[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/lit/ - Literature


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: perpe.jpg (12 KB, 183x275)
12 KB JPG
Thoughts on perpetual copyright?
>>
Billionaires are the best. We love billionaires here. No need for these threads here. You can leave now please and thank you.
>>
>>25656173
>creators deserve protection that lasts forever
>creators usually expire before 95+ years plus death of the author
???
>>
File: lynch.jpg (7 KB, 320x180)
7 KB JPG
>>25656173
intellectual property laws are bullshit
>>
>>25656173
imagine if we weren't allowed to quote shakespeare or milton
>>
>>25656194
You shouldn't unless you're willing to give due compensation to his estate (Warner Brothers). The people who purchased licensing rights from his descendants deserve to be fairly rewarded for their efforts.
>>
>>25656362
That's not how perpetual copyright works retard
>>
You can't own ideas because they preexist their so-called creator, and are in fact not created, but discovered. Copyright and the very concept of authorship itself should be abolished.
>>
File: mad stan.jpg (33 KB, 500x372)
33 KB JPG
>>25656362
there's only one sane response
YOU GOTTA BLOW IT ALL UP, MAN
>>
>>25656173
I dont mind copyright as an insurance tool for the creator or founding entity, but I dont think it should last more than 30 or 40 years. If you havent made a lasting brand in that time, that is your fault or the fault of your bad idea. maybe you can get a small remittance after.
>>
Copyrights don't actually incentivize people to create, it does the opposite. They sit on their fat asses and collect of old creations without any incentive to make good, new ones.
>>
>>25656370
I am not bound to please thee with my answers
>>
>>25656173
Jesus christ
>>
>>25656173
I find the legal personhood of ecological preserves far more interesting, because it is a step in the correct direction of forcing exploitative corporate interests who have purchased the state's consent to rob our descendants to face an appropriate degree of accountability

If you ruined someone's evening by assaulting them or desecrating their home, you would be charged with attempted battery or breaking and entering+destruction of property at the least, but if you attach hundreds of millions, or billions to a fake person called a corporation you're allowed to permanently ruin millions of persons and animals ability to enjoy a place that will never exist on this planet again in some places with no consequences other than "a fine" which is simply another avenue of bribery

If an individual did ecological damage on the scale of these companies with plans to "make it better at some latter date for a purpose which theoretically betters all of us", we would put them in prison for decades as a matter of serious arson and there would be no option for them to purchases amnesty from the state
>>
No. Intellectual property is bullshit, and plagiarism is actually based
>>
>>25656616
shut the fuck up, hippy
>>
>>25656173
that would only benefit jews who buy up every successful property.

if you make something, copyright will cover it throughout your entire life. That should be enough on its own. But then copyright will cover it 70 years after your death. That means not only does it protect you but it protects your children and your grandchildren so they can continue to profit off it, assuming they don't just immediately sell it the moment you kick the bucket. This should be more than enough.

So who exactly benefits from copyright protection that lasts longer than that? Only companies.
>>
You shouldn't be able to "own" an idea or concept. That's just evil. There is literally no reason to not put your book or writing under a free license or public domain. It doesn't matter whether it is copyleft, permissive, or public domain, everything is better than „all rights reserved“ or those retarded CC licenses with the No-Commercial or No-Modification suffix. With software there are still arguments that you would like to make money, and there those arguments make a little bit sense, but for books or texts it literally has no downsides, everybody who wants a physical copy of your book will buy it since it's still cheaper than doing it themselves, and better quality too. It's a sign of good will and means that you are happy to let other people use parts of your writing and let other people print it and not threaten them with potential legal pressure like with copyrighted books.
>>
>>25656173
Most jewish thing to ever jew. Its sole purpose is to ensure that people who do not contribute to societ can receive even more money they don't deserve. Only retards pay for entertainment.
>>
>>25656616
Might as well lmao. Considering all the retarded shenanigans already happening. Like the semi-sovereign corporations that masquerade as Indigenous Nations to abuse indigenous right slegislation. Indigenous Right's legislation in the Anglosphere, what a glorious clusterfuck. It's somehow wide-open for abuse but fails to help of protect those it's meant to.
>>
>>25657605
facts
>>
>>25656173
art, information, and ideas should be free and publicly accessible. originators deserve recognition, but they do not "own" the work they did. that is retarded. if you put it out there, it belongs to everyone.
>>
>>25656173
i'm for abolition, but i'd settle for life of the author and no restriction on derivative works.
>>
>>25656374
Based Platonist.
>>
>>25656374
>>25657595
Copyright doesnt protect ideas, shitheads. That's why no one ever sued over Sherlock Holmes, Eragon, Hunger Games, 50 Shades of Grey, Fortnite, or Five Nights at Freddy's, which blatantly took ideas from elsewhere.

Copyright only protects your personal expression of an idea. This prevents people from copy/pasting what you made and reselling it, but still allows people to copy the formula you used, so long as it's their own prose and characters. Copyright works well enough already.
>>
>>25656179
Replace creators with (((creators))), anon. Now you might understand.
>>
>>25658842
Copyright is used as a threat by come companies. Disney was infamous in the 20th century for taking public domain stories, making movies out of them, then suing anyone else who made a movie out of the same public domain property.
>>
>>25659073
So what? Any court would throw that case out.
>>
File: 1769671031133479.jpg (27 KB, 1024x576)
27 KB JPG
>>25658233
>writer something good
>Amazon/Netflix/Disney sends a hit squad to your house to kill you
>hijacks and bastardizes your work in order to turn a couple of shekels
>>
>creatorsrightsmovement
obvious astroturf but given some artists actually are pompous fuckwads enough to support something like that i encourage whatever fucks them and them specifically over
>>
File: groliousrippor.jpg (74 KB, 1080x769)
74 KB JPG
well it is our cultural heritage as an anime porn website. we must honor our precious japanese culture.
>>
“Rap” ( which is non-music according to both information theory and music theory btw )has been stealing actual creative ideas for many many years now
It’s simply DEI gone mad
>>
Anne Rice would love this.
>>
>>25656173
It would only create eternally-cascading generations of trust-fund nepo-babies. Christ knows we don't need any more of those.
>>
File: 1782905786186731.png (3.36 MB, 960x1428)
3.36 MB PNG
>>25656173
>perpetual
lol, lmao
>>
>>25659397
slayer statutes are a thing in inheritance law already. that could be ported with some effort into copyright law.
besides, netflix and disney are concentrations of wealth that only exist because of the existing IP regime, and would fall over very quickly if it were abolished. amazon is slightly different because they have multiple actual businesses that do real things rather than just collect IP rents.
>>
>>25656173
Wonder what billionaire came up with this shot. Life of the author + two weeks notice so the kids can find a real job
>>
File: 1473804970808.jpg (43 KB, 480x451)
43 KB JPG
>>25656173
>Thoughts on perpetual copyright?
>>
>>25659077
Lawsuits are extremely expensive and can take years to settle. Most companies would rather avoid them entirely, even if it means capitulating.
>>
>>25656173
In the music industry, someone already created every possible 8 note sequence and copyrighted them
I imagine an llm would shortly be set to create every 1 page excerpt, and the whole industry would swiftly collapse

Anyway, in general people don't have "Rights" to modify the behaviour of others, and as of such cannot have the "Right" to prevent someone from printing writing or sharing a book
>>
>>25656476
That's why all the places without copywrites in the modern world make so much of the worlds most prolific content nowadays.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.