[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/k/ - Weapons

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1794601309006858.jpg (351 KB, 1639x1802)
351 KB JPG
How scary would a unified EU military be? Would they need to agree on uniform equipment? Does America even sell them gear if they try to form up as an alternative to NATO?
>>
For the citizens of the EU very scary.
>>
>>65651927
First you have to figure out who controls it
>>
>>65651937
The US
>>
Let's try to discuss weapons guys.
What should be their
>fighter jet
>mbt
>service rifle
>what will their navy look like
etc.
>>
>>65651938
No like actually

Which legislative body of the EU actually has the unilateral authority to set foreign policy and potentially deploy a military force without unanimous agreement from every member state?

If you turn it into a UN Security Council thing where even a single no vote kills the whole initiative the organization is DOA.
>>
>>65651946
I can see smaller nations cooperating fairly well but France, Germany and Britain will never allow the other to leverage their military. At best you'll see a UN Security Council situation
>>
>>65651927
>"muh EU army"
What this actually means is a unified command and coordination structure for the various European national militaries that was provided by the US before now, but that is considerably less clickbait-worthy.
>>
File: 1696897434484899.jpg (902 KB, 1659x2500)
902 KB JPG
>>65651927
With what fucking money? Are Euroids finally ready to drop their universal healthcare?
>>
>>65651927
It would be very, very bipolar schizophrenic.
Everything is already unified through NATO command so the whole idea is a pointless meme anyways.
>>
>>65651946
The more difficult question, who has authority to end the war?

All of these questions ultimately lead to one of two arrangements: a voluntary organisation, or a mandatory one
>>
>>65651936
fpbp
>>
>>65651927
>GDUK to produce all AFVs
>Damen gets all warship contracts
>Saab will build all warplanes
>GSG the sole contractor for small arms
the world will tremble
>>
>>65651946
The President of the European Commission gets absolute control.
>>
>>65651946
We'll do it live, fuck it!
Let Poland, the Nordics, and the Balts, write the policy. And let them employ the French preemptive thermonuclear """warning shot""" doctrine.
That's how it's done.
Just ignore and dismiss the counterproductive kraut bureaucracy, the endless anglo-bong cuckoldry, and any delusions of "authority" or "legitimacy" presented by anyone claiming to represent the entirely phony and fabricated "nation" of Belgium.
>>
More seething third-world spam.
>>
>>65651958
Universal healthcare, especially with how gutted the health sector is, makes up a small amount of the money spent.
Way more money is spent on neets, "immigrants", pensioners.
Now go bankrupt from a root canal treatment, retard.
>>
>>65651927
>How scary would a unified EU military be?
It would scare the living shit out of everyone involved.
Pic very much related.
>>
>>65651994
then the euro wakes up and finds an army with the latest hardware that never gets approved for use
>>
>>65651927
Not very. Russia might be scared, but that's because Russia considers the poorest country in Europe to be its peer adversary.
>>
>>65651927
Cool, now how many Europeans would actually be willing to undergo conscription and fight, if needed?
>>
>>65651958
>muh euroid healthcare spending
By every single metric, the US spends more on healthcare. Per person, as proportion of gov spending, as a proportion of gdp, etc
Euros just don't let their doctors scam them
>>
>>65652067
Just use the countries with existing conscription systems as barrier troops and send the west europeans to act as meat waves.
>>
>>65652069
>pure insurance spending
Is less.
>proves government healthcare is nothing but a scam that should be dissolved
Never change Europeons.
>>
>>65651927
A "unified" EU Army would only exist for a single reason. If a member state finally got fed up with "enrichment" and started to remove kebab the EU Army would come down on them and either go full 1945 Red Army or disarm the people and allow the "enrichment" to continue.
>>
>>65651936
>>65651937
>>65651938
>>65651940
Lol, Russians, Americans, Chinese and Browns shit their pants at the very premise of this thread. Which means, of course, that an EU military is the best thing for humanity as a whole.
>>
Its pretty fuckin blatant how much /pol/fag samefagging is going on in this thread.
>>
>>65651946
The EU will federalise and become something akin to a United States Of Europe. So the EU army will be under the Federal Government, and individual states will raise smaller forces to supplement it, probably becoming reservists like the National Guard. The termplate works, so why change it?
This isn't speculative by the way, Russia laid the fuse for this in 2022 and Trump lit it in 2024, so I assess this is at this stage inevitable. A complete Russian collapse might forestall it before 2030 because then the singular threat of Russia will be gone. HOWEVER, it will still happen because the westernmost successor states (Muscowy, Tatarstan etc.) will rush to join the EU as quickly as possible and China will swallow up the East until China or Chinese proxies are right up to Europe, at which point it all starts again.
>>
Eurofags can't even collaborate on making planes together, a unified command structure without the US to tard wrangle everyone would be a schizophrenic mess.
>>
>>65652089
They really hate this idea, lol.
>>
>>65651943
>F-35
>Leopard 2
>Hk416
>>
>>65651946
I guess the same way NATO missions are deployed, Bosnia, Afghanistan for example. Except instead of every individual euro NATO member agreeing to go they just deploy the whole EU military as a unified force. It actuallymakes it easier for these countries because they can just give the thumbs up and don't have to worry about how much or what to send or how to send them.
>>
in the spirit of 'one scheme suits no one', a universal european camo pattern
>>
>>65651927
Would be one of the most powerful in the world. Mostly because the level of incompetence is beyond your imagination outside of the west.
>>
>>65651946
Why wouldn't it work just like NATO but Euro exclusive?
>>
>>65652142
Because it just can't! Okay!
>>
>>65652090
>a war between the US and the EU would result in an unconditional EU surrender in under 6 hours.
Not before I rape the American Expat next door
>>
Russia can protect Europe
>>
>>65652168
And then you woke up
>>
>no unified chain of command and rank structure
>no unified weapon, ammunition and hardware standards
>no unified procurement and military industrial complex
>vast disparity in tech and troops quality between individual members since lots of small countries need their military built from ground up
>extraterritorial disputes and jurisdiction conflicts
>language barriers
>commander in chief is ursula fucking von der layen

