Is the lack of real world experience causing the literary world to crawl up its own ass and lose all relevance and power?
>loseIt lost it fucking decades ago. Radio and TV killed it. Literature is a hobby on par with model trains or collecting spoons, it doesn't change the world.
That is probably accurate. It all springs from the experience of reading other books, or even more so from watching television and film. It’s this self-referential literary cyclone that gets more empty with each generation, like running a copy through a copier and running that copy through a copier ad infinitum nauseum, which is now becoming automated by means of the friendly computer assistant. The only authors who manage to make something interesting have to turn in on themselves and become actually insane because if you turn outward for inspiration it’s like THX1138 (see, I made a film reference to express what I mean. However, it is important for the one guy who bothers to read this shitpost to know that I am just talking out of my rear end and nothing ‘written’ here deserves to be regarded as anything but static, noise on your shining screen of wonder. The air around us is vibrating with transmissions of pornography and narcissistic madness video clips, the power lines are humming with sorcery and here we are tied to the image board again. Feed me false light, be my flat angel fallen from satellite heights above, be my troll bait tonight
>>25648409The only "real" literature you're going to be able to read these days are autobiographies. Edward Snowden, some guy kidnapped in a third world country, war vet, etc. Everything else will be tainted by incest.
>>25648409yes and >>25648418>TV killed it.the lack of real world experience is killing TV (and movies) as well. Hop on over to /tv/ sometime, they've had threads about: >>25648494>It’s this self-referential literary cyclone that gets more empty with each generation, like running a copy through a copier and running that copy through a copier ad infinitum nauseumofc replace literary with film. You can see it (literally haha) in a lot of the schlock that comes out these days.>>25648494>However, it is important for the one guy who bothers to read this shitpost to know that I am just talking out of my rear end and nothing ‘written’ here deserves to be regarded as anything but static, noise on your shining screen of wonder. The air around us is vibrating with transmissions of pornography and narcissistic madness video clips, the power lines are humming with sorcery and here we are tied to the image board again. Feed me false light, be my flat angel fallen from satellite heights above, be my troll bait tonightbeautiful anon
>>25648409Did the literary world ever have real world experience?
>>25648409Its both.Theres a lack of rigor in the modern arts. I really doubt you are going to find many authors who have learned multiple languages and honed their craft seriously for years. I doubt you'll find many twitter illustrators who have done cast drawings, or studied anatomy, or done master studies.The lack of real world experience is also a huge factor, as these people usually live in a giant memetic echo chamber of social media now.But I wouldn't phrase it like they are being rigorous in study to the point of being cloistered from real-world experience. They are both disconnected from the outside world and the inside world.
>>25648538Yes. Soldiers, farmers, world travelers, revolutionaries, whatever you please. Before the computers chomped down on our flesh most men had to acquire experience of one kind or another even if they didn’t wish to do so. Just to get around town you had to be something of an explorer
>>25648494)
>>25648409I don’t care about “real world experience” in literature, and neither should you.
>>25648409it got too boring. could lie blame at the modernists who stopped writing for ordinary people. tv is having (had?) a golden era because it genuinely good shows like sopranos that also had a dominant entertainment motive. writers like eliot and dickens raised people upward by giving them something to hold on to. once you train audiences to expect nothing from high art except difficulty, obscurity or ideological homework, they’ll naturally turn elsewhere. mass culture didn’t shift downward spontaneously; the upward pull disappeared.
>>25648409If you have a strong enough inner life and enough lucidity then it doesn't matter that much.
>>25648494Kek.
>>25648494There are certain modes that modern man cannot write about simply due to the experience being now impossible. Unfortunately we will never get fully authentic accounts from the scrum of the maniple system. Or the struggles of an Anglo-Saxon farmstead on the brittonic frontier. Or a river community about to be put under the wheel of the Yamnaya. Or one of those hermit civilisations deep underground in Turkey that looked like they had to bury themselves against some kind of prowling fiend for six months in the year. But real-lives are out there to be had. Most writers are pussy typists first and foremost, however. But decent vital literature can still be written today even if you're not shooting russians in the congo, and the basic Brandon Sanderson trap of writing re-re-re-re-re-heated trope slop can be avoided if you take a route straight through what is known as reading the classics (Iliad etc, not 19th century house warming slop), developing a sense for the world and just getting out there and enjoying life. Literally just stop consuming modern slop, even if it is "pleasant".
