[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/lgbt/ - Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, & Transgender


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: scarletmacaw.png (2.04 MB, 1800x1350)
2.04 MB PNG
Normal healthy man here. You guys know this shit is all fake right?
>>
>>45309930
everything is fake yes
>>
Birds being CIA drones has been known by the gay community since the 50s, yes.

Why do you think Mao had all those kids beat them with sticks, he was harvesting the electronics
>>
>>45309959
I mean the concept that men can become women and vice versa is fake and so is every outgrowth that stems from that faulty premise
>>
>>45309930
Yes, and I want to be an even better fake.
>>
>>45309930
I don't know I saw some at the zoo and they seemed pretty real to me.
>>
File: IMG_9265.gif (1006 KB, 372x298)
1006 KB GIF
>>45309930
Get a load of this simulation fag
>oh I’m not an npc, I’m a straight white guy, let me pay my taxes please
pffffff what a loser
>>
>>45310005
I have lots of contrary opinions but the belief that male and female are arbitrary/fluid is not one of them
>>
>>45309930
Gender was created by the CIA, you're not a man because men aren't real
>>
>>45310072
Have you remembered to thank the cia for creating men?
>>
File: IMG_2797.gif (888 KB, 500x286)
888 KB GIF
>>45310056
>guys listen I have opinions, opinions make me a real white human male. Everything has to stick to the parameters of a system, no I’m not a bot, I’m a white human heterosexual male
>>
>>45309984
let me be real…
1.why are you here?
2. Who literally gives a shit? like yes there are genuine bad apples? you can say they assault/rape/etc so many people but let me put something in your head “chad”. yk how many cis-het white/black/hispanic/etc people get charged for assault and rape?
So “Chad” before you come here hating people, i genuinely think you should look at yourself and realize how hateful you’re being to people who really just want to live. some people transition and that GIVES THEM a reason to live. i have the idea you’re one of those closeted chads who are so insecure, they want everyones life miserable!!
hope you rot in hell!!! <3
>>
>>45309984
yea thats also fake as i said everything is fake. ur life is based on facades and lies
>>
>>45310184
Then why does it feel so genuine?
>>
>>45310114
>>45310130
kek listen to this projection, you don't even know anything about me besides the fact that I disagree with the idea that sex is changeable, and you're calling me a "chad" and an npc basically, I wouldn't define myself as a chad and you have no grounds to assume that I'm some herd mentality cog in the machine type. If having one opinion in common with the majority makes someone an npc then literally everyone is either an npc or a mindless contrarian. You also accused me of hating people and told me to rot in hell. I'm just here reading because it interests me, and the one small post I make is met with insanity.
>>45310184
>everything is fake
wow. profound. If you're older than 20 I think you may be retarded
>>
>>45310223
because u are used to it and are fine with it for the most part. if anything its less genuine than people going their own way. but thats okay, we all have our own ways of coping... i just dont think u should take it as seriously as u do
>>
>>45310261
I mean plenty of us don't think sex is literally changeable and still transition, the situation is grim but it's about the most we can do.

Hormones do have tangible effects especially when used young, that's about the best we have atm.
>>
>>45310261
>If you're older than 20 I think you may be retarded
why do you think that
>>
>>45310287
That's sensible. I can't relate to the experience of yearning in futility so much for something I know is impossible. I could wish I was even more attractive, had an even bigger cock and even stronger arms, but at the end of the day I'm happy with what I've got and wouldn't reroll the dice on any of it. It makes me sad to see people torturing themselves, I think the problem is these people have no sense identity and possibly something unrelated also drives them to resent themselves, so they reject their own immutable characteristics.
>>45310295
Because "everything is fake" is a middle school aged child's idea of profundity
>>
>>45310374
>Because "everything is fake" is a middle school aged child's idea of profundity
sure it might be surface level but why do you think that its retarded
>>
>>45310393
this is fake so no point in responding
>>
File: IMG_3528.gif (800 KB, 220x178)
800 KB GIF
>>45310261
>if you disagree with me you are insane beep boop I AM A STRAIGHT WHITE MAN! I AM A PILGRIM IN AN UNCLEAN LAND
>>
>>45310420
see? its not that hard
>>
File: 5478562396.png (110 KB, 300x303)
110 KB PNG
>>45310374
Yes, that's why at least I agree with dysphoria as a medical condition, as someone who has it basically.

