[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/k/ - Weapons

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: IMG_0604.jpg (158 KB, 962x764)
158 KB JPG
Can Americans pull that off?
>>
>>65661637
yes and we should've did it
>>
Yes? American and British air power was vastly superior to the Soviet Union, plus the navy as well. You've got dozens of groups you can support for anti-commie rebellions. Bongs had Centurions rolling out which were fantastic. While the Soviets had IS-3s, USA + UK had faced plenty of heavy armour.
>>
>>65661637
To a degree at least. Poland is flat ground with rivers, forests and swamps forming the only defensible ground, and as we saw three times in WW2 it's not very defensible at all. Allied airpower would dominate and the Soviet supply lines were stretched and vulnerable to a hostile population. Czechoslovakia and the Balkans are a tougher call, they have naturally defensible borders. The Baltics and the Soviet land itself would be unlikely, the shortened supply line would likely grind the invasion to a halt again. Still a preferable outcome though.
Best bet for the Allies would be try to open second and third fronts in Karelia and the Black Sea while the Soviet forces shifting east would be held there by America.
>>
But why destroy Germany beforehand? They were already fighting the Ivans.
>>
>>65661658
Maybe this little event called Pearl Harbor?
>>
File: 1776715761378025.jpg (2.71 MB, 3000x1982)
2.71 MB JPG
>>65661637
Waiting forty years for the enemy to collapse on their own is a valid strategy.
>>
>>65661648
>You've got dozens of groups you can support for anti-commie rebellions.
If only bong intelligence wasn't infested with commies. They pretty much helped killed Baltic and Albanian resistance in our timeline, imagine the hell they'd do if Unthinkable happened.
>>
File: 1655589071080.png (422 KB, 715x725)
422 KB PNG
>>65661637
Pull? Sure. Pidors were wrecked to shit with the german rampage and lend lease plugged in all the holes left in the machine.

Would? Absolutely not. just like today, there was no political will to fight pidors head on. Too far/out of sight, out of mind etc. Stalin, as a typical thieving gangster, knew that his chances were dodgy from all of the probing he did on the allies post war. Culminating with the Korean war that supposedly scrapped his temptation to pull the trigger on a later european war a couple of years further. Of course he died/maybe was assassinated in 1952 by Beria so we will never know for sure
>>
>>65661637
Yes. A western invasion would have been joined by local anti commie forces
>>
File: 1671464069057294.webm (2.91 MB, 640x360)
2.91 MB
2.91 MB WEBM
>>65661658
Germany was geographically way closer to the allies of UK and US. Latter via relatively free access to the north atlantic. Thus they were an existential threat and hitler was the devil incarnate. vatniks and stalin were too far to be perceived as a similar danger so it was easy to bankroll them as long as it fucked the germans

if their position had been switched at the start of the war we would have historical pics of Churchill, FDR and Hitler sitting together in the Yalta equivalent. Deciding how to carve up europe post war. Communists would only exist as an organized group as edgelord prison gangs. University campuses would have their rot of open, self confessed nazis and their apologists littering the student bodies and academics discussing the virtues of Hitler and how misunderstood visionary he was
>>
File: HWTiNQKWwAAo2H6.jpg (204 KB, 852x1144)
204 KB JPG
Dear diary
Today OP wasn't a fag and the anons are based
>>
>>65661686
>Of course he died/maybe was assassinated in 1952 by Beria so we will never know for sure

Stalin was 74, so it's very possible he simply just had a stroke but people were too scared to bug him so he lay there suffering for hours until he died. Fucker could have easily had another 6 years of power though, and could have caused so much more harm. Putin is 74 too, but modern medical science means this fucker is going to live to at least 80.
>>
Brits and Americans should have made a landing in Poland somehow, just to stop the USSR advance. I don't know if it's feasible, but a post-WW2 scenario with a divided Poland but in-tact Germany is far more tolerable, AND it would mean that any post-war conflict is more managable. Remember, the USSR wouldn't just occupy these territories, they were drafting the men and then using all the factories and economies to fund their war machine.

You can even go back farther: French should have mounted direct and indirect conflict against the Germans when they invaded Poland. Royal Navy ships a bunch of French army units into Poland proper, while the rest of the French army fights and invades Germany from the west. Poland might not fall, or it might forestall the USSR invasion.

