Sci-fi peaked here.
>>25481990solaris is pretty good, too
Plotless, rambling, pointless.And all the characters are called Billy, Jimmy or Tommy.
>>25482037>PlotlessExpand on that, please.
>>25482047not him but i sort of agree, and it's what i love about it.the intrigue does not come from interpersonal conflict, there is vanishingly little. the intrigue comes only from waiting to see what else the highly competent and co-operative astronauts find on the alien spacecraft.it's just such a nice change of pace. i love my dostoyevksy and my shakespeare, but reading them sort of gives the impression that human beings have never been able to work together. it's nice to see our kind in a more positive light.
>>25482480they don't call the book "hard sc-fi" for nothing. It reads more like scientific journals and record keeping on one of those 19th century voyages.
Childhood's End > 2001 > Rendezvous
>>25482037>And all the characters are called Billy, Jimmy or Tommy.GIGAKINO
>>25481990DV is doing the adaption, and it's gonna PEAK.
>>25481990i read it in a day the first time i picked it up because i couldn't put it downjust listened to it again the past week while doing chores and it's still amazing even after you know what happens
Overlords and mystery ships, oh my. -- It's been said that the Golden Age of science fiction is 10-13 because at age 14, normal boys discover girls.
>>25481990I prefer book of the long sun there isn't really anything particularly interesting to cut your teeth on in rama
>>25483604I believe everything that's been said.
>>25481990Read this as a kid in the mid 80s. Blew my mind. At that age, the big-dumb-object concept was completely new to me and I loved it.
>>25481990Might make a good film. Modern films are great on visuals and poor on characterization. But that's just what the doctor ordered for RWR.Wasn't someone famous trying to get a production together recently? Morgan Freeman or someone?
>>25481990>supposedly highly advanced society>breed a race of uplifted simians to circumvent anti-slavery laws on a technicality.I hope the third ship makes the sun go into three successive supernovas.
>>25483873the fact they were called simps was prescient
>>25483876
>>25483876It would explain a lot about how their soceity keeps functioning with all the polygyny going on.
>>25483892th... they are literally me
>>25482480>the intrigue does not come from interpersonal conflictthe interpersonal conflict is between the planets (e.g. mercury unilaterally launching a warhead) and to a lesser degree the members of the rama committee (e.g. petty disputes between academics waving their peens)
Why do so many people on this board laud this book in particular when Childhood's End is so obviously superior?
>>25486241unseen alieums >>>>>>>>>>>> seem alieums
>>25486259CE just carries so much more emotional weight though.
>>25483808>Modern films are great on visualsAre you blind?
How are the sequels quality-wise?Also same question for Space Odyssey
>>25483808morgan freeman was going to produce it when david fincher was slated to direct. before that, ridley scott was going to do it.now it's denis villeneuve, who is going to use CGI at every opportunity like he did with DUNC and bladedunner 2049.
>>25486668the rama sequels are outright garbage. clarke didn't want to write them at all. rama 2 starts with a diatribe about how the existence of aliens caused the am economic crisis, which did not make sense and had no relevance to the plot. the new astronauts are not competent and i think one even complained about being sent to an alien spacecraft because the ship is an exact copy of the last one. skip it.
>>25486692the problem with 99% of sequels in passive media is that they aren't neededmystery is what drives rama forward, and the autist's realization at the ending of the book just makes your imagination spiral and leaves you with a deep sense of wonderactually writing out sequels collapses the infinitude of what could be to what happened, and it almost always results in feeling let down
>>25486684>cgi is le bad!retard
>>25481990>only sci-fi book OP has read
>>25487548Wow, great argument, faggotron. You really convinced me with all those hot opinions.
>>25482508>>25486241how prominent is the polygamy?
>>25489983There's no polygamy in CE. In fact the humans live in perfect (modern) comfort, peace & harmony right up until the Overlords pull the rug right out from under them.
>>25483892>being cloned, they were also sexlessIs this an example of the "hard sci-fi" of the 1960s? LMAO.
>>25487548t. zoomer who hasn't lived long enough to see his favourite films age like milk
Miss this nigga!
