[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/k/ - Weapons

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


Looks like foreign ships are back on the menu, boys!

https://news.usni.org/2026/11/13/the-new-six-frigates
>While a successful frigate program has eluded the U.S. Navy for decades, the service is working toward using a foreign design for a new class of ships in the next few years
>Now the Navy is prioritizing frigates that can escort other ships instead of performing anti-submarine warfare, which was the main mission of the now-cancelled Constellation-class program
>The service wants a platform that can enforce a blockade and protect against medium tiered threats
>>
>South Korean Chungnam-class
>Turkish Istanbul-class
>Spanish F110
>Japanese Upgraded Mogami
>French/Italian FREMM Evolved
>British Type 31 Arrowhead
>>
>>65653908
>Start the project that became USS Constellation
>select a foreign design
>cancel the project due to foreign design not working
>restart project
>start by looking at purchasing a foreign design
>>
File: 1772600260235731.png (1.11 MB, 1181x656)
1.11 MB PNG
>>65653920
Given free choice I'd personally lean towards Mogami due to the high degree of automation and the modern 360 CIC. It's also ALREADY being modified for australian export, so they have experience integrating other western systems.
>>
>>65653920
>French/Italian FREMM Evolved
as the kids say, are we deadass rn
>>
>>65653939
I would be funny, if it weren't so sad.
>>
>>65653939
The Constellation was so radically altered from the FREMM as to be a completely new design, which is a problem when the entire point of choosing a foreign, proven design was to cut down on costs.
>>
>>65653939
No, it's even worse than that.
>Start with building a lightly armed multi mission corvette
>Get bullied into trying to buy a ship that can perform escort duties, even though that's a job that's impossible for anything less than a destroyer
>Cancel that project when it inevitably costs as much as a destroyer
>Try to buy another lightly armed corvette
>Now in the process of being bullied into buying another small destroyer
It's all so tiresome.
>>
>>65653970
Does the concept of the frigate just not exist in your mind? It's a ship type that acts as an intermediary between a green water corvette and a blue water destroyer, and it was the intention behind the Constellation-class.
>even though that's a job that's impossible for anything less than a destroyer
lol
>>
>>65653979
Yes, it's something that's completely irrelevant today. All of these 6000-7000 ton "frigates" with dozens of VLS cells are just destroyers for poor countries. That's not what the US Navy needs, we have much better destroyers. What we need are shitty little boats with maybe a 3" gun but are still blue water capable.
>>
>>65653939
why is it when navy is involved everything goes to shit?
PSC has taken YEARS with no ships delivered.
while the ASC is expected to deliver the first ship in two years.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polar_Security_Cutter_program
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arctic_Security_Cutter_program
>>
>>65654010
You can easily get a ship that is 3k or 4k tonnes with dozens of VLS cells and blue-water capability, believing that the frigate exists only for "poor countries" is so painfully retarded and American. Once the Hazard Perry-class got sold off the sub-80 IQ brainrot of "frigates bad" began to set in.
>>
>>65654023
The OHP class was already incapable of meaningfully performing escort duty, just look at what happened to the Stark. Those ships were relying on the American flag as their first and only line of defense; the job could have been done by a rowboat and gotten fewer sailors killed.
>>
>>65653970
>even though that's a job that's impossible for anything less than a destroyer
Then what is a frigate even capable of?
>>
>>65653939
The USN is like the pre-Endor Imperial Navy. They self-sabotage any procurement of small ships because they fear losing funding and justification for the big huge prestige capital ships.
>>
>>65654078
Bro the Trump-class is going to get glassed from orbit by the new Democratic legislature and the Ford-class has experienced setbacks, killing the small ship projects has not prevented these.
>>
>>65653908
Wait, didn't we settle on those cutters?
>>
>>65654052
Nothing, that's my point. They're fundamentally just slightly smaller, slightly cheaper destroyers now. A corvette that's 20% of the price of a Burke is useful, you can buy a lot of them and use them for any of the very many missions that exist that aren't particularly dangerous. A frigate that's 80% of the cost of a Burke is just a warship that you aren't planning to use for war. You might as well pay the extra 20% to get a ship that's even better at escort duty in addition to keeping up the numbers of large surface combatants. Trading 16 Burkes for 20 Constellations would give our Navy fewer options, not more. Yeah, there'd be a few more hulls but those hulls aren't suited for front line combat and don't add very much volume otherwise.
>>
>>65654099
No, that was a decision made by the old Navy Secretary who got fired a while back. The powers that be decided that we shouldn't base our procurement decisions on the whims of a guy that got himself fired, so now we're back to repeating the Constellation fiasco.
>>
>>65654110
Fired or not, the Legend-class derivative was so patently dogshit on its face that everyone could see how stupid it was.
>>
>>65653908
Not this shit again. Navy will pick a design, engineers and/or Congress will sperg at the fact it cannot tank a 16-inch shell or some other inane shit outside its mission purview, demand the design be modified so it can do so, ballooning the costs and defeating the point of choosing an existing design in the first place, causing it to get cancelled from cost overrun.
>>
>>65654116
Yeah, it was just LCS but worse, but on the other hand LCS derivatives are a political non-starter and the Legend class was closer to what we need than Constellation or Constellation 2: Electric Boogaloo.
>>
>>65654023
The point isn't that they can realistically fight off a coordinated attack on their own, the point is that they have the endurance to keep up with shipping and can last long enough to alert an actual battle formation which can effectively engage a threat.
Where most Euro navies fail is having the "actual battle formation" part.
>>
>>65654212
Sounds like something a coast guard cutter could do.
>>
>>65653942
>high degree of automation
USN will not go for that willingly. Damage control requires crew to have a chance of working and until they accept that the little guys are disposable in the current year they're going to want enough bodies aboard to at least try to save the boat.
>>
>>65654294
Then none of these ships will meet the needs of the USN without massive changes.
>>
>>65654294
You can automate damage control to a certain extent. It was a big deal on the Zumwalt, and probably on the Mogami too, since Japan is the only other country that takes damage control seriously. They're not like the bongs, who had a destroyer burn down and sink from a single missile that didn't even explode, while an American frigate was hit by two missiles of the same type, both of which exploded, and subsequently returned to port under power.
>>
Simping for automation was partially responsible for the abject disasters which were the Zumwalt and LCS classes.
>>
>>65654325
Except Mogami's already exist in large numbers and by most reports are actually great, the biggest complaint was the lack of VLS cell density, which was fixed in the upgraded version that the USN is looking at (doubled from 16 to 32 VLS cells).
>>
>>65654325
Zumwalt was not an abject disaster, it was a more capable platform than a Flight III Burke and no more expensive; it was canceled for political reasons. LCS had problems, but those were almost entirely the result of the politically-motivated decision to buy both classes.

Constellation was an abject disaster: a ship class canceled for being useless before the design was even complete, without even the excuse of a war ending or new developments making it obsolete. You can't blame that on automation, it had a 30% larger crew complement than a Zumwalt despite a fraction of the capability.
>>
>>65654206
>LCS derivatives are a political non-starter
I'll believe this when someone actually tries.
>>
>>65653920
It'll be Upgrade Mogami, without a doubt in my mind.
>>
>>65654367
Each Zumwalt cost $4.2 billion, you are simply lying. As for the LCS classes, they are bad irrespective of both existing in tandem, the USN tried to make their Lego aluminium ships with absurdly low crew complements and failed.
>>
>>65654325
I'm starting to actually hope China pulls a dipshit manuever so the USS Oakland can scuttle a Type 52 and this tired ass tripe can be put to bed.
>>
>>65654326
As the other anon pointed out, unless they can be modified to meet the USN's damage control requirements then it's not happening.
>>
>>65654385
I'm sure its 57mm main gun and 4 M2 Brownings will singlehandedly save the day and exonerate its entire class.
>>
>>65654397
>NSM
Your refusal to engage in even the most mildest of good faith only makes your position seem more unreasonable.
>>
>>65654412
A module not given to every Independence-class, yes. Also do tell what the armament of said class has to do with the issues borne from its high automation and low crew complement? Having 8 extra missiles doesn't make repairing the CODOG any less of a bitch.
>>
>>65654377
>prototype has enormous unit cost

wow shocker
>>
>>65654412
Oh, and isn't it rather bad faith to say that what is effectively a corvette getting the MASSIVE upgrade of 8 whole missiles means it can kill a destroyer with 64 VLS cells?
>>
>>65654377
>Retard knows nothing about the program apart from what he read on the wiki article
Follow the source for that $4.2B figure and you'll find this:
>The total procurement cost for [the DDG-1000 program] includes $3.8 billion for DDG 1000, $2.8 billion for DDG-1001, and $2.4 billion for DDG-1002. The balance of the procurement costs include $3.8B for non-recurring engineering (NRE) and $400 million for post-delivery and outfitting
The actual cost of building the first ship was under $4B and the other two were under $3B each. Meanwhile, even the IIA Tech Insertion Burkes cost $2.8B and the Flight IIIs are up to $3.5B.

