[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/k/ - Weapons

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: barry lyndon battle.webm (3.99 MB, 1200x720)
3.99 MB
3.99 MB WEBM
How did the intricacies of musket combat work? How would a highland charge or Swedish rush work against a three rank volley? How would it go in the absence of artillery or cavalry? Were there any big improvements in the time between the matchlock and minie ball? How useful were they on sailing ships?
>>
It didn't exist, it never existed. It was always a fake meme for television. No one ever marched in a row staring down enemy muskets, bows, cannons, whatever. It's been the same thing that war always was, dudes doing hit and runs in small squads and guerilla tactics through the forest.

Sorry anon. Don't let the media dehumanize you further.
>>
>>65641590
>
>>
>>65641494
>Were there any big improvements in the time between the matchlock and minie ball?
Flintlocks (inclusive - miqulet, snaphaunce, etc.), wheellocks, the proliferation and improvements of sabots and enclosed ammunition, percussion caps and percussion locks, VASTLY improved metallurgy, improved power chemistry, multiple bluing technologies, early conicals, breech-loading rifles, the list goes on.

>How useful were they on sailing ships?
Very, depending on where you draw the line for "musket", but you don't seem too particular on that point.
>>
>>65641920
>, improved power chemistry
The big one right there. Massive increase with corning, another massive increase with the optimisation of the chemistry. Just the British experiments with density allowed them to reduce their powder charges by over 25% and still show better velocity.
>>
>>65641494
>Were there any big improvements in the time between the matchlock and minie ball?
The flintlock was a major improvement over the matchlock. The percussion cap was a major advancement over the flintlock. Paper cartridges were a major advancement. The bayonet was a massive advancement. There were a lot of massive improvements over how the guns and powder were made.
>>
File: images(8).jpg (20 KB, 605x330)
20 KB JPG
>>65641494
Flintlocks continually evolved and got better throughout that time period.
Compare a giant kludgy jacobean lock to a joeseph manton or durs egg
>>
File: dsc-1787.jpg (202 KB, 1920x1080)
202 KB JPG
>>65641978
>>
>>65641978
It feels like you started speaking Scottish halfway through your post.
>>
>>65641590
>, dudes doing hit and runs in small squads and guerilla tactics through the forest.
so, you telling me that waterloo is fake?
>>
File: KarolinskBataljon.png (478 KB, 960x1326)
478 KB PNG
>>65641494
>https://nativeoak.org/pages/library
Link rel is a good digital library about the topic.
>How would a highland charge or Swedish rush work against a three rank volley?
Depends entirely on the terrain and the quality (and lack thereof) of the involved troops on both sides. The point of those shock tactics was to minimise the exposure time to incoming fire while forcing the (hopefully unprepared) enemy into a decisive melee engagement. Of course, those tactics were one-trick-ponies and hinged strongly on the physiological effect they aim to inflict - when the enemy holds his position or worse, is able to perform local and ordered withdrawl, then the charging unit is caught woefully out of position and is vulnerable to all sorts of hostile fire. And the charging troops also need a high degree of training and esprit de corps in order to perform such a dangerous maneuver. The lack thereof was the cause for the eventual downfall of both the Scots and the Swedes.
>How would it go in the absence of artillery or cavalry?
What do you mean by "it"? Shock tactics or linear warfare in general?
>Were there any big improvements in the time between the matchlock and minie ball?
See what the other Anons typed.
>How useful were they on sailing ships?
Very much as they allowed to target the men working in the rigging and even enabled the destruction of the rigging and sails itself. In addition to the sharpshooters in the fighting tops.
>>
Anyone feel like OP is asking for help on a homework assignment?
>>
>>65641494
Warfare fucking sucked in that whole era I'm gonna be honest
>the guns are inaccurate so uh we have to all stand in a row and get really close and everyone takes turns
Absolute buffoonery
>>
>>65642273
He seems honest, the post is dumb but I think its worth helping him out.

This kind of warfare never existed without artillery, the larger cannons predated handheld firearms, and cavalry is the reason these large formations of men existed in the first place. The Napoleonic wars codified these strategys because its impossible to control small groups of co-ordinated men without communication systems like radio, so you have to get your entire army within the view of the commander.
>>
>>65642299
>and cavalry is the reason these large formations of men existed in the first place.
pretty sure lines existed because thats simply the shape that maximizes forward firepower
advancing as scattered individuals is a good way to get ganged up on, regardless of the weapon you are using
>>
>>65642273
I doubt that linear warfare is part of any school curriculum.
>>65642291
Muskets were reasonably accurate in their engagement ranges, which were commonly up to 150 meters. Modern firearms have effective ranges of up to 800 meters but most firefights occur within the up to 300 meter bubble anyways (in urban contexts even less than 100 m). And nobody took turns firing their volleys.
>>65642299
Massed infantry formations were always arranged in rectangles and columns. 18th century lines were less massive than what the ancient greeks fielded.
>>
File: snipe.jpg (76 KB, 987x551)
76 KB JPG
>>65642380
>>65642330

