[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/k/ - Weapons

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


I just got a subcompact 9mm pistol with a 3 inch barrel and was looking around for some carry ammo. I can't help but notice that most JHP ammo is like 4x the price of FMJ and it got me thinking. Is it even worth it? A bit of advice from the late Paul Harel (R.I.P.) that I have kind of come to agree with is that generally you should train with what you carry. There is also the fact that the pistol in question only has a 3 inch barrel, meaning expansion may be questionable with some ammo and I am not sure if it is rated for +P ammo (Its a PX4 subcompact). So honestly is JHP worth the asking price over FMJ?
>>
yeah
>>
>>65654389
not really. the nickel plated cases that many jhps come with are nice for long term corrosion resistance. you might see the absurd argument that you want the bullet to expand so it doesn't go through a bad guy and hit a not bad guy but that's never gonna happen.
>>
I carry FMJ and don't worry about it for two reasons. First is my pocket carrys are .25 ACP and 9x18 so JHPs are kinda dumb. Second is my primary carry is a g19 with a 15 round and 2 27 rnd magazines. With 70 rounds I doubt that JHP or FMJ is going to make a difference so I just use my training ammo, the same rules really apply to any compact or fullsize 9mm, one standard cap mag holds enough rounds to end the threat, you're not getting into an extended gunfight.
>>
>>65654426
>you might see the absurd argument that you want the bullet to expand so it doesn't go through a bad guy and hit a not bad guy but that's never gonna happen.
That literally happened all the time. You can look up NYT articles from the '90s, when the NYPD was one of the last police agencies in the US to switch to hollowpoints, which provided statistics for how many bystanders and cops the NYPD shot thru other people each year.
>>
>>65654389
If you're going to go with FMJ, you might as well return your 9mm and get a .380 instead. It'll be softer shooting if it's not a simple blowback piece of shit, and .380 will poke the same size hole through a guy.
>>
>>65654522
it's not the 90s and I don't live in NYC and im not a cop
>>
>>65654553
Hollowpoints can also protect the shelf of anime girl figurines behind the prostitute you're murdering in your remote cabin inna woods.
>>
File: HG81VYAbsAECJZ4.jpg (85 KB, 1179x988)
85 KB JPG
>>65654522
>heres a small data set, from a biased source, from 40 years ago
nah
>>
>>65654571
>anime girl figurines
I have funko pops actually
>>
>>65654389
I got the Hornady low recoil pink ribbon JHPs for my wife but now she shoots +P better than me. Sometimes I EDC the pink ones myself on days when I feel like I'm not on my game.

t. decrepit oldfag
>>
>>65654389
>Is JHP even worth it over FMJ?
Go ask any emergency room surgeon and/or any mortician.
>>
>>65654571
Ive never considered the collateral damage of my anime and manga shelf in the event of a home self defense situation.
I think its time I switch to the gucci tier guaranteed to expand in the bad guy ammo instead of the plated wadcutters i use.
>>
>>65654575
>from a biased source
NYT was anti-hollowpoints, because they were more deadly to people being shot by police. The argument was, basically, that the amount of people the NYPD was shooting through other people wasn't high enough to justify killing more intended targets with evil hollowpoint murderbullets.

>from 40 years ago
Oh, has FMJ design changed to reduce penetration?
>>
>>65654623
They literally can't tell the difference between the holes left by 32acp, 9mm, 357 magnum, 10mm, and 45acp, much less JHP vs FMJ.
>>
>>65654650
>has FMJ design changed to reduce penetration?
yes. truncated cone fmj penetrates less though soft tissue then the older rounded tip fmj designs.
>>
File: HUI85rFakAAEq-P.jpg (111 KB, 1175x1164)
111 KB JPG
>>65654650
>NYPD was shooting through other people wasn't high enough to justify
So your source disproves your own point?
>>
>>65654708
>They literally can't tell the difference between JHP vs FMJ.
LOL, your delusions are funny.

