What would a post nuclear army look like?
Just like a pre-nuclear military, assuming they aren't starting from scratch. Maybe a stronger emphasis on mopp and decon training, but otherwise same shit.
>>65649579Depends on who the army is in questionBut it will mostly be small, petty bands of warlords and gangs trying to take whatever they want for themselves or getting revenge on those they blame for the reason for the apocalypse, until someone bigger comes along and either curb-stomps them into submission or wipes them out
>>65649579Choose your fighter
>>65649579Frankly the NCR would be a better fit.
Marines become pirates, soldiers become outlaws.
>>65649579Like a 1950s/1960s or African army.>little to no uniform standardization>little to no body armor>an assortment of small arms>light, mostly civilian, vehicles>older helicopters>prop planes>potentially horses depending on the regionIt would be pretty kino actually
A bunch of disposable, starving, desperate people thrown at an enemy because the actual force behind them are total despots who commit such extravagant atrocity to dissenters that anyone doing actual fighting is motivated exclusively by fear and booty. So in other words, modern day Russia.
>>65649579Too many variables to give a proper answer without contextual grounding.
>>65649579It would look like the national army of the country in question. What a stupid question. The military has access to weapons, gear, supplies of shelf stable food, water purification, a rigid command structure and most importantly contingency plans for this. They also have a mandate from the people of the country to restore order. It's not even in question. Even if most of the army gets nuked, enough of it will survive in the form of reservists etc. to assume control very rapidly. The only other thing a post nuclear army would look like is either the invasion forces of the people who nuked you or UN led relief efforts (very low probability though).
>>65649854>Soldiers become the lawFixed for you
>>65649579The thousand year Reich of the engineer class
Batons, a lot of people beating each other with batons and a lot of smiles.
>>65649579I was reading a book that had a post apocalyptic army with veterans leading it and everyone else was forced into joining or killed. all the women were turned into sex slaves.The other army in the story was formed by the national guard, local firefighters, police, and civilians.
>>65649579Just play Metro 2033 nigga, they’ve got multiple types of armies to analyze>retarded meat-waving Reds>marginally less retard cargo cultish (they literally built a functioning Panzer III mounted on rails) Nazis>semi-professional soldiers of Hanza and Polis decked out in pre-war kit like NVGs>Children of the Underground (random working class stiffs with whatever firearms they had on-hand)>literal child sex cannibal cultists>generic anime thug bandits who are only three to serve as walking loot boxes>the odd Stalker>Spartan Rangers, who are literal aging Spetsnaz glowniggers (plus a US Marine who presumably bonded with them over their shared affinity for rape) who genuinely believe they’re obeying orders from a government that no longer exists, so elite that their numbers have dwindled to the double digits because they won’t accept randos unless they’re carrying the super sekrit challenge coin
>>65649579They would look super gay.
>>65649579Low tier "military">local gangs/raiders simply taking what they want potentially forming pacts or confederations with other groups or a particular stable hub to do business withmid tier>warlords running trade routes and trading posts>pure infantry with minimal motorization>training would be on par with typical insurgent forces (weapons familiarization and a lot of learning "on the job")>mostly garrison troopshigh tier>entire regions under its control with limited manufacturing capacity>conscript force using regimental/officer corps method of having your SL's and PL's and up be well trained and have them train the conscripts>basic fire and movement emphasizing battle drills mostly>decent standard issued equipment with capacity to repair and replace parts>bulk logistics done via rail most likely using steam locomotives with last mile having decent motorized capability, still probably using a lot of handcarts and pack mules (comparable to the bulk of the Wehrmacht during WWII)At most, things would probably resemble WWII era tactics and force makeups, doing things like taking the cannons out of M1 Abrams tanks and making towed AT/direct fire guns out of them.
>>65650238they have plans but its hard to say if they will survive on contact, that and much of the militarys ability to sustain itself would get nuked as well or will get fucked by the supply chain nukage (both literally and metaphorically)
>>65651011What flag?
>>65649922You are in denial.
