How do I convince my pet incel not to transition? I am the only friend he's ever had, and I think those thoughts are a result of me interacting with him. He brings it up regularly. He would be a sex pest hyperpoly transbian if he went that route, and I need to keep him from becoming that and regretting it ten years later. We're both young adults.
>>45287012What do you think adults means. We're both 20.
>>45287002Just let her troon out hypocrite.
>>45287023I am trans because I like men. I have a boyfriend and we've been dating for four years. He is thinks he is trans because he wants attention. He has had nobody other than me his entire life.>>45287031Because I clarified our stage of life for context?
>>45287043>I am trans because I like menoh my god kids are so annoying
>>45289038It's a statement of fact. Seethe about me transitioning at 14 all you want. But more importantly this is not at all related to the actual purpose of this thread.
>>45287002Does he get to suck your gock?
>>45289686No. He isn't my boyfriend, I'm monogamous, and post SRS as of this year. Once again, this isn't related to the subject of the thread.
>>45287043>He is thinks he is trans because he wants attention. He has had nobody other than me his entire life.>actually im trans for all the RIGHT reasons you see. every other tranny is a disgusting PERV except ME.you sound like a shitty friend. let her troon out and let her asshole be a revolving door for her polycule. she'll get over it eventually
>>45289705You could still get a strapon and let him suck on it
>>45287043>I'm a heckin valid twanny because of my overclocked sexism!!I wish everyone really appreciated how insanely sexist theyfabs, troons, and poons are
>>45289715>>45289734My transition has nothing to do with the subject. In fact I have actively pointed that out several times. The only reason I mentioned it was because I was called a hypocrite erroneously (because, once again, my transition isn't relevant to the topic). I don't care what trans people do with their time generally, I just know him transitioning specifically would not go well. I have explained this to my transbian friends and they agree with me.
>>45289716That's not how monogamy works.
>>45289752> I have explained this to my transbian friends and they agree with medesu id never stop my friend from trooning out even if i knew theyd end up being a walking optics nuke. its not my life, not my decision, not my problem. if she troons out and starts becoming insufferable, just end the friendship. not saying you have to actively encourage transitioning, but actively discouraging it makes u a shitty person imo
>>45289787He has said he doesn't experience dysphoria and that he wishes he were a woman because people would like him more. This isn't an assumption of mine, it's just how he himself views things.
>>45287002you sound like a terrible friend, desunot too different than my former incel friends who moved away from me when i trooned (and they failed to convince me not to)>He would be a sex pest hyperpoly transbian if he went that routeAnd?Also, what if you're wrong?I ended up a married woman and it hasn't been 10 years yet. Didn't end up a transbian (due to lack of opportunity) nor poly (though I thought about it).Neither of you can truly know what will be in 10 years and it's arrogant to claim otherwise. Even though I had a plan and it mostly worked out, i still wouldn't have believed it in 2017 that in 2026 i'll be legally married to a man and on an srs waitlist.if he has even a slight chance of making it as a tranny, not only you should let him try, but you should help, if you're a good friend. life's too short to be lived as an incel.
>>45289814>He has said he doesn't experience dysphoria and that he wishes he were a woman because people would like him morenta but he is right. speaking from experience.also, it's simply not true that one needs to experience dysphoria to want to troon out.
>>45289814just let her troon out. if youre a good friend youll help her with social transition so she doesnt have to go through a cringe phase and embarrass herself
>>45289864>>45289878>>45289884So I should convince him to transition purely because he thinks that that he would get more attention? I don't understand how encouraging that would be a good friend behavior. He doesn't take care of himself and in my opinion that's the root problem. I have been slowly helping him with that and now he takes regular showers.
>>45289814This implies that he knows what dysphoria is like. Show him the DSM 5 criteria and the gender dysphoria bible. If he relates to that and is not an idiot who thinks women have it easier, then it’s all good. You can’t stop it either way if he wants to do it, but he should atleast know what he is getting into or if he is just too numb to recognize the dysphoria.
>>45289916You people assume I'm either stupid or malicious. I have talked about it with him at length. If I didn't, I wouldn't have said that that is an opinion of his and not an opinion of mine.
>>45289907>So I should convince him to transition purely because he thinks that that he would get more attention?Under how many layers of autism are you?"Do not repress him" is not the same thing as "encourage him to troon out". You could just... not be an inconvenience??!You don't have to agree with his reasons. You don't owe him help necessarily. But you do owe him not to be an annoying foid who can't help herself from policing males' behavior.>He doesn't take care of himself and in my opinion that's the root problem. I have been slowly helping him with that and now he takes regular showers.Now we're talking.Yes, that's good for you. And yes, some incels are incels at least in part due to their own behaviors.However, what happens when/if after he does everything right he still gets no play? (as it happened to me) then what?the reason i trooned at (almost) 23 instead of almost 2 years earlier is because i really tried and thought that eventually things would/could improve if i just do everything "right" (and also trannies who insisted i shouldn't try because i don't have the magical "right" reasons to troon).
