngolian cavalry assault korean positions under nuclear artillery barrage
>>
>>65623290
>nuclear dummy bomb
That would be a nuke with an inert warhead, which wouldn't be very useful.
You want a:
>nuclear dumb bomb
>>
File: 1786210855423330.jpg (190 KB, 800x1131)
190 KB JPG
>>
>>65618980
Well in theory it should be able to get down safely with only three engines, so you have a some degree of redundancy.
>>
File: cj1.jpg (36 KB, 987x475)
36 KB JPG
thoughts?
>>
>>65624903
Kill piñata
>>
>>65624903
I rate it 6 out of 6 incoming scimitars
>>
>>65626037
I pray for Medusa support then
>>
>>65624903
I don't like the silly fin to but otherwise much better design than the one with blended engine

I also appreciate the game covering every kind of aircraft and I look forward fun feature with this one.
Between the inevitable laser and the not suspicious at all arrival of drones simultaneously, I expect fun gameplay loop.

>>65627566
>implying it won't do its own jamming
I'll be surprised if the laser don't let you destroy at last 3 missiles from huge distance away.
The only annoyance is that the laser will likely not be automated, leaving you vulnerable to multitasking problem.
>>
File: lift.png (57 KB, 935x779)
57 KB PNG
>>
>>65623458
Why yes I would like 12 stealth glide cluster bombs
>>
>>65617740
>>65617750
a normal osprey is not even fucking good or passingly competent at doing the bullshit mission it was specifically designed for just to appease the seething faggot that sent a bunch of helicopters into an Iranian sandstorm
>>
>>65620358
we Rotodyne now
>>
>>65620362
Can you picture an apple in your head anon?
What do you see?
>>
>>65628291
Why is tilt wing lower than tilt rotor?
>>
File: x32.jpg (127 KB, 1920x1080)
127 KB JPG
*saxophones*
>>
File: usnswath.jpg (132 KB, 1200x804)
132 KB JPG
>>
>>65629484
In that plot aircrafts on the left are optimized for hover, aircrafts on the right are optimized for level flight while retaining VTOL capability. In other words pure VTOL on the left, VSTOL on the right, and everything inbetween in the middle. The tilt wing must be more focused on speed and range than the tilt rotor. A few deductions:
>the main reason to move the whole wing instead of just the rotors must be because wings' profile have longer chord length
Wings create more lift in flight, but are a bigger impediment to airflow during hover when stationary, hence the need to get them out of the way. Tilt rotors also have huge wing sections dropping down like flaps for the same reason, but at a certain point it must be just easier to move everything and call it a day
>rotors being smaller than tilt rotor can be for prop efficiency at higher speed and/or for ground clearance
A bigger disc can cause the propellers' tip to go supersonic at higher airspeeds with great decrease in efficiency, so a smaller rotor is less speed constrained. Also smaller props can be angled more horizontally without risk of striking the ground, assuming the same wing height, so I would say that it's more likely a tilt wing would be able to take off and land like a regular fixed wing aircraft, with just a minimum of wing tilt like a F-8 Crusader, and unlike a V-22, but this is speculation on my part.
>>
>>65629701
>>
File: EgSdtUJWsAMo67i.jpg (66 KB, 825x571)
66 KB JPG
>>65623722
My nigga.
>>
File: Avpro_AFA.gif (30 KB, 600x600)
30 KB GIF
>>65633099
Someone tell me why this design won't work.
Is the thrust to weight ration? Engine placement? Engineers fever dream?
>>
>>65633103
The cold war ended which meant there was no longer a need to develop technology to defeat some massive behemoth like the Warsaw Pact. Especially since most of our wars have involved counter insurgency where things like airlifting entire divisions rapidly into a region is not a necessary thing. Why do you think the Pentagon has been constantly hyping up the Chinese boogeyman for so long?
>New big threat = new toys
>>
>>65633103
Thrust to weight and disc loading. With that size it's going to be so heavy and it's already hard enough for fighter jets.
>>
>>65629827
Oh, I see. It's not inherently more inefficient, it's just that a tilt wing WOULD place more emphasis on level flight speed, and sacrifice disc loading as a result.
>>
>>65623290
I love how Nuclear Option managed to make a pretty kino alternate universe. Ifrit, my beloved.
>>
File: kukri.jpg (858 KB, 1920x1080)
858 KB JPG
>>65617740
I hate the Ibis, it's such a pig. Even the Tarantula feels more agile.

