>“You don’t need no AR-15 rifle for a home gun, sonny! That might penetrate every wall in the house and hit your neighbor! Just get you a nice 1911! That’s all you need!”What boomer fudd lore have you had thrown at you?
>>65653451Do fudds really claim that bullets need to "get up to speed" after leaving the muzzle or is that just YT deboonking clickbait?
>>65653478I've never heard that before, if anything that sounds like what a vidyafag would say
>>65653478I feel like anyone who has taken even a high school physics course would know that’s horse shit
>>65653480Some ballistics channel I won't bother to look up claims this is the fudd cope for why .50 BMG doesn't knock over a house of cards, let alone rip limbs off on a near miss. The tests were done too close to the muzzle.
>>65653451Every boomer NRA member in my family worries about voting for pro-gun people all the time but doesn't understand why anyone would need more than three guns (and not scary black rifles).
>>65653451>penetrate every wall in the house and hit your neighborAs dumb as it is, I 'wargamed' out every feasible home invasion scenario I could think of and in none of them is an overpenetration a realistic concern with the layout of my house and the neighbors
>>65653451Do neofudds count?>bullets are solved science! 9mm is the only pistol cartridge in the world and no one needs anything but a PSA 10.5 AR-15!I mean, the fudd in the picture has been dead for 15 years by this point.
>>65653526>CCW handgun>home defense/shtf long gunYou dont need more
>>65653451>you wouldnt buy a gun on internet son, it's illegal and very dangerousBoomgger say what.
What is the best (worst) category of fuddlore?>self-defense advice>firearm handling practices>military history>boomer ballistics
>>65653451Had a boomer RSO seriously tell me that ricochet travel faster than bullets out of the barrel. Had to explain basic physics to him and the struggled to understand why that was impossible.
>>65653478One anon went on an autistic posting spree arguing that at HD ranges, 5.56 will not have stabilized enough to reliably fragment on contact with an intruderDo with that what you will.
>>65653612It's firearm history and it's not even close, because there's usually several layers of bull shit to wade through before getting to the truth See: Ivan's history lessons on the AR-15
>>65653478>Do fudds really claimno. The answer is always no.
>>65653655>He's 100% right though
>>65653704That's what he's saying I think, that Ivans videos are trying to undo decades of fuddlore about sabotage that never happened
A few years ago someone in law enforcement told me 5.56 is preferred by their agency for CQB because it doesn't go through drywall. I'm not kidding. He really believed that.
>>65653737I'd be curious what his explanation was for those California police who headshot a kid through a wall in that department store a few years ago
>>65653749I should have just showed him Paul Harrell's video comparing .223 to buckshot. Spoiler: both of them went through multiple layers of drywall before "killing" the soda bottles on the outside of the setup.
>>65653749Wasn't that only jut this past summer? The guy with the m16a1?
>>656538292021 it seems, officer fired three shots, one of which managed to ricochet off the ground and through the dressing room
>>65653860>5 yearsDamn. Time flies when you're a miserable wagie jej
>>65653649Whut...That makes no sense.
>>65653948One thing I've learned is that any random person is capable of having a conceptualization of reality that contradicts every piece of evidence to the contrary. I've had a debate with someone who completely unironically believed that Japan in WWII had greater industrial capacity than the US
>>65653451Okay but why do you need a semi-auto rifle for home defence? Are you expecting an intruder to be rocking up with NIJ IV protection? If so, where the fuck do you even live?
>>65653998The United States. Its kind of a sithole nowadays
>>65653960>believed that Japan in WWII had greater industrial capacity than the US>talking to /his/ schizo
AR15 indoors will make you go deaf, and it's too big, and if you are woken up and groggy it's not as easy to pick up and shoot a Glock 9mm with no safetya 9mm handgun with a flashlight attached is the better home defense weapon for 99 percent of situations. it's gonna be close range. rifles are for distance not intimate 10 feet away scenarios
>>65653998>Are you expecting an intruder to be rocking up with NIJ IV protection?Yes, police commonly wear this.
>>65654015Buddy you are not going to 1 v. everyone the police force, regardless of your tricked out AR.