>As for the LCS classes, they are bad irrespective of both existing in tandem
They are perfectly fine ships now. Yes, they had teething issues at first but that's not unusual and they've been resolved now. Yes, the mission modules came very late and they're no longer hot swappable as originally planned, but that's in large part due to needing them to fit in two very different hulls, both of which were changing as problems were identified and resolved. All of that would have happened much faster and much cheaper if only one design had been procured.
>>
>>65654427
Chinese ships are stuck with S-300s for air defense so that's actually an entirely plausible scenario.
>>
>>65654417
>A module not given to every Independence-class, yes.
Wrong. Or at least effictively wrong. I honestly don't know if the training boat in Mayport has them. Hopefully your argument is not pivoting on that but given your previous willingness to eschew reality...
> Also do tell what the armament of said class has to do with the issues borne from its high automation and low crew complement? Having 8 extra missiles doesn't make repairing the CODOG any less of a bitch.
Poor reading comp or running away?

>>65654427
No.
>>
>>65654444
I think currently about half the Independence class has received the L&S upgrade with the other half slated to receive it over the next two years.
>>
>>65654458
>>65654444
USS Oakland certainly has received it though, so he's a retard either way.
>>
>>65654444
You're the one who pulled the decidedly bad faith argument that a corvette can clown on a destroyer as "proof" that the automation in the LCS classes is fine.
>No.
I accept your concession.
>>
>>65654387
And as the other anon already pointed out, the JMSDF ships are probably already the closest to USN standards for damage control already. And none of the other ships in that list fare any better in that regard either.
>>
>>65654458
All 3 ships assigned to 5th Fleet and any forward deployed with the 7th Fleet have them. Half of those back at NB San Diego also have them from previous forward deployments. Any ship likely to see any contact is going to have them.
>>
>>65654468
Corvettes (it amuses me that people now will point to this when I used to be the only one to push back on the frigate designation everyone always insisted upon) can absolutely cause serious damage to not only destroyers but even cruisers. This is never more true than it is now in the missile-age.
>I accept your concession.
Grow up and learn to have a discussion.
>>
>>65654475
They're not, the RN is closest.
>>
>>65654475
>>65654482
Quit insisting things and start putting forth something - anything! - that supports your position.
>>
>>65654427
>buh muh vls!
holy shit please die
>>
If we were to agree that the Navy needs a corvette rather than a frigate, which foreign designs should be considered? Pohjanmaa? P1118?
>>
>>65654482
>the RN is closest.
History begs to differ.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMS_Sheffield_(D80)
>>
>>65654492
This is the missile age, VLS counts are immensely important regardless of what reactionary traditionalists in the realm of naval warfare have to say.
>>
File: ANZAC class upgraded.jpg (271 KB, 1280x854)
271 KB JPG
>>65654496
>If we were to agree that the Navy needs a corvette rather than a frigate
We don't, as a corvette can't meet the attack and self-defence needs of a trans-pacific escort ship requirements.
Half the mistakes in naval acquisitions over the last 30 years across the globe are navies getting ships too small for their current role and future growth.
Australia reaslised this and are replacing the ANZAC-class with Upgraded Mogami...and that's in ADDITION to a whole new fleet of bigger frigates for their anti-submarine role, the Hunter-class (T26).
>>
File: Hunter_Class_FFG_pic.jpg (616 KB, 1200x663)
616 KB JPG
>>65654514
>>
>>65654512
not most important
die die die
>>
>>65654512
VLS cells are only as important as the munitions inside of them.
>>
>>65654427
If its missiles outrange the destroyer's missiles, I mean...
>>
>>65654042
>The OHP class was already incapable of meaningfully performing escort duty
Correct.
>>
>>65654475
>>65654487
Fine. NATO ANEP-77, the US recognises this ship code and the Japanese do not and as such do not certify under its requirements. The RN does.

Aside from that. One of the reasons why FREMM had to be redesigned was for the USN's survivability requirements. The Mogami is too small and offer little options for crew size increase that would make it an unattractive option for the USN.
>Just buy the upgraded Mogami
A bit better, but the USN is looking for cheap and modular designs to bulk up the fleet. The USN would still have to redesign the ship and as such costs will jump. Not to mention the price at Japanese shipyards will not be the price for American shipyards. Britain is much more realistic for the idea of what the final price will look like. British shipyards are already building components for the USN.
>>
>>65654501
It's not 82 anymore, the RN learned its lessons.
>>
>>65654554
This was me >>65654487
You did a good job. I don't know enough about this to really take a stance or know if you are right but I appreciate you actually trying to make things constructive.
>>
>>65654554
Japan doesn't design to NATO standards because they're not part of NATO. That doesn't necessarily mean their ships don't meet NATO standards anyway. Meanwhile, we've seen exactly what kind of worthless dogshit non-American NATO members build: Sheffield, Helge Ingstad, the FREMM which needed to be completely redesigned, etc.
>>
>>65654622
ANEP-77 is about recognising that other navies meet a criteria that is acceptable by others, it's not mandatory. The USN and RN will still differ from ANEP-77, but it does give a baseline that is recognised by the US government.
>Sheffield
From an old class of ship that's retired, only relevancy this has to the discussion is the LCS. This whole quagmire is caused by the USN's inability to choose and build a frigate to their requirements despite good options. Glass houses and all that.
>Helge Ingstad
Crew incompetence leading to a collision and the sinking
>FREMM
Good frigate. As I stated, it was redesigned for one of many reasons. Another being the USN's inability to accept a lean frigate, and try to turn it into another Burke. Leading to rising costs.
>>
>>65654572
I appreciate the cordiality.
>>
>>65654663
>just ignore that time a Royal Navy destroyer got hit by a missile that didn't even explode and then burned down and sank, it was totally a freak accident and could have happened to anyone that puts flammable shit all over their ships
>FREMM was a great frigate, the USN just ruined it by getting rid of all the flammable carpets because they just have to change things for the sake of changing things
>>
Can any of the autists here explain how a trillion dollar military is so incapable of managing and maintaining it's navy
>>
>>65654691
Easy.
>Navy has a need for a new ship
>Navy requests $20B to design a new ship
>Navy receives $20B and designs the ship they need
>Navy requests $200B to build 50 of the ship they designed
>Congress complains that it's too expensive because they just spent $200B on a balloon popping machine
>Congress finds excuses to not pay $200B (i.e. "you don't need a ship that's essentially invisible to radar when someone can just look out the window and see it" or "this corvette can't tank an antiship missile and continue fighting so it's worthless")
>Navy requests $20B to design a new class of ship to address Congress's concerns
>repeat
>>
>>65654715
Is it really congress being dumbasses or does the navy fuck shit up on their end too with unrealistic designs or over-designing a frigate into what's functionally a destroyer/mini-cruiser and therefore obsoleting the idea of what a frigate is supposed to be in the first place. Genuinely asking
>>
>>65654730
Well, the Zumwalts ended up being cheaper and more capable (or would have been, had they not been canceled) than the Burkes that followed them, and the LCS was both conceived as and built as a low cost, low capability ship, so I think it's pretty clear that NAVSEA isn't systematically getting lost in the weeds for every program they run.

So the question here is "what went wrong with Constellation?" and to answer that, you have to look at why the program was started in the first place. Originally, LCS was supposed to result in around 50 hulls. In response to complaints that LCS wasn't as capable of a surface combatant as the OHP it "replaced" (the Navy was always adamant that the OHP was retired without a successor and the LCS was conceptually entirely different but no one listens to what they say) they decided to instead build around 30 standard LCSes, and then the final 20 would be a extended version of whichever class they liked better, which would have some VLS cells and maybe a better radar. But then the complaint was that while having a few SM-6s might help prevent the ship from being hit, it wouldn't do anything to save the ship from being destroyed if it were actually hit by a missile.

The Navy decided that addressing that concern would be far outside of the scope of an engineering change order, and now we have the Constellation program. Both LCS variants were entered into the competition since they already had a lot of work done on the frigate designs, but they were both political dead ends since journalists and congressboomers had spent the past decade using them as a punching bag. So at this point, the Navy basically has a choice between the FREMM, built in a shipyard that won't be doing anything else since the LCS production is ending, or the F100 built at Bath Ironworks and potentially impacting destroyer production while Marinette potentially has financial issues without an active contract.
>>
>>65654796
So the Navy glances over the FREMM design, point out a few changes they'd like to make, and the pastaniggers assure them that sure, they can do that, it'll be easy. So they award the contract and start cutting steel for the first couple of hulls since there shouldn't be too many changes. But then it turns out that between changing out the systems from yuroshit to American hardware and addressing the obvious problems, a lot of other stuff has to get moved around to make room and a lot of that stuff starts impinging on the already-built parts of the ship that weren't supposed to need to be modified. And on top of that, the pastaniggers are submitting blank documents as completed designs for sections of the ship in order to meet their deadlines, so they can do the actual design work later and submit it as a revision. So the shipyard is getting blank or placeholder designs for stuff they're supposed to be building, so they get held up on their work, and then when that part actually gets designed it changes something in the section next to it that requires them to go back and make physical modifications to stuff they already built. And then NAVSEA takes a red pen to their half-assed homework they turned in a month late, and that results in more changes to nearby sections that results in more rework at the shipyard. And on top of this, COVID bullshit is going on at NAVSEA and Fincantieri and Marinette, which makes everything take twice as long and cost twice as much.

Eventually the cost balloons from just under $1B (which was probably always fantasy) to well over $2B, so the plug gets pulled because at that point they might as well buy another Burke. It was bad enough that they would rather have bought a piece of shit Legend class for $1B than continue building Constellations for whatever they'll cost once the design work is finally finished (which they're still paying for).