Fuck I hate continental imperialists, all they do is muck things up, ruin the countries they fight over, and get people killed. Imagine if before WW1 the Kaiser just sat back and said "Germany will be the scientific, academic, financial, cultural hegemon of Europe" and decided to do everything to avoid a full blown continental war?
>>
>>65661681
The Europeans defated the USSR not the USA, The cold war frontline was in Europe. West Germany and France has national service consciption for generations.
>>
File: 1770577634144259.jpg (479 KB, 1280x856)
479 KB JPG
>>65661734
I'm going to bite.
Yes, it was a team effort. NATO forces arrayed along the inner-German border for forty years included large numbers of Brits, Germans, French, Danes, Belgians, Dutch, and Americans.
It was a team effort, with the United States quarterbacking and winning the Heisman.
>>
>>65661668
Based retard
>>
>>65661644
Americans need to learn from their lessons getting involved in WWII too little, too late, and follow the UK's lead today and confront Russia militarily. It is the only way for the US to retain any semblance of credibility.
>>
>>65661658
For being niggers
>>
>>65661644
Not doing it was the biggest blunder.
We had nukes. It would have been a cake wake.
Now they have nukes.
Perma stalemate with only surrogate action.
Thanks
>>
>>65661686
Lend-lease was the worst fucking mistake the WAllies ever made. Should've just let the two retards wear each other out.
>>
>>65661637
>>65661656
It's also unwise to consider just how much Russia relied upon the lend-lease practices of the Americans. Russia had the people, but the vast majority of the guns, tanks, and other weapons, of the Russian war machine had been supplied by the United States.
Without that supply being provided by the Allies, Russia didn't really have the industrial capacity for another war. Especially considering just how destroyed the Russian mainland was during the Nazi invasion.
>>
>>65661834
"Vast majority of guns, tanks and other weapons" is a crazy exaggeration. However many critical sectors of the industry would stop functioning without further LL and some stuff like high octane aviation fuel required for high altitude interceptors would cease to exist. The trucks wouldn't go anywhere but they would stop receiving spare parts.
>>
>>65661658
Things were already too far gone in western Europe to repair any meaningful and trustworthy relationship with the Nazi government. Hitler was butthurt, Churchill was butthurt, Free France was mega butthurt. Only thing that could and did resolve it is one side capitulating. Now, had Mr. Hitler focused east of Berlin and dealt with French and Anglo paranoia he may had been getting Lee tanks to invade Moscow.
>>
>>65661854
How does Churchill refusing to accept any peace offers factor in there?
>>
>>65661637
Probably, but why waste another 500,000 American lives so Churchill can remain in office a bit longer and America will have to rebuild even more of Europe? These "America defeats all the communists right after WW2" relies on America willing to waste massive amounts of lives and money to defeat countries for the sake of defeating them. Post Unthinkable America would be like post-WW2 Britain with a debt to GDP ratio likely well above 150%, and post Unthinkable Britain would be more like modern Cuba woth rationing likely continuing until the late 50s or 60s.
>>
>>65661890
Hitler would have to form Aryan NATO instead of absorbing everyone who vaguely was Germanic.
>>
>>65661890
>Hey you give up all ambitions on the continent and accept France as a German vassal in perpetuity and have it glibally known that your offers of security are worthless. Meanwhile we have zero means of actually defeating you and forcing you into submission.

Hitler had no leverage, if Britain refused peace Germany had no means to actually force their hand. They couldn't win in North Africa, they had no means of invading Britain, starving Britain with submarines was a meme and never feasible. Best case scenario you have a Napoleon style Continental System and blockade and Britain was just fine keeping that war in perpetuity until France collapsed 130 years earlier.
>>
Even Churchill was too optimistic, Britain's economy and infrastructure was collapsing by 1945 and without a serious uptick in US support (which wouldn't happen because the US overestimated the threat of the British Empire) the bottom would fall out. The Commonwealth was also not going to sign-off on it even if London tried to do it unilaterally, ditto France.

That's a serious problem for a plan looking at how a quick war could blunt the Soviet domination of Eastern Europe before the US (it was believed) would withdraw and demobilise. The lesser known defensive plan was also a stupid - even war losing - plan.

>>65661648
In term of air-power it was closer than you think. The Soviets had more aircraft which were also better deployed in 1945 with a doctrine to help win the war on the ground as flying artillery and low-altitude dogfighters which makes it even worse for the vastly outnumbered western armies trying to defeat numerically superior and battle-hardened Soviet units. You also have to look at the absolute shitshow that would be the Iran and Middle East campaigns.