it'll be smashing success! like austria-hungary!
>>
>>65652139
>Mostly because the level of incompetence is beyond your imagination outside of the west
I always recall people mocking the Germans for only having 3 "capable" Typhoons or something like that, when they're just autistically refusing to certify a plane that can't do literally everything it should be able to do.
>>
>>65652175
Fake news. Americans don't have sex
>>
>>65652184
Only the blacks while they watch though
>>
If we assume it would operate similarly to the US military (unified military under the direct control of the EU, with national militaries supplementing it similarly to the US National Guard), it would be the world's second military after the US. Barring them from parity would be primarily the US's technological edge in aerospace and their navy. The gap would likely shrink over time and perhaps even disappear, but it's pointless to speculate what the world will look like in 2060.
>>65651937
Fully independent transnational command structure. Rather than "borrowing" soldiers from national armies, it should be an independent organization under the command of the European Union, all of its members being permanent staff unaffiliated with any other national army
>>
>>65652032
My shit is free with my neetcare. Thanks :)
>>
>>65652201
Most cuckold porn users are from the US and India. They lust for it
>>
>>65652176
These problems only exist if you imagine it as a coalition of individual militaries, rather than a new, independent organization with its own command structure, procurement, recruiting etc. The only potential problem could be language, but in virtually all schools in all European countries we learn English as a second language from age six. It makes for a good lingua franca
>>
>>65652215
>>65652175
All me
>>
>>65652251
>95% of cuck porn users live in eastern and southern yurop
Source?
>>
>>65652208
>rather than a new, independent organization with its own command structure, procurement, recruiting etc.
Independent of what? The fucking EU?
>The only potential problem could be language
LMAO
>>
>>65652248
In that case Americans must be French at heart. Because they can't get enough of it. Data shows it
>>
>>65652254
It was real in his mind.
>>
>>65652261
It's because his mind is full with cuck porn (he is American)
>>
>>65651927
not
>>
>>65652269
>can't stop thinking about black dongs..
>>
>>65652267
Why would I go on /gif/ if they are spamming it? Seems like you just can't get enough of it
>>
>>65652307
>a yuropoor brought it up. it's all yuros think about
He brought it up but you were thinking about it before this thread was made
>>
>>65651927
We'd wipe the floor with the americans in a month.
>>65652010
Only the president. If it's the commission you have the exact problem >>65651946 describes just on the executive level.
>>
What is with the zegroid seething in this thread about "yuropoors"? I have only ever seen turdies like street shitters or ziggers use that term. Not like there is any difference between the brown hordes anyway
>>
>>65652347
It's >>65652344 and he is american, so he is into BBC. Kinda weird if you ask me
>>
>>65652354
>browsing this website since 2010
The state of your life anon
>>
>>65652360
>knows the history of black dicks
yikes
>>
>>65652347
My theory is that it's a Russoid and a pajeet false flagging at each other. It just feels so inauthentic.
>>
>>65651927
>unified
About one FCAS
>>
>>65651927
the EU army is just a fever dream. Wait until you tell countries like Spain, Italy and France that they have to help pay. It's just another we want Germany to pay for everything moment.
>>
>>65651927
It would never happen. The best the EU can hope for is to bully the Germans, Italians, Spaniards and French to maintain a 1980s level of military readiness and get them to use common small arms calibers and munitions. Poland is already ahead of the curve and fantasizing about mowing down fields of mobiks so they don't need the bullying.
>>
>>65651927
Troll thread.

>Nibbles on bait a bit

If you replaced Belorussia with the DPRK or just stationed their main Army corps there the Baltic nations would fall, the Norks would threaten Warsaw but probably be stalemated. Finland would be your only hope before massive amounts of devastation for humanity.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KhTWzZXylBM
>>
>>65651927
>continental military
Be great but they got a lot of shit to work out before things go smoothly
>>
>>65651943
F-35
Leopard 2
AR-15 clone
Burkeswarm
>>
>>65651938
>>
>>65651936
fpbp
The first casualties of a federal EU government will be EU citizens.
>>
>>65651946
Why does this sound like the HRE?
>>
>>65651958
Germany had good healthcare during the cold war and yet had a enormous military due to being a frontline country. So did Sweden with their enormous air force
>>
>>65651946
Create a separate branch of the EU superstructure, deployed at the request of member states and only against non eu members. Set goal will be to defend the indivisibility of the EU territory and nothing else. Doesnt override national armies but rather is an eu level field army level structure capable of independent operations within eu territory. Members to be hired from eu citizens, wrap up the ukraine war, get them in the eu, buy out their veterans to form the core of the army. Call it EUDF, nickname it the varangian guard for funz and go back to sipping aperol spritz. The eu way.
>>
That thread again.

Short answer: no.

Long answer: NATO exists. There's no point in doubling the Treaty structures, especially in current economy. To quote the venerable lord Ismay on NATO strategic purpose:
"To keep the Russians out, the Americans in, and the Germans down.”
Thou shall not mess with North Atlantic Treaty Organisation, unless thou crave American nuclear umbrella away, russkies at home and Kraut hegemony.
>>
>>65653068
Trump has shown Maerica wants out, teh rest of Europe has shown tehy want teh Ruskis out, that leaves the Germans to rise again.

Which is objectively good, because a strong Europe includes a strong Germany standing shoulder to shoulder with Poland, France, and all the others
>>
>>65653071
>Muh Drumpf
Have a (you)
>>
>>65652666
Just like the Chinese, Russian and American government, no?
>>
>>65653074
I don't mean Trump personally, but the MAGA coterie around him.
>>
they can't even agree on a 6th gen fighter program with only a few EU nations, how in the hell are they going to form a functioning military with so many cooks in the kitchen?
>>
>>65653083
>they can't even agree on an MBT/artillery/APC/IFV program with only a few NATO nations, how in the hell are they going to form a functioning military with so many cooks in the kitchen?
it is a mystery
>>
>>65651927
Very scary to pussia. And they're the only ones it would be used on anyway.
Not necessarily, for a transitional period. In the long term yes.
Yes, probably
>>65651946
There is none. Major political reforms of the EU would be necessary to make it close to an actual state with the legitimacy to oversee military defence.
>>65651958
The same money we currently use for our military? Except less, because of better economy of scale?
Don't be retarded anon.
>>65653083
The problem with fighters is that europe needs two fighters, a naval and a nonnaval one. France needs the former, but was politically tied to germany who needs the latter. Britain and italy are currently building the latter (probably successful), germany is just too late to join (otherwise it would have). Note that all these programmes and lock in effects happened before the ukraine war and trump i.e. before anyone took them seriously.
>>
>>65653068
Nato is no longer reliable. Trump has shown the world the US can and will threaten long time allies for petty reasons, and jeopardise the world's economy in order to please bibi's warmongering ambitions. A treaty is ink on a page, we need something more concrete to defend the union against external threats. Of course america recoils at the idea, because in doing so there would be no incentive from bruxelles to just allow the big american procurement firms to do as they please and strangle the domestic development of key assets like jets or drones, or the fact that america uses europe as a giant launchpad for their world police endeavours. Europe is both a vassal and a major client of american defense soluti9ns, a european armed forces would destroy a trillion dollar investment the american's been cultivating since ww2
>>
>>65651927
It's a shitty idea
>>
>>65653071
>that leaves the Germans to rise again.
With what population?
With what money?
With what leader?
>>
>>65653120
That's a lot of words, too bad I ain't reading them
>>
>>65651927
i have a better one for you

eu vs a unified balkan under greece (i know the chance of starting ww3 is high but lets pretend its not)
go
>>
>>65652255
Independent of the respective member countries, so that France can't throw a shit fit and pull half of the military out because the Germans told them to stop being retarded
>>
File: 1676892889135452.webm (2.99 MB, 1280x720)
2.99 MB
2.99 MB WEBM
>>65653038
sure. but then their own skin was on the line. Which motivates one to build an efficient and functional deterrent. These days zegroids have to get through Poland to get to them and that ain't happening

>>65651927
Ukraine war shows what actually works. Front line states have to pay the blood price (casualties) themselves. Friends, especially geriatric ones like all western countries, will not put their own blood on the line BUT they will back the fighters up with gear and fiscal support to keep them solvent.