So is it a NAVSEA problem? Lack of foresight, maybe. Not a lack of restraint.
>>
>>65654796
>but they were both political dead ends since journalists and congressboomers had spent the past decade using them as a punching bag.
Technological, too. In order to get a functional design, you'd have to completely redo it.
Freedumb was a dead-end from the get-go, since neither what the Navy got (semi-planing powerboat), nor the basic-bitch displacement hull (they say it's semi-planing, but not with that powerplant) variant ordered by the Sauds (by this point it does nothing different/better than a Sigma or Gowind, and it's not cheaper than either of them anyway, so it's just a political contract) are really any good.
Indep had a good starting basis, but it a) has to be built entirely from steel, which means redoing all hull buoyancy calculations; b) replacing the waterjets with a conventional CODLAD means a lot of internal repackaging (which has to be corelated with the first). As I understand, Austal did the second, but kept the all-alu hull, for their SSC proposal.
>>
>>65653939
>it hurt itself in its confusion
>>
>>65653970
>Get bullied into trying to buy a ship that can perform escort duties, even though that's a job that's impossible for anything less than a destroyer
Frigates are great for escort duties. But to make a ship small enough to be a frigate you do need to cut back on the number of helicopters, strike missiles, BMD, etc.
But retards want to make a frigate that does literally everything, which...Is a destroyer.
>>
>>65654978
>What do you mean it can't defend against the newest XZ-156 ChingChongPingPong class ballistic missile? It's worthless then!
Sums up post-LCS US naval design.
>>
>>65655001
>WTF our smallest escort ship that's designed to shoot down seaskimming AShM's and to send helicopters after submarines can't take on the biggest Chinese cruiser and win!? REEEE!
>>
>>65654850
>So the Navy glances over the FREMM design, point out a few changes they'd like to make,
They wanted to change 80% of the design.
The idea 'we will buy an existing design' is not compatible with 'we will change 80% of an existing design'. You cannot do both.

They fell prey to feature creep idiocy, and THAT is where oversight was required.
And if the USN accepts blank pages as 'documentation', AND pays moeny for them? Well, that might also require some oversight.
>>
File: Hunter midsection.jpg (189 KB, 1800x924)
189 KB JPG
>>65654978
That's probably what Australia will do to replace the 3x Hobart (AWD) with 3-6x Hunter frigates with increased central VLS payload instead of the multi-mission bay.
An anti-sub frigate and air-warfare destroyer with the same hull.
>>
File: HMAS Brisbane.jpg (751 KB, 1800x1038)
751 KB JPG
>>65655022
The Hobarts are our destroyers, our Burke-lites.
>>
>>65655018
>They wanted to change 80% of the design.
No, they wanted to change 15% of the design. The rest started getting changed because they changes they wanted required moving other stuff around, which required moving other stuff around, which then NAVSEA had to point out to the pastaniggers did something bad so it had to be moved around differently, and so on.
>>
>>65655001
It's a fair point, though. What good is an escort that can only defend against a small subset of possible threats? And by the time you have a ship that can defend itself and a couple of nearby ships from sea skimmers, ballistic missiles, drones, and what have you, you've basically got a destroyer, so why build a half measure ship instead of just using your oldest destroyers for that? Then by removing that role from your small surface combatants, you can build three times as many of something a third as expensive and use it to free up destroyers for combat or escort duty.
>>
>>65655035
Deleting the bow sonar (and associated keel bulb) has a massive impact on hull hydrodynamics, so it's absolutely not a "15% change".
>>
>>65655046
It's as simple as deleting the keel bulb and not bothering to reengineer the hydrodynamics.
>>
>>65654676
>could have happened to anyone that puts flammable shit all over their ships
Isn't that how the Hood blew up too
>>
>>65655035
So you're saying they were retards who bought a 'commercial off the shelf' warship, changed the design in 5 easy 15% steps, and then blamed the vendor for their own idiocy.

Because everyone else who bought that design managed to get working warships, but somehow the USN did not.
And instead of unfucking their own design and acquisition process they point at 'pastaniggers' and waste more money.

And they set out to repeat the process with a Korean or Turkish ship.
>>
>>65655080
No, Hood was a magazine hit.
IIRC it was Sheffield that succumbed to fire because the ship more or less melted and burned due to rocket fuel being on fire after a missiel hit.
>>
>>65654676
>Trying to use a 45 year old incident as a gotcha as if gallons of ink weren't spilled on lessons learned for future (now current) design upgrades
Just admit that you have a hate boner for UK stuff. The Falklands gave NATO a masterclass in combat damage control for the missile age and good lessons were implemented and shared with the rest of NATO, although uptake is variable. The Type 45s elevated radome is a very visible indication of that, which not even the US has implemented.
>>
>>65654313
>and probably on the Mogami too, since Japan is the only other country that takes damage control seriously.
What? The Japanese ships are known for having very little damage control, it's a doctrinal point. They believe Chinese missiles would do enough damage to their ships it isn't worth doing.
>>
>>65654042
>Stark
Bruh, they literally had their CIWS systems offline and it was an accident.

And the OHP is damn impressive for it's prize and size. Both the Stark and the Sammy B incidents would have broken lesser ships (and lesser crews)

as far as the frigate is concerned I'm leaning towards Mogami or the F110. Either way the most important thing is to just have the design finalized before a single piece of steel is cut or welded.
>>
>>65655249
Anyone could have told you to not build your ship out of flammable materials with a single source of water for fire fighting long before that happened. A much smaller American ship designed a decade before the sinking of the Sheffield took two hits from the same missile, both of which actually exploded, and didn't burn down. This is not just an oopsie, it's representative of the complete loss of britbong naval tradition since WW2. And that was a ship designed less than 30 years after the end of WW2. Here we are coming up on 50 years since the Falklands and you're going to try and tell me that everything magically reversed direction since then? The bongs barely even have seaworthy ships at all anymore.
>>
>>65654367
>zumwalt more capable than Burke
LMAO. Maybe the on-paper version of the Zumwalt that never existed, but the real life Zumwalt never got it's SPY-4 and has been stuck with a shitty AEGIS at home. Zumwalt shills are pathetic. The ship class was truncated because almost the entire air defense mission couldn't be accomplished by it. People just pretend that Destroyer = Destroyer without appreciating that DD(X) and DD-21 were in fact not DDG programs. It was always a coastal artillery vessel of questionable utility. And it's a shame because individual components that should have been stripped out of that class onto a useful ship to set the standard became stuck on those boats.
>>
>>65655540
>F110
No.. Navantia designed the Helge Ingstad which had serious design defects e.g. its hollow propeller shaft seal which allowed two extra compartments to be flooded, contributing to the loss of the ship.
>>
>>65655540
>They had the system with more incidents of friendly fire than successful intercepts turned off, and therefore the ship is actually immune to missiles
What kind of insane cope is this? The OHP is 0 for 1 in actually defending civilian shipping from missiles. They were only used in that role because it was judged that anyone would have to be insane to fire on an American flagged warship, and the one and only time the flag wasn't a sufficient defense on its own, the OHP failed to do anything but get Americans killed.
>>
>>65655571
>It's the "the USN didn't invest in completing the Zumwalt's software, and therefore it never could have been completed" shill again
If nothing else, they could have ripped out the TSCEI computers and installed Aegis instead.
>>
>>65655564
>both of which actually exploded
One of which*
>>
>>65655571
>Zumwalt is a failure because it never received its SPY-4
>Burke Flight III is a success despite never receiving its AMDR-X
explain this.
>>
>>65654010
What do we need the little boats for when satellites and drones exist?

If a destroyer does everything at baseline. I think a frigate should do ONE thing at an equal baseline.

So ASW for escort only or Surface Warfare or AA
Granted is having three boats cheaper than one? But some missions don't need the full suite of capabilities and just having a worse destroyer isnt cost effective.
>>
>>65655763
>If a destroyer does everything at baseline. I think a frigate should do ONE thing at an equal baseline.
That's more of a corvette, a frigate is a scaled down destroyer.
>>
>>65655763
>What do we need the little boats for when satellites and drones exist?
Neither is (yet) at a point where it can completely obviate the need for warships. Consider that infantry are still very much a requirement of modern land warfare despite the invention of firearms, motorized vehicles, aircraft, or (ironically) satellites/drones.
>>
>>65655763
>So ASW for escort only or Surface Warfare or AA
>Granted is having three boats cheaper than one?
No, it is cheaper to add more capabilities to a single ship than to have capabilities on different hulls. The hull count is to increase the amount of jobs able to be done and survivability. And for these expensive roles being vulnerable to another makes the whole platform not war worthy.
>>
>>65655763
What's required for surface warfare? What's required for anti-air warfare? Is there any overlap in those requirements? If there is, is it more cost effective to build two ships, or one that can do both? Even if it's cheaper to build two ships, how much overhead is involved in making sure each one is where it needs to be, versus every ship being useful wherever you send it?

ASW is something I agree can be done separately by a cheaper ship, since all you really need for it is a helicopter or two and a towed array. But you can fit those things onto a smaller and cheaper ship than any of these mini-destroyers, so why even look at them?
>>
>>65655763
>>65655786
Corvettes don't have enough survivability or endurance for the USN.
Single mission frigates enrage admirals because it makes planning too difficult for them.
Congress will eventually slash and whine multi-mission frigates because American shipbuilding is decrepit and it always leads to expensive and delayed ships that are worse than Burkes.