Now, the new Kukri mod? This thing flies like a dream
>>
what actual role will the 'tula have after the cargo plane drops?
Maybe I'm just blind but I only ever see it used in roles a cargo jet would be objectively better for. It's VTOL but too vulnerable to operate on the frontlines (and everything has parachutes so it's not like you really need to hover to drop cargo 90% of the time), it's probably cheaper but is still the cost of 2.5 revokers so losing one really stings, it's faster than the ibis but not by that much so logistics on larger maps is still fucking boring (the cargo plane is meant specifically to address this, iirc). It is cool though, so I guess it has that. It's also got that 76mm cannon but I would guess they're working on adding something similar to the cargo plane.
>>
File: VTOL transport.webm (2.01 MB, 726x400)
2.01 MB
2.01 MB WEBM
>>65633103
It would work
Just not worth the price and efforts while also only useful in niche situation.

Remember when they recently landed two C-130 to rescue a pilot in Iran, then had to destroy those because they could not take-off again?

Imagine a VTOL airlifter landing then suffering heavy damage on take-off because the thrust from the exhausts are too dangerous pointed at dirt.
>>
>>65633313
I don't hate the chicane but it really should be at rank 0 with the cricket instead of rank 2 with the brawler.
>>
File: Comanche flight.webm (2.75 MB, 480x360)
2.75 MB
2.75 MB WEBM
>>65633313
Kukri design is ugly tho, I dislike the Chicane rear, but it's still close to the Commanche fetish.
>>
>>65634084
We don't know if the new cargo will even have a good niche. It will be one huge target everyone will want to see going down.

Also the cargo gameplay is lacking in the first place.
It takes too long to deploy vehicles and you cannot deploy enough (or the right kind) to make a difference over playing a fighter.

The Tarantula best use is to spam AGM to overwhelm AA then use the side cannon to cheaply destroy everything now lacking defense.
If you want to drop cargo with precision you need to be able to hover.
And while I can imagine the CargoPlane1 landing on very small airstrip thanks to JATO, it will hardly be able to maneuver well enough to avoid being in sight of many missiles.
>>
>>65634099
I feel like AI really needs "escort" and "wingman" routines. The cargo jet by itself is a free target for a dozen scimitars, but protected by Revokers in formation, it may be fine
>>
>>65634251
While I expect it to carry the new drone, that's the wrong logic. At those range "escort" mean attacking the enemy so it is too occupied to attack the new cargo.
What we need are wingmen NPC that can be asked to follow you and shoot the same missiles as you to get through defense.

Plus you have plenty of PvPfag who hate that missile can intercept other missile. If it were up to them you'd constantly shot down by scimitars you can't dodge and be called a noob for not accepting that "realism".

