Why did Borges write "Three Versions of Judas"? What inspirations did he draw from to write this? Is it sacrilegious?
>>25656001IDK, but I remember asking during sunday school if Judas was forgiven because he was honestly sorry about what he did even to the point of killing himself and the priest gave me a non answer.
>>25656001The first Judas is normal Judas, the second Judas is Frankist. I am not sure where the third Judas comes from. Absurdist maybe.
>>25656001Talmudic gnostic slop like most of what Borges wrote.>>25656016If he had been really sorry he would have sought repentance instead of killing himself out of shame. Either way he's in Hell for suicide.
>>25656192Wow you know so much, you must be God’s “Chief Soul Disposition Officer”
>>25656192>If he had been really sorry he would have sought repentance>instead of killing himself out of shameWhat's the contradiction?>Either way he's in Hell for suicide.You should kill yourself too
>>25656001This story unintentionally predicted the “media literacy” meme if you think about it. The meme where chuds reevaluate an obvious villain from a movie or show as being awesome because that villain represents their values in a shallow parodic view as portrayed by the enemy. I don’t have much more to add. It’s a decent story. Borges isn’t one of my personal favorites.
Based on the Wikipedia article, probably "gnostic slop," like >>25656192 said. Some of the early church fathers record similar of beliefs about Judas in their time.>At the opposite extreme is the strange view held by the early Gnostic sect known as the Cainites described by St. Irenaeus (Against Heresies I.31), and more fully by Tertullian (Praesc. Haeretic., xlvii), and St. Epiphanius (Haeres., xxxviii). Certain of these heretics, whose opinion has been revived by some modern writers in a more plausible form, maintained that Judas was really enlightened, and acted as he did in order that mankind might be redeemed by the death of Christ. For this reason they regarded him as worthy of gratitude and veneration.https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08539a.htmBorges wasn't a practicing Catholic, so there's no reason to give him the benefit of the doubt and read an orthodox Catholic message into the text if there's obvious reason to think so from the text.>>25656016The doubt would be whether Judas really was "honestly sorry" and what it means to be "honestly sorry." Merely feeling guilty over a crime isn't the same as the Christian idea of repentance.
Why is Borges such a great writer? love him.Also, yes it's gnostic beliefs
>>25656177Third Judas is a kind of dark Kenosis. If we open it to outside of Christianity, maybe the Aghoris would be the closest, especially those who worship Dhumavati-Kali (the goddess of corpses) as the highest goddess
>>25656001It's Borges, so the answer to all three is being a sober man in South America.
>>25656016>>25656192Without Judas the original sin could never have been forgiven; therefore he should be forgiven on those grounds at least. Maybe not allowed into Heaven, but Purgatory at least. He was a vital step in the salvation of mankind. And as such, even Jesus forgives him and tells him to do what has to be done. Judas being in Hell is just another reason why I find Catholicism so fineky. I remember debating this in Catholic school when I was a child, although obviously through being a child I lacked in the proper intelligence to make my point, and often got a non-answer in response.
>>25658247The biggest problem with this argument is that it implies the end justifies the means, that it's morally right to do evil in order to achieve a good consequence. It's like saying that drunkenly killing your family in a car accident is good because it was the wake up call you needed to get sober. In that (hypothetical) scenario, it's good that you learned a lesson and sobered up, but it's still evil that you killed your family through your drunken negligence. Similarly it's good that Judas's betrayal led to the redemption of mankind, but it's not good that he betrayed an innocent man (as the narrative in the Gospels says) to die for money. His actions were evil even though they also had a positive consequence.According to Catholic doctrine, if you are guilty of sin, you need to repent of your sin to be pardoned. Judas's sin isn't unforgivable, The doubt is whether or not he repented. He showed feelings of remorse, but that's not the same thing as contrition. It's open to speculation, but the more straightforward interpretation of the text is that he wasn't genuinely repentant. Hence "it were better [or 'good' depending on the translation/source text] for him, if that man had not been born."Another interesting aspect of your argument is the possible implication that God owes Judas gratitude, because he couldn't have achieved the redemption of humanity without Judas's help. ("Without Judas the original sin could never have been forgiven.")Also consider that when you were child lacking the proper intelligence to make your point, you might also have been a child lacking the proper intelligence to appreciate the answers that you were given at the time.