>>65654719
>So your source disproves your own point?
NTA. Hello, ESL-chan. >65654575 claimed that the study was biased in order to make hollow points look good. The reply in >65654650 is pointing out that the bias was the opposite; they were trying their hardest to make hollow points bad and failed to do so.
>>
you can use CHEAP jhps. you dont have to use reddit ammo (Federal HST) you can use the black box winchester. barely more expensive than range ammo. and it'll kill a mfer for sure
>>
>>65654389
>Is JHP even worth it over FMJ?
Yes, manufacturers generally have better quality control standards for their defensive ammunition lines which alone makes it preferable for it for carry ammo. Handguns poke holes in people and hollow points make the hole bigger, and with modern designs that don't plug up from denim or deform much through windshields there's not much reason to chose a 9MM FMJ over a JHP. Just be wary that heavier 147 9MM JHPs designed for full-sized barrels (4' or more) sometimes have difficulty expanding at the lower velocity produced by 3' barrels. I'd step down to a 124gr or use a specifically developed line like the Hornady Critical Defense you posted.

> have kind of come to agree with is that generally you should train with what you carry.
Find a bulk, cheap round at the same grain weight and similar velocity as your preferred carry ammo and it shouldn't feel much different in training.
>>
File: 1764270729400902.png (522 KB, 833x1000)
522 KB PNG
>>65654756
>Yes, manufacturers generally have better quality control standards for their defensive ammunition lines which alone makes it preferable for it for carry ammo.
>he fell for the marketing to sell him a round for $2 each
>>
>>65654756
>Find a bulk, cheap round at the same grain weight and similar velocity as your preferred carry ammo and it shouldn't feel much different in training.
That's only part of it, and that aspect was more important when you were training with .38 and carrying .357, only to find you had no idea how to handle the gun.

The other issue is that many older autoloaders don't feed JHPs well, which you would want to learn before your life depended on it.
>>
>>65654751
Federal 9bple or prvi partizan jhp are probably the best value jhps in 9mm (as per op) for their ballistic performance, but anything will get the job done
>>
>>65654768
Having shot a lot of Blazer and a lot of Speer Lawman and Gold Dot, I can tell you that the latter have been a lot more consistent.

>>65654774
>That's only part of it
What other part is there?

>older autoloaders don't feed JHP
What autoloader are you carrying that doesn't feed JHPs?
>>
>>65654389
Load your own like a real kommando.
>>
>>65654389
JHP helps load the dice in favor of better energy transfer on impact but it doesn't change the dice you are rolling. It's useless on mousegun calibers, but with 9mm there's no reason not to spend the extra buck. Yeah the odds of JHP dropping some fuckwit where FMJ doesn't are slim, but so are the odds you'll have to shoot at somebody in the first place. No sense going for half measures.
>Practice with what you carry.
Up to a point. It makes sense to occasionally rotate your carry ammunition and shoot off the old stuff because you get a sense for how it shoots differently (if at all, because within defense distances it is usually insignificant), but you should definitely not be bankrupting yourself buying premium JHP by the case and shooting it exclusively. That's just stupid. There isn't going to be enough of a difference to justify wasting that much money as opposed to more affordable FMJ range ammunition.
>Expansion may be questionable.
In this day and age there are tons of different youtubers doing ballistic gel tests on virtually every loading out there, particularly for 9mm. I'm sure you can find somebody sending the ammunition you are considering out of some compact 9mm with a close enough to make no difference barrel length.

If your autism really can't be cured that way you can always buy or make your own ballistic gel and try it yourself.
>Not sure if +P rated
Consult the manual, if in doubt email Beretta CS. That's the sort of thing CS agents do.
>>
>>65654389
Underwood Xtreme Defense, lighter bullet the better. If your going to spend on good ammo at least get the good ammo.

But realistically basic ball ammo is absolutely fine. The extra dollar or so changes the punching of holes into the ripping of holes - it matters but shot placement will always be king.
>>
>>65654708
What matters is how much energy the round carries and how much of that energy it can dump into a person's body. The size of the bullet doesn't matter as much as the bullet's mass and velocity (F=ma). 5.56 rounds are nearly half the diameter of a 9mm, but they carry like 3x the energy, making them much more lethal.
>>
>>65654389
FMJs are expensive. Are they even worth it? You should try harsh language.
>>
>>65654449
nigga just say 75cpr scares you.
>>
>>65654449
You carry a makarov as a backup gun?



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.