My 16 year old sister has a trans girl in her class and I asked my sister about her (I am curious about trannies and want to be a trannylogist).Here's what I learned about her>you can absolutely not tell that she's trans from her face at all, she looks completely female (she showed me pictures)>when my sister showed me her class photo and I tried to guess which one was the trans girl I guessed wrong like 10 times>she's kinda in the largeishaggregated friend group my friend is in>my sister says she's incredibly nice, like very very nice>my sister says you can tell something is off with her body (that it's not female basically)>mentions that her ass goes inwards (?) like the guys' asses>also says she kinda walks strangely ("sways her hips too much to make it look like she has ass" - my sister)>doesn't change with the other girls (her choice)>my sister believes she takes hormones and stuff (says she goes to a doctor (my sister doesn't really have an idea (so she might just be on blockers for all i know)))>she doesn't like talk about the trans stuff, no one brings it upIf a youngshit doesn't body pass does that mean she has only been on blockers?
>>43739034>If a youngshit doesn't body pass does that mean she has only been on blockers?yeah probably women's faces are neotenous, the same as a cis boys, but their bodies are feminised, if you take blockers as a pre-pubescent AMAB you'll keep your neotenous features, but not developed a feminised body for which you need estrogen
>>43739084I see, so I am an extremist for trans rights then, since I now support giving estrogen (or test) to the young ones.
>>43739571first actual based ally in history holy shit <3yeah puberty blockers are by no mean perfect for reasons you've observed
>>43739583I kinda just feel bad for her now (the hip swaying is really sad when you think about it). I have heard trannies say that Norway is kinda shit and it makes sense to me now. The trans girl in question is in a very supportive environment (parents, friends etc.) but it seems our doctors (laws?) won't give you what you need
>>43739034>>43739571yup, if you want a more thorough explanation, all political discussion regarding it is purely artificial and forced. puberty blockers are almost entirely pointless for trans kids beyond politics.the issue is that dysphoria is latent from birth and onsets mentally essentially from when the kid can start to form any thoughts (which is why reppers think they don't have it, they've literally never known what its like to not have it) and reverse dysphoria undeniably exists (cisgender people experiencing dysphoria when made to live as the opposite sex or taking hrt) so the rate of false diagnoses are extremely low, and cis kids who think theyre trans usually avoid hrt or go off it extremely quickly and only really do so because of the cultural connotations induced toward being trans as a product of the massive political astroturfing involved in the whole deal (for some quick evidence of this, people weren't inherently opposed to the idea of trans people in the 20th century and all claims it's anti-christian are wholly fabricated)besides the consequences of a cis kid transitioning for 1 year are equal to that of a trans kid not transitioning for 1 year if you don't view the second as ontologically inferior so it's ridiculous to bar it.also if she IS on hormones it's extremely likely she's being given a comically low dose. undeniably medical malpractice but its normalized so(also your question at the end of OP will trigger a schizo poster that spams this board who incorrectly believes sex dimorphism is determined entirely by chromosomes. they are unironically insane. ignore them if they post)
>>43740810I don't say phenotype is only determined by genotype, just that sex is chromosomal. Of course phenotype is going to be different if you alter it, and I don't oppose it. Transgender care is important