To be clear, NO is nudging reality to keep the game fun, but MCM is real, just costly.
>>
>>65634313
Giving it a few auto-firing S1s might not be a terrible idea. They're small enough that they could conceivably be mounted on external turrets and they might not be good at anything except intercepting missiles but they are very good at intercepting missiles.
>>
>>65634337
An S1/S2 turret that could be mounted in the rotodome spot would be insanely cool.
>>
>>65634084
It can carry a good deal more then the Ibis and unlike BEG PLANE it can take off from helipads. Give you the ability to jump over smaller area and drop off heavier AA systems + radar. That and it's a far better gunship then the other helicopters.
>>
Dev stream is up, and currently the cargo jet has an option for a 20 megajoule capacitor and a 1.1 MEGAwatt laser.
>>
>>65629700
F-32 Corsair III?
>>
>>65634520
Medusa powercreeped to oblivion. If it can function as an AWACS too, which would make sense given the size, there won't be a reason anymore to suffer with that shitty meme. I like NO devs coming up with crazy stuff like the Tarantula, but of all designs, Northrop Grumman AV-8 Growler is hands down the most stupid.
>>
>>65623722
Goddamn this was such a hidden gem
>>
>>65634573
I mean the Medusa is half the price and can STOL or take off from carriers, it hardly overlaps
>>
>>65634595
Plus ARADs and jamming pods. Picking one enemy player and jamming them until they ragequit will never stop being funny.
>>
>>65634313
>What we need are wingmen NPC that can be asked to follow you and shoot the same missiles as you to get through defense.
Flight planning and execution to peel back air defences and achieve good strike results on sorties without simply spamming more missiles is the one part of the game that is rewarding and allows skill development past basics. Your suggestion would remove it for literally no reason or gain at all in favor of yet more spam. Why would this not be bad?
>Plus you have plenty of PvPfag who hate that missile can intercept other missile. If it were up to them you'd constantly shot down by scimitars you can't dodge and be called a noob for not accepting that "realism".
PVPers don't hate it because it's unrealistic, they hate it because it's degenerate and boring gameplay.
>To be clear, NO is nudging reality to keep the game fun, but MCM is real, just costly.
But this is also untrue. MCM is not real, in the sense that it's wildly unreliable - no one makes small missiles capable of reliably intercepting other small missiles manouevring with mach 6 closure rates. Nuclear Option and Warthunder are incredibly generous with how they depict MCM. Secondly, MCM in NO is not costly, it's strongly and reliably profit generating. It's only costly in the sense of opportunity cost for running better strike loadouts, which is a huge shame because there are strong disincentives to ever run heavy loadouts near or over MTOW on multiroles that would make them harder and interesting to fly.
>>65633313
I have yet to play any modded aircraft that wasn't super boring to fly because the flight model was too forgiving and the engines way too powerful. If the Kukri is anything like Aryx's Knockout for eg then ima hard pass on it, because it doesn't even feel like a helicopter to fly and it's not challenging, interesting or fun as a result. The Chicane was also more fun (but even weaker) before it got some sneaky changes to make it harder to induce rotor stall.
>>
>>65634573
The Medusa is probably the strongest aircraft in the game and is probably stronger than its ever been with the laser changes last patch. Even if they add AWACS radar to the cargo plane, the Medusa will still be the only AWACS that can generate a track on any other emitting AWACS and carry active jammers while doing it.

If Scims are ruining your day as a Medusa then you need to brush up on abusing their HoJ to collect them for notching.
>>
>>65634752
>laser changes last patch
Missed that one. Admittedly I haven't played in a couple patches, and to be fair I only play solo, so maybe multiplayer balance is a bit different. My main issue with the Medusa is the task saturation, and impossibility to multitask: that's a 4-crew aircraft and you gotta do it all, while also not being allowed to toggle jammers, meaning that you have to choose between targeting a single missile and jamming the fuckers that chuck them at your way. Also, at least in single player missions, people should stop nesting SHORAD next to huge SAM batteries, it makes DEAD impossible.
>>
>>65635414
>waahhh the game doesn't play itself for me
git gud
>>
File: 1-3.png (759 KB, 948x489)
759 KB PNG
>>65634737
My suggestion is nothing but realism, quantity is a quality on its own
Beside, you could have 3 wingmen Ifrit and still not have enough Ashm-300 to go through a lone Destroyer defense.
For a start I wish cruise missile would have an AI that automatically chose a trajectory limiting their passage over known AA.
>they hate it because it's degenerate and boring gameplay.
It's the total opposite! it's the only reason there's a gameplay at all for aircraft that cannot carry long range missiles and cannot hide!
What do you think would happen if you removed MCM? You'd make half of the aircraft into sitting ducks too annoying to fly and limit high altitude to a token of suicidal bombing run
>not real, in the sense that it's wildly unreliable
It's more real than being able to notch missiles in the year 2070, I'd maybe agree if you also make every other defense unreliable and adding fleet of NPC drones whose sole jobs are to jams enemies without taking risk.
>no one makes small missiles capable of reliably intercepting other small missiles manouevring with mach 6 closure rates
They try
https://www.twz.com/35038/tiny-missile-interceptor-to-defend-aircraft-against-enemy-missile-attacks-moves-forward
and the reliability issue is essentially a sensor problem which is going to improve on top of inter-vehicle datalink
>MCM in NO is not costly, it's strongly and reliably profit generating
Which is realistic: cheap missile kill costly missile = profit
>there are strong disincentives to ever run heavy loadouts near or over MTOW on multiroles that would make them harder and interesting to fly.
The only disincentives is wether you are controlling the sky with other players occupying enemies and intercepting missiles for you.
Without MCM you'd have even less reasons to fly heavy loadouts
>>
File: vtol.jpg (1016 KB, 1920x1280)
1016 KB JPG
>>65617740
I don't know what it's called exactly but manufacturers all seem to be adopting this style now. Fewer moving parts I guess.
>>
>>65636055
>Fewer moving parts I guess.
While not wrong, your example is just much cheaper, with no human risk and expandable
Electric engines are still only workable for smallish drones and modern computing played a big part in being able to use them.

