I've seen a couple of you homosexuals say the Stg44 was very complicated and slow to produce. That seemed ridiculous to me, so I looked it up.>10kg of steel vs 12,2 for the K98k>7 hours of work instead of 20>way cheaper tooYou could literally build 3 StGs for every K98k.>The system of production circles, each with its steering firm guiding and overseeing the circle firms and their subcontractors, all united under the direction of the Maschinenpistolen und Sturmgewehr sub committee, was highly efficient.
>>65658760I like to tease wehraboos and drive them towards suicide, but whoever said that about the STG was wrong. It was considerably more efficient than a Kar 98 to make. The FG42 is the one that was eye wateringly expensive and inefficient, like worse than your wildest dreams.
The real issue was that you had way way more K98s, 8mm ammo and factories that already had years or decades making K98s that the tooling cost to equip every Hans with an stg would require full exploitation of their conquered territories plus the Americans and Soviets agreeing to let the Germans work on it for 5-6 months in peace.
By the end of the war they had more rifles than they had ammunition and magazines to feed them with.
>>65658854Considering how quick they set up the production they had, that seems unlikely.Turns out, you really can shit out stamped guns like nothing else.
>>65658854>8mm ammo8mm kurz was literally made from cut down 8mm mauser. Again wehraboos get the rope, but this is wrong.
>>65658978>wehraboos get the rope"Wehraboos" are above average in education on WWII nowadays.
Although the production of the Panther was significantly streamlined, it proved impossible to halt and convert the inefficient production lines for the Panzer III and Panzer IV.
>>65659136>it proved impossibleNot impossible, just impractical considering how the war was going.
>>65658898>By the end of the war they had more rifles than they had ammunition and magazines to feed them with.This is the main issue. The ammunition factories were running at full capacity to supply 8mm Mauser and the K98 were not even close to the main user of it, it was far and away the machine guns that were eating up the ammunition. In addition to the ammo that was carried by the machine gun teams, even the riflemen carried almost as much ammo in belts as they did in stripper clips to feed those machine guns. German tactics were built with machine gun at the center.German's were desperately trying to supply the units that already existed with 8mm Mauser. With millions upon millions of 8mm Mauser rifles and hundreds of thousands of machine guns in the hands of soldiers in the field it is a logistical nightmare to introduce a new cartridge. If you could magic 3 million STG's into the hands of soldiers then you could convert like half your ammo production but that is not possible, instead you are drip feeding them in at tens of thousands a month and the units that get them need their own special supply line of ammo that the rest of the greater army can't use. Ammo is supposed to flow where it is most needed so you either over produce and end up starving the rest of the army or under produce and the new guns are hamstrung. The Germans chose the latter and they probably weren't wrong. The STG-44 program was a mistake because they committed to it too late. They either needed to start rifle and ammo production earlier before the war got desperate or accept it was an after war project and commit to building rifles that uses the cartridge currently in use.
>>65659227Those MG42s and MG34s were hungry and needed feeding.
Wait till you learn just how much easier the Jumo004 and BMW003 to produce then the DB605https://www.amazon.com/Making-Jet-Engines-World-War-ebook/dp/B01KHRXGCO
>>65659227>it was far and away the machine guns that were eating up the ammunitionI think they considered replacing the LMG in squads with simply giving 10 guys STGs, probably would have worked for most situations that don't need an HMG anyway.
>>65659674After the war, they wanted to ideally remove all machine guns from rifle companies and push them up to the battalion's heavy company, having all troops use STG-44s. Fairly retarded.They already tried to go that way during the war.