Where the Soviets would fall short is in the strategic air war and night fighting but that's not going to work in what was a limited surprise war. Destroying the remaining bridges and rail in Poland won't speed up the allied advance, it will just slow into an attrition war. A war the allies could win but only if we go into some fantasy land where nobody asks why they're fighting or why at least not deal with Japan first.

>>65661658
Because Germany was an enormous aggressive threat to the world in a way the Soviet Union never was. Wehraboos need to leave.

>>65661699
>>65661648
>You've got dozens of groups you can support for anti-commie rebellions

That's a both-way affair and pre-1956 it might turn out to be horribly one-sided in Italy, France and Greece. That's just looking at Europe without getting into the European colonies in the Middle East and Central Asia.
>>
File: 1781530381317569.mp4 (193 KB, 600x434)
193 KB
193 KB MP4
>>65661637
Baku is turned into a nuclear crater and any Soviet ability to conduct offensives over land is completely stopped. Causalities would still be extremely high for the allies but a mechanized army vs one that has to basically be foot bound is gonna go badly for the foot bound one.
>>
>>65661922
>Because Germany was an enormous aggressive threat to the world in a way the Soviet Union never was.
lmao go read a history book nigger
>>
>>65661922
The USSR was literally in offensive formations when Germany rolled into them. Stalin thought he was going to backstab Hitler while he was dealing with Europe and roll all the way to Paris. Germany was the bigger threat only because Stalin was retarded when it came to actualizing his goals.
>>
>>65661942
Operation Cobra, my beloved.
>>
There was a good post on twitter today about operation magic carpet, where the US converted over 300 ships to transport troops back to the US asap, they literally converted aircraft carriers just to ship troops home. like they demobilized millions of men and shipped them back home so fast the admirals called it a rout. so that was the mindset of the us at the end of the war, think of how desperate the rest of europe let alone the germans/axis powers.

it would have taken the ussr charging into europe and killing allied troops to make them attack, anything less would have caused a mutiny and political collapse at home, and it was probably the same for russia, even though they are commies their guys were jsut as exausted and wanted to go home (for the first time in 4 years)
>>
if the will was there, easily. however, the will to continue the war was absolutely gone among the populace.
>>
>>65661943
Okay.

>>65661949
That's a fringe theory from the 90s. Stalin literally did everything possible to avoid provoking Germany and then even once the invasion had begun was paralysed. What does exist is evidence based on unit reorganisation and rough plans to fight a war if it arose, none of which involve Stalin having any plan to the effect being found even after decades of searching.
>>
>>65661813
>Not doing it was the biggest blunder.
Supporting soviets for several decades straight was the biggest blunder. Not dealing with the issue Americans created asap is only the second biggest blunder.
>>
File: lendlease.png (2.39 MB, 1461x2066)
2.39 MB PNG
>>65661844
vast majority of strategic materials like aluminum, copper, rubber, explosives, propellants and their precursors would be more accurate. plus radios, avgas, planes, trucks, trains and a shit ton of food, especially non-perishable kind.
>>
>>65661637
>>65661656
Czechoslovakia joined the Soviet sphere of influence only after elections in 1948. And I believe that Hungary, Poland or Romania were also rather not aligned to either block in 1945. In other words, Soviets would be mostly alone.
>>
File: 1768435292988302.jpg (1.18 MB, 1860x1312)
1.18 MB JPG
>>65661961
>they literally converted aircraft carriers just to ship troops home
Even just as is carriers make for great transports just from having so much open space on them.
>>
>>65661961
>>65662011
And here is Saratoga during Magic Carpet too.
>>
Interior of Enterprise during Magic Carpet.
>>
File: 1783016769891379.jpg (146 KB, 1280x844)
146 KB JPG
this is now a based late war image dump thread

imagine being a soviet lend lease tank operator during unthinkable, ur getting friendly fired immediately
>>
File: 1788796290134665.png (1.07 MB, 1201x799)
1.07 MB PNG
>>65662039
I've seen these Emchas and an SU-(100?) labeled as being Dmitry Loza in Vienna though I have no way to confirm that.
>>
>>65661922
Found the tankie
>>
>>65661983
Several decades?
>>
>>65661972
>none of which involve Stalin having any plan to the effect being found even after decades of searching.
Most of the documents regarding the immediate pre-war period were destroyed on Stalin's orders in 1943.
>>
I'm not sure, but today combined Russian and American military could easily defeat Europe.
>>
>>65662086
ignoring Roosevelt saving imperial russia's far east from Japan US had continuously supported soviets with technology, equipment and food since the 1920s.
>>
>>65661922
>The Soviets had more aircraft which were also better deployed in 1945 with a doctrine to help win the war on the ground as flying artillery
the problem here is that western allied doctrine was about seizing air superiority and soviet air power would be drastically limited in coverage, IL-2s were already suffering high losses against the severely weakened luftwaffe and wouldnt dare to make an action against fighter sweeps