Nuclear Option Tarantula would be insanely difficult to build, maintain, and likely wouldn't have performance that good.
>>
>>65619223
You can keep hitting the same target without orbiting if you just reverse course and fly upside down. The sole downside is that it's slow and has the radar signature of a barn made out of aluminium strips.

>>65619445
It's the oldest plane in lore so, never. It also has the best soundtrack of any vehicle in any game ever.
>>
>>65635933
Everything in your post is wrong and stupid. Learn to fly low in Compasses and the like instead of whinging that MCM makes the game anything other than gay.

Also, a single Ifrit can kill four Shards perfectly reliably. Get good.
>>
>>65637075
Guess I triggered a lazy fag mad because MCM deny him no-effort kills, MCM is realistic and make the gameplay less predictable, deal with it.

>killing shards with the best stealth fighter/bomber
*yawn*
Unless you are killing them together with only one load or soloing an Argus without either being a suicide mission I don't care
>>
>>65637075
>instead of whinging that MCM makes the game anything other than gay
It seems like anon isn't the one whinging, you are.
>>
>>65636055
Unmanned vtol crickets when?
>>
File: choose.jpg (88 KB, 1600x900)
88 KB JPG
It really is nice to have a game that's not limited to jet fighter.

Nothing is off limit to the devs and we are almost getting a unique gameplay per aircraft

Flight model:
- classic propeller aircraft
- aircraft with canard
- jet with thrust vectoring
- VTOL aircraft, with and without vectoring
- classic helicopter
- tilt-rotor helicopter (to be fair it's a VTOL)
- helicopter with propulsion fan
- aircraft with variable wings
- soon a big cargo plane with JATO and thrust reverser

Oh and and anti-grav ??? alien saucer gameplay
>>
>>65620362
The worst part about socialization going to the internet is people like you used to get punched in the mouth for speaking until you developed a soul.
>>
>>65638583
I see you are an optimist
People like him used to die from their own stupidity, cleaning the genetic pool.
>>
>>65635933
Destroyers and carriers are a non-issue. You just pop the radar with a Medusa and they're helpless. The Argus is the only ship that needs any real effort to take down.
>>
>>65639948
That's only because the game don't protect them properly, destroyer and carrier would realistically have enough escorts with IR and guns to require more than one medusa and a swarm.
And the Argus itself can only be taken down if it's isolated and/or you've been spamming cruise missiles to deplete its defense.