Was is a stupid idea though? The US Civil war was when the system broke down in my opinion. Once Rifles were accurate and deadly to 200 yards, Commanders had to learn quickly, and we got skirmishers being more present. The English had it right with light rifle companies and we copied them with the 1st and 2ns sharpshooters, but you still need a big block of infantry to lock those units of enemy formations down so your skirmishers can pick them apart.
>>
File: 09_55.jpg (408 KB, 483x710)
408 KB JPG
>>65642416
Massed infantry formations and thusly linear warfare? Of course it wasn't stupid; this worked well for over a thousand of years.
>The US Civil war was when the system broke down in my opinion.
Already by the Napoleonic Wars massive skirmishing formations were deployed on the regular basis. Ideally, if training permitted, every line regiment had flank companies (grenadier & the dedicated "light" one) and both ought to be able to perform skirmishing duties. Napoleonic France went further and raised specialised "light" regiments where every soldier was trained to a higher standard than regular line soldiers and thus were capable of performing skirmishing, line and shock duties. But only with the mass production and introduction of rifles as well as specialised projectiles with limited self cleaning capabilities did massed rifle fire and the wholesale introduction of skirmishing tactics become feasable.
>>
>>65641494
Line combat of the 18th-19th century was basically a mix of rock paper scissors and a deadly game of chicken.

It depended on the interplay of infantry, cavalry and artillery to work.
Infantry holds ground and fights other infantry, artillery beats infantry but loses to cavalry, cavalry cannot beat well organised infantry etc. who wins or loses was more up to the individual training of the men than sheer numbers. French shock tactics were remarkably effective against continental conscript armies but when it came up against solidly trained Brits who stubbornly held the line no matter what they were less effective.

Cavalry was surprisingly important in this period as horsemen were basically the tanks of their time. They were fast enough toexploit holes in the enemy line and fast enough to respond to enemy breakthroughs.
>>65642416
>The US Civil war was when the system broke down in my opinion.
I agree. I'm not sure why contemporary American generals were so slow to adapt to European style extended skirmish lines. They tried using Napoleonic tactics but without the cavalry hammer that were so vital.
>>
>>65642416
Skirmishers were never a decisive component of any engagement. Just another shaping element. The average soldier couldn't shoot any better with a rifle-musket than they could with a smoothbore and neither they nor their officers had the training to close with the enemy in a timely and organized fashion. So they just sat there picking each other apart for no real gain a lot of the time.
>>
>>65641590
>It didn't exist, it never existed. It was always a fake meme for television. No one ever marched in a row staring down enemy muskets, bows, cannons, whatever. It's been the same thing that war always was, dudes doing hit and runs in small squads and guerilla tactics through the forest.
>>
>>65641590
Retard. Dudes writing about their experiences from back then is not fake media made for television. You can just read it.
You just think that because television and film dramatized it to often make it look dumber than it is, that the whole idea of linear warfare and fighting in formations must be fake.
>>
>>65642475
>They tried using Napoleonic tactics but without the cavalry hammer that were so vital.
US cavalry and soldiers in general were usually not up to the standards required to execute those tactics. gotta remember that both sides pretty much built their armies from scratch, the US didn't have a noteworthy army pre civil war
>>
>>65642930
Yeah but that still doesn't explain why they focused on using 50 year old tactics in an age where they had easy access to newer information and European advisors.

I mean the dudes leading the armies weren't idiots
>>
>>65642920
This, and the op webm is laughably stupid. You'd have to be intentionally suicidal to allow the enemy to shoot 5 volleys at you without shooting back. You'd EXCHANGE 2 or 3, then end with a bayonet charge
>>
>>65642946
>I mean the dudes leading the armies weren't idiots
some civil war buffs might argue otherwise for some of them lol, but either way you gotta work with what you got. I do remember reading a comment from a european observer remarking on how us cavalry were reluctant to charge home into melee and preferred to skirmish with their revolvers instead, but I have no sauce for that particular anecdote.
>>
>>65641494
>>65641590
Line formation combat was absolutely a thing, movies just depict it really stupidly to make it look really retarded. The whole point was to lay down way more lead than the enemy so they'd lose composure and flee so you could rout them, which is why reloading speed was such an important metric of training, no one's just marching forward and taking volleys while in shooting distance.
>>
>>65642946
because the US was using translations of French manuals. most of those were written before those modern innovations. those that weren't were written after the French intervention in the Italian wars of unification.
the French experience drawn from their involvement was that,
a) the bayonet can still win battles and campaigns
b) just shooting at each other produces more casualties than a failed charge and is far less decisive
now the French developed a much more intricate system around those experiences. a system that was taxing enough for a graduate from Saint-Cyr or West point. never mind the glut of political officers with their raw dog volunteers.
>>
>>65642984
>movies just depict it really stupidly to make it look really retarded.
As always, Waterloo is the standout example of how to actually portray Napoleonic warfare.
>>
>>65642976
Likewise during the Franco Prussian war, where cavalry was beyond obsolete with breech loading cartridge rifles, American observers were wondering why they had a cavalry reserve that was practically suicidal when they could be used for deep penetration raids into the enemy's rear. The Western front of the Civil War had corps of mounted troopers 10,000 strong disrupting rail networks for the entire theater of operations. It was different styles of thinking.
>>
File: 1778754302234834.jpg (631 KB, 1280x1920)
631 KB JPG
>>65641494
>Were there any big improvements in the time between the matchlock and minie ball?
No, nothing happened during this time. People just didn't bother back then
>>
>>65643144
bet that bitch is reading a cookbook
>>
>>65643153
>implying a typical fat person will actually cook instead of just eating premade slop
>>
>>65643184