>Where the Soviets would fall short is in the strategic air war and night fighting
soviets would lack the ability to seize anything but localized air power close to their lines, but overall air power would be allied

and soviet air parity would quickly disappear since the US had over 10,000 fighters in the US that were never shipped to europe due to germanys impending defeat
this would tip the balance in the allies favor in numbers
>>
>>65661922
soviets couldn't manage parity even against one fifth of the Luftwaffe, all while the other 80% were struggling against allied onslaught in the west.

the only thing in soviets worse than the air force was their navy.
>>
Soviet war plans until the late 50s basically boil down to fighting retreat across Eastern Europe to the Soviet border.
It wasn't until the USSR had sufficient nukes of their that they began making war plans aimed at striking towards western Europe. So yeah, unthinkable would've worked or at least it would've ensured Eastern Europe wouldn't be in the Soviet sphere.
>>
>>65662002
The very purpose of Operation Unthinkable was that Stalin had already established his grip on Eastern Europe.

>>65662099
How convenient that all the proof of a less likely thing were destroyed and nothing ever surfaced again.

>>65662124
The point is that the air space would be contested both in the air and by AD. Which was Soviet doctrine. The knockout blow from allied airpower wouldn't come, certainly not at the tactical level to turn the tide on the battlefield.

>and soviet air parity would quickly disappear since the US had over 10,000 fighters in the US that were never shipped to europe due to germanys impending defeat

That assumes that these fighters would arrive in time and wouldn't tip off the Soviets. We actually have the numbers from the planning putting it at 8,800 Allied aircraft against 12,800 Soviet aircraft without getting into the distances allied aircraft were flying during the war.
>>
File: 1776991386189816.jpg (436 KB, 1200x800)
436 KB JPG
>>
>>65662189
>The point is that the air space would be contested both in the air and by AD
soviets have no way to stop allied air superiority, their fighters fly too low and just lack overall combat performance

>Which was Soviet doctrine.
soviet doctrine wouldnt be able to challenge allied air power for very long or over a wide enough area

>That assumes that these fighters would arrive in time and wouldn't tip off the Soviets
discounting them would be dumb, since they would counter any losses taken early on
and these were generally the newer and more capable designs
soviets would have very little they can do about them even if they knew they were coming, there would just be more allied fighters in the skies and nothing they can do to offset it
>>
To add to the poster above, and correct me if im wrong but the allies had a huge advantage in long range tactical and strategic bombing, they could easily do something similar to a "big week" on the soviets and hit every air base in eastern europe, probably only the b-29s could reach deep into russia proper but that would just keep them focused on beating down actual soviet air power, then immobilize their ground lines of communication. so this guy is probably right.
>>65662162
>>
>>65662215
not on their factories in the urals, those are too far for anything other than B-29s, and only barely for those
but interdiction of rearward logistics would be deadly
>>
>>
>>65662221
>muh soviet "armies"
impressiev, the ploy to call your every unit a name that implies it's one size bigger is still working
>>
>>65662219
>those are too far for anything other than B-29s
Just fly there from Turkey/Iran, ezpz
>>
>>65661644
Wasn't everyone really tired of the war at this point though? Would be a hard sell if so
>>
>>65662226
BTFO him.
>>
>>65661637
>>65661644
>>65661648
>>65661686
If in the immediate aftermath of the Fall of Berlin, what would happen is an immediate revolt by the GIs after having been told that Ivan was their friend and that they were supplying them the whole time. But lets play some games, and declare mind control so this doesn't happen.

The Americans and British get a rude wake up call when the enemy is no longer falling over themselves to surrender. And an even ruder wakeup call when they find out how massive the Communist support was in France and Italy. The Communists were a cunthair away from controlling France originally, and Italy had to have its votes rigged to prevent the Reds from taking over in elections.

Yugoslavia and Greece fall immediately, there is nothing there that could stop what the Red Army has stationed in that area. As for Austria and Germany, the Western Allies will eat a million casualties in a month against an enemy with just as much arty and just as many tanks and they have.

Thats the issue for the West. they faced the dregs and leftovers that the Axis could raise against them, and most of those men surrendered when they could. The Reds won't surrender and are in prime fighting shape.