The compromise is an upgunned cutter that performs an OPV role outside of war zones. Maybe. Enjoy.
>>
>>65655800
ehhhh to be debated
>>65655801
Then just build a DD
>>65655811
Exactly no mean feat, easy to talk
a mark41 is a mark41
>>65655841
>>planning too difficult for them
In peace time perhaps but in this theoretical war i imagine it will be easier everyone knows what the convoy escort does

IDK what the Coast Guard cutter is going to do for the Navy. Navy should focus on warfare not gay ass civie shit
>>
>>65655841
It sounds like they want something with a lot more combat weight than any of the ships on offer in that case.

Makes you wonder why Babcock offered the T31 not something like the Hunter T26 derivative.
>>
>>65655861
>ehhhh to be debated
Then debate it.
>>
>>65653908
Just a reminder that the Korean ship is what is wanted because of the Philly yards but because of procurement laws a dog an pony show is required.
>>
File: whatdidjeffmeanbythis.png (34 KB, 170x218)
34 KB PNG
>>65655896
Drone good
Satellite cheap
https://www.defensenews.com/space/2026/09/15/space-based-isr-launches-to-grow-fourfold-in-next-decade-novaspace-says/
>>
File: bumpmythread.png (493 KB, 652x811)
493 KB PNG
>>65655902
If only it was so simple
>>
>>65655841
>Corvettes don't have enough survivability or endurance for the USN.
Corvettes are typically missile ships, burdened with AShM. They are more useful if you are trying to defend an area, not break into one. I don't think the USN needs corvettes, if you disagree what do you suggest for their role?
>>
>>65655861
>Then just build a DD
The issue this has is each destroyer costs so much it can't have a great coverage. The idea of a frigate is to make smaller cheaper halfway ships which can do the job well enough and be in enough places. A frigate isn't designed to be the top dog when it comes to a pound for pound fight.
>>
>>65655919
fuck huge AShM and B-21
>>65655925
>>The idea
No shit..... but what do you do with a 1/3 DD that costs .999999 of the price?
inb4 some foreign design lets ask what a small SURFACE ship even does

build more LA class and see attached image
>>
>>65655933
>No shit..... but what do you do with a 1/3 DD that costs .999999 of the price?
Have you considered buying a frigate that isn't 0.9 a destroyer? Example Mogami, Type 31, FDI, FREMM, F110, MEKO 200 etc etc
>>
>>65655914
It actually is.
>>
>>65655955
Several of those, being Eurofrigates, are 2/3 a Burke at most of a Burke's price though.
>>
>>65655955
The problem is, burger naval designers can't stop themselves from fucking that chicken, and always slopify an otherwise lean design into an inflation porn parody of what a frigate should actually be.
>>
File: euros_mad_resize.jpg (1.69 MB, 5312x2988)
1.69 MB JPG
>>65655955
Mogami list price is 450 million
oof Arleigh Burke is 2.2 billion

so 4.8 Mogami per AB
1/3 if done by crew

But Mogami uses Jap systems how much to convert?
How much to build here?

lol pic semi related expensive but impressive, Prius might be cheaper but how much can it tow?
>>
>>65654104
>A frigate that's 80% of the cost of a Burke
A Burke class destroyer costs $2.2 billion. The Constellation class frigate, at cancellation, as going to be $1.05 billion after the first ship. That's 47% of the cost for a ship with the same radar as a Burke, meaningful VLS capacity, sonar, and almost half the crew requirements. That sort of ship would be massively useful.
>>
>>65654850
>requires them to go back and make physical modifications to stuff they already built
They never got past the keel on Constellation. You're making shit up and simping for NAVSEA for some reason. NAVSEA literally never finish describing what they wanted and constantly changed requirements on the yard. Most of the "blank documents" were due to the Navy demanding that something be submitted so they could show Congress that "progress" was being made. By their own metrics, a module was 75% done once it was submitted.

The admirals in charge literally went to Congress and perjured themselves to hide how fucked the design process was. You think they lied to help out Fincantieri, or themselves?
>>
>>65655987
A big part of the reason Connies were canceled is because their cost bloated far past $1 billion, and no they don't use the same SPY-6 radar as either Flight III Burkes or the Flight IIA retrofit.
>>
>>65654850
>So the Navy glances over the FREMM design, point out a few changes they'd like to make

85% redesign is not "a few changes", NAVSEA deliberately 'fixed' the Connies until they were broken.
>>
>>65655960
You are telling me of those ships listed none can be made under $0.8 bn? You just want the USN not to have frigates.
>>65655961
If the reason is not that it isn't possible to build a cheap(ish) frigate is due to retardation I'll accept that.
>>65655975
I mean for us to find some sort of understanding what sort of price would you think is worth a frigate with 32 vls cells? As I said before it doesn't need to be more efficient than a Burke but simply allow the USN to be in more places.
>>
>>65656038
>As I said before it doesn't need to be more efficient than a Burke but simply allow the USN to be in more places.
The whole "how much of a Burke is X design worth" is a red herring. The USN needs a design which a) can do more than sink narcoboats and scare people traffickers (not the Navy's job in the first place, there's the USCG for that); b) be considerably cheaper to run than a Burke. Burkes are expensive hulls, especially the older ones (the older the hull, the more often shit breaks down, the costlier to keep running). Readiness rate is a constant problem, some of the really grody ones have equipment readiness rates rivalling the Moskva. They require a lot of crew to run properly, because of low automation (shit starts going sideways if short-handed for any longer period of time).
>>
>>65655841
>>65655919
LCS is a blue water corvette built to USN requirements.
>>
>>65656038
>You are telling me of those ships listed none can be made under $0.8 bn? You just want the USN not to have frigates.

It would do you a huge favor to actually read what you are replying to.
>>
>>65656065
>The whole "how much of a Burke is X design worth" is a red herring.

When the purpose of the frigate is to free up Burkes to be Burkes it is an issue when anons argue the frigate needs to be a slightly less capable Burke.
>>
>>65655987
A Burke class costs $3.5B. Constellation was canceled because the follow-on ships were going to cost $2.5B. Stop basing all of your opinions on what a wiki page says without even reading the sources.
>>
>>65656065
>The USN needs a design which a) can do more than sink narcoboats and scare people traffickers (not the Navy's job in the first place, there's the USCG for that); b) be considerably cheaper to run than a Burke
Ok, but that's not a frigate and the navy wants a frigate. You are talking about a patrol ship, a frigate is a warship designed for war.
>>65656072
I did. Your claim was a number of those frigates were the majority of a Burke's cost. Previously you said 0.9999999 a Burke's cost. Either way my point is that you are being retarded, and on that I am correct. Stop pretending that you can't get cheapish frigates.
>>
>>65656079
>Constellation was canceled because the follow-on ships were going to cost $2.5B
Not him but that was only the first in class, the others were substantially cheaper.
>>
>>65656132
Are you ESL by chance?
>>
>>65656129
>Your claim was a number of those frigates were the majority of a Burke's cost.

And your response was to assert I said all of them were, displaying a clear lack of reading comprehension.
>>
>>65656013
>They never got past the keel on Constellation.
Why would you say something so trivially disproven?

>Most of the "blank documents" were due to the Navy
...using a payment structure that awarded bonuses to the designer for "completing" designs on schedule.

>>65656023
15% redesign is what the Navy requested, 85% is why they canceled it.

>>65656132
The two ships being built are going to cost substantially more than $5B combined. If there was any hope of the follow-on ships being cost effective, the Navy would not have canceled the program.
>>
>>65656168
Picrel
>>
>>65655975
>Quoting the contract price of a previous version of a ship built in a different country and delivered without weapons systems as if it's somehow relevant
>>
>>65656156
No, my response was to >>65655960 which you were complaining about frigates listed. Nowhere in your post did you say x is shit but y would work. It was simply an attack on my point that there are cheap frigate options. There is no lack of reading comprehension, you simply do not want the navy to have frigates.
>>
>>65656197
Do you really not understand the difference between "several of those" and "of those ships listed none can be" or are you just pretending to be retarded?
>>
>>65656169
This is a graphic of 3d modeling progress, it literally says so in the image.
>>
>>65655572
Are you retarded? A 6,000-tonne vessel has literally collided with a 62,000-tonne vessel. What exactly would you expect? How can you expect a ship involved in a collision with a vessel more than ten times its displacement to emerge unscathed?

Blaming the shipbuilder without properly examining the navigational decisions that led to the collision is simply avoiding the real issue. The investigation should focus on whether the vessels complied with COLREGs, particularly the basic requirements for maintaining a proper lookout, assessing collision risk and taking timely and effective avoiding action.

