>Transgender dogma is naive and incompatible with FreudHe was so real for this
woah zizek came out as a terf? lol hopefully he gets cancelled so i never have to hear his sniveling again.
>>25423220what do you mean by transgender dogma and how is it incompatible with freud?
>>25423231transgender dogma is nominalism, relativism, skepticism and teenage rebellious faggotryi don't know how that's incompatible with freud since i haven't read him (he's a faggot)
>>25423220Just parroting what monsieur Miller and the École Freudienne de Paris have been saying for years
>>25423231It's because transgender dogma is about a desire to become your authentic self and in psychoanalysis this desire is pathologized
>>25423913Chopping off your dick to "become a women" is mental disorder
>>25423917what did you think the overman would look like?
>>25423230He did years ago on Compact. He called them footsoldiers of capitalism or something.
the Red Scare, Zizek, Christopher Lasch, 'anti-neoliberal' style of kulturkritik is completely repulsive to me on an aesthetic level, like it's completely reactive, motivated by sad passions, no imagination, no new energies, just stultifying moralism
>>25423220zizek is an intriguing example of a phenomenon that happens all the time: the de-Judaization of an essentially Jewish ideology (Freudianism). This happened before with Christianity and Communism (USSR).
>>25423919Hermaphrodites are not overman
Freud is a Fraud. When I become King, I will ban all european philosophy from the kingdom, and will institute a Mediterrabean philosophy-only policy.
>>25423917It's actually a venerable bronze age tradition of old phyrigia. It symbolizes the absolute compulsory devotion to the feminine spiritual, as the goddess cybelle drove attis to.madness out of jealousy that he loved another.
>>25423917guarantee you 99% of trans ppl arent chopping off their dick or wanting to chop off their dick
>>25423220>>Transgender dogma is naiveYes.>>incompatible with FreudFreud is equally full of shit.>>25423305>transgender dogma is nominalism, relativismtransgender dogma is gender realismbehold:- if you say that gender is a social construct, then you say that activities are disentangled from biological sex (men can cook, women can be programmers, etc.). Gender is relative (tomboys, etc.), but biology is set in stone.- if a child is coerced to take hormone pills, because he touched a doll (an 'unmanly' activity), then a *social category of gender* is maintained, while *biology* is attempted to be deconstructed for its sake. Deconstructed, because someone thinks that gender is real, so that all behavior should conform to some metaphysical template.>>25423920>He called them footsoldiers of capitalismThat's true. Transgenders is a pharmacy scam for goys.
>>25423220Note that he is not anti-trans, he loves to do this mildly annoying thing where he goes against some perceived left dogma only to then flip it around and support it in a more sophisticated way. In this case, his point is that the 'transgender dogma' he is against is Judith Butler's sort of view of gender as a performance that can be fluidly changed at will. The transgender experience is exactly his reason for rejecting it: transitioning is not just like, casually putting on a different dress, the same way an actor adopts a different role. its an intense, frightening experience that requires you to commit fully to a drastic change of your identity. His point is that in psychoanalysis sexuality and all its contradictions are very deeply entrenched in what the psyche is and how it works, and being transgender is exactly embodying the contradiction inherent to it.
>>25424026>>25424034two nice poststhanks, anons
>>25423220Saying trannies are incompatible with Freud is an argument in their favor. Freud was a hack.
>>25423220I don't respect Zizek because he exists solely as a way to funnel those who are predisposed to contrarianism into supporting mainstream/"correct" positions while still giving them the opportunity to maintain an air of superiority over normies I'm not familiar with his formal philosophy work. I just find his pop stuff frustratingly popular
>>25423220>Trans are incompatible with materialism since they depend on spiritualism to explain their problem.>But they don't technically exist anyway since actual transitioning never takes place. t. « Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ »
>>25423961>mediterrabeannever heard of it
As an invert I'm constantly taken aback by how inaccurately straight people perceive me. Even otherwise very intelligent straight men have weird and cartoonishly simplistic notions of why people might be gay, how such a thing affects other areas of life, etc.Transgenderism is an order of magnitude more complicated still, full of notions and feelings that most people never have to consider in their whole lives, and I hear even LGB people say bizarre things like "they're just perverts who want an excuse to be in a woman's bathroom." What a circus.I don't care about Freud or "dogma" and I'm not trans myself, just butting in to say you guys generally don't have a clue and are wasting your time and making fools of yourselves. Slavoj is probably even further from getting it since he's also a dinosaur!!
>>25424288good bait
>>25423220It's incompatible with nature, common sense, beauty, communism, literally anything at all.
>>25423220>incompatible with Freudno it isnt. wat nou
>>25424287
>>25424296freud stands for the rejection of philosophy and imposition of pseudoscientific doctrines like what if the child consents, only freud is compatible with trans kids
>>25424022believing you are the opposite sex is also a mental disorder
>>25424288keep shining sister
you guys are so stupid
>>25423220But not incompatible with Jung.Jung would take one look at the tranny fad, and diagnose a simple case of Anima possession.
>>25423922I think the issue is that The One-Dimensional Man was the best work and only worthwhile work on it and Marcuse even agreed with the criticism that it suggests capitalism is sustainable when it isn’t and confronts it that way
>>25423220so? Fuck Freud.
>>25424366>Mental disorderWe can actually just call it a mental order of a particular kind and then all mind our own fucking business