I don't mind ships being tough nuts to crack, but game is lacking in other target to use anti-surface missiles on
>>
Is the performance of anti-air defenses in this game realistic? Like I understand it isn't the 90s anymore and a single Silkworm isn't a 50/50 chance of doom, but the Hyperion, Argus, and Dynamo can literally wipe out an entire salvo of 20-30 anti ship missiles travelling transonic speeds on the deck.
>>
>>65638553
a little bit of everything for everyone to use
>>
File: 1767704251807876.jpg (938 KB, 2294x1508)
938 KB JPG
>>65617740
looks retarded with those small rotors
a single big hub is much better, pic related is roughly the same size
>>
>>65640240
I think it's a little better then it should be but for gameplay purposes I think it sits in a fairly good spot.
>>
>>65643620
They aren't roughly the same size at all, the Mi-26 is about 33% larger
>>
>>65643620
>better
For what? Payload perhaps, but not much else: speed and range of the Mi-26 are abysmal and any tilt rotor will have higher speed and range anyways. Yes, a bigger slower rotor/propeller is in theory more efficient than a smaller faster one, but at a certain point there are technological limits to the viability of a fuckhuge rotor, like the fact that you're hanging 56t of inertial mass to a rapidly spinning shaft that also needs to be as light as possible. I can see a modern Mi-26 built with CFRP and whatnot, but it's going to cost a pretty penny. As for speed, single rotor helicopters will always incur in the hard limit of the retreading blade stall, so multirotor is the most sensible way to get around all the limitations.
>>
File: image2.png (3.75 MB, 2559x1331)
3.75 MB PNG
>>65643620
Large rotors are limited by the tips reaching supersonic speed.
Not going to say the Tarantula is 100% realistic but it's credible enough
>>
>>65645258
the osprey works well and the tarantula is just a bigger osprey
>>
>>65648860
To be honest the Osprey work poorly and the Tarantula carry much more proportionally.
It's literally a VTOL C-130
>>
>>65617740
>>65618256
Wouldn't the propwash from the front set of propellers reduce lift from the second following set of props?
>>
>>65650167
I think that only happens if the propellers are rotating in the same direction. If they rotate in opposite directions then the second set produces more lift.
>>
File: kairos2.jpg (368 KB, 1920x1080)
368 KB JPG
Would it make more sense to engage an ekranoplan with anti-ship missiles or anti-air missiles?
>>
>>65650750
Anti-air. Unlike a ship it isn't floating on the water, so you only need to disrupt the aerodynamics a little and it will smash into the water and tear itself apart.
>>
>>65617740
Are the tilting propellers necessary? Couldn't you just upscale drone design?
>>
>>65651120
>what if my little faggot drone was made 100x bigger?
War can only be so gay
>>
>>65651120
Tilting propellers lets it fly faster than a helicopter can, like a plane.
>>
Future-wise electric propellers can be powerful and lightweight and allow a simple actuated linkage.

Rather than tilting a whole wing, you can have a static wingbox and very large flaperons and popout leading edges. Now you have a less narrow point of failure than the wing pivot point.
>>
File: file.png (209 KB, 1024x513)
209 KB PNG
>>65650167
As the other anon >>65650246 said, as long as they are contra rotating it's actually better
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contra-rotating_propellers

>>65651120
Drones can only tilt themselves for speed because they have no one aboard, no difficult cargo and a smaller body.
Seriously, we shouldn't have to tell you something that obvious.
>>
>>65651556
The wing tilt along with the propeller because if it didn't it would block the airstream.
The Osprey don't do it because its wings are smaller and the rotors are wider so it's negligible.
>>
File: Lun-class ekranoplan.webm (2.31 MB, 640x480)
2.31 MB
2.31 MB WEBM
>>65650750
An Ekranoplan has all the disadvantage of a plane and a boat with very little of the advantages of either.
To have enough speed it's not going to be heavily armored.

That said, if the right part are armored, AA missile might actually lack the punch to do more than disable engines.
Anti-ship missiles however would completely wreck it. So would other kind like anti-tank missiles.

I could see surface effect anti-ship drones.
>>
File: shrike.jpg (860 KB, 2509x3120)
860 KB JPG
F-5E Tiger II
>make it fatter
YF-17 Cobra
>make it fatter
F-18C Hornet
>make it fatter
F-18E Super Hornet
>make it fatter
F-18 Block III
>make it fa-
>...
>no, retvrn to tradition
>>
>>65651752
In its day it would be airborne so largely invisible to sonar yet be low enough to be undetectable by look down radar. Running at a few hundred miles an hour made it a very interesting proposition.
Technology has largely overtaken it.
>>
>>65652896
Even with cold war technology I don't think it could be used efficiently.
It's like the Russian "golden fish" K-222 submarine, they thought that by maximizing speed they would completely defeat torpedo interception.
The problem is that same speed made so much noise the US enemy would easily predict its movement and the noise deafened the submarines own sensors.