Non White detected. Begone.
>>
File: 1434834602990.png (70 KB, 853x787)
70 KB PNG
>>65642416
Accurate rifles didn't actually mean much. Sure, you could train your men to fire at 200 or 300 yards but the training for such a thing was always lacking. Judging distances is a skill that is hard to learn. The tall ballistic arcs of big heavy balls or even menie balls means that a small misjudgement would make the rounds fall way off from the enemy. Even after rifles were mass adopted your soldiers were still firing at 100 yards or less.
>>65642712
Skirmishers were mostly taking pot shots at the enemy line and trying to get them to fire a volley too early. If they fire too early then their volley won't do much damage to your line.
>>
>>65643355
another issue is that black powder will put out a ton of smoke, so in any significant firefight you'll risk ending up struggling to see anything at significant distance anyway
>>
>>65642712
>The average soldier couldn't shoot any better with a rifle-musket than they could with a smoothbore

Yeah, but average soldiers weren't riflemen until breech-loaders started coming to the fore. Riflemen in the Napoleonic Era and earlier were generally superior (not not necessarily by much) marksmen who were used to engage in skirmishing, scouting, harassing and ambushing.
>>
>>65642291
>we have to all stand in a row and get really close and everyone takes turns
Real life wasn't like Hollywood depicted it. They were standing 75-150 meters apart IRL and didn't take turns.
>>
File: Ming_musketeers.jpg (54 KB, 500x501)
54 KB JPG
>>65641494
Ottoman musket with serpentine lock spread via Central Asia before the Portuguese spread the arquebus snaplock via the ocean route.
>>
>>65642416
>The US Civil war was when the system broke down
Not really a great example, that was amateur hour. The quality of both troops and commanders was absolute dogshit.
>>
>>65641494
That was poor drill, but dramatic.
The correct way is the first rank fires while the second reloads, etc, thereby keeping a constant stream of fire to reduce the attackers ranks before they can close with bayonets.
>>
>>65641920
Also the entire line of bayonet improvements.
>>
>>65643771
>American Civil War
>>
>>65642416
https://youtu.be/UUmeV1e8aJQ
Posting this video as Paper Cartridges talks a lot about how Americans and Europeans saw warfare in the 1860's. In one of his Prussian videos he talks about why shock tactics were relied upon by Austria up until the late 1800's.
>>
File: Sherman.jpg (74 KB, 600x600)
74 KB JPG
>>65642416
>>65642443
>US Civil War
The real game changer came with Sherman and his urban redevelopment of Georgia and South Carolina. "Living off the Land" wasn't a new strategy since Napoleon did that.
But Sherman also targeted the industrial and commercial output of the enemy to great effect.
Though this is tactics and not weaponry, still a good reason to post this pic though.
>>
Daily reminder that redcoat memes are used by Armatard and warriortard to divide Americans from their mission of supporting UK-led initiatives to contain Russia.
>>
>>65648792
>But Sherman also targeted the industrial and commercial output of the enemy to great effect.
I'd argue that this was nothing new, and the civil war only differed by taking place in a more industrialized/urban economy not quite as dependent on agriculture
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chevauchée
In fact one could make a case that military foraging had a similar effect in of itself:
>a food production surplus is necessary to support people in other economic activity like manufacturing, because the finite time/effort they spend in other work can't be invested into producing their own food
>just keeping itself supplied is enough for an army of noteworthy size to quickly strip the local environment bare
>if staying in one place without dispersing to garrison, resulting food shortages will force skilled workers to divert time/effort into subsistence to sustain themselves
>>
>>65648838
Why should I care what happens in europe
>>
>>65641991
Underrated post
>>
>>65642976