Since Borges wasn't formally religious, it's not sacrilege. He just had an interest in gnosticism. I don't think he knew it, but the story is probably about the ending of the age of Pisces and the entry into the age of Aquarius. Nils is a figure who occupies the beginning and the end of the Age of Pisces, as Borges writes that he would have been a formidable heresiarch had he been born “in Asia Minor or in Alexandria, in the second century of our faith.” In conceiving of Runeberg, Borges anticipates the yet to be discovered Gospel of Judas, a gnostic text at the beginning of the Age that mirrors Runeberg and Borges at the end. It seems that a sympathetic understanding of Judas as a figure essential to Christianity is found almost exclusively at the tail ends of the Age of Pisces. When Borges considers the objections of Runeberg’s contemporaries, he has the “rigid Bishop of Lund” point to Luke 22:3 as an objection. Here is Luke 22:1-14 in the KJV:“Now the feast of unleavened bread drew nigh, which is called the Passover.And the chief priests and scribes sought how they might kill him; for they feared the people.Then entered Satan into Judas surnamed Iscariot, being of the number of the twelve.And he went his way, and communed with the chief priests and captains, how he might betray him unto them.And they were glad, and covenanted to give him money.And he promised, and sought opportunity to betray him unto them in the absence of the multitude.Then came the day of unleavened bread, when the passover must be killed.And he sent Peter and John, saying, Go and prepare us the passover, that we may eat.And they said unto him, Where wilt thou that we prepare?And he said unto them, Behold, when ye are entered into the city, there shall a man meet you, bearing a pitcher of water; follow him into the house where he entereth in.And ye shall say unto the goodman of the house, The Master saith unto thee, Where is the guestchamber, where I shall eat the passover with my disciples?And he shall shew you a large upper room furnished: there make ready.And they went, and found as he had said unto them: and they made ready the passover.And when the hour was come, he sat down, and the twelve apostles with him.”The man bearing a pitcher of water is the sign of Aquarius.
>>25658964I forgot to mention, Borges was also probably inspired by Thomas de Quincey's essay on Judas.
>>25658822I appreciate your effort-post, and see your point, particuarly regarding Judas having not repented, which clarifies a lot, actually. Despite being raised Catholic and attending Catholic schools, this reasoning was never actually brought up for Judas's damnation (or if it was wasn't emphasised). Of course, the act of reconciliation is ingrained in Catholicism, and therefore makes sense that Judas neglecting this would therefore lead to his eternal punishment. Whereas with more liberal Christian thought, confession sn't viewed as a must as long as a person genuinely repents their actions within their own soul. This has given me much to consider. I do not agree with your comparison, though. Although it is obviously an extreme example, one act is borne from selfishness and the end goal is ultimately small scale, and the act of suffering vs. good could only be subjective. Sure, getting sober and changing your life for the better is a good thing, but it doesn't negate the suffering caused. I do not believe this could be applied to, though, as Judas, despite his actions being borne from selfishness and suffering, was an important mechanism in the maintance of the moral universe (i.e. the salvation of mankind, past, present, and future). I do not necessarily believe he is owed gratitude per se (not that I believe God would feel such a thing, as I do not view Him as a tangible entity with earthly emotions), yet I believe he should be granted some kind of existence within the moral universe he played an important role in maintaining (and Hell is the abscence of morality, therefore exists outside of the moral universe as God intended).Perhaps my ideas aren't very well put together, or simply too subjective to my own interpretations and understandings, but I would be interested to see what you think. I should also clarify I am not anti-Catholic, and in-fact have been open to rejoining the church recently.