The only use I see for Ekranoplan today would be for quick cargo transportation.
They cannot be intercepted by a submarine or other boat, even if the later had anti-air missiles it would need to be already on the way.
They would be too fast to plan an intercept, and you'd need to operate a stealth aircraft to intercept from the air.
They are also too fast to intercept with mere drones, you'd need a proper anti-air missiles to hit a target flying as low as you can fly.

Sure they have plenty of limitation, the sea, the weather, but they could make the difference. Like say, resupplying warship in missiles very quickly.
>>
>>65651752
>So would other kind like anti-tank missiles
I don't buy that.
Anti-tank weapons work for one of two reasons.
> small crew compartment near guarantees crew loss by spalling and richochet
> fuel and munitions are highly volatile and easily detonated by penetrating fire

In terms of bulk, HEAT/EFP do fuck all, they're quite narrow in effect and if it weren't for the squishy/volatile elements, would produce through-and-through wounds to tanks.
An Ekranoplan has the bulk that this could be prevented. Self-sealing fuel tanks, tanks that dump their fuel when penetrated, simple cut-off valves for penetrated tanks...these would prevent fuel fires pretty well, engines can just be shutdown and isolated.
Munitions can be concentrated in an armoured magazine or dispersed with blow-out panels.
Crew can be armoured or dispersed or both.

I think AT weapons have a fairly low probability-of-kill from single hits and would require multiple hits on target to reliably achieve anything worth talking about.
>>
>>65652937
The unsolvable problem was that it needed a perfectly flat surface to maintain the right altitude. It was fine on a lake but it never would have worked on the ocean because of all the waves.
>>
>>65617740
Wouldn't there be some pretty wicked air turbulence in forward flight when the rear props are in the rotor wash of the front props?
>>
>>65617740
>one engine fails
>100 troop load dies
>>
>>65652989
>Wouldn't there be some pretty wicked air turbulence in forward flight when the rear props are in the rotor wash of the front props?
I have no expertise in the field but it seems to me that the rotor wash of the front props probably isn't that chaotic and is likely highly structured based on the shape and speed of the front props.
Due to this, I feel like you could engine the rear props to interact with the structured turbulence in aerodynamically useful ways.

Whether this is an achievable engineering task is far beyond my understanding though.
>>
>>65652989
It'd be no worse than what a contrat rotating helo gets. Which is not enough that it matters
>>
File: Martin P6M SeaMaster.jpg (387 KB, 758x913)
387 KB JPG
>>65652949
>An Ekranoplan has the bulk that this could be prevented.
That's absolutely not the case.
Best case is a small missile not hitting something empty with no critical system, or causing only enough damage to force an emergency landing.
Anti-tank weapons focus on piercing through armor first, then exploding, but ground-effect flier would have no armor to speak off, all the energy a HEAT head normally use to pierce through armor would instead tear apart the aerodynamic structure.

Oh and if it damage the hydrodynamic structure (the floater) you might end up trying to land, only to have water slam the interior if as if you hit a wall.

>Self-sealing fuel tanks, tanks that dump their fuel when penetrated, simple cut-off valves for penetrated tanks...these would prevent fuel fires pretty well
Sorry but that's wishful thinking and I am well versed in airliner with separate hydraulic system and fuel lines.
Features like those are not easily built on aircraft and those rely on the damage being accidental, not originating from explosives.

>engines can just be shutdown and isolated.
Imagining a design where the engines aren't next to each other (unlike the Kaspian monster), loosing one engine could already be too much to maintain the speed or balance necessary to maintain the ground-effect (they don't have as much leeway when it come to lift)
At best it's a mobility kill.

