[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/k/ - Weapons

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: vk3002db.jpg (21 KB, 625x215)
21 KB JPG
What could have been.
>>
>>65654643
>Combining the worse aspects of the Panther with the worst parts of the T-34
Sanely left on paper.
>>
File: Vc-tank-edelweiss_webp.png (779 KB, 950x760)
779 KB PNG
Valkyria Chronicles ass tank.
>>
>>65654668
>T-34 but with a better gun, optics, a radio system and a 3 man turret
>worse aspects
???
Instead they got the Panther which turned out to be a heavy pig and all that weight wrecked the drivetrain/trans which was in a very hard to access place in the front of the tank.
>>
>>65654668
It's literally just a Panther with less internal space and minor other alterations.
It doesn't really have any aspects of the T-34. Different suspension, engine,gun, turret ring, etc.
>>
>>65654643
Driver and radio man seating looks like it would be hell, even compared to Soviet tanks.
>>
File: Indien Panzer.png (464 KB, 1078x440)
464 KB PNG
>2026
>I am forgotten
>>
Soviet tanks were able to achieve a smaller hull size by placing their fuel tanks inside the fighting compartment; were the Germans planning to replicate this design while using gasoline engines?
>>
>>65654671
IIRC Edelweiss was based on a kitbash of Panther II and Walker Bulldog model kits.
>>
>>65654915
The chassis is taken from Pz III.
>>
>>65654687
>drivetrain/trans
was inadequately designed from outset and wouldn't have been any better or suitable had the weight been kept in 35T range
Panther was a 35 - 40 ton (+) tank and needed final drives and transmission for a heavy vehicle
(it already used the 60-ton Tiger I's engine from the beginning)
But in 1942 there wasn't any time available to completely re-engineer the urgently required vehicle's automotive drive components.
>>
>>65654687
Drivetrain/Transmission was fine for the Panther
The Final Drives, literally a bolted-on part, was the issue.
>>
>>65654782
this thing is ass in WoT
>>
File: 1790531496907877.jpg (142 KB, 936x810)
142 KB JPG
>>65654687
>>65654961
see that tiny green gear on the panther diagram on the left? That was the only link between the drivetrain to the final drive. When it shredded its teeth, the entire tank sat in place
>>
>>65655123
>We'll make a final drive so cheap we can make infinite of them! What could possibly go wrong??!
>>
>>65655123
>>65655127
So where did "The Panther was over-engineered" come from?
>>
>>65654671
I've never noticed it before, but the artist really loved to strap leather shit on everything, huh.
>>
>>65655152
Retarded normalfag people who don't know what the term 'overengineered' means.
Overengineering something means making something absurdly complex, or overbuilt. Panther was not especially complex, and it wasn't overbuilt either.
Ironically the issue with the Panther is it was underengineered in areas.
>>
>>65655078
Such a fucking grind
>>
I see one issue: germans do not have a rear transmission developed.
>>
/r/ variant of jealous gf meme with Hitler turning his head at Maus and neglecting OP's tank.
>>
>>65655165
Yes, also my favourite part is the bedroll/picnic mat/WW1 fire blanket on the side of the tank. I like to think picnic.
>>
>>65654643
I'm out of the loop, was there some kind of plan for the Germans to clone the T34?
>>
>>65654687
Forgot the part where the radio-man and driver have no way of escape, but through the side hatches that create a weak spot.
Or the interleaved drive wheels that are a total bitch to change
>>
File: T-70_german.jpg (48 KB, 640x454)
48 KB JPG
With the Germans already having shortages of alloying material to make good steel armour.

I don't think switching to a cast hull and turret would have been beneficial*, if Germany even had that kinda tech?
*cast is less effective

Further with the real bottle necks being crew and fuel, why not make better tanks?

Hezter exists and is cheap af
and
https://tanks-encyclopedia.com/beutepanzerjager-su-85r-mit-8-5-8-8-cm-kanone
>>
File: Panther.jpg (57 KB, 800x419)
57 KB JPG
What could have been?
>>
>>65655280
Those tended to really suck until after WWII
>>
>>65656187
Source? From my memory, Valentines, BT-series, KV's, IS-1/2, and other such vehicles didn't suffer any notorious failures or feats in terms of their transmission, or because of it being rearmounted as opposed to front. Of course, save for the T-34 needing a rubber hammer for the driver to switch gears, which I personally attribute to Africa-tier QC on their singly most-produced tank (especially after the Stalingrad factories got moved beyond the Urals, the machines now manned by noobs with zero training and a high mortality rate).
>>
>>65654643
sir your t-34 has autism
>>
>>65655682
Germany could cast just fine but casting sucks for mass production and efficiency which is why the US Army immediately panicked and wanted to switch to welded turrets after the battle of the bulge when they foresaw actually having to replace their tanks due to incoming losses.
They then quickly gave up on it again when the war ended without any need for that after all.
>>65657235
1. British tanks were stupidly unreliable. Despite the memes, the only nation with more reliable tanks than Germany was the US.
2. We literally have stalin complaining about their transmissions being notably less reliable than those of the German panzer III/IV. I could paste the report for you if I were on my computer. You can probably just ask your favorite AI for it though.
>>
>>65655771
Schmalturm is peak aesthetic though.
>>
File: DFFOO_Kuja.png (406 KB, 442x701)
406 KB PNG
>>65655165
It was the style at the time.
Very funny seeing it on a tank when you look at it from that perspective but edelweiss rocks it.
>>
>>65655538
There was never a plan to clone the T-34 (some officers suggested doing it, but nothing bigger than that)
The Daimler-Benz version of the Panther tank resembled the T-34 though, which is what the picture is.
>>
File: 7SbHUgN.png (190 KB, 801x543)
190 KB PNG
>>65657473
>We literally have stalin complaining about their transmissions being notably less reliable than those of the German panzer III/IV.
That was a manufacturing problem due to them desperately throwing QA/QC out the window for a time. Once they calmed down and Stalin stopped having panic attacks when he looked at a map, factories were directed to increase quality and the problem was resolved.

But yeah, for a time the T-34 wasn't being made very well and no work was being put into solving the existing issues that all designs have at some point. Pic rel is a chart of factory tests. the Percentage is the number of batch tested tanks that were able to cover a 300km test without breaking down. Additionally, every single tank had to undergo a 30km factory test and then a 50km military acceptance test beginning in mid 1943. Those tests were discarded during the crisis phase of the German invasion.

Another factor in the increase in tank quality was that engineers were given time to improve parts and components. Later T-34s had very little in common with early T-34s in the same way an M4A3(76)W HVSS had very little in common with the early production M4 tanks.
>>
>>65658489
>factories were directed to increase quality and the problem was resolved.
Nope, they literally never stopped sucking during WWII.
>>
What is worth lamenting about here? Looks like a slightly less retarded T-34, plus the kriegsmarine needed all the diesel anyway



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.