I've got a Pietta reproduction black powder cap-and-ball revolver (the model in the picture). As far as I can tell, it's as safe to carry with 6 loaded chambers as 5, because you can put the hammer into a notch between the caps. Why didn't/don't they make the SAA with that feature, allowing to be fully loaded and carried safely?
yeah
fuck yamudda
The Thuer conversion had a neat safety.
>>65656753I’ve got one of the steel frame Pietta’s like yours except in .36 caliber, and an 8” barrel. I wish I would’ve gotten the 5” barrel though.I’ve also got a Pietta SAA. I’d love to sell that thing, because I’m honestly not a big fan of it. I got the 4.75” barrel, and even still, they’re bigger and heavier than I thought.
>>65656753Not feasible. Long ass firing pin where the hammer of the black powder guns don't have that, also the cartridge rims needed space so there wasn't room to cut a notch between the rounds.
>>65657383thank you for a reasonable, understandable reply!!
I think you can technically rest the hammer down firing pin between cartridges but then you're relying on it staying there and never slipping up that 0.05". Im sure someone tried and died.
>>65656753>Why didn't/don't they make the SAA with that feature, allowing to be fully loaded and carried safely?Because the SAA built the safety into the trigger group. It's relatively fragile and unsafe by modern standards but for the safety to mechanically fail you have to drop it on the hammer hard enough to break the hammer and/or trigger group while retaining enough force to detonate the primer. This can be an issue if you have a gun with poor metallurgy or one that's clapped-out but generally is more of a "not best practice"-tier issue rather than a "potentially lethal safety hazard"-tier issue.
>>65657538So the SAA to all reasonable expectations, is safe to carry with all 6 chambers loaded, and the hammer-only-on-empty-chamber practice is just fuddlore? There are other things I could think of that would also make it safe... for example, a thin wooden shim (or cardboard or folded paper--something reasonably stiff) between the pin and primer that would fall away when the hammer is cocked (which would advance the cylinder, dislodging the shim). It just seems unlikely that a design flaw this dangerous would continue to exist for 100+ years, past the invention of the transfer bar safety and the like. I mean, you can still buy brand-new production SAAs for $2300, or buy a Ruger Vaquero that is less than half the price but either equal to or superior to it in any way you can measure.
>>65657729Its not safe and the original SAA has no safety of any kind. It doesnt take a big hit on the hammer to make the primer go off. Carrying half cocked is better but still not exactly safe and now its even more likely to catch onto clothing and gear. Theres reasons why modern replicas like Ruger Vaquero that have actual safety features. Ubertis you can order with or without their floating/retractable firing pin
>>65657735 The vaquero doesn't exist anymore.
>>65657738They very much exist theyre just not manufactured anymore.
>>65657729>and the hammer-only-on-empty-chamber practice is just fuddlore?No, people were doing that in the 1890s and probably before that too, pic related. The original edition of this book was published in 1888 and didn't mention resting the hammer on an empty chamber, which suggests people read that version and then wrote to the publisher/author to complain that he was giving unsafe advice.
>>65657894Also if the Colt safety notch wasn't known to be prone to shearing off, then the Iver Johnson "Hammer the Hammer" marketing campaign wouldn't have been nearly as effective.
>>65657735A weak safety is still a safety.
Why do we only hear about the SAA being unsafe? There weren't many rebounding hammers or transfer bar safeties in the early 1870's.
>>65658364because all guns are unsafe. it was considered an acceptable risk up until ww2. any bullet could blow up your gun. any drop could set it off. this was expected. you didnt want it to happen and it was unlikely but it was still consider possible.nobody assumed thier gun was dropsafe.there would be features but nobody is glock claiming it wont go off.ivers hammer the hammer is about 1 form of safety not saying the gun is idiotproof.then we get into the modern era of lawsuits and shooting competitions with codified rules and now we care.its like trigger discipline they didnt have it in ww2. you can see pictures of troops with none in vietnam.the saa made it into the modern era through hollywood. the rest didnt exist in enough numbers to care.
if the 320 came out in the 1960s nobody would care if it went off when dropped. the thinking would be of course its dangerous its a gun. guns are dangerous.the british with the l85 didnt notice their rifles went off when dropped. being drop safe was not a requirement.its now that we can expect guns to not go off factory ammo not to explode your gun and not jam. older designs were like that. theyed have something that would supposedly make it safe but they werent trusted 100% it would fix one possibility but not all of them
>>65658364Because people didn't keep making reproductions of the other 1000 handguns from that era for the next hundred years.
One black powder revolver or two for the aesthetic
>"guns were never drop safe and nobody complained in the 1800s!">ignores direct evidence that actually people did care and took appropriate precautions to minimize the risk of a dropped gun firing
>>65657729>So the SAA to all reasonable expectations, is safe to carry with all 6 chambers loaded,Depends on the SAA. In a vacuum, it's GENERALLY safe but strictly inferior to later safeties. If you're buying a used SAA in 1880? Fuck that.>and the hammer-only-on-empty-chamber practice is just fuddlore?No. Parts could and did break on 19th century firearms - especially repeating firearms - on a regular basis and if you're choosing between "five shots instead of six" and "maybe shooting yourself" then you'd be a fool to not take the former unless you think that that sixth shot might actually matter. Not to mention the fact that even setting aside the possibility of a discharge, carrying with the hammer down on an empty chamber means that you're less likely to break something in the trigger group if you drop it. When you're separated from the nearest gunsmith by hundreds of miles and potentially quite a few unfriendly indians, that matters quite a bit.
>>65659898>>65659898>took appropriate precautions to minimize the risk of a dropped gun firingMinimize not eliminate. They still knew it could go off when dropped.Thats the difference. Now its supposedly eliminated where the 320 is an outlier. Everything before the 60s drop at your own risk. There would be features to prevent a gun going off when dropped but not like glocks we have a 100% drop your gun out a helicopter drop safety.
>>65660172>They still knew it could go off when dropped.If they were carrying on an empty chamber, the only way this could happen is if they dropped it after cocking the hammer in preparation to fire. And it'd not like if you Israeli carried a modern pistol for fear of it not being drop safe because chambering a round on that is an extra step in a gunfight but you would already have to cock the revolver anyway so it's not an extra action. You're equivocating when it isn't warranted.