What is needed is making all the good things done with Ukraine into formal and obligatory structures that are not subject to the daily whims of politics within individual member state. Things like each member being obliged to make yearly payments into NATO trust fund which serves as a war chest to prop up members under attack. Same goes for producing hardware stocks into vast warehouses that are deployed as needed among those members that need war fighting capacity. Mines, tanks, IFVs, APCs, artillery, mortars, AA , ballistic missiles, aircraft etc. I would also tie EU and European NATO membership into a single package. Slackers who want to skip on NATO obligation payments and hardware production, since they are safely tucked away behind not insane neighbors (Slovakia, hungary, austra) will lose their membership in both clubs if they fail to fulfill their commitments

This way you can cover the vast difference in member state needs. When somebody like finland, estonia, latvia, lithuania, poland or ukraine need conventional, predominantly land warfare gear to fight off the cancer of east. Then southern members, like italy or spain, need predominantly maritime gear and support to guard their naval borders from invading migrants. UK or Norway in contrast need ocean support to secure the atlantic like ASW capacity
>>
>>65653199
>I would also tie EU and European NATO membership into a single package.
exiting the EU is time intensive and extremely bureaucratic process. as Brexit showed. Most don't know that while the vote took place 2016, the Brexit itself was only completed in 2020

Tying EU freezing up your funds to skipping NATO payments is a better option
>>
>>65653202
Merz has already signalled a veto against the next EU budget unless everyone pulls their weight on ukraine. The EU is an organization of negotiation and consensus, but if enough strong powers throw their weight around to make every do their part, it can happen.
>>
File: 1794014274594575.jpg (38 KB, 231x410)
38 KB JPG
>>65651946
A legislative body won't do
A much more reasonable solution is to proclaim a new Universal Roman Empire, with the Pope selecting the monarch
All leaders will pledge fealty to the new Emperor thus making it a personal union & sidestepping sovereignty concerns
Like Imperial domains of the past, subject nations will have control over their local affairs via existing legislatures
This would not only draw on numerous countries heritage & histories but would remove the need to have things like a shared language, etc.
Needless to say since it's held the title most recently, German candidates for Emperor will be considered first...
>>
>>65651937
political control / oversight could easily be organized within existing structures.
you'd have a commission member for defense, the country supplying said commission member wouldn't be fixed ofc and they would like the rest of the commission have to be voted in by the EU parliament (that gets elected directly on the national level)
votes on defense in the EU would be as many touchy subjects are already via double qualified majority where both a quorum of member states and a majority of citizens represented have to be in favor depending on the subject at hand by a simple or two thirds majority.
a transition in to a single EU federal army (pray to God they don't try it) would be overseen by the council and thus the member states minsters of defense and their heads of the executive.
that being said you wouldn't get German drill, French MRE's and Polish chill. But German bureaucracy, Polish MRE's (still not bad desu) and Belgian drill
>>
>>65653199
> I would also tie EU and European NATO membership into a single package
congratulations, that's already how it works with the mutual defense clause in the EU constitution treaty. if for some reason the EU decided to mandates defense spending instead of budget control, they could.
but NATO is just the better vehicle for defense co-ordination
>Front line states have to pay the blood price
you'd have to be retarded to believe that. first and foremost those geriatric states that would never lose a single drop of blood all have forward garrisons on the eastern flank already as part of NATO. they are already putting their blood and lives on the (border)line.
secondly because the EU as not just a political but economic union wouldn't survive that. if the EU were to die like that all those states you accuse of not having the balls to pay the price will end up paying far more. they'd all have a depression to rival the great depression as all of the sudden those deeply intertwined economies are cut off from each other, with all the misery and death that such economic woe brings with it. they'd end up with as many dead and as much treasure lost as simply fighting.
>>
>>65651927
>alternative to NATO
wouldn't it just replace it's current member states in NATO?
sure the rest of the alliance would have to adapt to how that would change the power dynamics in NATO. but it would mess with the why of NATO
to keep the russians out, the Americans in and the Germans (or Poles with how they are arming) down
>>
File: 1749316671597665.jpg (26 KB, 780x520)
26 KB JPG
>>65651958
>muh universal healthcare

Only a handful of European states spend more per-citizen on healthcare than the United States (the likes of Norway and Switzerland).

People on the US really need to stop getting scammed with their tax dollars going to law-mandated middlemen (insurance companies and physician groups).
>>
File: 1764547046040200.jpg (139 KB, 960x929)
139 KB JPG
>>65651958
lol
lmao
>>
File: 1789502018910500.png (473 KB, 996x843)
473 KB PNG
>>65653263
>you'd have to be retarded to believe that
go tell that to Ukraine retard.
>inb4 not EU/NATO, does not count
if you really believe that is the main reason then you truly are an idiot. As much as this makes you seethe reality is that there is no political will to fight pidors head on. If that were the case a enforced no-fly zone over at least west ukraine and allied expedition corps taking over minor tasks like guarding the border with Moldova would have already been in place years ago

NATO needs a reform and arguably has needed since 1991. It has been put off for decades and today the war in the east are its flowers. Ukraine clearly shows what works and what does not as the same exact dynamics play when balts or poland are attacked. Only difference would be a little bit more hands on approach, at first, because of the token contingencies stationed there.
>>
>>65653234
>>65653261
>>65653263
I've already said in this thread that the only realistic way forward is for Europe to federalise.
>>
File: 1787843304733920.png (998 KB, 1080x1498)
998 KB PNG
>>65653281
>look at this thing that is different in a dozen different ways
>and don't say it is different because I say it isn't
there is a reason whey super powers or at least nuclear powers prefer not fighting each other directly. with the only two nuclear power that do so repeatedly being on par with subsahara jeets.
>>65653283
you wouldn't even need to federalize all of the EU. a confederation on the Swiss model would be preferable to all but (and even most) of the Eurocrats.
heck you wouldn't even have to go that far i you want to get creative and funky with the structure for and around a joined army.
>>
File: 1424787040004.png (42 KB, 521x800)
42 KB PNG
>>65653294
There's three pillars of federalisation right.
1. Reserve bank
2. Federal treasury
3. Federal defense

1 is in already in place and 3 has 80% level of support. And you can't have 3 without 2. So at this stage, federalisation is pretty much inevitable UNLESS Russia collapses completely in the next year or two.
Trump supporting Russia to try and restrain Europe and curtail it's rise ironically makes the rise of another superpower competitor more likely.
>>
>>65651927
Italian bravery
German logistics
French generals
British discipline
>>
File: 1783895504737776.png (783 KB, 764x750)
783 KB PNG
Western Europe squabble over each other, and Eastern Europe makes a new, non-communist Warsaw Pact.
>>
it's honestly quite depressing that each time this thread pops up in the catalogue it's inevitably yet another D&D trolling pulled by either some jingoistic magatard or a zigger loving turd worlder, and discussion about military procurement for a federal army are inevitably drowned in a sea of unwanted /pol/ opinions.
>>
>>65651927
Never gonna happen, though I do think that some of the small countries that are much closer in alignment should pool armed forces with their neighbors to act and operate as a single force. At a minimum, Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia should unify into a single Baltic armed forces, BeNeLux should be fully unified, and the Nordics should be fully unified.
>>
File: Waffen SS Bolts.jpg (10 KB, 249x269)
10 KB JPG
>>65651927
This was tried in Europe before.
>>
>>65651958
>With what fucking money?
7/10 people are stupid enough to think that they won't have to pay for an EU army.
>>
>>65652319
>We'd wipe the floor with the americans in a month.
With your army that doesn't exist? US spends double what the rest of NATO combined spends. You'd all need to triple your spending just to try and catch up.
>>
>>65651927
Literally no one here in the EU cares
>GLOBSEC
lmao
>>
File: Untitled.jpg (217 KB, 788x1120)
217 KB JPG
>>65653414
WRONG
Eat shit, Ivan Pajeetovich
>>
>>65651937
>First you have to figure out who controls it
Vote.
Every single citizen of the EU will be made to vote for any single military decision, and nothing will be done without a vote. Soldiers shouldn't even have the right to shoot a bullet without being authorized.
And abstention would not be authorized, you have to ask every single EU citizen.

