/noguns/ here with a stupid question, but I didn't see a stupid questions thread. What exactly defines a "new" gun design? If I take an AK and chamber it in a different cartridge, is it a new gun? What about simple bolt-action rifles? They're just a tube with a bolt in the back, what differentiates a Mosin Nagant from a Remington Model 700? Aside from "one fires a slightly bigger bullet so the barrel is slightly wider". Are firearms a "solved" design? Even modern automatic rifles appear to be just the usual AK or AR15 action with minor tweaks and a different-looking plastic case
>>65660326If it is any less similar than 99 percent then it isnt the same gun. E.g. SVD and Tigr are the same gun, but SVD and SVDS are different guns.
>>65660392Then where's the market for a new gun if it's exactly the same gun as before but with new furniture or a slightly different caliber?
>>65660401If people buy it then there is market for it. What mobile phone do you have? How is samsung any different from any other phone brand? How is one chair better than any other chair?
>>65660326>If I take an AK and chamber it in a different cartridge, is it a new gun?Yeah? Why wouldn't it be? If you think an AKM and a AK 74 are the same gun try to feed each with eachother's ammo
>>65660429Isn't the only different the width of the barrel and some minor adjustment to the gas tube?
>>65660432And? Its still a different gun, with different mechanical differences to allow the different cartridge to be used
>>65660392>SVD and Tigr are the same gunkinda, it depends on how anal you want to be and what year of production the SVD and Tigr are
>>65660438How does that work legally? If I take a Glock pistol and make the barrel thicker to shoot 12 gauge, can Glock sue me for copyright infringement or not since it's a "different gun"?
>>65660573Glock could only sue you for a copyright violation if you copied their owners manual word for word.Patents cover design. You would want to consult a patent lawyer before you went into production, but there's not very much about a Glock pistol's design that was ever protected by patent.Notably, Smith and Wesson copied Glock so closely with the Sigma that parts were interchangeable, and Glock did sue S&W.
>>65660573well, this is a fun question. there is no international patent law, but in your example glock had already established their company in '85 before they went to market in '86. They owned their US patent for it's duration and I'm sure they did this in every country that they intended to commercialize in.I think in a lot of euro countries there's some sort of universal patent system that gives the holder the right to have it indefinitely until sold or dissolution. That being said you would not have been able to SELL a glock clone while it was active. But under US patent law you WOULD still be able to MAKE glock clones, just not for sale. Glock obviously owns their own Trademark and Copyright. Interestingly enough, is VERY protected in the United States even if not formally submitted. I don't know the case law, but many cases in the US have favored the side of the company/writer that came to market first, rather than the one who filled the paper work first. In order to protect small business. Not sure about similar law in europe.
>>65661354additionally, the patent has since expired and you are free to make as many clones as you want in the US
>>65660326>What about simple bolt-action rifles? They're just a tube with a bolt in the back, what differentiates a Mosin Nagant from a Remington Model 700?If I give you a blank sheet, or computer with cad software, how much can you layout what you just spewed out? How much would you bank on that the poor technician looked at this document would not reject it on first glance? Would you bank on your face and hands to fire that gun loaded? Would you bank on your life firing that gun at a man whose buddies would return fire and move when it goes off?Do you know these things by name only or by heart? The grace period in your life of glancing around is over. Answer it in action not on paper.
>>65660432Yeah but that's the difference between it going 'bang' and firing the round out the end, and going 'BANG' with it blowing apart in your hands (or just not feeding a round to begin with).Generally you stick to the manufacturer specified model even it you re-chamber it, just specifying that it was re-chambered, unless you ARE a manufacturer making a large amount of re-chambered firearms, in which case you'd likely give it a unique model name to specify to the end user that it's not new, and uses a different round to the stock model.
>>65660432it's the same design, the dimensions of various parts are different, i.e. AK74's bolt is smaller, similar to the AK100 series which is based on it, despite being offered in 7.62x39 as well.
cz600 is a new design for a bolt action, never been done befohremovable bolt head, removable barrel just with screws, 6 locking lugs, partial-control feed action, etc.
>>65660668>Glock could only sue you for a copyright violation if you copied their owners manual word for word.>there's not very much about a Glock pistol's design that was ever protected by patent.wrong and wrong, BB techs was made by ex-glock engineer and produced one handgun the BB6, glock sued them because they used ideas they had during glock production but was never put in place, Glock had patented all those ideas without telling them and it caught them by surpriseFNH was sued by Glock for using a polymer recipe that was too close to the Glock polymer, Glock won in court and FNH had to change their whole recipe (squishy FN45 fiasco).Glock sued multiple video game companies for using the Glock name and model name.everything in a glock is patented down to the polymer recipe, everything is also copyrighter and they can strike you with a DMCA without hesitation because they don't like what you are doing, compared to all other gun making companies Glock is the one that sue the most for the pettiest reason
>>65661441All inferior to a classic mauser-derived action
>>65661354Free terrible legal advice to add here: IP law is basically quagmire and the only winner is the US Government when they pull the ol invention secrecy act on you and banish your patent to the shadow realm with 0.000001% of ever getting any money from it. For example, I would agree with this poster but would advise paying particular attention to the "trademark and copyright" comment, and that suits can be brought for "imitating with intent to deceive consumers" for at the very best: a tremendously expensive waste of time.
>>65660326Bolt action rifles were solved in the 1930s (winchester model 70) all deviations from that design have been for the purpose of making a cheaper shittier gun for more profit
>>65661499oh, true. there's always the litigate until bankruptcy strategy.
>>65661491
>>65661457>Glock sued multiple video game companies for using the Glock name and model name.You're right on everything else but wrong on his one. The first lawsuits trying to get the gaming companies to stop using Glock's designs lost, but the later lawsuits (when Glock realized games are free advertisements) in which Glock demanded the companies use accurate models to show off their guns were won.
>>65661491>>65661519I'm a huge Mauser/M70 fan but a lot of modern designs are superb and have distinct advantages. I say this having killed like 15 animals with a CRF M70 in .30-06. People really put on the rose-tinted glasses for old rifles, old cartridges etc.
>>65661815what are those distinct advantages? Is it relatively minor characteristics like "the bolt handle is more ergonomic" and "the cheek rest is comfier" or do they have legit features that make them far superior?