"Don't use a suppressor with a nielsen device on a fixed barrel, sonny! You might, uh, vaguely damage something somewhere. You need to buy a fixed barrel spacer!"oh, so having the suppressor violently bounce around is only safe if the fucking barrel is also loose and tilting in the opposite direction, yeah ok fucking retard i guess if the barrel is completely still, for some reason THAT causes a baffle strike you complete fucking geriatric buffon.
>>65654055A nielsen device only moves back and forth, it doesn't tilt up or down. But yeah, using it on a fixed barrel is completely fine, other than being pointless
>heres my 100yr old book on how to shoot, written by a guy who gun in gunfights with retards for a living!
>>65654051You don't have to win to make your point.
my first handgun was a 1911 because I believed the fuddlore.
>>65653960>I've had a debate with someone who completely unironically believed that Japan in WWII had greater industrial capacity than the USThat's not a debate. That's you delivering a history lesson.
>>65653998why wouldn't I want 30 rounds and a can to shoot niggers with?>I NEED TO NERF M'SELFretard
>>65653596>Bill of NeedsThat doesn't sound right now does it?
I heard the bouncy 22 thing quite a bit growing up.
>>65653451The strangest one was an older fellow saying that 8mm Mauser is one way compatible with 8mm Lebel in order to use French ammo supplies which is why the French moved to 7.5
>>65654150>here's my two cents, written by a guy who can't spell
It's impossible to use 30-30 past 40 yards according to some random faggot that shows up to my work
Worst advice from fudds is anything related to the 1911 and the idea of not wanting a suppressor "because you want everyone to hear". That and soft support for gun control
>>65654305Sounds like certain /k/omrades saying that 9mm doesn't work and that .22 hits like a bb gun.
>>65653451My dad dropped his .40 GLOCK once. He tried to catch it and it went off. The bullet went through three walls and got stuck in the kitchen sink.
heard multiple anons here say you shouldn't run glocks with a full mag + 1
>>65653998>Okay but why do you need a semi-auto rifle for home defence?So I can pull the trigger again if the home isn't properly defended the first time? I figure you're just playing along with the bit but I always thought it was strange that people who are perfectly okay with the concept of blasting an ounce of lead through an intruder's chest with a shotgun suddenly balk at the idea of double tapping them with a rifle.
>>65654331That's American housing quality for you, those walls were probably composed of wooden planks and sound insulation foam.
>>65654351Pretty much. Hanging pictures in this house is a nightmare, you can never find a stud.
>>65654192His argument was that the Japanese conquests had given them access to more labor and resources throughout asia compared to the mainland US. Retarded yes, but there was some train of logic>>65654256That idea has been repeated by pretty much every close comparison of ammunition of rival nations. With NATO vs. USSR, you'll hear 152/155, 100/105/115/120/125 and 5.56/5.45 all being claimed to have some "smaller shell in larger gun" compatibility, usually being presented as some genius idea depending on who they're trying to hype up
>>65653451Surprised it hasn't been posted yet but the best fuddlore is always the one about "if ya shoot someone inna head with .22 it'll bounce around in thur skull!"
>>65653704>>65653655>>65653733>>65653733>sabotage that never happenedIt happened. No cleaning kits and issuing ammo with dirty powder.
>>65654418Cleaning kits and maintenance instruction were well supplied for the initial units who got the M16, it was follow-on units that had not been trained prior to arriving in Vietnam that reported SHORTAGES of cleaning kits, on top of not being properly trained on the rifle. The ammo was the best that was capable of being provided at the scale needed, the fouling issue was largely overblown as a result of cleaning material shortages and later testing validated the Army's choice to stick with WC 846.
>>65654418>sabotage or retardation, call it.
>>65653572That's the weirdest meme I've heard since it relies on unironic doublethink to work>All cartridges above 32 ACP are equally effective>380 is completely worthless, 9mm is the minimum viable option>Anything above 9mm has terrible capacity and shooting performance, just use 9>Anything below 9mm has terrible ballistics>30SC? Worthless>5.7? More like 22 magnumBasically you're a retard for picking a more powerful cartridge with less shots or something with more shots but less individual lethality because 9mm is god apparently
>>65654429>it was follow-on units that had not been trained prior to arriving in Vietnam that reported SHORTAGES of cleaning kits, on top of not being properly trained on the rifle.concession>The ammo was the best that was capable of being provided at the scale needed,acceptedAnd now that Vietnam Veterans are dying out like the WWII vets, the army and its bootlickers feel comfortable pushing these lies.>>65654433Malicious sabotage that should have been called treason and rewarded with death by firing squad or hanging for dozens of men, military and civilian.Don't issue the fucking weapon when it isn't fucking ready.