It started when I was a literal child, I tried for two decades to will it away with every other manner of thing and it was ultimately futile, 'just be a feminine guy bro' type things didn't do anything and it just kind of came down to 'well, it's this or roping'. I have no delusions about how much it can accomplish, I'm a feminine male trying to appear as female as possible as a cope.

I do wonder if brain sex theory has any merit, but we probably won't see real unbiased studies on that for decades with how polarized this issue is on either end of the political spectrum.
>>
>>45310423
Not necessarily but when I make a point and then describe my reasons for why I think it's the case and you respond with this, you can't possibly deny that I'm the one who's reasonable and you're being emotional, I'm open minded and you're dogmatic. There must be some reason why you think what you think, I'm asking you to explain it but you refuse.
>>
>>45310454
I like beautiful "feminine" things too. I love some stereotypically gay music like Abba and Depeche Mode, I have an appreciation for flowers and nature and such, I can even recognize what makes the male body beautiful, but I've never for a moment ever wanted to BE a woman. It doesn't turn me on sexually to think about acting like one, nor would it be fulfilling in any other way. I think if God could put my mind in a woman's body as I am now I would probably feel like most of you now.

But that's not the same as being born and living a life as male or female, and over time developing the desire that it could be different. I know there's cases throughout history of "trans" people but it's very obviously escalated by many orders of magnitude since the 2010's and I it's very very plain that this is the media's doing. I think there's a growing contingent of people in the modern world who have never faced any major trials or tribulations at all in their lives and thus have a greatly diminished sense of self compared to previous generations. I think part of it is that people unconsciously want to create problems to solve and obstacles to overcome in the absence of conflict.
>>
File: Agamemnon.jpg (87 KB, 1200x1200)
87 KB JPG
>>45309930
>normal
>on 4chin
>>
>>45310672
Yeah uh, I had dysphoria when I six in like 1997 and came out to my parents in 1999. I don't think the 2010s trans boom is responsible for my dysphoria.

What you're describing, I get the break you're having with things. It's not really about beauty though, beauty is useful for being read as female socially because female social roles also center around providing it, but ultimately that's just a tool to try to get closer to being read as female in social situations despite not being female.

It doesn't turn me on either, I'm not agp in the slightest. I like guys, usually taller than me and my only actual fantasies tend to be fairly domestic sadly.
>>
>>45310775
If you never transitioned do you think you would just be a gay guy? Don’t you think there are examples of kids doing tons of weird shit, not just violating the conventions of their gender but of their nature overall, which are not indicative of anything and never lead to anywhere abnormal in the long run? What if it would’ve been just a phase? Be honest, fuck what anyone else here thinks. Do you think the AGP transbian types are more of a genuine danger to themselves and people around them than the “straight” trannies? By “danger” I mean more likely to commit violent crime, groom children, harm themselves
>>
>>45311012
no, I tried to just 'be a gay guy' for many years, my parents were accepting of that but deeply skeptical of trans things, but ultimately sex didn't have a lot to do with it, I felt like I should have been born female and even if I wasn't female it wasn't going anywhere.