Else it's not a democracy and I have the right to go burn all center of power.
>>
>>65653566
Fuck off, Ivan.
>>
>>65652150
>Not before I rape the American Expat next door
Total French (Algerian) Victory
>>
>>65651927
>scary
Scary for the europeans because the """free""" healthcare and welfare services gravy train stops once the US military leaves.
>>
>>65653280
I'm curious to see how this would look if broken down by demographics
>>
>>65653748
miga cope.also /qa/ lost
>>
>>65653276
>Only a handful of European states spend more per-citizen on healthcare than the United States
And all tax their citizens MASSIVELY more than the United States.

Between myself and my wife household income is in the top ~10% of earners, yet our effective tax rate is ~23%. The AVERAGE taxpayer in France pays 28% and the AVERAGE German pays 38%.
>>
EU Army doesnt make sense but having the smaller countries in Europe combine would be a pretty good idea.
>Nordic Army
>Baltic Army
>Czechoslovakian, Slovanian and Austro-Hungarian Army
>Ibarian Army
>Benelux Army
Think that would make alot more sense due to proximity, same terrain, economy etc. Atleast these should do procurement together to reduce costs.
>>
>>65653777
Did you remember to add tips?
>>
we kick the mutts out and we make NATO a Euro only club (Canada can join the EU as honorary europoors) boom, Euro army.
>>
>>65651927
European Citizen here, no I fucking don't, the EU should actually die.

>>65652088
Hello, Ursula.

>>65651958
No, and the EU would never ever ever ever stop importing rapefugees, and they will try to fight you if you try to stop it.
>>
>>65653831
The Americans make up the overwhelming bulk of NATO power, you fucking retard.
>>
>>65652069
>Euros just don't let their doctors scam them
Oh, that's really cute, you actually think this. Go ask the Brits how well the NHS is working out for them, or how good is in Canada once they have elbowed themselves into EU membership for whatever insipid reason.
>>
>>65653791
My impression is thats the whole intent behind the Sako AR and shared scandinavian camo; though that shits already hit the rocks because they all insist on keeping their own camos and sweden and norway say the quality sucks and have started buying their own shit.
>>
>>65652082
That's probably why Brussels is so desperate for it in recent years, Euros are getting more vocally anti-migrant with each year.

>>65652095
China isn't retarded enough to get up to direct war with trade partners (Europe), which is why their support of Russia is lukewarm. They'll snatch the stuff they think is good and that they can hold.

>>65652142
>>65652146
Because we're fucking allergic to military spending. We could 10x current European military spending and it'd still be far behind.

>>65653791
That'd be much more tenable, but giving the EU any say over any of those would be disaster.
>>
File: lol8.png (311 KB, 1227x678)
311 KB PNG
>>65655019
>>
>>65655038
Canada will thank us for that some day.
>>
>>65651946
>foreign policy
I'm pretty sure an EU army would be used as an internal police force.
>>
>>65651927
>How scary would a unified EU military be
If a war broke out, they would take approximately six trillion years to decide on a course of action.
t. Euro
>>
>>65655014
hello fellow citizen from europe oblast i also agree that EU should disband and disarm all its vassals
>>
File: file.png (48 KB, 220x194)
48 KB PNG
>>65655113
*rootless
*systematically
>>
>>65655113
>>65655116
Retard.
>>
>>65655091
Who the fuck said anything about disarming, you German retard? Is it a slip of the tongue for your dream for Europe?
>>
>>65655159
>instantly shrieks about Germany
You do sound like a zigger. We need a stronger, armed EU to keep vermin like you out.
>>
>>65655174
Who is more desperate for even more control over the EU than the German state? Who is sending German riot police to Poland to try to assist in a coup against its democratically elected government? That's some pretty fucking Russian tier shit to engage in.
>>
>>65655174
Who keeps buying Russian gas? Germany is, pretty interesting fraternizing with the enemy on their part.
>>
>>65655156
No gun, no opinion, eurofederalist faggot cattle.
>>
>>65655178
>a coup against its democratically elected government
Oh, you're PiStard. Check.

>>65655180
Weird, last time I checked Germany speed-built several LNG ports to be able to stop importing russoid gas.

Anyway, you 'eu skeptics' are literally Putin's useful idiots, if you're actually real.
>>
>>65655192
Yet they fell for the green meme and destroyed their nuclear power, which would have been both more environmentally friendly and allow for strong self-sufficiency in power production.
>>
>>65655198
>fell for the green meme and destroyed their nuclear power
Decisions made 40 years ago by the Kohl government, upheld 20 years ago by Merkel. Also, repalcing gas imports with uranium imports pretty much equals telling your children comforting lies.

We need Thorium breeder reactors, but the research (especially in Germany) was tainted by anti-nuclearist hysteria (funded by the KGB btw) on the political side and gross incompetence, mismanagement and corruption on the industry's side.

Pining for what should have been does not help, we ned to deal with what we have. Just cover every acre with wind turbines, idgaf.
>>
funny how a simple idea triggers the muttmericans and the global south unilaterally
>>
>>65655208
>Also, repalcing gas imports with uranium imports pretty much equals telling your children comforting lies.
What the fuck are you babbling about?
>>
File: 1468603216003.jpg (523 KB, 875x744)
523 KB JPG
>>65655187
Your fear is delicious.
>>
>>65655228
I think he's suggesting it'd be no more secure, which I don't really believe. Continuing decent relations with Australia is like 90% of the supply security done if you're doing nuclear power and that's pretty easy, even France kissed and made up after the sub deal exploded. It's substantially easier to stockpile that stuff ahead of time than it is NG for a whole host of reasons too.
He's right about it not being much good worrying about it now though, things are where they are.
>>
File: 1794451590266410.png (169 KB, 250x411)
169 KB PNG
>>65655270
You sound very upset.
>>
>>65655270
>>
That's just NATO without the US. Aside from calibers, comms and logistics you don't need to standardize much
>>
File: do the army rap.jpg (230 KB, 2000x1047)
230 KB JPG
There isnt a single good reason to have USA troops in Europe. Look at what they bring to Poland.

https://taskandpurpose.com/news/pentagon-assault-report-2025/
>>
>>65651927
>EU
>unified
lmao
one bad sneeze and it's balkan war 2.0 but on a bigger scale
>>
>>65655178
>coup against its democratically elected government?
it was the pis party that illegally appointed hundreds of judges.
>>
>>65655228
Do you think uranium is just laying around in Germany, or France?
Hint: It fucking well doesn't. What littel could be found in Germany and Czechia was stolen by the Soviets to make their first few bombs.
France import theirs from some thirdie shithole, sorry I mean gloriously independent former colony in Africa IIRC..
All the eastern euros used to import their uranium from the ziggers, and even had outright deals with rosatom.

Imports from Austrialia might work. Maybe Canada.
However: This is still replacing one set of imports with another.
This is fighting symptoms.