If there was navigational negligence or a failure to understand and apply the most fundamental COLREGs requirements, that must be acknowledged. Blaming the builder to hide crew negligence does fuckall they didn't even close the watertight doors
>>
>>65656214
>Grand modules under construction
>>
>>65656221
>How can you expect a ship involved in a collision with a vessel more than ten times its displacement to emerge unscathed?
No one's expecting it to be unscathed, we're expecting it to still be floating.
>>
>>65654850
>pasta niggers and frogs have their frigates build and in the water
>pasta niggers and frogs have both bid, won and build boats FREMMs for other countries
>but some how it's all the pasta niggers fault and not the USN
>>
>>65656210
I do understand, but you simply do not understand how people speak if you think I've misread. You've criticized by suggestion of ships, without saying any of them are at the price point you are happy with. What you are doing is a tactic in an argument to cherry pick to attack the general concept.
>>
>>65656226
>we're expecting it to still be floating.
Why? That seems a you problem.
>>
>>65656232
>"I didn't make a basic reading comprehension mistake
>>
>>65655919
>Corvettes are typically missile ships
Retard
>>
>>65656226
It would have still been floating, had the crew not fucked off with the quickness, leaving all bulkhead doors open.
>>
>>65656253
No, I didn't. Are you now saying that of those listed ships there are vessels of the correct price point to which you'd consider them a good addition to the USN?
>>
>>65656231
>>65656236
>Why do those silly Americans even want good ships like Stark and Fitzgerald when they could save so much money buying scrap metal like Sheffield and Helge Ingstad?
>>
>>65656266
Why are you comparing ships built 50 years ago to modern ships?
>>
>>65656266
>we want ships build the way we build them!
>let's go buy a design abroad!
inside the US there are two wolves, NAVSEA and congress, both are retarded
>>
>>65656284
I'm comparing a 50 year old ship to another 50 year old ship, and a ship in active service to another ship that would be in active service if it hadn't sunk.
>>
>>65655594
The OHP is 2 for 1 in taking catastrophic damage and limping home. Let's see those other frigates take mines and exocets.
>>65655661
It"s all would've could've should've. Same with the constellation or the LCS. Ships on paper are one thing. Actual ships in the water are another.
>>
>>65656310
Yes, the sane move would have been to build out the Zumwalt and Independence fleets and use the Burkes for escort duty. But somehow we're here looking at foreign garbage again.
>>
>>65656129
>a frigate is a warship designed for second-line conflict and auxillary duty
Fixed
>>
>>65656324
The OHP being able to consistently survive catastrophic damage does not make it effective at protecting other ships.

>Actual ships in the water are another.
This is cope. By this measure we should buy ships from Indonesia or some shit instead of designing ships because their existing dogshit is automatically better than anything we might build in the future.
>>
Can we have a discussion about what the role of a frigate is? Or what even "escort duty" entails? Both strictly in the modern (and near future) sense of course and be sure to specify whether you are approaching it in a general sense or USN particular.
I see so many anons tossing these ideas around and butting head with other anons doing the same and it seems fairly self-evident that they are talking at cross purposes because they are originating from different definitions. Maybe if we hammer these out we can have a more constructive thread on frigates? I know, I know, I'm a silly-billy.
>>
>>65656350
Apparently a frigate is 4/5s of a destroyer and escort duty involves intercepting missiles with your ship and then hopefully not sinking.
>>
It's best to just buy the Type 31 off the brits.

>uses NSMs
>has NATO compliant damage control
>elvated radome
>UK is a trusted safe ally (not in a dangerous theater like Japan/korea)
>UK shipyards/designs are made English first, the systems are all in English, no translations required
>US government has an excess of UK currency to burn
>32 Mk41 VLS cells
>90~ crew
>60 marines
>>
>>65656381
>UK is a trusted safe ally (not in a dangerous theater like Japan/korea)
Why would that matter? The ships will be built in the US regardless.
>>
>>65656315
Yes, you are comparing a ship 50 years old to a modern one. Why?
>>
>>65656385
won't the initial group of ships have parts and software sourced from the home nation to speed up production?
If Japan goes to war with China, It would have affect US frigate production, no?
>>
>>65656350
I'd say the ability to defend itself and others without being the high end option. Due to that I'd say it requires a sonar and a small AAW suite.
>>
>>65656381
Add a towed array and I'd be happy.
>>
>>65656400
The idea of Trump's "Finland model" bullshit is that the same shipyard that builds the ship normally will build the first two of the American variant and then production will move to an American shipyard. If Japan were to go to war with China, the US would go to war with China as well, and all major combat operations would be over by the time the first ships were to be delivered anyway. At that point we'll have another end of history situation and Congress will cancel all military spending so it doesn't matter.
>>
>>65656417
That makes sense
I didn't mention it, but the 'trusted' part was meant to exclude Turkey.
Reason being it's an embarrassment for the US navy to rely on fucking Turkey.
>>
>>65656315
>>65656266
Sheffield was still floating 5 days after it got hit and only sank under tow due to heavy seas in the south fucking atlantic before they could patch weld the hole. Stark was in the placid Persian Gulf and immediately got towed to Bahrain, stop being a disingenuous nigger.
>>
>>65656409
What sorts of threats will it have to defend against?
>>
>>65656350
>Contain air threats in a region with VLS, be that missiles or jets.
>A gun to sink civilian/unarmored ships
>Ability to house a crew of marines for naval boarding
>Ability to rescue crew/civilians from a sinking ship

It's nice to have some missiles to sink other warships, but it shouldn't ever be put in that situation doctrine wise. It should blockade enemy civilian ships and planes around itself. Be that by a coastline, a strait or a carrier fleet.

In a China-US, US frigates should be in the middle east, arresting chinese tankers, cutting off Chinese supply lines. Frigates do this, so more Burkes are in the pacific fighting chinese warships.
>>
>>65656432
AShM, drones, subs. Not that it should be invincible, but tough enough that if you want to sink it you'd be starting a war.
>>
>>65656381
>It's best to just buy the Type 31 off the brits.

Where would it be built.
>>
>>65656453
>In a China-US, US frigates should be in the middle east
Disagree, frigates have a role in US-China conflict. They would have VLS cells enough to be useful and to bulk out defenses and to be on the outer layer of the screen and be detachable.
>>
>>65656461
A good 80% of the surface fleet should be in the pacific in that situation, but it's the frigates you can go without, not the Burkes or Fords.
>>
>>65656467
I don't think you'd spare any ships with VLS outside of key zones in the conflict. How does leaving frigates in the middle east helps you win the war?
>>
>>65656473
If there's a China-US war, China's gonna fund Iran to block the strait again.
The US would want forces there in the conflict. Not major forces, but enough to protect US and allied shipping, while blocking chinese shipping. Arguably, the US could forego protecting the region, and hand off the duty to the Euros, but if the US had to do it, it'd be cheapest/easiest to use a few frigates.
Ideally, there should be more frigates than active Burkes, as well, so ideally there'd be 80+ frigates in the Pacific, and like 5 or so in the middle East, with allies, and in other strategic regions globally.

Of course you'd want all the VLS you can get in the hotzone, but other regions need sustained ASW and VLS presence in such a war.
>>
>>65656495
I say these numbers, fully aware that in such a war with china, the US would have less than 30 frigate available, and that's a consistant failure of the US government and Navy.
>>
File: NSM ship.jpg (89 KB, 1013x680)
89 KB JPG
>>65656453
I would think a 4-canister deck launcher for NSM would be bare minimum, probably x2. Very doable on both LCS, ANZAC and most other older smaller frigates.
>>
>>65656495
What would that achieve in this scenario? Higher oil costs? It doesn't stop the transit of US vessels. But assuming I'm wrong and missing something, there would be a decent chance of a US boots within Iran at that point. The war would be at such a scale then it would be on the cards without any real opposition.
Assuming the middle east isn't active in the war then I would assume Europe to pick up the slack.
>>
>>65656507
I think 8 NSMs should be on a frigate, but it's not required for a frigate to be a frigate.
And I think the definitional requirement is what Anon was asking for.
It's like ASW capabilities, you definitely want frigates capable of ASW, but not every frigate needs it. You can frigates without, and some that can do ASW.
>>
>>65656513
>It doesn't stop the transit of US vessels.
To the regions of the war I mean.
>>
>>65656516
>It's like ASW capabilities, you definitely want frigates capable of ASW, but not every frigate needs it. You can frigates without, and some that can do ASW.
Would they not the primary tools for ASW? They are cheaper than a destroyer and will disperse your detection net.
>>
>>65656455
Does this include both sea skimming and ballistic AShMs?
>>
>>65654676
Like I said, it's 2026.

>>65655564
>Here we are coming up on 50 years since the Falklands and you're going to try and tell me that everything magically reversed direction since then?
The problem was cheaping out and building out of aluminium and various other deficiencies that have since been corrected in both the RN and USN. Mind you, the USN built the LCS, a class prominently made out of aluminium. Level whatever criticism you have of the past RN, but it will never changed the fact the current USN has aluminium ships.
>naval tradition
This is irrelevant to doctrine within shipbuilding.

What's your point? Do you want to compare ships of the line next? Or the Invincible class battlecruisers of WW1? This is ridiculous.
>>
>>65656513
>>65656519
It's just another theater to force the US to focus on and divert attention away, and the Chinese view US citizens as fickle and anti-war, so high oil prices would destabilise the US in the eyes of China. China knows that Americans don't want to die over Taiwan. Japan maybe, but not Taiwan.

>>65656527
Yes, they are. However, if you have a large fleet of frigates, not all are required to be ASW capable. It's better to have a specialise ASW vessel.
To use the Royal Navy for comparison, they have 5 Type 31 frigates that are general purpose. They have 8 Type 26 frigates that are ASW specialised. Both are brand new 2020s era Frigates.
>>
>>65656539
Sea skimming definitely yes, ballistics are less of a requirement. I'd err towards no or low capabilities to defend against them.
>>
>>65656557
>It's just another theater to force the US to focus on and divert attention away
But what would they do that requires that level of focus when this big one is going down between two superpowers?
>so high oil prices would destabilise the US in the eyes of China
Considering the scale of the war I think that is quite unlikely to cause destabilisation. Bigger thing would be the multi-ethnic nation trying to conscript troops.