>>65660236The image shows something different.
video gamer thread
>>65658760ammo and magazines were the biggest hurtles to stg adoption, often troops in the field would only have 3-4 mags and magazine fitment and reliability somehow manages to be worse than an M1 carbine. of my 13 magazines only 4 work at all and one of them still has a hiccup every now and again.Original STG's also had pretty loose headspace from the factory, and a distinct lack of QC or finish detail.t. MP44 owner
>>65661220>magazine fitment and reliability somehow manages to be worse than an M1 carbineComplete lie btw.>of my 13 magazines only 4 work at all You realize that your experience isn't relevant here since you either have modern copies or 80 year old beat to shit originals, right?We have the tests they ran in the field, anon. None of them confirm your nonsense.>Original STG's also had pretty loose headspace from the factory, and a distinct lack of QC or finish detail.t. fuddlore mongoloid
>>65661237>>65661220Just to set a little bit of context for the report, HGr Nord was mostly occupied with the Siege of Leningrad for the year of 1943. While the beginning of the year saw some stiff resistance to the Soviet offensives at the beginning of the year, namely Operation Iskra and Operation Polar Star, the region had stabilized more or less by April of 1943. Since the sector was relatively quiet compared to the larger operations of HGr Mitte and HGr Sud, the HWaA along with the OKW thought this a good region to test the new MKb42(H), of which 2,000 were shipped to HGr Nord on April 21st, 1943. A troop trial conducted by the 6th Company of the 23 Grenadier Regiment found mixed results with the MKb42s in a report dated August 7, 1943. A very small amount of early production MP43/1s were sent along with the MKb42(H)s to see if the difference in operation (closed vs open bolt) were preferred by troops. The MP43/1 trials came about a result of these trials and testing at the Infanterieschule had found the closed bolt MP43/1 more desirable for a fighting rifle than the open bolt MKb42(H). The trials for the MP43/1 were to be carried out by the 1st Infantry Division, one of the original divisions of the Wehrmacht and one of few that existed in the pre-Nazi Reichswehr.The final reports of the first troop trial on the front performed by units of the 18th Army [HGr Nord] with the first 500 MP43/1s date from late November to early December, 1943. This indicates that the selected infantry companies of the three divisions of AOK18 had received the test weapons in late September and early October, since according to the order of the HGr Nord as of September 23, the final reports were to be filed two months after reception of the weapons.
>>65661242Compared to the earlier trial reports about the MKb42(H), which had been critical, the AOK18 reports about the MP43/1 were all very positive. As a good example, the vivid final report of Hauptmann Gotfried Uhlig, leader of the 3rd Company of Grenadier-Regiment 43 dated December 2, 1943, which clearly describes the superior characteristics of the MP43/1 and attests that it was largely able to replace the LMG is presented in full as follows:>3rd Company, Grenadier Regiment 43>CO HQ, 2nd December, 1943Final Report about the Troop Trial with MP43/1>The company which performed the trial fully equipped with MP43/1 has been on mission without interruption since the beginning of the Russian campaign, and always in the northern sector of the Ostfront. Nearly all of its leaders, and most of the men are therefore familiar with every existing kind of combat action. The unit consists mainly of East Prussians, then West Germans, North Germans, Berliners, and Pomeranians.>A 200m-long clavey trench, and a 800m-long combat wall which is erected in palisades from different layers of boggy timber, constitute the battle position.>If the enemy was relatively inactive in the beginning, his activity has now increased considerably after a successful advance of the company more than 2km deep into the enemy's main battle area. He reinforced his battle position and the crew. For the past three weeks, he is performing regularly every two to three days strong combat patrols towards our main battle line, supported by artillery, anti tank gun, and mortar fire. Smaller Russian patrols approach steadily their own line. A total of 10 of our patrols were sent to the enemy's forward line during the duration of the trial.
>>65661248>In order to equip the company, which has a combat strength of 85 men, with the new weapon, it was drawn out of the combat position for three days to change arming. Instead of 12 LMG, 4 MG were kept which were employed as HMG. The remaining part of the company was equipped with the MP43/1. Then the soldiers moved again into the old battle position without having had any special training with what was for them a completely new type of weapon. The 12 former LMG stands were occupied by the 4 MG and by MP gunners. They did not need to be reconstructed, since both the height of the firing position and the traverse range of the weapon were nearly identical to those of the MG. Due to the longer magazine, the remaining rifle stands and alert stands had to be reconstructed so that the gunner had a covered position. Traverse range and camouflage remained the same. In regard to defensive measures, no important tactical changes or reconstruction of the battle positions was necessary. The bunkers were provided with an enlarged anteroom since in the coming winter not only the machine guns but also the machine pistols have to be stored outside the warm bunkers. The machine pistols will be brought into the bunker only for cleaning, to prevent steaming up and freezing when they are brought outside again.>The MPs are in their mounts, one magazine inserted, with the magazine pouches beside them ready to grasp. In case of repelling an enemy approach, the immediate readiness of the MP has proven extremely favorable. The important advantage in agility at close combat over the LMG is clearly realized and of great advantage when repelling sudden, unexpected enemy advances. What we did not forsee is the advantage of the MP's versatility in case of counter-attacking against enemies who penetrated our own trench. In this case, the MG fails totally, because it is too inflexible and unwieldy in the narrow trench.
