no, transgenders are just a neutered slave caste for female elites to humiliate and control
gender and sex are determined by chromosomes

>>43724489
this could work for me. being a court eunuch is kinda aesthetic

>>43724471
gender is a two sided coin, how you see yourself and how society sees you. you are a woman because that's how you see yourself but that doesn't mean that other people will treat you that way. that takes a lot of effort. I wish it didn't. if you're struggling, make sure you find community outside of this website. I come here because it's funny, not because its helpful. I hope you find yourself, but you are a girl.

>>43724471
Honestly gender identity as a concept is a psyop, it's a lot freer to not care about whether you count as a woman or not

>>43724471
i believe you should look into "agender", since that lowk seems to be how u may identify
tho the humiliation ritual is not that bad if u jack off to being mistreated, it's up to you

>>43724580
yeah i mean kinda but i do want to be a woman i just don't really think i am one, i just really don't want to be a man. identifying as agender doesn't really solve the "people see me as a man problem" so it feels kinda pointless. this is a broader problem with my identity in general, its just a series of negations. i don't really feel like a person at all, mostly just like a collection of things i don't want to be. i feel like a ghost.

>>43724471
Gender is a spook. You can call yourself whatever you want, it doesn't actually change anything material. On the other hand that also means if it's convenient to call yourself a woman you can just do it.
Wanting to be a woman does mean that you might be comfier in a body with female secondary sex characteristic though.

>>43724471
You are a third gender thing
Forever

Don't worry about it
Nonbinary amabs are redundant since they want to be transwomen but are cowards