>>65654443>Don't issue the fucking weapon when it isn't fucking ready.So now you've backpedaled from it being sabotage to being issued too quickly. Which is it? Who, specifically, is sabotaging things? Why?>the army and its bootlickers feel comfortable pushing these liesNigger these facts have been known since 68 at least, it's retards like you who whine about dirty ammo when that wasn't the issue, just what caught the most flak
>>6565444210mm is exactly the amount of bigger bullet you can go before the drawbacks become too much. 10mm can give you the grain weight of .45 ACP in the heavier loads while allowing you to keep a double stack mag. Or just have a 50% heavier bullet traveling faster with similar mag capacity.The issue of course is recoil. Follow up shots on 10mm are slower than 9mm. Its just physics working against you. All in all, taking everything into perspective, including price, 9x19mm is the Goldilocks of pistol ammunition.ps.40 sw is a waste of fucking time.
>>65654456>So now you've backpedaled from it being sabotage to being issued too quickly. Which is it? Who, specifically, is sabotaging things? Why?Oh how cute, you demand it be just ONE thing going wrong.
>>65654461vagueposting award or something
>>65654461>you demand it be just ONE thing going wrong.No, I want you to validate your claim because up until now you've danced around specifics. I contend that you do this because as soon as you try and make an argument for when, where and what this "sabotage" is, it will fall apart.
>>65653998I've been attacked by 4 dogs at the same time. They fucked off after I fired one shot but what if they didn't?
>>65654473>>65654467lol how many hours do you have left on your duty shift?
>>65654486uh oh anon's popping flares
>>65654418gene stoner sabotaged the m16 by being a retard and not chroming the bore and chamber in spite of that being the industry standard for all military weapons at that point
>>65654457Fuck you my man, I appreciate 40 and 10 mil since 40 has the benefit of fitting in 9mm frames and having more options where 10 is an overall better cartridge but limited by what I can shoot it out of. Personally if I'm going to 10 I'll just move up to 357 or 44 if I really want power, 40 is more than enough otherwise but is available in more than just glawks and 1911s (and tanfos but they don't import them anymore IIRC)
>>65654497Stoner's biggest fault was pushing .222 too far with the IMR powder. Yes he didn't think the resulting .223 would be the final design but him, Armalite and Colt should have been far more upfront on the powder limitation than they were
>>65654497That and thinking a forward assist was bad. Gene clearly has never handled a gun in the field because after my experiences with a FAL and a G3 there were many times I wished I had a way to force the bolt home without ejecting a live round
>>65653478>he doesn't know about the fudds' secret stash of gyrojet guns and ammo
>>65653704He is, if nothing else he's put actual time into researching and reading the meeting transcripts and reportsThe specific topic i was referring to was the whole "The AR15 is/isnt a military weapon and why" thing
>>65654182Well, do you regret it? I think I'd like a 1911 or some kind of .45 eventually.
>>65654401>Retarded yes, but there was some train of logicBy "train" you mean one of those Temu ones that runs of AA batteries, and runs in a little circle on a card-table.
>>65654305I believed the 30-30 pussy talk and dented the fuck out of my steel plate and I feel dumb for believing it.
>>65653451I kinda hate that the 1911 is 'da boomer gun' because i really like it. It's not the best at what it does anymore, i know that, but i love it's aesthetics, i enjoy shooting it and i think it's history is neat.Leave 1911 alone she's tired and old ;_;
>>65654429>and later testing validated the Army's choice to stick with WC 846The decision to go with WC846 was borderline criminally negligent.
Imagine not having multiple .416 Rigbys (and a tribal boy to reload them) as your HD
>>65654055why have an oscillating piece (for lack of a better word) on anything fixed?