>>65650238>access to weaponsThat break and require constant repair, specifically lubricants that you will no longer have>gearthat you have on you and nothing else>supplies of shelf stable foodSo you can sustain your military for 5-7 days? Then what?>water purification bulk water purification requires generators and gas to run said generators. Have fun ordering your army to forage and filter/boil their own water like everybody else.>rigid command structureMostly blown to shit with communications beyond fucked combined with now having problems everywhere which leads to conflicting ideas as to what to do or which orders to follow. This also ignores personal ambition of leaders and units and how they would react to the entire country being blown up. Maybe they don't give a shit what Washington wants them to do anymore?>contingency plansmostly ended with the nuclear exchange and the plans that extended beyond that were written in the 50s and 60s. There is no plan. >mandate from the people to restore orderlol, lmao even.
>>65651018Generic SPQR flag with the Aquila
>>65649579>What would a post nuclear army look like?Like this.
>>65651049Lolz he thinks a full scale nuclear war is unsurviable! Don't you have a shovel?
>>65651049Thats just 29 Palms
>>65651024Literally every single thing in this post is wrong. Astonishing.It's predicated on a nearly complete ignorance of how the military works. In it's way it's perfect since there's no way to address the poster because it'd be akin to trying to explain an airliner to a fish.
>>65651031Elagabalus, is that you?
It depends on whether the nuclear apocalypse is total or simply a breakdown of the global economy levels of bad. There's a lot more interesting things in the latter scenario IMO, a post nuclear war going into long term resource war military would be quite interesting.
The faggots who despise the shoddy treatment of the NCR in the TV series, are those faggots who self-inserted the NCR as a replacement for a large well-equipped state-organized military with uniforms and rank structures like the one the US has now, its basically the COD and military fetishists which /k/ is infested with. They are upset that the NCR no longer exists as the vehicle for them to live out their fantasies of pic relatedThese are the same faggots who make those hour-long videos about reforming the Minutemen in Fallout 4 into a massive Commonwealth army that uses Gunner-like BDU uniforms and different specialized branches
>>65651057Well, under the assumption that OP thinks that every nation and organization in the world is obliterated to the point that every conventional military is wiped out, the chances for everybody else doesn't bode well either.
>>65651016In the immediate aftermath of a nuclear war, the central government would be dictatorial with no separation of powers whatsoever.Governments have access to what are called buffer depots. These are depots where food, fuel, and medication is stored for usually six months before it is put on the commercial market. It is a strategic reserve. Access to this kind of resources will buy the central government loyalty of the military and law enforcement … you do not bite the hand that feeds you, in this case literarily.All privately owned property would be pooled and become government property with the exception of the clothes you wear and some spare clothes. Initially, you would be paid in food, shelter, and medical attention.This is the first stage in the Reconstruction and Reconstitution of Forces Phase.The second phase would see the limited introduction of newly printed money (all previous currency would be declared null and void). You would now receive your pay in currency and there would be a slow but steady conversion from a purely planned economy to a partial free-market economy. At this point, you could buy luxury items such as jewelry, bicycles, make-up, etc, but not yet real estate or cars (fuel would still be scarce).The third stage would see the introduction of new elections at the local level, followed by elections at the regional level and finally at the national level.It should be noted that a lot of local and regional boundaries would have changed due to shifting populations, contamination, etc.After these elections, separation of powers would be re-introduced and the military would slowly but gradually begin to transfer authority back to civilians.Finally, economic restrictions would be lifted and you would be able to buy whatever you want.It is estimated this whole process would take between 10 and 15 years.
>>65651099That depends on the preposition that1. the central government survived getting wiped and2. the public, or even state level governments still care about the opinions of the fags whose decisions got them nukedState level balkanization is just as likely a scenario as the old nation is written off as a failed example of a state, with interactions between them degrading into barter or local power moves based on their remaining resources and practical productive ability.
>>65650283No, they would clash with the police, and since they have better weapons would likely win.
>>65649579this nigga
>>65651094>t.contrarian faggot
>>65651062>actual zero reply>attempts to try to make anon seem stupidGet the fuck out of here retard.
>>65649751If you can find them, then you can hire The Dysgenic Team
>>65651071No, but it can be if you close your eyeshttps://files.catbox.moe/ic04b5.mp4
>>65651188whoops, fucked video. Here's the shitty versionhttps://files.catbox.moe/xt0jcy.mp4
I miss Jericho. Awesome show. Shit was nuts.
>>65649579Literally the NCR
>>65651289>t.raped by literally every tribal and raider they fight
>Just another thinly-veiled excuse thread by some faggot wanting to talk about his franchise on the wrong board
>>65649579
>>65649579For a developed state, I like to imagine something like this.