>>65661905
Try a solid million at minimum. The Germans deployed less than 4000 tanks to defend France against American and British liberation. The Soviets brought over 5000 to the Fall of Berlin alone.

So when Patton got to do his great relocation to fight in the Battle of the Bulge? He wouldn't be able to do so, because he would already be busy fighting against Soviet armies himself.

All this while France and Italy turn hostile. Again.
>>
>>65662202
>soviets have no way to stop allied air superiority

Could the Soviets contest an airspace with the aircraft and AD they had available? Yes. There is no real argument about it over the period covered by Operation Unthinkable.

>their fighters fly too low

Less relevant than you think for actions that influence the immediate battlefield. There's an optimum height for supporting ground operations which impacts tactical and ground-attack, ceiling is an advantage but this is still an era of dogfights. This is really why Soviet aircraft were designed that way compared to the best allied aircraft that were optimised for bomber escort and very long-range missions.

It's also not a complete walkover on a fighter-fighter level, manoeuvrability and weight was a Soviet advantage while Western aircraft held the advantage in power, ceiling, armament and night-flying. I'd also question how far you can lean into an air-power victory given we have the Korean War to go off where it wasn't able to strike a decisive blow.

>>65662215
You're underestimating just how much mass the Soviets had. Strategic bombers would work but it would take a long period of time to degrade the Soviet airforce and AA with what the allies had available, this is without getting into other priorities like supporting WW2.5 down below.
>>
>>65662310
>Could the Soviets contest an airspace with the aircraft and AD they had available
no, not even close
soviets would struggle to wrest any kind of air parity
>>
>>65661993
This is true. But that stuff is already shipped and sent, its one of the many reasons its called "Operation Unthinkable".

Without that though, we could have made landfall in France in around the same time. Germany would have been stuck trying to hold down and extract anything useful out of the former Soviet Union. And then the march to Berlin takes longer but is only a little bloodier, because America isn't actually in a rush like the Soviets were.
>>
>>65662320
>>65662310
It also forgets how long it took to pound Germany into rubble. Which is a smaller country with more conveniently closer air bases.
>>
>>65662328
Germany also had several times the industry of the entire soviet union, with much better science and engineering behind it. it also wasn't quite struggling to keep its population from starving to death in the meantime despite the bombings.
>>
>>65662310
> manoeuvrability and weight was a Soviet advantage while Western aircraft held the advantage in power, ceiling, armament and night-flying
Good thing the Americans haven’t spent the last three and a half years fighting against aircraft that had an advantage in maneuverability, right?
>>
>>65662341
oh god, imagine the kill ratios of late-war US aircraft against the garbage plywood shitrods of the soviets. it'd make German aces look away in shame.
>>
>>65662328
strikes against logistics closer to the front would be absolutely destructive and prevent the soviets from moving troops horizontally across the front
>>
>>65662310
mass is kind of a disadvantage when faces with mid range logistics strikes, all those artillery need ammo ships on a few banged up railways through poland, germany and the balkens, a whole lend leased motor transport pool that is now being hunted down by thousands of allied planes.

sure the first weeks will be a test for allied formations but soon those soviet armies will run out of fight and struggle to even move.
>>
>The tankie thinks his little commie fantasies would stand up to the combined hatred of Curtis LeMay AND Bomber Harris
LMAO
>>
>>65662334
>several times the industry
no.


>better engineering
also no. Ther KV and IS series were bother superior heavy designs.
>>
>>65662347
>The speed of the advance of the Army and Marines from the east across Siberia is only limited by how fast the SeeBees can build new runways
>>
>>65662375
>no.
yes.
>Ther KV and IS series
literal irrelevant nothingburgers

got anything else to say, pidor?
>>
>>65662051
Soviet M4's have a certain "orkish" quality to them. Like captured Leman Russ tanks in 40k, except they were given not captured.
>>
File: 1625858573319.jpg (34 KB, 580x548)
34 KB JPG
>>65662381
>tfw you just spent 4 years building a massive supply chain across 10000 miles of oceans, carving ports and airfields into isolated atolls and pacific hellholes, then you're told to build a railroad across Siberia
>>
File: videoframe_40205.png (1.97 MB, 1920x1080)
1.97 MB PNG
>>65662347
> imagine the kill ratios of late-war US aircraft against the garbage plywood shitrods of the soviets

Thanks to this little known late war friendly fire incident, we don't have to imagine.

https://youtu.be/TNBlwhjKrYw[embed]
>>
>>65661753
waiting until later was literally the smart move for the US.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.