Wind and water and even solar is rigth here. We must use it. All teh fearmongering around it is just the coal/gas/nuclear lobby shitting thier pants at the prospect of their eternal cash cow going away.
>>
File: ckhuaukou5ha1.png (35 KB, 271x186)
35 KB PNG
>>65653075
Yes, just like that.
I would like to remind you that
More Americans died in the American civil war that in WWI, WWII and every post-WWII conflict combined
Twice as many Russians (and Ukranians, Poles etc.) died in the White-Soviet war than in WWI
Throughout history Chinese killed more Chinese people that everyone else put together and multiplied by 10
>>
>>65655325
>This is still replacing one set of imports with another.
this will always be the case for germany, it just has no natural resources worth speaking off. even wind turbine production needs parts and resources from china.
>>
File: 1777198203625816.webm (2.49 MB, 800x800)
2.49 MB
2.49 MB WEBM
>>65651936
>>
>>65655328
Rare earths for the magnets can be sourced from Canada. Just saying.
>>
I must admit, it's extremely convenient that any criticism of the EU can just be brushed aside as being "Russian propaganda."
>>
>>65655328
>>65655351
Yeah if I was Germany and I had to pick, I think I'd probably rather stuff that Australia and Canada can chuck on a boat. Other than outright wartime conditions fucking with trade over a sustained period, in which case shit is fucked and you're operating on contingencies anyway, I think they're about as secure as you could possibly want for suppliers to Europe.
>>
>>65655352
most EU criticism is national politicians shoving every unpopular decision on the EU. these guys will go to brussels and push for some specific legislation there, then complain about said regulation at home and blame the EU for it.
>>
>>65655223
So...which western European nation will be the primary ruler and will the other nations bend the knee to the will of said nation?
>>
File: 1773551080060708.png (144 KB, 2000x1550)
144 KB PNG
Considering the last time germany decided to go to war the world needed to come togheter to beat them, you draw your conclusions.
>>
>>65651927
>How scary would a unified EU military be?
the efficiency gains could increase their illegal immigrant dinghy escort operations by an order of magnitude
>>
>>65655373
no unified army, but unified research and development as well as production and procurement. right now europe has a higher defense budget than russia. by far even, but its mostly small, redundant infantry stuff, no strategic deterrence at all and even in euro nato every country basically still does its own thing. you see that with the 5th gen fighter jet programme. 2-3-4 different programmes. this is an incredible waste of money and actually harms military power. also the small countries basically dont participate in reasearch and development at all and often dont pull their weight in production and procurement either leaving the larger nations to foot the entire defense bill.

a lot could be fixed here without desolving national armies.
>>
>>65651927
On paper? Very.
In practice? Clusterfuck.
>>
>>65652142
because NATO is held together by US intel, command and control, and all the specialised EWAR and air force and spec ops and logistics etc shit that European militaries don't have
especially at the corps and army level this kind of shit would be working on

say you want to field 36 brigades? the Balts have difficulty equipping even a single combat brigade with full NATO-spec C3 gear. Poland has a big land army but half of it is still Soviet-origin.

anyhow, so you group them in 9 divisions. only 4, maybe 5 nations, have full Divisional HQs capable of NATO-spec C3; Germany, France, Britain and Italy, perhaps Spain. currently, the US provides the rest to NATO.
and then you have to group those 9 divisions into say 3 corps, and then tie those corps together into one unified command. who can do that? ONLY THE US ARMY.

without somebody stepping up to fund, staff, equip and train further division HQ assets, corps HQ and perhaps an army group HQ, the EU Army will only be a hodgepodge of individually-operating divisions and brigades.

>>65655414
>and often dont pull their weight in production and procurement either leaving the larger nations to foot the entire defense bill.
yup
there is a mismatch of funding and manning, because no nation wants to have a setup like say Norway paying Polish soldiers and buying German equipment to defend the EU with

>>65655394
Consider that Norway and France turned traitor twice in that war, Italy once.
>>
>>65655422
>because NATO is held together by US intel, command and control, and all the specialised EWAR and air force and spec ops and logistics etc shit that European militaries don't have
>especially at the corps and army level this kind of shit would be working on

Not really true. While the USA have been pissing around on their own NATO on the other side of the Atlantic is still holding strong.
>>
>>65652032
I love how misinformed Euros are about US healthcare.
I have the same health insurance plan as about 300,000 other Americans who work at my company.
MRI last year only cost $65.
And I didn't have to wait 6 months for it.
>>
>>65655014
>European Citizen here
Very European citizen, yes. Which oblast?
>>
>>65655426
cause NATO Europe isn't doing shit, and Ukraine is relying on US C3i

go on and list the C3 and ISTAR assets NATO Europe has without the US. tell me which nations can provide a proper mobile field corps HQ, AND its own Divisional HQ, with the full panoply of C3i assets.
>>
>>65655439
UK.
>>
>>65655436
yeah but mri here costs 0 eur and you wait 3 weeks for a knee mri. in austria that is. our health insurance is also public and not private so it doesnt have to make a profit and pay out dividends. and it negotiates the prices for the entire country so doesnt has to be in a bidding competition with other health insurances like int he usa. we also have twice as many doctors per capita than the usa and they leave med school with 0 student debt so they dont have the pressure to ripp off patients like in the usa. though the medical system varies greatly accross europe so thats only a snapshot.
>>
>>65655446
My MRI took 5 days from request to execution
It cost $65.
I also didn't have to pay half my earning in taxes
>>
>>65651946
If individual nations can't simply opt out of any action then its a supranational body which can override the sovereignty of members which makes it imperialism.
>>
I came to this thread, and all I see is seething niggers.
>>
>>65655439
>France, Germany, the UK, Spain and Italy don't have any C3 ISTAR assets of their own
>unless you individually list them
how about you go fuck a cactus
nothing the US does can't be replicated by any of the larger European countries never mind the continent combined
the historic reliance is due to the US preferring to contribute assets that are easily redeploy able to NATO. both because they can then use them outside of it's NATO commitment and to allow the other NATO members to put more of an emphasis on other things.
that however doesn't mean they don't have or could build those capabilities them selves.
>>65655456
that would make the US federal/state relation ship imperialist
>>
>>65655443
all they have are the C3 assets. they would need to borrow others; they have only one ISR satellite for example

>>65655478
coulda woulda shoulda
the Europeans could have spent the recommended 2% on defence the last thirty years and either deterred Russia effectively from trying anything, or kicked their shit in, but here we are

>>65655446
>austria
median salary: €4,000/month
tax wedge: 47% (you take home €2,120 of your pay)
VAT: 20%
average out-of-pocket healthcare expenses: €125/month
>USA
median salary: $5,333/month
tax wedge: 30% (they take home $3,733 of their pay)
sales tax: 7.5% average, 10% in the 5 most expensive states
average private insurance and out-of-pocket healthcare expenses: $500/month

in short, the average American can spend an additional few hundred a month for healthcare, they would still take home more pay than you
>>
>>65655439
>>65655422
That's not entirely true. Five eyes is mostly led by the UK, although I know it's going to hurt your pride to hear that.
>>
>>65655483
Space is one area where the USA contribution would be difficult to replicate, it's true, but back on Earth they have the capabilities. For example RAF rivet joints are doing regular missions over the Black Sea.
>>
If Europe was smart they would ally with China.
>>
>>65655486
>Five eyes is mostly led by the UK
I know it's going to hurt your pride to hear this, but even the French and the Germans have more ISR satellites than the UK