>>65651317>beats the Khans so badly they run and hide>vipers are essentially gone>fiends only around because the legion supports them and the khans give them super meth>subjugated Super Mutants and now has them in their ranks>ghoul troopers who can fight in super irradiated zones>decimated the brotherhood of steelCome on anon
>>65651349>future golem>star of davidchecks out desu
>>65651353>BTFO'd by one nuke>turned into a memberberry on a shitty tv showohnonono xisters...
>>65651192Sorry, I am not sophisticated enough for this kind of stuff.The idea that you might have made that video because of my comment, creating a brief connection, left me feeling somewhat disoriented TBQH.
>>65651357>tv showOh boy have you not seen what they’ve done with Caesar’s Legion?
Nuclear war would be a nothingburger in spite of what the doomsday clock fags, the fictional media consumer fags, (debunked) nuclear winter fags, and any other fag would tell you. we'd be back to 100% normality in 8-12 years tops
either something like fallout with proper radiation mitigation equipment like power armor or a mixed assortment of normie stuff in regular clothing. post nuclear is ambiguous, post nuclear total war where 90% of the population died is very different than post nuclear where 3 bombs were dropped in CA and nothing of any actual real world value was lost.
>>65649579Being stuck in the UK, I guess it's primitive weapons, like crossbows, swords, knives and blunt weapons, with only the most elite soldiers armed with whatever firearms can be found That said, what would YOUR nuclear army be, and what would it be armed with?
>>65651182Since apparently your idea of what happens when nuked is every supply depot, every gas station and every blade of grass will disappear immediately, I don't need to make you look stupid. You are stupid.
>>65651357>Watching the tv show period and accepting it as canonWhat's it like being retarded, anon?
>>65651856>ncr goy meltychuds like you lost the culture war, get over it :^)
>>65651869Oh, you're just trolling. My bad.
>>65651869NCR is the troon larper faction doe, house and/or yesman ending is canon since the securitrons got upgradedf4 minuteman ending is canon too since radio freedom exists
>>65651873>NOT MUH HECKIN VIDYA FACTIONS NOOOget over it already dweeb>>65651876SNCA
>>65651881anon the show lore literally supports your faggy viewpoint its shit you should care about kek
>>65651094>The faggots who despise the shoddy treatment of the NCR in the TV series, are those faggots who self-inserted the NCR as a replacement for a large well-equipped state-organized military with uniforms and rank structures like the one the US has now, its basically the COD and military fetishists which /k/ is infested with. They are upset that the NCR no longer exists as the vehicle for them to live out their fantasies of pic relatedYou can just say tranniesOh wait, that's all New Vegas fans lmao
>>65652125Anon why must you ruin every discussion
What would need to happen for an army to return to bolt action rifles?
>>65649771Women are not going to have rights in fifty years anon, or ever again after that.
>>65650238>Economic collapse is LITERALLY IMPOSSIBLE!!!! MONEY NEVER RUNS OUT!!!! BORDERS NEVER CHANGE!!!The fact you even mentioned the UN tells us everything we need to know.
>>65649579All armies around today ARE post-nuclear armies.
>>65651559Guns are medieval weapons and black powder is made from piss.
>>65652125outside of dead money (aka the retard mulcher 9001) FNV is only slightly better than the bugthesda fallouts desu, the fanbase is definitely just as faggy and hates actual gameplay kek
>>65652264>Contingency plans NEVER work!>Every single civiliian will immediately turn on the government representatives, be they military, police, sherrifs department, DVLA, firemen! EVERY ONE>NOBODY will have any national or civic pride at all! NONE! There will be NO ATTEMPTS to rebuild!Your fantasies are stupid because you are stupid.
>>65651353>>subjugated Super Mutants and now has them in their ranksno they don't. cut content is irrelevant.>>ghoul troopers who can fight in super irradiated zonesbarely any ghouls are in the NCRA and they're heavily concentrated in the rangers, who are a very small organization.>>65651094Not wrong but you could have worded it less offensively. This is both 4chan and coming from me, of all people, so I guess it's kind've silly to say.>>65651342Real talk I really hate the depiction of the enclave in most fallout fan works or discussion (even moreso than their depiction of the other factions, which is also frequently awful) because it often goes into enclave 'reformism', which is another word for 'I want America to show up again and don't give a fuck about any of the actual story elements, established lore, or themes of the Enclave'.>>65652364Loved the game but a lot of people make it out to be the Christ of games, crucified by Todd Howard. Which it isn't.