>>65653451>>65653451>might penetrate every wall in the house and hit your neighbor!given american cardboard walls, thats probably true. >>65653489>>65653480ive heard this from artillery. the round is still accelerating when it leaves the barrel and reaches peak velocity a few meters out.
>>65654256>>65654401I had a fellow gunsmith try to tell me that Hungarian Mosins specifically were modified to be able to shoot 7,62 Nato. He was told this once and has apparently shot some rounds in this manner. He is prone to believe in such bullshit.
>>65655060It was the best option available for them, they ran multiple rounds of testing and every other option was worse.
>>65653451>be me a few years ago>looking for surplus rifle locally>want a Carcano but can’t find one>find Mauser instead>talking guy about how initially I wanted a Carcano>”oh you don’t want a Carcano”>why’s that?>”The machining is rough on em and that causes them to wear out faster”>huh, ok (idk about that)
>>65654304>knows exactly what im saying but chooses to attack the typo because hes petty.
>>65655317Not unless it's rocket assisted or some such, once it completely leaves the barrel it's not under pressure and not being accelerated
>>65655390if that were true there would be no muzzle blast wave. as the muzzle blast wave is literally gas in the barrel pushing the surrounding air aside as it leaves the barrel. it probably also gives the projectile a little push too. might not be much but enough to cause peak velocity to occur a few meters outside of the barrel, maybe just decimeters.
>>65655378even if that isnt necessarily true they are literally the most grittiest jankiest bolt action of the world wars that isnt a black powder conversion. makes the mosin feel like a pre-64 model 70 in comparison
>>65654505Nta but moving up to 357 or 44 drops your shots from 16 to 6-8. Not the end of the world, but worth mentioning.My biggest gripe as a 10mm appreciator is the lack of full power ammunition in brick and mortar stores.
I am become fudd, destroyer of polymer and aluminum
>"Kydex? You don't need that plastic stuff! It scratches up your gun! Get a leather holster instead!" Like I get it with a range toy you don't use for anything else. But with an EDC, it's gonna get scuffed up eventually no matter what you use
>>65655235because you bought a suppressor for your 9mm handgun but it literally fits on everything from your retarded kel-tec P50 bullshit to a good ol' turkshit MP5 and even a fucking 7.5inch 300 blackout AR but when you're having fun the fudds start screeching about how you're doing it wrong o algo
>>65655378I was nervous about going into gun stores at first but I quickly learned it's like sports no one knows anything and you can bullshit your way through a conversation with minimal internet research.
>>65655779What length barrel is that and what is the hand guard?
You don't need anything but an AR and a glock but you don't need the AR or the glock what you really need is a 1911.
>>65656465Famas
>>65654350this, but double tapping them with a jhp 9mm will stop them as well, and it's easier to just leave on my desk
>>65656465it looks like the end of a 16" carbine shopped onto a midlength for some reason.
Boomer stories? I'll bite.So I was building a m91/30 out of cheap spare parts (I already have a nice hex receiver m91/30, but I wanted to try something for funsies). Needed some trigger parts and a ejector. Hit up one of the local gun shows and peruse a vendor I see at almost all the local shows. Fat old dude with bins full of random shit, he also has a fat younger assistant who is just as autistic as him (son maybe?). Ask the old shitter if he has any spare m91/30 parts, specifically the few little parts I'm looking for. This retarded old geriatric fuck starts going on about how he has tons of mosin parts in bins at home but "you can't just take parts from one and put them in another because the tolerances from rifle to rifle is just way too varied! I used to have a gunsmith buddy who would fit spare parts to rifles but he wouldn't touch it until you gave him $400 just to look at it! I've been doing this for 100 years! yadayadayada!" Uhh... sure old man... I look at the guy at the table across from him and say "I guess I don't know anything about my own firearms!" Anyway, I go home and hop on ebay and just order the spare parts on there. They arrive and fit/function just fine. Who lets these fuckers out of the nursing homes? m91/30s are cheap mass produced slav rifles, not some individually hand crafted piece of art with every part being meticulously fitted and machined to fit each rifle. Do these retards even listen to themselves?
>>65656730So like was the guy not gonna let you buy the part?