>>25486241I like both and I also like The Dispossessed.
>>25482037thischildhood's end is his best THOUGHEVER
>>25486684>now it's denis villeneuveit's actually perfect book for him
>>25490807That mechanical keyboard is still great.
For me, it's the ending of 2010.
just gonna leave this herehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pu4n5YXPaMQ&t=1247
>>25482037agreed, if I don't see at least one Ranjeet by page 50 I stop reading
>>25481990>>25494779Kill yourself, OP.
>>25483892This was me in my 20s when I was in an accounting firm
>>25481990the only good part of this book is the part where he describes a woman's tits bouncing around in zero gravity>>25486668Odyssey book 2 is unnecessary but still an okay read, 3 and 4 are dogshit that I can only assume were done purely for money
>>25490764damn you weren't kidding. i'm past the halfway point and he's only made scant reference to the impracticability of monogamy. very unlike him.
I read Childhood's End this week and its pretty embarrassing if /lit/ thinks this is good. It's naive technocratic nonsense and also very ethically mean-spirited. Even if you want to believe the nonsense like that Karellen can resolve all ideological disputes with a particularly well-reasoned speech or that religion would fade away naturally as mankind became learned, its just frankly embarrassing that his paradise of unrestricted artistic expression makes their key advancements in anime and video games. I don't know what else to say, it's the world view of a redditor perfectly distilled.However I did laugh at the first page introducing the black main character in act 2 beginning with an impassioned defence of using the word nigger in polite conversation.
>>25495356You didn't understand the book at all and I would even argue that you have a bad faith approach to it.
>>25494779Ranjeet is such a badass name compared to Jimmy
>>25495383>Ranjeet is such a badass name compared to Jimmy
>>25481990And this is to go even further beyond...
>>25495365Sorry I guess all the deep symbolism of the guy orchestrating resistance from behind the scenes being literally blind and employing a fat retard to do his bidding.
>>25495391*went over my head.
Why were 20th century scifi writers so obsessed with psychic powers and telepathy
>>25495469because it's, like, a metaphor for mankind becoming better in the future, man, but with that power also comes responsibility, maaanUnfortunately, few stick the landing... or the flight path. Pic related got it right.
I think the best modern sci fi is the 3 body trilogy, and from the last century i really like forever war, that author has many bangers even if he likes to shit the bed on sequels>>25482480>>25482488Yeah, i love that too but nothign happens and nobody seems to feel anything from it either. It's too impersonal and too uninteresting.>the thing comes>it's really cool>some cool shit happens inside it>it leaves >oh well
>>25496201>>25495469It’s also because Campbell was a culty weirdo obsessed with psychic powers, and would pressure and bully writers into including it in their novels
My favourite sci-fi novel? UBIK by Philip K Dick.
I just finished RwR today. Fantastic. I loved it. Reminded me deeply of journals kept by previous century scientific expeditions on Earth. I really liked that the mystery was not solved, but instead simply presented and left on the table for speculation. Wonderful. Too bad we couldnt reenact it for real with Oumuamua.
I feel like that bomb plot came out of nowhere
>nobody goes aboard Rama and says they have to motherfucking science the shit out of this shit>there's no Rama AI to make hilarious quips about the situationHonestly I'm glad this style of dry, boring, and frankly too white sci-fi died out
i've finished childhood's end and i liked rama way better. also, why couldn't the overlords into telepathy but they could make all the humans at the bullfight feel the same pain? seems pretty telepathic to me.
>>25498328can you explain why the one ESPer lady thought she was the one doing the stuff that the kid was doing?
Can't wait for Villeneuve to turn it into sterile bland soulless flick.
>>25500269>He doesn't understand pictures-stories What makes Rendezvous with Rama not sterile, bland and soulless? What is it saying?
>>25498586There are plenty of reasons to dislike Rama without purposely shitposting and creating fake fabrications. Reading ONLY the most popular entries in their respective genres does not make you an interesting or unique human being. Go back in time and get your kid self raped by Clarke.