>To use the Royal Navy for comparison, they have 5 Type 31 frigates that are general purpose
>General purpose
>No sonar
Its a cost cutting driven error on their part, that's all, not something doctrinal.
>>
>>65656581
Then why is the Type 31 being considered over the Type 26?
Also, the US should cut costs and complexity when they can, the Navy needs ships, not great ships, but functioning operational ships.
>>
>>65656589
>Then why is the Type 31 being considered over the Type 26?
Cheaper. If they went for it a towed array would be added, there is space left for it. A towed array is in the 10s of millions, on a vessel this expensive its worth it. I would bet on anything that by the end of their service life they will have received a towed array.
>>
>>65656589
Type 26 is too expensive and doesn't have enough spare buoyancy for future expansion.
>>
>>65655001
LCS can't even defeat coastal batteries from the 40s though, let alone missiles or drones (which can strike from up to 40 miles off their launch point), which is a bit of an issue when it's meant to operate within shallow waters, e.g. the range in which those systems can tag it.
>"Just don't approach the coast"
Okay I guess they have to dip from escorting shipping whenever it takes a route in sight of land.
Like Hormuz.
>>
>>65653908
lmao not again
>>
>>65656409
>the ability to defend itself and others
Defend from what? If you say "everything" then you are just doing the same dipshit over again.
>and others
How close and vulnerable are these others?
>>
This debate over ships is all well and good but without considering where they will be built you are only having a surface level discussion.
>>
>>65656592
The USN has the budget depth to turn the Type31 into a truly formidable GP frigate. For the RN the baseline cost is around £300m per unit, the USN can absolutely add an extra 200m - 300m for upgrades to bring the frigate into potency. Probably talking $800m per unit, but can probably go lower if the USN orders a decent. amount.

As for the RN, I would expect a towed array to be added to be added at some point in the future, probably towards the end of the 2030s. Still not good, but I do expect it to happen. Just wish the MoD would press the treasury to release more funds to order more.
>>
>>65656611
*some grammar errors here, do forgive me
>>
>>65656607
>Defend from what? If you say "everything" then you are just doing the same dipshit over again.
Every kind of threat, but to the low end of the sort. There should be no general weaknesses apart from high end attacks or scale.
>>
>>65656611
I really don't think it'd cost that much to improve it. And there will never be enough money while ngubu and abdul gets gibs, and boomers have massive pensions. They care more about fraying internal stability than any military threat.
>>
>>65656542
>the USN built the LCS, a class prominently made out of aluminium
Aluminum construction has come a long way since those day. This is just typical armchair admiral/dockmaster rhetoric that makes it abundantly clear you have no idea what you are talking about.
>>
>>65656542
Sheffield was not built out of aluminum.
>>
>>65656603
>a ship can't perform the mission it wasn't designed to do
Shocker
>>
>>65656608
Mobile, Alabama
Austal
Independence-class
>>
>>65656618
>my frigates need to be able to conduct ASuW, ASW, AAW, BMD, MIW, EW, and land attack
May I introduce you to the Constellation program?
>>
>>65656640
I've fallen victim to the myth! Good to be corrected

>>65656639
And yet any ship intended for intensive combat is steel

>>65656625
It wouldn't cost much at all. Various upgrades like converting one QE class to a catapult and upgrading and acquiring more T31s would probably fit into the foreign aid budget.
>>
>>65656652
Most frigates can do all these apart from BMD and MIW. And I was not speaking about them, BMD is higher end and MIW is too low end for a frigate.
>>
>>65656660
>It wouldn't cost much at all.
There's a lot of money in the system, defence is just not important to them. The third biggest item it debt interest.
https://wheredoesitallgo.org/
>>
>>65656660
The LCS is not intended for "intensive combat," CongressBoomer-anon.
>>
>>65656664
Do you see how I asked what you specifically meant and said don't say everything? And then you went and literally said everything? And then are surprised when I assumed you meant everything?

>Most frigates can do all these apart from BMD and MIW
You're overstating, you don't need to do this.
>>
>>65656669
Boomers are bleeding the West dry. Both directly and by insisting on mass immigration because they are convinced it will allow them to maintain/expand their lifestyles.
>>
>>65656676
>Do you see how I asked what you specifically meant and said don't say everything?
It was meant within reason, I didnt mean fly but that fits within everything. Be sensible.

>you don't need to do this.
Do what in particular? What is not needed?
>>
>>65656682
I'm going to redirect you to the original post. "You know what I mean" vibes aren't going to cut it. Until you can be an adult, we don't have anything else to discuss. >>65656350
>>
>>65656685
>I am going to be pedantic
K, have fun.
>>
>>65656672
You have to assume that eventually all your naval assets are going to enter an intensive combat area

>>65656669
Yeah it's a travesty, something like £20 - 30billion is doable for the gov but it would require reducing welfare and pension support.
>>
>don't look at the journalist's twitter
>>
>>65656688
>intensive combat area
Just fuck off and die. Go back to wherever you came from, you don't belong on /k/.
>>
>>65656611
>The USN has the budget depth to

If your argument is dependent on "the USN' has infinity money" then you are just a fool.
>>
>>65656694
Fuck off tourist
>>
>>65656648
>yard being bought by Hanwha

Yes the korean ship is the most likely.
>>
>>65656698
That's not the point at all, the USN has a bigger budget depth than the RN. So much so they can afford to spend the needed money to make the frigate into something worthwhile.
>>
>>65656708
And they'll have made 6 'worthwhile' frigates by the time they need over 50.
>>
>>65656716
Jesus Christ
>>
>>65656708
bigger budget doesn't mean unlimited budget
we've also seen how "just making a few improvements" sank the constellation/FREMM program
>>
>>65656723
I'm talking about basic improvements from the RN's, towed array sonar, more MK41cells and a better radar. That's it. Very affordable for the USN. The USN budgets is what over $350b? The RN's is around £20 - 30b. Significantly more leg room.
>>
>>65656704
Yes, it was already clear this was your take given how you were so strongly prioritizing "build location."
>>
>>65656729
>just add a bunch of things that drastically affect the basic design of the ship
>couldn't be easier!
nta
>>
>>65656733
>just add a bunch of things that drastically affect the basic design of the ship
nta but apart from the VLS cells, that should all be easy. There is plenty of space for it, the ship is designed to be configurable.
>>
>>65656732
My take is more to do with anons deluding themselves into thinking ships like FREMM EVO or Type 31 have even a remote chance.
>>
>>65656744
Adding a towed array requires significant calibration and test and usually moderate changes to internals and minor changes to the hull.
Adding a "better" radar usually involves adding a lot of reinforcement to the mast and beefed out cooling and power delivery solutions, which has plenty of knock on effects.
Adding VLS after the fact when its not FFBNW is perhaps the largest alteration a modern ship designer can consider.
You don't know what you are talking about.
>>
>>65656645
>The littoral combat ship is not in fact, meant to engage in combat within littoral waters
Should had just called it a lightly-armed minesweeper since that's what it's actually being used for
>>
>>65656744
>that should all be easy
I'm so tired of tourists who rocking up with all of their "expertise" derived from video games and have no idea how things work in the real world
>>65656769
Breath of fresh air
>>65656760
FREMM Evolved is a longshot for a variety of reasons but I don't think the Arrowhead is completely out of the race
>>
>>65656782
>Dunning-Kruger Effect
>This cognitive bias happens when a person with low knowledge in an area overestimates their understanding. Because they lack deeper context, they rely on simple, surface-level clues to feel confident in a strong opinion.
>rely on simple, surface-level clues
Really jogs the noggin'.

Btw you should check the definition of littoral
>>
>>65656769
Retard 1
>>65656784
Retard 2
>>
>>65656769
>Adding a towed array requires significant calibration and test and usually moderate changes to internals and minor changes to the hull.
>Adding a "better" radar usually involves adding a lot of reinforcement to the mast and beefed out cooling and power delivery solutions, which has plenty of knock on effects.
Sorry, but it seems you do not know the class. There is space allocated for a towed array which is not occupied and the mast is rated for larger radars. That is the sales pitch behind the ship, you can change it to your specification.
>>
File: Littoral_Zones.jpg (35 KB, 666x292)
35 KB JPG
>>65656794
>"For the purposes of naval operations, the US Navy divides the littoral zone in the ways shown on the diagram at the top of this article."
>About 60 meters from shore
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Littoral_zone

That isn't even a mile's clearance. You will never see a LCS operating this close to shore.
>>
>>65656815
>>65656769
Here's a sales video.
https://youtu.be/0y-Wfvhks7Y?si=WkeAoXQ6u5R4PMg1
>>
>>65656816
>About 60 meters from shore
Thank you for demonstrating so confidently how much of an absolute complete retard you are.
Simply brilliant.
>>
>>65656815
>>65656822
Whilst these are good replies, these two anons
>>65656769
>>65656784
Think they know better than Babcock
>>
>>65656815
>>65656822
The Polish variant had to make substantial alteration to the stern for a towed array and do significant redesigns to the mast + power/cooling.
>>
>>65656872
So it's already been done, why are you making a fuss then?
>>
>>65656816
That's the depth you moron.
The entire point of the Independence's design is that it uses stealth to close the distance and secure the first strike under littoral conditions to make up for shortcomings in active defense. The Freedom class is/was a jobs program that has done irreparable damage to the LCS's perception and on the way to being retired for coming out of the shipyard obsolete.