>Munitions can be concentrated in an armoured magazine or dispersed with blow-out panels.
Put aside rearming Ekranoplan today, you are better keeping everything outside, and not being hit.

The only reason Anti-Tank missile might have difficulty destroying a ground-effect vehicle is because they would be faster than the targets they are optimized for.
An Anti-Air missile would typically home straight to the engines.

>>65652988
It's true that unless you increase the wingspan and manage a ground-effect higher over the sea (making it essentially an aircraft) weather would severely limit its use.
>>
File: file.png (817 KB, 1050x528)
817 KB PNG
>>65653010
Never bothered the Chinook.

The rotors of the Tarantula are all mechanically linked, you'll need to loose the engine and damage shafts (or the blades).
And even then...
If it's carrying something as light as soldiers, the Tarantula can easily fly with only 2 engines as long as they are opposite around the center of mass.
>>
>>65653181
>Anti-tank weapons focus on piercing through armor first, then exploding
[citation needed]
Are you confusing anti-tank with WWII anti-battleship or modern anti-bunker?
It's definitely not how a HEAT warhead works.

>all the energy a HEAT head normally use to pierce through armor would instead tear apart the aerodynamic structure.
No, it would just punch straight through with a bit of side splatter of very hot and fast copper spray that wouldn't do much unless it hit something energetic or flammable.
>>
>>65617740
big target
easy to be detected
most likely slow enough to be hit by missiles
>>
File: 1527405398050.jpg (167 KB, 1800x1095)
167 KB JPG
>>65653204
Dude, that basic knowledge here, the HEAT warhead is a shaped charge
>wouldn't do much unless it hit something energetic or flammable
Wishful thinking since your target is a flier full of fuel, structural elements at their limit to reduce weight, and we can also add controls if it doesn't have enough redundancy.
And let's not forget opening a hole in a seaplane floater that has to land, and no I'm not talking of it sinking, I'm talking of the water hitting not a strong slope but tearing the whole structure apart as water is less forgiving than compressible air.

Then there's tandem charge behind the HEAT one
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tandem-charge
>Examples of missiles that use tandem charges include the BGM-71 TOW, FGM-148 Javelin and the Brimstone.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AGM-114_Hellfire
>Hellfire II's semi-active laser variants—AGM-114K high-explosive anti-tank (HEAT), AGM-114KII with external blast fragmentation sleeve, AGM-114M (blast fragmentation)
>The AGM-114R "Romeo" Hellfire II entered service in late 2012. It uses a semi-active laser homing guidance system and a K-charge multipurpose warhead[21][22] to engage targets that formerly needed multiple Hellfire variants.

Not saying something like the Kaspian monster couldn't get lucky and survive, but that would be ridiculous luck and I would focus more on not letting the missile hit than surviving it.

Anyway, as the other anon mentioned, it would have to be reliable over sea.
>>
>>65653220
Remove the CH-53, CH-47, C-130, C-17, and C-5 from service right now, military planners never thought of this.
>>
>>65650750
AA, AShMs would probably have issues tracking it and while it would be unlikely to be a 1 hit kill like most aircraft i doubt you'd need more then 3-4 missiles to insure a crash
>>
>>65652949
>>65653204
Lol, you're severely underestimating the terminal effects of an ATGM dude. Yes there is a directional component, it's still approximately 20 POUNDS of TNT exploding just outside the skin of the aircraft, it doesn't even matter if the jet happens to miss everything critical, it's gonna blow a hole in the side of the plane big enough to drive a car through.

Think about it this way, ordinary anti-air missiles use an expanding rod warhead that blows up many meters away and just peppers the target with little wires, and that aerodynamic disruption is already enough to cause a plane to tear itself apart.
>>
>>65654918
>Lol, you're severely underestimating the terminal effects of an ATGM dude.
That's fair but someone was claiming that a HEAT warhead was going to penetrate and explode internally.
The actual explosive in the HEAT would be the damaging aspect, not the copper penetrator which would be a through-and-through.
There's not a small number of stories where HMMVs laughed off RPGs because the copper just punches through and most of the cabin is empty space.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.