>>65655487
and the US has orders of magnitude more ISR and EW aircraft than all those 3 put together
it is what it is, just be white and tell the truth
>>
>>65655490
Spread out all over the world while NATO in Europe is really only concerned with that little corner of Earth.
>>
>>65655483
>Europeans could have spent the recommended 2% on defence the last thirty years and either deterred Russia
2% means nothing when its spent on tents, housing repairs, apcs and conscript training. that doesnt deter russia at all. my country (austria) just spent a fuckton of money on a leo2 upgrade package that included zero drone protection. we are also constitutionally forbidden from working together with other armies in case europe gets attacked. our constitution even requires us to close border and airspace and let no nato transports or any other military transports through. technically if ww3 breaks out we are legally required to fight both nato and russia. oh and weapons exports to countries in a state of war are also forbidden, so no supplies from austria either. austria alone is also too small to buy any meaningful hardware to cope with modern war like in ukraine. we are doomed to lose even if we put 30% of our gdp into the military. and east europe arming could even backfire when the russia aligned chuds win the elections and hand all the fancy modern western equipment over to the russians or, even worse, use it against the west. europe has to make its mind up at first and actually decide wheter it wants to defend itself or not. here in austria the chuds who have a literal treaty of mutual support with putins party are poised to win the next national election so it will be orban 2.0 here. thats a far bigger issue than "muh 2% muh 3% defense budget"
>>
>>65655497
>thats a far bigger issue
true, true
you have my sympathies
>>
File: Picture1.png (212 KB, 936x686)
212 KB PNG
>>65655483
>in short, the average American can spend an additional few hundred a month for healthcare, they would still take home more pay than you
yeah but nobody here in austria gets 100k usd medical bills while you see such bills getting posted by americans every other day. also our doctors dont have to pay off several hundred k in student debt, which means they are less likely to sell you stupid shit and profit from you not knowing better. when an american doctor sees a patient there is always a conflict of interest. he has to milk the patient as much as possible and the american hospital has to earn a profit so they cheap out on everything they can and charger horrendous sums for anything.
>>
>>65655496
but as anon said,
>>65655478
>easily redeployable to NATO

>>65655505
mate, most countries have public healthcare and health insurance including mine, most people know the scams to pull in those systems where massive costs are charged to insurance because "not my problem, insurance covers it". you think NHS doctors aren't wastefully profligate with treatments and supplies, because "it's all paid for by the government / insurance anyway"? who dyou think you're trying to fool?
>while you see such bills getting posted by americans every other day
the Americans have 33x your population. that means even if both nations are equal, you will see 33x more stupid shit coming from the US than you see coming from your neighbours.
and no country does not have stupid people who will, regardless, attempt to gain sympathy and cover up their own stupidity by telling you one side of the story, which is particularly easy to do on the Internet
how many stories do you know of people who wasted thousands of euros on stupid purchases or (more to the point) were involved in accidents by their own stupidity - stupid sports stunts, drunk driving, getting STDs from fucking Russian whores, whatever - that resulted in having to pay damages or fix broken shit or whatever? you're delusional or lying or very sheltered if you think Austria has none of that
now imagine if Austria had 33x more people and therefore 33x more such cases. that's the US.
>>
>>65655489
china wouldnt aggree to that, they want a weak, disorganized europe. 30 small individual states that they can individually bully.
>>
>>65655505
But if they pay for health insurance why would they then pay the non-insurance meme amounts?

The thing that really should incite envy is US homestead exemptions like in Texas or Florida. You can be bankrupt and they can't take your house and car. I don't even think all of the US does means testing.
>>
>>65655519
Technically true but in practice I doubt the USA would ever empty out the Pacific theatre for example to move it all to Europe while China remains a thing. That's also a temporary "show of force" measure rather than assets permanently stationed there.
>>
>>65655523
>But if they pay for health insurance why would they then pay the non-insurance meme amounts?
NTA but a lot of those sort of posts are "lol look at what my healthcare costs would be if not for insurance"
and those that aren't, the ones crying about getting Gofundmes, are probably those fuckwits who didn't register for Medicaid or didn't have private medical insurance and happened to get fucked
don't tell me that such people don't exist
I should know, for a period I was one of them

>>65655530
>in practice
no nation today can fight a 2-front war so they would undoubtedly leave a small force in the Pacific, and the Gulf, and wherever else they have minor interests, and devote a large number of assets to the ETO in a Cold War Goes Hot situation
to me, a "show of force measure" implies that they're unable to turn the tide of the war, even if they do inflict significant damage. but let's face it, the US military is so huge, even just half of it could curbstomp the Russians. that's plenty left over to hold the line elsewhere, temporarily
>>
>>65655549
Ignoring the whole nuclear annihilation thing other powers are unlikely to just stand still while you do that. Your little token force is a little token force with your main focus heavily engaged elsewhere. Perfect time to strike.
>>
>>65655478
US states are not nations, a nation state is supposed to be the ethnic homeland of a nation (ethnic group) and defend the interests of the native group. Ideally no foreign entity will exercise any form of influence over native people in their own homeland.
>>
>>65655559
usually they pinkyswear the other side not to fuck around
at least, that's what the Brits did in '82, and the US in '91

what do you think China would do?

>>65655478
>that would make the US federal/state relation ship imperialist
they'd be less imperialist than the fucking EU right now
>>
>>65655577
Perhaps not direct attack but certainly they would start throwing their weight around a lot more harassing shipping, grabbing islands etc.
>>
>>65655483
The whole argument against American healthcare boils down to:

>Hurr DURRH I'm a complete retard who cant manage my own finances or spend an afternoon learning how health insurance works, waaaaahhhhh let me just pay 4 times as much for my healthcare but it's in taxes so it doesn't count waaaahhhhh
>>
>>65651946
How did the United States military come under control of the war department/president instead of the states?
The European commission has the backing of the European parliament and the member states represented by the European Council.
>>
>>65651958
They'd save money by having a single structure and procurement instead of 27+ different ones. There's already progress in bundling capabilities.
>>
>>65655490
>I know it's going to hurt your pride to hear this, but even the French and the Germans have more ISR satellites than the UK
Lol, the USA has basically zero, ZERO effective humint anymore. The UK handles all of that.
The whole world loves themselves a posh accent and a high handed manner, and that can be leveraged a million ways for gathering intelligence.
Why do you imagine that the Russians spend so much money and time online trying to trash British prestige and run them down at every opportunity?
>>
>>65651958
Kick out the browns and spend the gibs they would have received on their military instead
>>
>>65652159
Just like a fox can protect a henhouse
>>
File: 1635696739630.jpg (214 KB, 345x336)
214 KB JPG
>EU
>collective total testosterone level less than singular Uzbek preteen girl
>scary
You fags piss yourselves and make 18 panic threads every time Putin farts
>>
>>65655830
Combined EU military would be something of the order of 2 million active personnel (active serving soldiers never mind conscripts) making it one of the strongest on Earth.
>>
>>65655852
>2 million active personnel
2 million pussies that feel Americans should die on their behalf instead of themselves
Yeah, very scary
>>
>>65655856
Europe has fought actual wars for their own existence. Do not underestimate them.
>>
>>65655858
>>65655852
One of the key strength the EU has is that small countries don't see it as a threat but as something to aspire to.
>>
>>65655860
It being seen more commonly as the new aspiring power here rather than something benign changes things. The future of the EU depends on it proving that it deserves to supersede the various very proud nations of Europe. Coming together due to war may be that catylist.
>>
>>65655852
>Combined
Britain, France and Germany will never combine their armed forces in any meaningful manner. Literally never. Might as well say "what if the US and China combined militaries?"
>>
>>65655888
We are already all NATO members and engage in combined weapons procurement. A full on combined military from there wouldn't be such a step on paper. The real stumbling block is that each wishes to remain a sovereign nation rather than subject to some federal authority.
>>
>>65655768
>Why do you imagine that the Russians spend so much money and time online trying to trash British prestige and run them down at every opportunity?
jesus christ what level of cope is this
>>
>>65651927
>and we shall create...a Grand Army of the Republic
>for peace, stability and security
>>
>>65652082
I think you have a weird imagination. Anti-immigrant sentiment is perfectly fine, anti-immigration legislation is perfectly fine.
What isn't fine (and isn't fine anywhere) is deporting people with legal immigration status and taking their shit. But that will never happen, because it's illegal.
>>
>>65655483
>muh 2%
okay that's nice but doesn't adress that the Europeans have the C3 and ISTAR they would need to beat the russians. mind you not all they would want but need.
>deterred russia
how come the massive US defense pending didn't deter the russians?
also do note that russia borders Finland a EU member state that wasn't in NATO so the US wouldn't be bound to defend them, just the other EU member states and somehow that was enough to deter the russians from going after them. what better way to show that the westen alliances are worthless and to break it up than to go after a EU country directly.
>>65655569
>US states are not nations
not after the civil war or war of northern aggression that ended with the south occupied and ran from Washington/by baggers
a war that also involved burning down the richest part of the south to the ground
oh and ofc to over night abolition of the souths biggest concentration of capital
>>65655577
the EU allows it's member states to leave if they want to, does the US allow it's states to leave?
>>
a) I want to propose the fifth mutt's law "if a discussion about European defense goes on long enough a mutt will bring up healthcare"
b) regardless of the the pro's and cons of the models European life expectancy is 5 years longer than the US's and idk but living 1/16 longer does seem like it's worth something
>>
>>65655483
I think you don't understand the difference between VAT and Sales tax.
>>
>>65651927
>How scary would a unified EU military be?
Very scary to the citizens of the EU.
>>
>>65655298
The article you posted said the cases were about US military member on US military member in poland, not on polish citizens. Did you even read past the headline?
>>
File: HSmZ-_raoAAEasV.jpg (2.15 MB, 4096x2816)
2.15 MB JPG
>>65653283
Europe is never going to federalize, their cultures are far more disparate than the USA was when it federalized and even then the USA still required a civil war to solidify federal control. What European nation is willing to wage war against its neighbors to solidify control under it?
>>
>>65651943
>fighter jet
eurofighter
>mbt
eurotank
>service rifle
eurorifle
>>
>>65655717
By being principally federally funded rather than state funded. Eventually the state militias became so toothless and the states so willing to cede expeditionary warfare responsibilities off the to the federal government that the Militia Act of 1903 finally gave birth to the structure we recognize today.
>>
The EU already lost their chance to federalize. They had the chance during Brexit, when they could have declared war on the UK to bring it back into the Union by force much like the USA did to the Confederates. By refusing to do so, they relinquished themselves of the authority necessary for any sort of centralized control necessary for an EU military to have teeth.
>>
>>65656590
>They had the chance during Brexit, when they could have declared war on the UK to bring it back into the Union by force
Why would they, when they're destroying Britain by doing nothing?
>>
>>65656662
Britain's economic growth since Brexit is like 6 times higher than that of Germany.
>>
>>65656707
>Britain's economic growth since Brexit is like 6 times higher than that of Germany.
Why are you lying?
>>
>>65656590
>>65656662
You entirely miss the point of the EU.
It is the realization that getting rich together by trading is the ony way because we've tried conquering each other for 1000 years and proved beyond the last shred of doubt that it does not work.

And if it almost works, foreign enemy powers (Russia, US, Britain, etc.) will intervene to stop Europe from being united.
Which is why all the anti-EU people fall for Russian (and now even MAGA) talking points and are nothing but useful idiots for these foreign powers.
>>65656707
Point in case, blatant lies to 'support' EU skeptics. Britain has gravely wounded itself by leaving the EU.
>>
File: LuOFiF0.gif (362 KB, 300x166)
362 KB GIF
>>65656662
And this is why the EU will never be a federation.

The goal isn't to 'destroy Britain'. It's to bring it back into the fold. The fact that 'destroying Britain' is their goal instead of returning them to the union means that they still think of Britons as the 'enemy', as competitors and rivals instead of as fellow citizens.
>>
>>65656707
Britain has caused itself generational ecoonomic damage, and brexit was paid for by Moscow. Curious, isn't it.
>>
File: 1584329292876.jpg (72 KB, 1024x576)
72 KB JPG
>>65656835
>It is the realization that getting rich together by trading is the ony way
That's called a trade league, and it's NOT a nation-state. It can be useful for prosperity, but it will never possess the influence or power of a nation-state of the same size.
>>
>>65656848
Is this some kind of gotcha?
How did Germany start? With a league that dropped tolls and allowed easy trade.
How did the US start? Witha congress of 13 very different colonies banding together.

Working together is in the common interest, not working together hurts everyone. This is so blindingly obvious that arguing against it requires willfull ignorance of reality, and funnily enough we now have Britan as a proof of concept for how fucking stupid it is to leave this massively beneficial arrangement.
>>
>>65656894
>How did the US start? Witha congress of 13 very different colonies banding together.
Those colonies were much more similar to each other than the European nations are, AND they had to throw out their articles of confederation entirely because they didn't grant enough federal power, AND they had to fight a civil war to reinforce that federal power.

Europe is not prepared to do the same. They aren't even willing to fight to keep nations in the union.
>>
>>65656894
>How did Germany start?
Through war, largely.
>>
Just give Poland nukes and let them have their own NATO on the eastern flank. Western Europe is full of rapefugees
>>
File: Revised_Intermarium_Plan.png (250 KB, 1280x1131)
250 KB PNG
>>65656944
Some revised version of the Intermarium would be way more likely to succeed than any EU army.
>>
>>65656944
>rapefugees
he said the thing!
>>65657033
ah, the retarded polish power fantasy
>>
>>65656933
Two things. War, and trade.
External enemies fightng in the Germanies (30 year war is teh best example) (France, Sweden, etc.)
And the various pprinces, kings, aristocrats attempting to carve out their own little slices opposed this move towards a more unified Germany.

The parallels are baffling, if you look at it carefully.
>>
File: You_defend_Belgium.jpg (52 KB, 500x325)
52 KB JPG
>>65657055
>War, and trade.
And Prussian dominance too.

IF the EU was willing to let Germany take control of the EU and control it, you might see it federalize, but as it stands any attempt by the Germans to assert a hegemony over the EU would lead to nations splitting off from it, and Germany isn't willing to conquer those nations to bring them back into the fold.

Ironically the closest Europe ever became to being properly united was when it was occupied by Germany in WW2.
>>
>>65657066
>Prussian dominance
The movement towards unification was probably unstoppable after French nationalism and Republicanism showed everyone the way.
Prussia just had a sequence of good kings and a very good chancellor whiel Austria pretty much stagnated.