Multiple ships in the Independence class are currently deployed in Hormuz and are doing FINE. The chances of Iranian sensors picking one up and firing on it before it completes its mission are negligible. If it were to be pulled into escort role for whatever reason instead of clearing mines, it would have a smaller signature than the cargo vessels it escorted unlikely to get disabled before it reported the attack.
>>
>>65656816
>About 60 meters from shore
dude... that graphic says it's 60m from the seafloor
>>
>>65656881
I doubt the equipment Poland affixed (and did the alterations for) will be the same as the ones the USN would choose.
>>
For the Type 31 bros, their American bid would use spy-7

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uwzcS2DbC-w
>>
>>65656872
From what I remember that's not true, do you have a source that the ship's hull had to be seriously altered?
>>
>>65656902
>Let's not get carried away. A lot of hurdles to go through
Do you even critically look at the things you yourself post?
>>
>>65656902
They mention towed array and bow sonar multiple times.
>>
>LCS bad because it can't function as a coastal assault ship
>The solution is to replace it with a repainted coastguard cutter that hasn't been meaningfully improved since the days the Iowas were still in service
>>
>>65656901
Picking at hairs here
>>
The truth is that admitting the Independence is a success would mean admitting that shitcanning the Zumwalts built on the same technology for more Burkes was a Godawfully bad idea.
>>
>>65656918
>do you have a source that the ship's hull had to be seriously altered?
Not one I care to find again. It was original reporting from a Polish source and I honestly don't know how I'd easily track it down.
>From what I remember that's not true
And what source is it that you are remembering?

>>65656936
(You) asked the question. Its pertinent to the point I raised. I have no idea what you expected. Maybe you could present something yourself that backs your stance rather than just grilling me on mine?
>>
>>65656940
>The truth is that admitting the Independence is a success
Its a pile of expensive shit
>>
>>65656940
>the Zumwalts built on the same technology
What?
What is this new shit where people are always trying to link the LCS and Zumwalt?
>>
>>65656947
>And what source is it that you are remembering?
I don't have one to hand, but the whole ship is sold on being configurable and the dimensions are the same. I think it is safer to assume it is the case considering everything else than not.
>>
>>65656954
>I don't have one to hand
Okay.
>>
>>65656967
Cool.
>>
>>65656947
i wasn't the nta
>>
>>65656951
They both got the dorito angles from Sea Shadow to reduce their radar profiles.
>>
>>65657003
You think that because Zumwalt and one half of the LCS both feature low-observable features that they both are derivative of the Sea Shadow...and that they both received so much Congressional pushback as some sort of indirect result of this? Am I following you correctly?
>>
>>65657049
I'm not the fag who made that claim, but from their original doctrines it's clear that both of them rely on reducing their detectability to effectively perform their roles.
>>
>>65656951
>What is this new shit where people are always trying to link the F-35 and F-22
>>
>>65657064
Terrible example.
>>
>>65657064
More like the YF-23 and X-32.
>>
>>65656639
And it's completely pointless unless you need the ship to be retardely lightweight to meet arbitrary speed requirements.
>>
>>65657374
Its not like making it out of steel would improve its survivability; LCS is meant to get into killing range through stealth, fire its payload, and withdraw before reinforcements tag it. Speed is very much a necessary consideration if you want to actually use it in combat instead of treating it like an overarmed auxiliary ship.
>>
>>65657385
>LCS is meant to get into killing range through stealth
It isn't meant to get within killing ramge
>>
>>65656231
>>65655018
>They wanted to change 80% of the design.
>The idea 'we will buy an existing design' is not compatible with 'we will change 80% of an existing design'. You cannot do both.

This is literally "retarded faggot, the client", it happens in all industries.
>>
>>65657374
There are plenty of other advantages:
>better agility
>almost no corrosion
>cheaper maintenance and fabrication
>no magnetic signature
>cold weather resistance
>heavier radars or same radar mounted higher
>longer range
>shallower draft
>better sea keeping
>most displacement available for weapon systems or munitions
And, I know you are going to love this one
>greater scrap value
Don't get me wrong, I get what you are saying (steel is a more durable construction material), but lets not pretend like aluminum doesn't have serious benefits of its own.

>>65657406
It is meant to enage in medium intensity combat enviroments and that absolutely includes such scenarios as ambushing a hostile warship.
>>
>The Chinese military sees the Littoral Combat Ship armed with anti-ship missiles as a key element of a U.S. distributed maritime force in the Western Pacific, according to a translation of a 2020 Chinese government research paper on the U.S. Navy’s distributed lethality concept
>Chinese researchers “compared the littoral combat ship (LCS) with other surface combatants, arguing that the former’s modularity, cheap price, high speed, and other characteristics enable it to become a powerful tool in future distributed lethality tactics,” reads the “The U.S. Navy’s Distributed Lethality Implementation Method” paper from the Marine Design & Research Institute of China (MARIC). MARIC is the central research and development arm for China’s shipbuilding sector.
>While the ships were operating in the South China Sea, the LCS drew three People’s Liberation Army Navy (PLAN) ships to monitor their operations, while an Arleigh Burke guided-missile destroyer typically draws a single Chinese warship to tail it
>Beyond the LCS, the paper acknowledged that more U.S. surface ships with more anti-ship missiles operating in small surface action groups, rather than larger formations like carrier strike groups or amphibious expeditionary strike groups, would complicate Chinese operations in the Pacific.
https://news.usni.org/2021/08/11/chinese-see-u-s-littoral-combat-ship-as-powerful-tool-in-future-distributed-conflicts
>>
>>65657498
Aluminum is more likely to develop stress cracks over time (this basically condemned the Ticos due to their alu superstructure), welding alu is still dodgier compared to steel (despite tech improvements), general usable lifespan is overall shorter due to said higher fatigue coefficient, and alu is combustible under the (in)correct conditions. Also, there's the constant risk of galvanic corrosion when different metals are in contact (mitigated with gaskets, but those degrade over time, another issue with steel-alu mixed ships).
>>
>>65657544
>Don't get me wrong, I get what you are saying (steel is a more durable construction material), but lets not pretend like aluminum doesn't have serious benefits of its own.
>>
>>65657548
The advantages of alu are better suited to civvie marine construction, rather than military.
>>
>>65656729
The Ford and Columbia classes are soaking up most of the ship-building budget for the next few years. This decade was always gonna be tight on spare funding, and NAVSEA should have known that.
>>
>>65657544
>Aluminum is more likely to develop stress cracks over time (this basically condemned the Ticos due to their alu superstructure)
This was more an issue of the hybrid design than of the aluminum as a material of itself.
>welding alu is still dodgier compared to steel (despite tech improvements)
This is only true of traditional welding techniques. Friction-stir welding is actually significantly cheaper and was what was used on the Independence. Besides, given the far easier ability to fabricate with aluminum they are able to avoid having to do a lot of the welding you have to do with steel construction. This is sort of a toss up and as you pointed out, aluminum techniques are only getting better.
>general usable lifespan is overall shorter due to said higher fatigue coefficient
This is really only an issue in heavier ship types and thankfully we are talking about a corvette equivalent.
>and alu is combustible under the (in)correct conditions.
No it doesn't. Are you fucking retarded?
>Also, there's the constant risk of galvanic corrosion when different metals are in contact (mitigated with gaskets, but those degrade over time, another issue with steel-alu mixed ships).
No one is talking about hybrid material designs but you. But if we really need to then the gaskets last a decade or two (and exist on all-steel ships) and you don't account for the use of Detacouple and the like.