I don't think AGPs are inherently more dangerous than other trannies honestly, they just have much worse optics because they sit at a fault line of a lot of societal fears about maleness and the unkown.
>>
>>45309930
do you want an award for being a normalfag?
>>45310374
Chromosomal sex may be immutable but secondary sex characteristics are not.
>>45310672
dysphoria is not "liking feminine things"
>>
>>45311567
It was my understanding that most troons fully believed that people could change their sex to where there’s no meaningful difference between a biological woman and a trans woman but it’s good to see that you’re not that retarded anymore. This was the case not long ago.
>>
>>45310056
Well, don't forget the intersex conditions.
>>
>>45311567
Also seeing as 10% of the threads on this board are people talking about killing themselves I’d like to offer some advice on how to not go insane and jump off a bridge but it involves renouncing the whole catechism of tranny dogma
>>
>>45312076
Irrelevant
>>
>>45312006
Anymore? Depending on what you mean by "meaningful difference" I never believed that and it's never been a popular opinion on this board. "TWAW" is just meaningless virtue signaling.
>>45312097
"just be normal bruh" is not actually useful advice for people who never were and never will be normal
>>
>>45312006
you must be new here, or very young, that kind of thing really only happens in mainstream lgbt spaces where things like queer theory and gender studies supercede reality, which is a mindset most people here don't have, and really only became mainstream around partway through the 2010s.
Prior to that most trannies didn't need to literally convince people of anything, the goal was to just kind of exist and if possible avoid drawing unnecessary attention to ourselves.
>>
>>45312257
>>45312192
No, you’re full of shit, or you’re new. Very predictable of you to deny the past idiocy of your community but I was here then too. It was no more than five years ago at most that the prevailing belief on this board was that trans women are exactly the same as real women and you were not only evil but stupid if you thought different. Some people weren’t complete cultists, but most were. I remember reading thread after thread full of retards defending this exact position, and this opinion still seems to be the norm everywhere but here. “Trans women are women” is a famous refrain.
>>
>>45312192
You’re using “normal” as a substitute for simple-minded, I would call it healthy or natural
>>
>>45312323
I've been here longer than 5 years... Idk how hyperbolic you're being but if you're intending me to take your statement literally it was definitely not the prevailing belief.
>>45312386
I'm using "normal" to mean normal. It's not inherently simple minded to be normal if you have enough brain capacity to understand that not everyone is the same or works the same.
>>
>>45309930
we are fucking proteins that came from a meteor that reproduced for millions of years and eventually evolved to think, build computers and frogpost
we are overdue a total life destroying meteor but by sheer luck we are still here fucking around with made up concepts like economies
what the fuck is real?
the pixels on screens are just different wavelengths of light that we interpret as an images
at any time we could be wiped out from sheer indifference from the universe and wavelengths won't mean shit
language will have no meaning
nothing will look like anything because eyes won't exist anymore rocks will just exist as just large unperceived clumps of particles
what the fuck does it matter if it is all fake
you don't see chromosomes or proteins, you see human beings with souls and shit
and if you wanna view things as fake then like waste your time arguing about unperceived proteins on the other side of the galaxy
>I like dopamine
>kissing my boyfriend gives me dopamine
>my boyfriend playing with my tits and fucking my ass gives me dopamine
>being perceived as a woman makes my life easier to navigate
if you wanna be like "it's all fake" then nigga care about currency language or proteins instead since it matters the same amount
>>
>>45312476
>I've been here longer than 5 years... Idk how hyperbolic you're being but if you're intending me to take your statement literally it was definitely not the prevailing belief.
Whatever man. It may have been longer, ~8 years, but the experience is logged in my memory, I saw what I saw and it's informed my opinion on the subject to this day. I could dig through the archives and point to things but no matter how many examples I come up with I know I'll just be accused of cherry-picking. The opinion was definitely more popular and it's still verifiably popular in places other than here. Fine, you're a slim cut above the rest. It's still full of people who wanna kill themselves, maybe you don't have it all sorted out.
>>
>>45312547
>there are things we don't understand
to
>nothing matters
is a hell of a leap
>>
>>45312476
>I'm using "normal" to mean normal. It's not inherently simple minded to be normal if you have enough brain capacity to understand that not everyone is the same or works the same.
two relevant points:
>most of the people here are <25
>being trans saw a gargantuan spike in incidence around the time that it became a pop culture topic
You would have to be retarded to not see these as related. Being normal wasn't nearly so torturous for all of human history before the 2010's. I don't think a lot of the people that post here have ever actually tried being normal. I think from the time they could reason they've identified as "counter-cultural" (which is a misnomer because there's little to no social cost to being trans- in fact there are many benefits- the costs are all self imposed and avoidable). Rejecting it is what exacts a cost. The confused people here would ultimately be healthier and happier if they rejected it and followed the previously established path.
>>
>>45309930
The irony of this whole pissy pseudo-intellectual ego masturbation you're doing is that YOUR position is entirely based on vibes.
Pure unadulterated vibes + post hoc rationalisation of your disgust reflex.
>there's little to no social cost to being trans
hahahahahahahahaha
>in fact there are many benefits
clownwrld.jpg
>
how could you possibly know that?
seriously.
So did you only finish high school or do your have one of those business "degrees"?
I'm trying to figure out which exact kind of overconfident midwit you are
>>
>>45312323
you don't seem capable of learning, every now and then waves of sneeds find their way here when one of our memes breaks out so maybe you just logged in on a bad time because I genuinely have never seen that be a mainstream thing here
>>
"baby's first transphobia" type thread
bro is like the level 1 transphobes you fight in the cave when you start the game
>>
>>45310551
>open minded
>starts a thread with the preconceived notion basing an entire demographic through stereotypes, or being incapable of fathoming the trannies that do have improved and happier lives post transition
You’re just bait engagement.
>>
Yeah it is all fake. The only thing more fake is heterosexuality. Try fucking a girl without performing and let's see how it goes, good luck!
>>
>>45312844
I don't entirely disagree about the trender problem, but I also highly doubt that most of those people identifying as trans online or on surveys are actually transitioning. The recent numbers are most likely very inflated from what they actually are.
>Being normal wasn't nearly so torturous for all of human history before the 2010's
It was for some people. Trans people were definitely around before the 2010s even if it was considered icky to talk about on mainstream tv.
>there's little to no social cost to being trans- in fact there are many benefits
okay dude I'm sorry but this is just completely delusional, the real world is not a discord
It isn't "confusion." People are born different, that's why there is no universal path they can all take to the same destination.
>>
>>45312981
I’m not angry and “pseudo-intellectual ego masturbation” is your categorization of me, my only casual interest is in finding out why you people think pretending you’re something you’re not will make you happy. Believe it or not it troubles me to see so many miserable people over an issue that has a simple solution. There are obviously undeniable benefits to being trans and few practical costs. The people who don’t like you hold no power over you, the people who want to use you as a feather in their cap are hiring and eager to promote. The only lucrative line of work you’re less likely to advance in is anything that deals with customers/clients face to face, and even then it’s not universal. I barely finished high school and never wanted for money.
>>45313012
I am very open minded but I have opinions too. They can change and frequently do. I admitted that maybe I overestimated here >>45312677 and conceded.
>>45313017
I have no idea what you’re trying to say
>>
>>45313124
Being open minded typically doesn’t mean drawing conclusions off of stereotypes especially when it comes to judging demographics. Your usually go and learn more about a community directly so you don’t just develop knee-jerk reactions like people have towards white people being pedophiles that love bombing 3rd world countries, or black people and crime, or mexicans and border hopping.