>>65661250>During patrols the weapon stood up well, especially becasue of its low susceptibility to dirt and sand. The inevitable dirtying caused by the men crawling did not impair its performance at all. It was ready to fire at any time. The ideal weapon for patrols! Because it is not as unwieldy as the MG, it is always combat ready, and has more effect and performance than the rifle (presumably K98ks).The previously used patrol weapon, the MP40, cannot be compared to the MP43/1 due to its susceptibility to dirt.
>>65661253>In an assault the MP43/1 has shown its superiority to other weapons even more, and proved outstanding. An attack of the company in full strength was made against a fortified position which had been in enemy hands for three quarters of a year, constituting a main strongpoint in his defense system. The position was pushed through, and the company penetrated more the 2km in the enemy's main battle area, took prisoners, destroyed bunkers and positions, inflicted considerable casualties on the enemy and gathered booty before returning to our own position according to the order. The rapid advance and the successful repelling of strong enemy counter-attacks is thanks to the good performance of the MP, and its immense increase of firepower. Combining deliberate individual fire with the highest possible increase of firepower was most effective in the defense of counter-attacks as well as at the withdrawal when the enemy was exploiting. By this, with every man being both an infantryman and a machine gunner in one person, while in the past these functions were separated, the performance and effectiveness of each MP unit in contrast to the old one equipped with rifle and MG will be practically doubled. Despite the worst weather during the attack (slush, rain, mud) none of the MPs failed, except those destroyed by direct combat effect. This success is especially remarkable because the company had had the weapons in hand for only 14 days and were not properly familiar with their special handling (prevention of dirtying and getting in of sand, particularly when lying down in the prone position). Of the three accompanying MGs one was destroyed by mines, the second failed after 600 rounds due to dirtying, and only one remained combat ready through to the end of the mission. If equipped according to the old weapon allowance (LMG and rifle), three squads would have lost their firepower.
>>65661254>This is not to mention the fact that in case of a more intensive MG employment, the enemy is able to locate these weapons easily by their distinctive bursts of fire, and focus on them much earlier, resulting in a significant loss.>During withdrawal, the significant superiority of the MP was shown. When in former times the MG had to perform the change of position by being the first to break away, the squad was left in this weak moment of breakaway with only the firepower of the rifles. This time, the firepower remained constant, no matter which one of the gunners withdrew alternately, and there was no need to consider the time-consuming redeployment of the MG, which is not possible to hide from the eyes of the enemy.>During the eight-weeks-long trials, all kinds of tests were made with the machine pistols. They were not cleaned for a long time; soaked in water; dirt was put into the magazines, and the barrels were overloaded and overheated by extensive firing. In all these cases, no deficiencies occurred, which would have impaired the war suitability of the weapon.>The MP43/1 came up to all our expectations.>Now it is important to put it in the right frame according to the experiences made, to fit it in and integrate it, together with the other weapons, into the units, so that its outstanding qualities can best be made use of. The suggestions made in the appendix for both an MP company and for an MP battalion are based on the experiences of the company during the campaign and the performed trials. They refer as far as possible to the ordered KStN [Table of Organization & Equipment].>The aim of the re-organization is seen as:>Restriction of the number of weapon and ammunition types to as few as possible, with the goal of the most possible increase of fire and the ability to concentrate anti-aircraft fire and high-angle fire at any position, as well as to simplify the weapon technical training to have more time for the necessary combat training.