>>65656980Sounds like he didn't have them there
>>65653596>handgun for daily carry>12 gage shotgun for bird season and short range deer season>20 gage shotgun for ducks>big game rifle>small game rifle>spares>youth rifle for your children and/or nieces/nephews or grandchildren >youth shotgun for the same group(s)>.22 for keeping in okay practice And that's just as an average fuddboy needing to cover your regular hunting needs while staying in regulation just in case a fish and game officer jumps out of nowhere having been filming to ding you for breaking regulations.
>>65656980No, he didn't have them there. He just wanted to rant incoherently.
>>65656313I've never had much of a conversation at a gun store so far. Maybe I'm just too autistic though. Last two, or really one and a half times since one was a pawn shop, went>walk into pawn shop and stand around waiting by the guns for 10 minutes while the employees ignore me, until one sort of notices finally>hey can I see that side by side shotgun>yeah, here you go. it's either a 20 gage or a 16 gage, don't remember. >look it over for a bit, it's a 16 gage and is an alright price of $190 since it has been there a while>stand around holding it for another 10 minutes until they come back to check in>yeah this one is alright, I'll take it>okay>standard FFL related paperwork follows>say thanks and walk out with it after paying and getting the receipts for itthen on the way home I stopped at a local gun store to buy some shells and look at a few things>go in>grab a box of 16 gage shells off the shelf>grab an extra magazine for a handgun I've been enjoying shooting at the range lately >go up to pay>16 gage?>yeah.>pay, leaveMost the time it's just some basic question/response kind of thing and I've never talked to another customer while there.Basically if an autist like me can do it, most anyone else has nothing to feel too nervous about.
>>65655317>>65655390Could be the basebleed perhaps. During the transitional phase it would still accelerate the round ever so slightly before air resistance and gravity started slowing it back down.
>>65653612Bad Self Defence advice actually throws you in jail though and leads to statements so foul you can feel the handcuffs around your wrists.>go out into the dark and fire two blasts in the airAlways gives a wonderful chuckle
>>65654958Just hammer it out by flipping the target and shooting the dents
>>65653998>Are you expecting an intruder to be rocking up with NIJ IV protection?I would if I was was planning on doing some home intrudingsafety first
>>65657407some gun stores, especially the small family owned ones, have old fudds that will show up everyday just to hang out and socializeyou can tell the people working there fucking hate him but won't tell him to buy something or fuck off because he's the owners uncle or hunting buddy or some shit
>>65658485>nocansNGMI larper
>>65658372I prefer>just shoot through the dooras my preferred felony advice
>>65653612>self-defense adviceDad's home defense wonder 9 was alternating jhp and fmj.
>>65656313I just already know more about everything than 95% of people that would work at a gun store so nothing bothers me. Sometimes I'll play along with their laughably false fuddlore for lols.
>>65653612Military history is full of BS because the vast majority of the actual design processes were either not actually documented or are still classified and forgotten about to the point that no one could ever find the documents again.
>>65658372I like>Load your guns with rock salt/ less lethal ammunitionYou know, as if assault with a deadly weapon just depends on what you had loaded
>>65653998>Are you expecting an intruder to be rocking up with NIJ IV protection?For their sake, I certainly hope so.
>>65661479Honestly, I think that it's worse than that. Most design processes, even if we don't have a full picture, exist to some extent and are available. The problem is that they're often both complex and dry that no one is really interested in learning about them, so the bullshit stories that sound great over a beer catch on instead. Earlier example in regards to the early M16 performance is a prime example, it's a pretty nuanced story with a lot of back-and-forth with different agencies and parties making decisions that from their perspective is the best choice to make things work out, but going into the procurement processes is boring so "it was sabotage" becomes the go-to story that gets repeated
>>65658511picture is 4 years old and was taken in NY
>>65657407Probably for the best. Gun shop employees are subjected to some of the worst boomers and spurgs that are lonely and trauma dump on them. Not to mention the risk of them “getting a bad feeling” about you and rejecting the sale.
>>65656254while it fits ive heard that it can cause baffle strikes but im not super versed on the suppressor stuff anyhow; i figure its just too easy to buy a $20-30 grovetech fixed mount or something similar so i didnt bother risking it