>>65652404oh yeah>decimated the Brotherhoodall we really know is that both sides lost a solid amount of people and the brotherhood eventually took a back step and conceded victory, such as it was, to NCR. for his part hardin mentions Helios as being the worst action he ever or heard of, so it doesn't seem like they were getting their ass kicked seven ways to sunday. there's an extreme paucity of war on the NCR-BoS war in general which hopefully doesn't change because with the way S2 has been i don't think they're capable of portraying anything well anymore.
>>65651610That wasn't what was said you retarded faggot. You're talking about supplying an entire army with no refineries, transportation, and many other resources available. Something as simple as lubricating your M4A1 becomes a challenge because there is no more CLP to lubricate it because the entire supply chain has been fucked.
Neo-feudal contract mercenary companies.>Company consists of 12-20 men who fill the NCO/officer positions and are well trained>Negotiate contract with local warlord for a job>Either do the job themselves, especially things like raids require high expertise or operate as an actual company>Rank and file along with supplies are provided for the contract>Additional services can be given just for establishing training and bootstrapping local officer/NCO corps for warlords, militias, pseudo city-states, whoever>Like a pirate crew or Crusader order who weren't retarded with the money, they would set up contracts with proper shares along with how potential plunder is divvied between people within the company and with the patron who hired themHaving a group of highly trained and motivated men who actually know how to wage war would obviously be a massive advantage and would fill a very likely role in a post nuclear exchange world.
>>65652830>ALL refineries, depots, oil tanks, hardware stores, warehouses will be destroyed! ALL OF THEM!>ALL transportation will be destroyed! Every car will be assigned a nuke!Your fantasies are stupid because you are stupid. In a nuclear war scenario the military is empowered to seize basically everything they want. From trucks and tankers at sea right down to your car. Fucking yachts and sailboats will be pressed into service as light transport. So basically unless the enemy has enough nukes to glass over your entire country, there will be resources left that the military will commandeer to keep the country running.
>>65649579I have the answer in /tg/ form.
>>65651342TBF, the lore accurate enclave is retarded.
>>65653184Meant for>>65652404
>>65652264Money literally never runs out.
>>65651353All of this got handed to them by the player character for free and the only reason the BOS ever gets beaten is because the narrative would be boring if they were ever allowed to win.
>>65651094Absolutely. Its kinda tedious because the NCR as they are is a pretty thoughtful look at how a resource-stretched post-apocalyptic military would equip themselves, with hemp and leather being key components of their outfits, fabric pith helmets to combat the desert heat and semi auto rifles being issued as every round is loaded by hand potentially in prewar cases so neither the supplies or budget can afford full auto. Yet every motherfucker wants to reimagine them as mass issuing Vietnam/80s/GWOT era uniforms (depending on the specific artist or modder) and combat armor and NODs; when they lack the capability to even maintain the power armor they got for free from the brotherhood, to say nothing of making their own night vision at scale, and the only decent armor they field that isnt prewar shit they inherited or captured is the patrol armor, which is explicitly expensive as shit, handmade in tiny quantities and after all that only on par with basic combat armor which is by that point literal centuries old. All of their vehicles are salvaged and they utterly lack artillery unless the player butters up the boomers, yet they're constantly envisioned as being capable of modern small unit tactics and mobility warfare; and not being an utterly broke mobik force of unsupported infantry. It kinda reminds me of stalker, where a similar length of time passed with no official entries so the community took it and ran with their own interpretation so no modern stalker mod has any resemblance to the original artstyle, everyones wearing a plate carrier and gorka suits and the mercenaries are decked out like a crye catalog; when the whole thing with stalker is theyre all dressed to protect them from reality-bending anomalies first and foremost with gunfire a distant second, so all their outfits are custom made non-conductive flame-resistant chemical coveralls rather than conventional combat uniforms.
>>65651094>salty Legion fanboy didn't see S2Also any complaints about the NCR almost always apply way more to the Legion.
>>65653184Yes, they are. They're meant to be retarded. It's a fundamentally non-workable ideology and plan outside of doing what they were trying to do in F2 and killing the rest of the world. That's failed so they will never get America back.