>>25649580Fall to them as you find your stomach serves you.No profit grows where is no pleasure ta’rn.In brief, sir, study what you most affect.
>>25648409That's why most of modern American fiction is trash. Nothing special ever happens in the USA, they delude themselves that living under Orangeface is a life- altering experience, and many don't travel the world like a Colin Thubron.
>>25649563Nobody wants to read about your "inner life" when they've got their own to think about.
>>25648409Has it and is it that is the tense you mean. Continuing present.
>>25650431The inner life of man is at root one. Every story is about you, about us. There would be no comprehension without the tacit recognition that all this narrative is the within showing itself to the without with which we wander about ever grasping for escape in dissipation and division
>>25650519Once again, nobody needs to read about it when they have direct, personal experience of it.
>>25648409Yes.
>>25648409It's like eating shit and then eating shit over and over and over. Eventually you just become India.
>>25648409fucking kek, what movie is this?
>>25656595teacher's pet (1958)
>>25656595It’s Teacher’s Pet and the context is almost the exact opposite of what the OP is implying because it’s about a stuck up guy trying to infiltrate the journalists he hates and learn their ways.
>>25649602Modernity in general is boring. A large percentage of the American population has been rendered insane by doing the same thing every single day with only brief periods of enrichment
>>25648494mustard snack goes in one ear and out the other at 2.4ghz
>>25648494
The MFA and its resultant short stories have been a disaster for the literary world. They have greatly increased the perception that microaggressions in academia experienced between ages 22 to 24 are worthy experiences to put on paper.
>>25648409yes absolutely
>>25648409I don't know how anyone could say it isn't. Postmodernity is the equivalent of 12 tone chromaticism for classical music, and look how well that's doing nowadays.
>>25648409Yeah, it's why no one here can write for shit.
>>25648409It's kinda always been like that. You have to wonder what a medieval farmer really thought about, because the vast majority of writing from the past is written by monks and cityfags. Sure you can even say>but what about this farmer/trapper guy who wrote some stuff?but if they knew how to write then they still weren't the average person. So yeah. Fags write the future and this is why the world tends toward evil, but that's another story.All that being said, a fag in medieval times still probably had more life experience than fags now.Anyway, the reason I came to /lit/ today is because I had an idea I wanted to throw out there: The Giver but at the end the protagonist finds themselves surrounded by cannibal barbarians. Totally changes the meaning right?lol how do women do these captchas? Fucking Based!
>>25648409It's a chuddy answer but the decline in literature is mostly due to women dominating the market and publishers catering to their tastes.
>>25662905>cant say something he admits is true without also bending the knee to untruthutterly mindbroken
>>25648409what you're describing isnt new but universal. You cant simultaneously live your best life and write about it. The people with the most life experience are never going to produce the most literature.
Hair metal is the most artistically credible music genre because they sang about partying and boning babes before, during, and after partying and boning babes.
>>25648494Well said lol. You aren't wrong about the "ouroboros" nature of our current culture. It reminds me of what Orson Welles was saying about movies just being an homage of one another:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dg-qaeIcuyI
how do you get people with real experience to write instead of getting writers to get experience
>>25662905Before TV, movies, and video games, the most talented creative people could only make literature, paintings, sculptures, or architecture. I'm not disagreeing with your statement about women.
The most successful franchise in HISTORY was created by someone inspired by GOING FOR A WALK IN THE WOODS. This is the level of outside influence required to break from the pack these days. 99.9% of creatives just watch TV and play video games then regurgitate their deconstruction of Slay the Spire crossed with marvel merged with gay porn for women.
>>25648409The problem is no one goes to grammar school or is taught the classics anymore, so they wouldn't know how to write their experiences even if they wanted to.