>>65661256>It might be possible that for psychological reasons the front-line troops-the fighters-were unwilling at first to give up the weapons which had saved their lives during hard hours of battle. Therefore the company -subordinate leaders and men- approached the new weapon hesitatingly and with harsh criticism. But after all the tests and after the MP43/1 had proved itself in heavy fighting, every man is convinced of the superior performance of this weapon.>The company wishes to continue fighting with this weapon. Moreover, due to their own excellent experiences with it, the company considers it urgently necessary to equip other troops with it as soon as possible. The Machine Pistol Platoon of the Grenadier Company should not be the final aim, but rather the Machine Pistol Company in the MP battalion.>Uhlig, Hauptmann and Company LeaderHauptmann Uhlig was later awarded the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross as commander of the 2nd Battalion/GrenRgt 43 on November 26, 1944.
>>65658760I appreciate historical manufacturing posts like this but please post the source for the book.
>>65661277Sturmgewehr! From firepower to striking power by Hans-Dieter Handrich.It's the old edition with about 550 pages though, the revised one has 720
>>65659099The boomer are al old and dying and archival research autism as well as primary sources are more available than ever making true conversations about ww2 German arms production and capabilities better than ever. It is a shame image boards are dead because most ww2 autists I know are now very well educated and into reading actual books, technical manuals etc. A lot of the weirdo kids i grew up with spouting things about tigers snapping their drive-trains every two feet and shermans exploding at the slightest touch are now actual engineers and so on. Not everything in life is trash
>>65658978...That was needed for the machineguns already on the front. Now youre adding extra supply chain logistics to the country that needs horses and 36+ variations of the same uniform.
>>65661291>The boomer are al old and dying and archival research autism as well as primary sources are more available than ever making true conversations about ww2 German arms production and capabilities better than ever.You forgot the part where you say only a select group of people do that and non-boomers are getting mindraped by youtube slop instead.
>>65660939shut the fuck up useless cunt. Plenty of people actually like reading about weapon procurement and manufacturing during a war. Post a gun you own you useless fucker
>>65661298Is it really that bad. I suppose I've entered unc mode and am disconnected with modern internet media. I haven't been on youtube for history in a long long time. Although I suppose all the ai thumbnails in my suggested videos for ww2 stuff are blatantly awful
>>65661342I've seen a guy insisting that "30-50%" of stg44s went right into the junk in the factories and the source he linked for it was a podcast of guntubers.
>>65661277dubs and also it was revealed to me in a dream
>>65658760The STG44 was rushed into production early on and it had really bad manufacturing issues that weren't ironed out before the guns were being made in mass numbers. Sure, within the year it was 'pretty good', but it had started abominably and the Germans just had to brute force it.
>>65661283>Sturmgewehr! From firepower to striking power by Hans-Dieter HandrichSpeaking of, most of the pages are text for obvious reasons, but the images he put in are pretty cool as well. Here are technical drawings that help you understand the single manufacturing steps of the parts he talks about in that section (there are others)>>65661453>The STG44 was rushed into production early onCompletely wrong.>and it had really bad manufacturing issues that weren't ironed out before the guns were being made in mass numbers. Also incorrect, if you scroll up a bit you can see an early test at the front of an entire company. There are others. Another one tested them in Greece and put it through the dust picked up while driving on dry Greek roads for days to check how it holds up. It did very well.The only real issue was that the spring tended to seize up in early models after prolonged usage in wet environments because the wood of the stock swelled up. The fix was to simply bore it out a bit more and that was done both in the factories and by the armorers are the front.>Sure, within the year it was 'pretty good', but it had started abominably and the Germans just had to brute force it.None of this is true.The stg44 is probably the last gun you'd ever call "rushed into mass production" of the entirety of WWII.I don't know why you feel compelled to spread this nonsense (lie about it?), but it's just ridiculous.
Nvm. Retard posts like this >>65661453remind me why I'm out of touch. I guess people are incapable of reading and this >>65661291is totally out of touch.
>>65661453Source?