Like you came to this thread immediately establishing that trannies are delusional, can not possibly be happy or better off transitioning, and hovering around this idea that if they just accepted themselves they’d be better off; like as if trannies didn’t ALREADY try that as a starting point, or have seen professional help in not being a tranny to begin with.

It just comes off as
>i know better than you but I also have humility and intelligence above the rest
Get off your high horse first.
>>
>>45313153
Sometimes the truth does align with stereotypes, they aren’t established out of nowhere. You can’t know how I arrived at this conclusion, or how many times I’ve questioned it or seen it verified. I have no agenda, stake, or interest in seeing any outcome, I have my opinion based on what I’ve observed in others and what I know about myself. That’s how I reached this conclusion.

I suspect that most trans people’s efforts to accept themselves were strongly undermined by the fact that it’s currently a movement in vogue. They’re largely young and impressionable and parents hold less and less influence over their kids’ ideological development as the internet becomes more pervasive in our lives. This is backed up by the fact that incidence of trans identifying kids spiked drastically when it became a regular topic of conversation driven by the media. All these causes are what form my basis for thinking that being trans is just an artificial and damaging fad.

I guess would prefer to be liked but not at the cost of altering what I want to say. What I’m trying to say is: we normal people feel bad for you, we want you to know we don’t hate you, we’re not disgusted by you, but we think that you’re trapped in a feedback loop of delusion, which was set in motion by unelected amoral oligarchs who hate all common people and want us all to be weaker collectively.