>>45289907>So I should convince him to transition purely because he thinks that that he would get more attentionhonestly i think this is just cope from his end. hes probably a pussy and has never made any big life decision so he wants to rationalize it as something thats not a big dealhe sounds depressed af. there could be a lot more going on hes not telling you about. help him see an endo and teach him how to socially transition and carry himself as a girl. you can literally prevent the things youre worried about him doing. maybe becoming a poly transbian is out of your control but like he'll probably grow out of that eventually
>>45289947>You people assume I'm either stupid or maliciousnta but while i don't think you're either, I do think you're at least as brainwormed as he is (or at least that's how you come off as in your posts).he is right to think being socially female is easier and YOU are right to think that he should take better care of himself (and good for you for encouraging at least that). more things at once can be true.JFC why can't you people just fucking drop this black-and-white extremist thinking? le sigh
>>45289655you don't know anything about why people transition. you didn't transition because you like men. go do your homework, kid!
>>45289973He would be fairly handsome if he actually took care of himself. The social awkwardness stuff would be a problem for him either way, so that's not a good reason in its own right.>>45290003He isn't generally depressed. His mood is fine in all ways other than socially. I don't mind teaching him to present more feminine, but I think hormones could make things harder in his future.>>45290004This assumes that he won't get attention if he took care of himself, which he probably would. It's like burning a house down to bake cookies instead of turning on the oven.
>>45290116>three replies, all wrong
>>45290097You are entitled to your opinion. In any case I don't think that is important for the topic.
>>45290131Yes, I'm sure strangers on the internet know my friend of three years to whom I am the sole support network of better than I do.
>>45290116>but I think hormones could make things harder in his future.yes, hes probably not going to be able to block his feelings out anymore once hes on e. better he does that now rather than later. if he listens to you, you can sculpt him into the perfect girlget him on hrt and a therapist
>>45290157I literally know her personally
>>45290137homework not done?
>>45290180Once again, I have talked to him about dysphoria and poked and prodded a lot. He isn't good at hiding things from me, whether or not he knows the thing in question. If he were repressing, he wouldn't exclusively feel bad socially instead of generally, he would have felt something when I interrogated him, etc. His mental health isn't poor, he just has an obstacle to being social that I am already helping him with.
>>45290116>The social awkwardness stuff would be a problem for him either wayyes, but nowhere near as mucha socially ackward female gets by way easier than a socially ackward incel and you know it.>so that's not a good reason in its own rightwho died and made you the arbiter of what's a good reason and what's not?>This assumes that he won't get attention if he took care of himselfit is an assumption based on statistical realitysure, it's not an absolute, but it's very likely that you are wrong.
>>45290221>His mental health isn't poor>incel that just started learning how to take showersidk his mental health sounds pretty shit to mewhy are you trying to gatekeep being trans? if youre there to help him i honestly dont see how this could go bad. are you upset solely because of his reasons for transitioning? i doubt hes done enough self reflection to give you any kind of honest answerlet him troon out
>>45290232He's 6'2" and moderately muscular. You are making assumptions based on statistics, I am making assumptions based on knowing the actual person and what he looks like *and* statistics.
>>45289947> stupid or maliciousPor que no los dosPlease tell me some more statements that are off topic so I can trigger you, I enjoy giving people exactly the attention they crave by posting their personal issues and sperging when they don't get the answers they wanted
>>45290290Transphobia is a real thing and he could trivially get by without it. He is an open book on every subject and I know what repressed dysphoria looks like. He could be handsome or socially shunned. I think one of the options is obviously better. My goal is to resolve this problem of his and he has already made progress.
>>45289864>wouldn't have believed it in 2017 that in 2026 i'll be legally married to a man and on an srs waitlist.nta but if you are who i think you are, i'm very happy to read this.congrats on making it.
>>45290331why are you asking for advice then if youre so sure of yourselfif you force him to rep bc hes not "trutrans" then youre a shitty friend imoeither help him be a girl or force him to cope and repi couldnt live with myself if i did the latter
>>45290382The question was how, not why. Regardless I don't care if people are 'really transgender,' I just know that this is a solution to a short term problem with long term consequences, and it's in his best interest as a person who knows him not to go down this path.
>thinks being an evil asshole is the gateway to achieving a trve femsoulholy
>He would be a sex pest hyperpoly transbian if he went that routewhat's another drop in a big big pool?
>>45290425I don't care about soul passing. I am content enough as it stands.>>45290437He's my friend and I care about him? I said before that I'm the only form of support he has and I don't take that job lightly.
>>45290406no one here is going to help you with how to make your incel friend repand no one should
>>45290449>I am content enough as it standsthe point is that you should not be.
>>45290406>20 year old acting like she knows enough to give someone life adviceholy shit my sides are going into orbit
>>45287002>He would be a sex pest hyperpoly transbian if he went that routeDo you know what happens to most cringe poly transbians? They get the puppygirl phase out of their system in their early 20s then mature to be chill about sex. Cis people do the same sex crazed things in their teens, its just seen as normal. >He brings it up regularly.Then he probably is just trans. Let them explore it and let them be cringe. Ideally, get out of their life because you're clearly a little bit of a sociopath.
>>45287002Tell him how much you regret it even if you don’t and how you’ll never be a woman and just wish you never tried. Tell him HRT gives you lots of fake health issues, you break your bones if you fall, you are horny but can’t cum, you get hot flashes and mood swings, etc.
>>45290932I actually did get hot flashes at one point early on. But yes, this is a general thing I'm considering (although I would be honest about my experiences).