>>65657553
Wrong. But you're free to actually show something with authority that demonstrates that rather than just blindly claiming things that are demonstrably false.
>>
>>65657553
Cheaper maintenance, better manuevarability and draft, better fuel economy, and MORE RADAR/MISSILES are "better suited to civvie marine construction, rather than military" to you?
Coming into a thread and refusing to engage with the people who are directly raising counterpoints to you is certainly a style.
Please try and actually address what people are saying to you rather then just continuing to circuitously repeat your same perspectives/claims over and over.
>>
>>65657406
The SUW module disagrees.
>>
The fundamental reason these procurement and design programs keep failing is because surface ships are no longer viable for combat, only for police actions on failed states and non state actors.
Every procurement program goes through the same stages in which the requirements are put on paper, every option taken into consideration either fails to meet them or asks for an unrealistic price. The design process then spins in circles because it has to do another round of discussion every time someone asks what happens when the enemy launches an anti ship missile at it because the answer is that it gets shit on and dies.
The Chinks might be able to get some use of theirs by staying at home under the protection of their own missile forces and fucking around no further than the island chains, but expeditionary naval warfare is a thing of the past.
>>
>>65653939
>starts a project
>selects an already matured platform
>decides the platform is big enough
>changes it at be 7 meter shorter
>the design is now completely thrown out cause the changes being made basicly means a new ship
>nobody pays for such a thing
>decides to cancel it
>chooses a shit ass domestic design
>says nothing for 7 months
>now back on choosing from international companies
>gets fremm back on the list
>>
>>65657498
>It is meant to enage in medium intensity combat enviroments and that absolutely includes such scenarios as ambushing a hostile warship
Medium intensity warfare has increased lethality due to drones. It's defences arent capable of allowing it to perform in that environment.
>>65657616
>Hellfires will allow us the take this $400 million vessel into contested environment
>>
>>65657829
The problem isn't Hellfires, it's ammo capacity. Two 4x racks don't really offer great staying power.
>>
>>65657862
The problem is that a modern medium intensity environment is vastly more lethal and the LCS is not able to operate within it.
>>
>>65657616
The SUW module is designed to fight speedboat swarms, not warships. The idea was that it could be used to support a Zumwalt in the Persian Gulf, but there aren't any there and a Burke is too big of a target for coastal missiles so it's dangerous for them to operate there regardless of whether they have defenses against speedboats and USVs.
>>
>>65657829
But that's literally what its designed to do.
Why do you keep saying things that are clearly wrong but expect me believe any of it?
>>
>>65658013
>But that's literally what its designed to do
It was designed for a mission that no longer exists. The mission requirement of the vessel was poor. If it was still suitable the LCS classes would have been at the front of the Iran war rather than retreating.
>>
>>65658125
The medium intensity warfare is still there. The main issue is that the lethality window has gone way up, compared to 12 years ago.
>>
>>65658136
>The medium intensity warfare is still there
Yes, and lethality has increased in medium threat environments, making the vessel unable to perform its function.
>>
>>65658151
I'd say the bigger issue is that there's no easy (or even difficult, for that matter) way to improve meaningful firepower for the existing ships. There isn't a lot of room to install APWKS/Coyote launchers, AA autocannons, or other such cheap anti-drone weapons.
>>
>>65658136
>>65658151
This is why nothing less than a destroyer belongs anywhere near the Persian Gulf, and why the retards imagining a fleet of frigates opening the Strait of Hormuz are wrong. There's still a role for cheap shitty boats to do low intensity stuff elsewhere, freeing destroyers for the actual fighting. There's no role for a mid-size combatant in a war zone.
>>
>>65658174
What if I told you the LCS was designed from the beginning to mount a pair of autocannons, and that was the very first mission module to be completed?
>>
>>65658174
>I'd say the bigger issue is that there's no easy (or even difficult, for that matter) way to improve meaningful firepower for the existing ships
The ships are shit, that's my point, they were built for an environment that does not exist.
>>65658210
A frigate can easily belong there with destroyers. What would it lack? And why would you send destroyers in a low intensity zone when you've got a war going on? You'd say to naval command I get you'd love this Burke but we really need it to patrol the Mediterranean because we usually do that?
>>
>>65658237
Jesus Christ anon, do you really think we have 70 Burkes in the Arabian Sea right now?
>>
>>65656381
>>UK is a trusted safe ally (not in a dangerous theater like Japan/korea)
>Sand niggers try to bomb US/UK base
>UK lets them out on bail the next day
>US forced to evacuate bomber fleet from UK
Very safe theater
>>
>>65658249
I did not say that, I said that the frigates belong there with the destroyer. Not that I'd sail 70 frigates down the straight. It was a rejection of the idea that medium cost warships are useless in high intensity zones.
>>
>>65658304
What you said was
>You'd say to naval command I get you'd love this Burke but we really need it to patrol the Mediterranean because we usually do that?
And that is literally, exactly what's going right now. What's USS Paul Ignatius up to at this moment?
>>
File: Safran-NGDS-HK-Rockets.jpg (58 KB, 1593x1200)
58 KB JPG
>>65658233
I know they had provision for a pair of Bushmasters (some of the older photos have them installed), but those are oldtech: they're chainguns, instead of revolver cannon, they lack AHEAD rounds (or equivalent), they don't even have independent targeting optronics (like modern RWS).

And, besides, autocannons on their own are insufficient. You need a podded APKWS (or other cheap guided missile) with decent magazine capacity, like the Safran NGDS, or Naval Group Rampart.
>>
File: lmp2.png (1.94 MB, 1920x1080)
1.94 MB PNG
>>65658379
>>
File: tcg istanbul.webm (3.66 MB, 1280x720)
3.66 MB
3.66 MB WEBM
İstif class is pure sex
>>
>>65658379
>some of the older photos have them installed
It's part of the SuW package guns module, so they're just on a few of Freedoms now. No AHEAD ammo, but the main gun does have ALaMO.
>>
>>65658379
There are both prox and programmable airburst rounds for the 30mm Bushmasters.

And there are also swimmer APFSDS.
>>
It's really incredible how much of a disaster the LCS classes are.
>>
>>65657862
Would 24 hellfire be enough? 32?>>65657882
It is capable, you just don’t know what that looks like and keep wanting it to be the tip of the spear
>>65658125
See above
>>
>65658705
(you)
>>
>>65654313
bro you lost a whole LHD in port because a sailor accidentally set some trash on fire
By the Navy's own assessment the crew were "unprepared" and training was "deficient" so don't pretend the US Navy in 2020s is shit hot on damage control.
It's a shadow of what it was at the end of the cold war for the same reasons the Royal Navy was in the 1980s
>>
>>65656381
>UK is a trusted safe ally (not in a dangerous theater like Japan/korea)
rofl, lmao even
>>
>>65658732
>It is capable
Capable in what scenario? At what price point? What are you wanting shipborne hellfires for?
>>
File: millennium.jpg (7 KB, 273x184)
7 KB JPG
>>65658379
I'd rather the 35mm Millennium Gun which is already deployed with several navies
>>
File: Unamused Charles.jpg (82 KB, 800x450)
82 KB JPG
>>65653920
>FREMM
>>
>>65654622
>ship :(
>ship, japan :)
>>
>>65658822
Brown seethe is always entertaining.
>>
>>65658942
Its never happening. People talk about the political backlash from trying to restart an LCS line don't have any idea how crazy it can get with the literal Constellation 2.0.
>>
>>65658822
Seems you're right, it was a Wasp-class that had its fire suppression systems disabled due to undergoing maintenance, which proved rather unwise in the event.
>>
>>65659779
Honestly, they should just develop their own ship again. Something between an LCS and an ESB, not completely unarmed and slow as a pig, but also not ridiculously fast and built to warship survivability standards. There is totally room to build a large, cheap, moderately fast (25-30 kt) ship that can serve as a helicopter and drone mothership to do anything that needs doing anywhere there won't be missiles flying. If there are missiles flying, we have 75 Burkes to handle it. If we really, truly need ships to be convoy escorts in the Pacific for a war with China, we can just slep the Flight Is and use them for that. They'll be capable enough there without modernization, and they won't see nearly as hard use as they are currently.
>>
>>65658931
It's not an either/or. They're complementary. A 35 mm has roughly 2.5-3 km usable range. An APKWS (or equivalent) has about 6.
>>
>>65658210
I mean, wasn't it Iran themselves that ran a frigate-heavy, speedboat-heavy navy only to get squashed by the USAF and USN in a matter of days? It's no wonder the US has cold feet when Iran lost the equivalent of multiple destroyers of tonnage with nothing to show for it.
>>
>>65653908
now 7

https://www.navalnews.com/event-news/euronaval-2026/2026/11/rheinmetall-pitches-gmf-140-frigate-us-navy-nato/
https://youtu.be/Bxl7j-OLQ4A
>>
>>65661251
>Aegis
>64 VLS
>SuW
>ASW
>AAW
>BMD
WHY? This is a fucking destroyer.
>>
>>65654427
>who can see who first
>who can reach who first
>who can hit who first
This is all that matters, if a corvette can detect, fire on and penetrate the destroyers AD without being detected, ranged on or it's AShM intercepted then that is all that matters
>>
>>65661641
Only thing I can think of is they're just giving up on the idea of a small, cheap ship entirely and trying to replace the ~$3B Burke with a $1.5B mini-destroyer. I guess it makes sense to buy a less complex destroyer with Burke production falling below replacement level soon.
>>
>>65657544
>>65657498
It's a mixed bag to be honest.
I don't think aluminum is combustible to the point where it would affect a ship, but it melts at half the temperature of steel and loses significant strength at ~150 degrees C.
Having said that I'm still pissed that the HMS Sheffield article has one sentence on this and the sources debunking the aluminum fire issue is a glossy advert from Austal and a paper from fucking Alcoa. But it's wikipedia so I shouldn't expect better.

As far as corrosion is concerned you're correct that you get that oxide layer but you still end up with the same amount of maintenance because constant checking for pitting or crevice corrosion. You still end up with magnetism due to the cathodic protection (not that signature matters with the LCS waterjets), the heatsink properties make insulation and condensation an issue and even though it doesn't get brittle like steel does, steel starts the cold weather test with 3x the stiffness.

I will concede there's reasons to use aluminum beyond the weight saving and speed requirements.

>>65658732
The LCS was supposed to be the tip of the spear. It's all devolved from the original concept of an expendable, low crew ship that goes into the fray and takes the casualties that would be unacceptable for a big ship. But the Navy couldn't accept that so more and more stuff got bolted on the LCS until we ended up with a ship that is too costly to lose. And arguably outdated as droneboats can take over the OG mission the LCS was supposed to do.

>>65661641
germans call their destroyers frigates for PC reasons.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.