>Ironically the closest Europe ever became to being properly united was when it was occupied by Germany in WW2.
And who moved heaven and hell to stop this and cut Europe into pieces postwar?
Admittedly the nazis did a shitload of heinous things that needed to to be stopped.
>>
>>65657093
>And who moved heaven and hell to stop this
As bad as the eternal anglo is if Hitler had slowed his roll a little and used their success to use more political influence instead we could've seen Mosley fix things up and maintain peaceful relations with Germany instead.
>>
>>65655325
Where the fuck are you going to get the rare earth to manufacture solar panels yoh retarded oompa loompa?

Oh wait, fucking China, Australia, Africa, and South America. Except oh wait, its infinitely fucking easier to recycle uranium, plutonium, and thorium than it is rare earth, which was why before you retarded enviornmentalist commie shit stains took over France, the French used to do just this, because turns out you can recycle uranium at a 98% return rate after 25 years of service. WOW thats fucking shit isn't it? We need to build wind turbines that are 3 generations old by the time they're built and solar panels that stright up can't be recycled, by yesterday. Thank you globohomo.
>>
That retarded ibfographic you're miss citing includes moneh spent on medical research you muppet. The US spends the most on medical research of every country in the world, more than the next 5 countries combined.

Nevermind the fact you're citing the guy who cofounded fucking Blackstone, which Larry Fink was working at before he went off to form fucking BLACKROCK HOLY SHIT WHO KNEW NOT LIKE IT WAS IN THE FUCKING. NAME. BLACK STONE BLACK ROCK WOW NEVER IN A MILLION YEARS WOULD I IMAGINE THIS TO BE THE FUCKING CASE.
>>
>>65657284
>Where the fuck are you going to get the rare earth to manufacture solar panels
Canada, Ukraine
>yoh retarded oompa loompa?
ah yes, insults instead of actual arguments
>>
>>65657335
Yes, you effeminate cock sucking bitch, I am using insults to denigrate your gene pool pond scum phenotype logic. Now whats your 1rp squat?
>>
>>65656894
>How did Germany start?
The German Empire of 1871 didn't have a unified military. Bavaria, Saxony and Württemberg operated their own forces right up to the world war.
>>
>>65657366
Exactly. How was it before 1871?
Hint: No internal tolls and trade.
>>
File: all edge no point.jpg (11 KB, 474x347)
11 KB JPG
>>65657348
>I am using insults to denigrate your gene pool pond scum phenotype logic.
>>
>>65657389
The German confederation formed in the Vienna congress was a fairly loose association. The wars against Denmark in 1864 and Prussia in 1866 were fought by the individual armies of the member states with little structure beyond that. Closest you got was the united fleet formed after the 1848 revolution but that was fairly irrelevant since it only lasted a few years and contested a single battle.
The North German confederation was more of an extension of Prussia than a union of German states.
>>
>>65657440
So it took several decades, an external enemy or three, no internal tolls. . .interesting, wouldn't you say?
>>
>>65657644
Prussia was an internal enemy.
>>
>>65657658
>le german unification was le bad
>>
>>65657687
The war of 1866 was between the German Confederation and Prussia, one of its members. It's often reduced to a war between Austria and Prussia but the rest of the Confederation was involved in one way or the other.
>>
>>65657703
Habsburg insistence on their ramshackle Empire will remain asone of teh more tragic events of teh 19t hcentury.
Without that Empire, and Austria as part of a unified Germany, there could be no WW1.
>>
>>65657390
That doesn't look like a +400 lbs below parallel squat, tons of fun. Don't you have a Reddit to moderate or some gay, retarded shit like that?
>>
>>65656537
If the Quebecois and Anglo canadians can do it, anyone can. Eat shit, Americunt.
>>
File: IMG_1081.jpg (260 KB, 1170x1286)
260 KB JPG
>>65658308
If Europe was so eager to be unified, they wouldn’t have fought back against Germany so hard the last two times they tried to unify the continent. Euros have nobody but themselves to blame for not being unified already.
>>
>>65658408
Not even Germans want Berlin to be the capital.
>>
>>65658408
Cope harder
>>
>>65658445
>t. malding frenchie
>>
>>65658408
Impressive delusion, not sure if you're an actual German, or if you're some sort of weird foreign larper who attached himself to another country's nationalism out of mindless teenage contrarianism. Probably the latter.

>>65658482
Oh yeah, only the French had any kind of objections to that shit, because France was the only country which Germany attacked.
>>
An 'EU Army' means that the UK, US, Turkiye and Russia fucks Europe up.

Another world war just to stop an EU Army will seem worth it for policymakers.
>>
>>65658551
The French are the only Europeans delusional enough to think that they honestly deserve to lead Europe over Germany, when they needed to be bailed out of two world wars and can’t even manage their own budget. German hegemony over Europe is inevitable, it’s been the trend for the past 200 years and despite all the fussing and whining about it from Frenchies and Britons they’ll have no choice but to accept it sooner or later.
>>
>>65659915
Oh, I'm confident that Germany's neutered army and surplus of rapefugees will let them take Europe by force. Third time's the charm, Fritz!
>>
>>65659915
You retarded Krauts can't even maintain your rotary wheels well enough to train your pilots on your own fucking aircraft. The ADF has your government shitting its pants and tearing itself apart because its so fucking terrified they might lose in the race to the bottom.

But sure pal, mommy says you're the specialist boy which is why you get to race at the specialist boy olympics.
>>
>>65661053
There is no unified Europe without Germany at the helm. It’s either Germany, or you accept being 2nd fiddle to the USA.
>>
>>65661095
>There is no unified Europe without Germany at the helm
France or Poland can do a better job being the leader of Europe than Germany.
>>
>>65656208
Try making a cogent argument why not?

>>65656106
>a yuropoor will bring up healthcare
FTFY
It's their go-to across the entire Internet for any criticism at all
They've sacrified borders, wars, technology, commerce, and freedom for it
>life expectancy
Control all statistics for blacks and the muricans win. The numbers don't lie.

>>65656088
>the Europeans have the C3 and ISTAR they would need
Substantiate that statement, don't just say "nuh uh they do" and leave it at that.

>>65655768
>shift goalposts to humint
Sure Jan
>the whole world loves
Money and the firepower to protect it. Your poshly-accented Fabians are talking about paying reparations to turdies while slashing defence operations and budgets, that's all the "humint" you're leading in

>>65655691
Essentially, yes
>>
>>65661166
France can’t even manage itself without riots every 2 seconds and Poland is submissive to Germany
>>
>>65661095
Ursula wrote this post while jerking off furiously.
>>
>>65655582
>grabbing islands
That would depend on how fast a military and political QRF can react, and on that score, it's not like the US has done fuck-all about e.g. Fiery Cross anyway even without being engaged elsewhere

I dunno I'm not imaginative enough like Tom Clancy was, but I know they'd do sneakier shit
Like maybe bug more undersea cables
>>
>>65661219
>Control all statistics for blacks and the muricans win.
Oh cool, do we get to cut out the poorest 12.4% of our population too to fudge our statistics as well?
>>
>>65661226
The people are allowed to protest in France dullard
>>
>>65651936
fpbp There's no way this won't be used domestically 90% of the time.
>>
>>65655325
Isn't this the #1 reason France is all over the Sahel?



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.