>>65653224The problem with how the NCR is depicted in NV is that it's a bug-eaten figleaf to hide how the NCR was portrayed in 2 and and explain how the NCR hadn't wiped the floor with the Legion long before the events of the game. So suddenly a nation-state with a functioning education system, industry, and infrastructure suddenly doesn't know how any of that works. The smart thing to do would have been to change the portrayal of the Legion into an actually functional state that can match the NCR, which would also have the benefit of fixing the logical problems of the Legion's existence.
>>65652390Anon no society on earth could survive even 1% of its population turning against it openly.
>>65649579Obviously.
>>65652404>>65653584Factions are allowed to have character development. Different members of the Enclave that disagree with their leadership has been a thing since 2.
>>65655267'Character Development' and 'Gutting him of everything it's ever been to wear as a skin mask because I think his face looks cool'.>Disagree with their governmentAutumn wasn't exactly a sterling pillary of morality. His daring idea was to only kill some/most wastelanders and extort the rest, instead of killing literally everyone. Every time you see an actually genuinely moral person in the Enclave they usually defect because it's a fundamentally evil organization that will not change.
>>65655804By any metric all of the factions are fundamentally evil.>BoS: decentralized stratocracy who violently horde technology that either let everyone else rot or turn them into pacified vassals>Followers of the Apocalypse: soft power version of the BoS who think pacifism will totally work in the Wasteland (please ignore their armed guards)>Institute: everyone not in the Institute is just a rat in an experiment >Minutemen: at best barely capable of what they claim to do, falls apart the moment they lack a charismatic and forceful leader>Railroad: will gladly let the Wasteland remain a shithole as long as one robot can get a mindwipe>NCR: speed running everything wrong with the Old World>Legion: jumped up raider gang held together by a cult of personality centered on a hypocrite who >House: delusional and actively destroying the progress of society so he can try to relive his heyday
>>65653184>>65653584They were always meant to be a commentary on those fags whose understanding of the US starts and ends with a red white and blue sticker and a slogan. They don't even know what the American values they purport to fight for are anymore, and that was before the US itself got nuked. Even in success they wouldn't have gotten the US back, just an irradiated waste followed by demographic collapse.
>>65649579Depends entirely if they can manufacture cartridges or not. If yes then lots of tube carbines or trap door breechloaders. If not, back to black powder muzzle-loaders.
>>65650556>>literal child sex cannibal cultistsThat was only in the book, and I don't remember any sex involved. Also the guys explanation on why they tenderize their meat to death was nonsense.
>>65649579If the threat of large scale nuclear warfare is gone, then the large combined arms armies of World War II would return, as long as people can support them.
>>65656684God, that would be so fucking kino.
>>65652404>cut content Literally in fallout 2
>>65657282The large amount of changes from F2 NCR (and NCRR) to FNV makes me very hesitant to just carry things over, particularly when we know that anti-mutant sentiments in NCR are on the rise + the rangers went from a dedicated anti-slavery militia to a government deathsquad. Without something in FNV saying otherwise I'd err on the side of caution.And even if they aren't, again, they're a very small subset of a very small group.
>>65657305Like, I wouldn't be shocked if they get mentioned as having existed contemptuously with FNV, but I wouldn't be shocked if they weren't either.
>>65655924What percentage of humanity would you destroy?
>>65653191Honestly, the fact that the BoS are in the process of crashing the NCR economy with no survivors is pretty impressive for how small they are. The bigger question mark is why they even had their epic spergout in the first place. Fallout 1 ended with them and the NCR being on great terms, and they're barely even in FO2.
idk I've read about how total state collapse occurs in different regions. I don't know how the meme started with thinking returning to the frontier to survive off hunting trappings would work. After the Society Union fell the rural areas completely emptied, people sold apartments to afford plane tickets back to cities. Only local police who declared themselves emperor stayed around. You absolutely wanted to be in the cities where they prioritized supplies.Basically, if the state collapses, places where trade is inevitable like port cities are where elites will be moving to anyway because they be enforcing order as soon as possible. So you'd want to be in New York if shit hit the fan. And in that instance, the police take charge in martial law, with the swat guard as the praetorian. The opposite is CHAZ.
>>65659798Anon that's not a collapse that's like a fucking birthday party compared to what we're talking about.
>>65649579Like this, minus the medieval larp.