>>65661465>>65661482This could be egg on my face. My source, after searching up the numbers I remembered, was a post by Matthew Moss, who is reputable as a firearms researcher.But upon rereading today, the specific article I got it from did not cite his evidence. https://www.historicalfirearms.info/post/60614907035/historical-trivia-early-receiver-stamping>Up to 1/3 of all StG-44 receivers stamped by CG Haenel (the manufacturers) during World War Two had tears in them caused by some of the corners of the receiver being at the limit of the steel plate’s elastic potential. The stamping process sees steel plates shaped by being pressed into dies (templates) of the desired shape. By the end of the war the quality of German steel was waning due to the pressures of war, this added to the issues when stamping. >The torn receivers were set aside and repaired by welding the tear back together. I sent him an e-mail asking about what is source was. But I have no way of knowing whether the thread will be alive when or if he ever gets back to me.
>>65661565>CG Haenel (the manufacturers)Considering he wrote that, I doubt he knows what he's talking about.Haenel did the final assembly, yes. But so did Sauer & Sohn, Erma and Steyr. Handrich goes into detail on how production was set up in pic related. There were hundreds of firms involved. Some of them just made receiver parts. It's pretty unlikely that all of the ones Haenel used had that specific problem and it wasn't fixed and even less likely that it was true for every other company involved in the final assembly.
>>65661283Great book. I sold mine for $600 years ago to a collector. They regularly go in and out of production and if you’ve got a desirable book on an off year you can make bank.
>>65661635I just wish I'd have the revised edition. Maybe there's info on the mythical high rejection rates in there. It seems unlikely, considering the context and method involved, but maybe Moss knows something we don't and Hanrich didn't.
>>65661617This is the reply, thats the book being referenced in the thread. I'm DL'ing Sturmgeweher! myself now, so I'll be able to see where if at all that was mentioned. The unfortunate part is that the article is about 13 years old so he may have just misremembered the specific source from among many.
>>65661841I spent like an hour yesterday going through that exact book to find that number lmaoI don't think it's in there, but maybe I'm retarded.Pic related are the relevant chapters for production and I haven't found it anywhere in there. Maybe it's scattered somewhere else.
>>65659674>what is sustained fire
>>65661928It's not particularly sustained if you divide it by 10 and German machine guns worked with bursts anyway.
>>65661851Just doing some naive word searches and skimming, I'm not seeing anything about it. Nor anything like it. The description is fairly specific, so I'm going to assume he got it from *somewhere* but named the wrong source. I'm not going to badger the guy about the article, but I'm fairly confident that anecdote doesn't come from the Sturmgeweher! book.
>>65662106Apparently Ian from Forgotten Weapons mentioned it on a podcast, potentially based on the article you linked.I'll write him an e-mail and ask what his source is.
>>65661635They'll never get back into production, CG is dead and buried.They were the greatest books, I agree. I pray daily for a similar work updating their FG42 book. No scans online for the updated STG44 book, so? The G43 book got updated (Rough Forged) and there's a scan running around. great book also.
>>65662156>No scans online for the updated STG44 book, so?The revised edition?Probably not.
>>65658849>>65658978Nigga do wehraboos live in ur head? I swear ww2 fags are some of the most projective whiniest people on the planet.
>>65662224It's just redditors who tried to hard to fit in on reddit and are now too used to fighting against windmills to stop.
>>65661635>Great book. I sold mine for $600 years ago to a collector.Shit, I thought I was the only /k/-tard buying/selling $600 books. Pic related. A couple years after I bought it for literally 600 dollars, I saw one online for $60. No regrets though, it's worth every penny to me. Also someone around here has 4 figures worth of "Jane's".>pic relatedsorry, it wouldn't upload. But it's "Early Empires of Central Asia" by McGovern
>>65662336I’m bougie homeless now as a full time RVer so my collection is essentially gone. I keep a couple books in storage at $250 a month but once I swing back to my home state they’ll be gone too.Honestly 90% of what I want I can find online these days. Highly encourage you to scan everything you can and upload it to free websites. It’s a godsend to guys like me.