The trans issue is a drop in the bucket of social dilemmas but it’s really tragic that so many young people are languishing in this self imposed torture chamber because they were never had a chance to witness and understand normal healthy human behavior specifically as it pertains to sex. This generation, myself included, was so inundated with porn and social decay from elementary school to the point that many believe this is how it’s supposed to be. The few of us that were lucky enough to elude this sick plot feel it’s incumbent on us to scream that this shit is fucked up.
>>
>you people think pretending you’re something you’re not will make you happy
Is the leit-motif of "straight" "heterosexual" "men"
>>
>>45313124
>Believe it or not it troubles me to see so many miserable people over an issue that has a simple solution.
Do tell me the "simple solution" to my dysphoria. inb4 "le media" or "le ideology", it started pre-puberty when transgenderism was not in the public eye. I live in a third world country where transgenderism is not highly publicised and would not be acceptable. I've tried getting a job and lifting weights and dating girls and being "a normal man" because I originally held all of the opinions that you put forward in this thread, and none of it made me want to peel my skin off any less, because the trans issue is downstream of my irreparably abnormal psychology and not any ideological conviction, as you seem to think.
Also, the reason that you're being so poorly received is that you're claiming to be open minded while also attempting to mandate a particular life path dictated by your own conception of "normalcy". Telling people that you know best what they should do with their lives is a uniquely effective way to piss them off regardless of whether or not they're trannies.
>>
>>45313387
the oligarchs have you trapped in a feedback loop arguing with trannies on 4chan bro
wake up trannies are on the same team as you
>>
>>45313541
I'd like to append to this, because I don't think I made it fully clear, that gender dysphoria arises from objective sexual dimorphism and not from the spooky "gender ideology" windmill you've been tilting at over the course of this thread. This can easily be proven by reading repgen once.
>>
>>45313706
it's so frustrating reading the 'this all comes from gender ideology' nonsense people spew as a trannie that had dysphoria as a child in the 90s and transitioned before the mid 2010s

I had no ideology beyond 'shit, I don't want a male body I'm so fucked this is so weird'.
>>
can WE STOP FUCKING REPLYING TO BAIT
>>
>>45310374
>I could wish I was even more attractive, had an even bigger cock and even stronger arms, but at the end of the day I'm happy with what I've got and wouldn't reroll the dice on any of it.
Hylic cattle wants an award for being hylic cattle
A day ending in Y
>>
>>45312006
>there’s no meaningful difference between a biological woman and a trans woman
What's a "biological woman"? A >2-3SD category (~0.1% or less, which transitioning trannies are) is automatically going to differ significantly from the median, regardless of category
>>
>>45312323
>The hylic immidiately morphs into a 3 year old throwing a tantrum when any of its beliefs get questioned
Sure, trannies are the dogmatics...
>>
>>45313387
>nooo my retarded assertions are le trooth lalala *puts fingers in ears*
>>
>>45313541
>>45313706
>>45313795
The simple solution is to accept that you’re a man and fuck women instead of men. Just like some children don’t like eating vegetables, some children have low tolerance for labor or have a short attention span, we condition them to these things because we know it’ll be good for them in the long run. Simple doesn’t necessarily mean easy. I think if porn was illegal and impossible to obtain that would get us 90% toward meeting this goal. Just because you hatched a crazy impossible notion when you were a child and held onto it all this time doesn’t make it any more legitimate in my opinion. Lots of children have to let go of impossible fantasies, this is the only one I can think of that’s afforded this deference. I can imagine why me saying this would insult you but nothing anyone has ever said has dissuaded me of this position. Sorry.
>>
>>45313887
lol you’re calling me base and deterministic when you’re the one who wants to throw out all of medical knowledge about sex because it doesn’t suit your headcanon? I see you’ve read a Wikipedia article on Gnosticism, I have a five foot long bookshelf of Hellenistic texts. Shut up. Lmfao
>>45313905
I was told several times in this thread that this is an uncommon opinion here and I was glad to hear it, it sucks that some of you haven’t gotten the memo.
>>45313912
Is saying “you’re full of shit” throwing a tantrum? Ok then
>>45313929
It’s a mystery why people don’t take you guys seriously
>>
>>45314063
Nothing to "let go of" retard. If I could do that I would've done it long ago, but sadly things like mirrors exist that remind me of the issue even when I'm not thinking about it.
>impossible notion
The thing is it's NOT impossible because of medical transition. If you want to talk about whether or not it's possible for a man to become a woman then you're engaging in a pointless metaphysical debate. The actual issue is whether or not transition can improve the condition of people with the tranny mind virus, which it clearly can. If you accept that such a thing is possible and still continue to debate ideology or metaphysics then you're opposed to transition on an unspoken moral ground that you're hiding in a pretense at rationality.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.