> I do remember reading a comment from a european observer remarking on how us cavalry were reluctant to charge home into melee and preferred to skirmish with their revolvers instead,

That's because at the beginning of the war most Union and Confederate cavalrymen were raw recruits. Prior to the war the US Cavalry Corps was tiny, and primarily used for scouting, courier service, and occasionally skirmishing with native tribes in the Great Plains. Cavalry swelled with draftees and volunteers during the war, but neither the armies had the institutional knowledge to use them conventionally in the European manner. However, as the war progressed and American cavalrymen gained experience and confidence, cavalry charges and melee with sabres became more common, as is attested by official military records.
>>
>>65654570
You're right, Israel is more important.
>>
>>65655433
>"if you dont support X you support Y" strawman
everything outside of the CONUS isnt MY (John Q Anonymous') problem
>>
>>65654570
>Oh no, we're alone against china! How could this possibly have happened!
>>
>>65641494
>How did the intricacies of musket combat work?
That's a hell of a question, in summary you present with your men and attempt to coordinate effectively to force your opponent from your objective.
>How would a highland charge or Swedish rush work against a three rank volley?
Depends if they have bayonets and strong discipline.
>How would it go in the absence of artillery or cavalry?
A painful slug fest for everyone involved.
>Were there any big improvements in the time between the matchlock and minie ball?
Tons, the socket bayonet, more reliable lock works, standardized patterns, metallurgy and manufacturing changes, inspections.
>How useful were they on sailing ships?
Vital, for maintaining order and repelling attacks.
>>
>>65642291
It all comes down to coordination, if your men are too lose they get disorganized and shot to pieces or run down by cavalry, if they're too rigid or slow artillery will blast them, tough spot.
>>
>>65642330
Yes, but it's also protection against cavalry so they don't ride down your men. Forming square or even just fixing bayonets and staying still is essential, safety in numbers.
>>
>>65642189
They never found any bodies at the alledged site of Waterloo.
Checkmate media zombies.
>>
Rifles were accurate to about ~v80 yards and took 30 seconds to reload. If you blow your load from too far away, you'll do minimum damage and the enemy will close the distance before you manage to reload and face rape you with a devastating volley instead. That's why line warfare had to be the way it was. 18th century warfare was also mostly about maneuvering back and forth until one of the armies got into an untenable position and a relatively quick fight forced the badly positioned army to surrender. No commander wants a head on fight where you just march into each other on an open field because it results in painful losses even in the best case scenario. People weren't stupid.
18th century warfare was also generally much smaller scale than people think it is, and these types of mass casualty events with thousands of corpses littering the battlefield people might imagine because of movies and the like are more of a 19th century thing.
As soon as you get into the 19th century and rifles are more accurate and armies larger, tactics immediately change and you see more skirmishing, trenches, etc. and things we might associate with modern warfare.
>>
>>65660619
Because they were turned into fertilizer.
>>
>>65660676
>there are no corpses at Waterloo because … ugh..the Belgians turned them into sugar
Cool story bro.
>>
>>65641494
It was the optimal use of the available technology and tactics of the time, our ancestors were not stupid.
>>65641590
People like you are distressingly stupid and historically illiterate yet here you are with your nonsensical tard 2 cents. Your existemce is depressing to any reader with any knowledge or understanding..
>>
File: ffs.jpg (90 KB, 672x672)
90 KB JPG
>>65660619
>They never found any bodies at the alledged site of Waterloo.
>>
>>65642946
>European advisors
Observers
Europeans present at both sides of the civil war were there to check out how the Americans are doing and write back home about it. They weren't there to teach Americans how to fight. Also the fundamental issue was that both armies lacked a good officer's corps. They mostly had to learn the basics on the fly.
>>
It's impossible to understand Napoleonic linear warfare without emphasizing the centrality and dominance of cavalry.

The reason you line up guys up several ranks deep in close order with muskets equipped with long bayonets is because that's literally the only way to stop a heavy cavalry charge from punching a hole through your lines and then cutting down everyone as they flee in terror.
>>
File: IMG_20260428_173357.jpg (1.84 MB, 1542x2048)
1.84 MB JPG
I was out shooting in the woods with my brother awhile back, and we had been spending all morning shooting our long rifle. I went down the road a little ways to another group that was shooting towards the same spot to ask for a quick cease fire while we exchanged targets. They were some college bros, seemed alright. First thing they say when I approach them was "Are you guys shooting a musket!?" clearly excited by the novelty. I then corrected them by saying well no, actually it's a muzzle loading rifle and muskets are smooth bore but sometimes you have rifled muskets which are actually... by which point I realized I had literally just sperged out harder than ever before in my life and their smiles had turned to puzzeled looks. I just said "...uh ya it's a musket" and asked for a cold range



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.