I don't understand the question. Do you mean does /lit/ support lit/ writers? Do you mean are any of them any good? Are you asking why any of them would claim association with /lit/?Regardless, those pages from Sinner Sees and First of Rus read like they could be lifted straight from Brandon Sanderson. Not a compliment, btw. And I'm too fatigued by them to read the other four.
>>25659505What have you done? Now you'll summon them.
>>25659759we all know it's one of the authors themselves that made this shit thread
>>25659759TB reporting in>>25659796Wasn't me>>25659639I'm curious if you can elaborate on what makes them (especially mine) so Sanderson-esque or if you just picked the biggest meme author you could think of
>>25659971Dialogue that leads absolutely nowhere. Every character is snarky. Awkward action descriptions. Not as bad as the other one though. That same scene takes place nearly verbatim in Mistborn.
>>25660032I wonder if you're trolling or if you actually believe you can tell any element "leads absolutely nowhere" from page one alone lol like of course you're still nowhere you've walked a foot down the mile lmao. Snark isn't a Sanderson trademark but very broadly a millennial one. And in the case of Sinner Sees you'll notice that Sam (the protagonist) happens to not be particularly snarky, and if you dig further that the author is closer to gen Z. Your third point is too vague. You'll need to elaborate with specificity for it to mean anything.As unironic critique I rate this a low figure but as bait I rate it a fine large one.
F. Gardner and his consequences have been a disaster for /lit/
>>25660729There are eight consecutive lines of >Nu-uhThat is what I mean by dialogue that leads nowhere. And you're saying? > When she realized who I was, it must have relaxed her. is not awkward? Plus the boring run on sentences about Astrid kicking the door shut and Roxanne getting the door opened, anong others.
>>25660750I feel NJB is a real challenger for F. Gardner's meme status. Gardner has seniority sure but NJB is uniquely abrasive and tenacious enough to put up a solid fight. I've never even seen Gardner deanonymize.
>>25660776Oh, so by what you said, you meant something else. Because dialogue being negatory doesn't entail that dialogue leads nowhere with the presence of subtext.>Boy, this iceberg is so stubby, we shouldn't bother diving to see the rest of it, there's probably nothing there-(you) Boring is another vague word. Pointing out run-ons is definitely solid critique. I'd thank you if you weren't full of it since those aren't run-on sentences.
Here's It's All Forgotten Now. People really seem to like the story The Mall Walkers. Maybe you give it a read? Personally, I think The Laundromat Clown is the best one. PDF>https://litter.catbox.moe/c86jp3b75u9ao4xw.pdfEPUB>https://litter.catbox.moe/hlt6ss3smfzgosq1.epub
>>25660788Was Frank as belligerent and mean as Boor? F Gardner is insane now, but back then I thought his shilling was honestly hilarious. Boor seems kind of bitter.
>>25662303>Was Frank as belligerent and meanNo, the only time I get angry is when people talk in movie theaters
>>25662339Are you really F Gardner? Would love to know what you think of the up and coming lit authors.
>>25659505I'm a 46 year old editor with 20 years of experience in the industry, a few published works under my belt, and little patience for bad literature. Maybe I can help.(Given the website we're on, I'll be more blunt than I'd be IRL.)>Sinner SeesNo artistry in the descriptions, just the bare minimum "at least it's grammatically correct" level. Not a single beautiful sentence, no intriguing thoughts, no characters who do or think something unusual and interesting. Nothing but the most bland prose imaginable.Banal dialogues I've already read hundreds of times. The "forget about it" / "forget about what" / "there you go" exchange was so cliché it made me physically cringe. How can an adult write like this? Are you a teenager or are you targeting them? Can't you tell immediately that it's trite garbage?This first page shows me that the author is thoroughly mediocre both in thought and skills. Zero interest in reading more of this uninspired redditprose. I've reached the point where it's physically unpleasant.2/10>First of the RusThe entire first paragraph is a thinly disguised infodump. We don't need to immediately know everything that passes through her mind and the implications of her frowning. They are obvious and should remain subtext, I don't need to read sentences like "if she held an unpleasant demeanor, frowned upon in such circles". Really? Being unpleasant is frowned upon in such circles? In which circles is it not? You're overexplaining things that are already obvious, which makes the reading a slog. You either can't distinguish between what should remain subtext and what should be explicated (a fatal flaw) or you're scared of losing the reader's attention or confusing him (also fatal). Write the story in the best possible way, not in the way that you think would be more palatable for the average reader, or you'll disappoint the intelligent ones and you will still be misunderstood by the dumb ones.Here the prose is less reddit-tier but still no intriguing or beautiful sentence. Don't really feel like reading hundreds of pages of this.4/10>It's All Forgotten NowNot a huge fan of the telegram-like style that is unfortunately so popular today (short sentence-period-another short sentence), but the character shows some personality ("he was capable of landing himself a desperate 37 year old afraid of dying alone") and you present a world interesting enough ("No one made it to 50 at the Agency") that I wouldn't mind exploring it further. Some intriguing concepts as well ("Vinny knew he didn't own his thoughts. The rest of the world thought they did.")7/10
>What the Last Dodo ThinksLots of big boy words, but if you can use them properly and avoid sounding like a Thesaurus, I don't mind. It can even help characterize the protagonist, if he's overly cerebral and pretentious.I like that it doesn't immediately jump into some action scene. Starting in medias res is in fashion because writers are afraid of losing the reader, but it produces bland, uninteresting bullshit (why should I care what happens to a character I still don't know?) I like that you give the story time to begin properly. I see some signs of a character with a personality ("a banal and undeniable atrocity he had to accept in many other areas", "the Pope had said something about the soul", "gained a couple of sand dunes") and a world that, thank God, isn't immediately infodumped on the reader, but is slowly revealed (a talking mirror?), letting the reader do some work.Also, we see the protagonist do something baffling (pissing on the wall and the towels), which raises curiosity: what the hell is he doing and why?The prose isn't a slog to read and it generates enough curiosity to continue.7/10>The Chemical DivorceGreat title. Great incipit too ("My friends, before they were puddles"). Generates lots of curiosity. The world is clearly very unusual ("last week's holocaust", the entrance is wearing him or he's wearing it) and not at all overexplained. The prose is light but with a good rhythm, the dialogue are not banal, they further the world-building and the characterization.8.5/10>King of LABaffling. The descriptions are hamfisted (beautiful women everywhere, hip sharply dressed industry types, fancy hors d'oeuvres) and the worst part is that they use loaded, generic words like "beautiful, fancy, hip" that should be avoided at all costs, since they are lazy and ineffective at producing clear images and feelings. It sounds like a kid's first attempt at storytelling. Banal and insipid. It also comes off as edgy ("cocaine being lined up", "a man well-versed in the practice of power", wow, look how cool this is). Tasteless word choice, bad rhythm. Didn't even want to finish the first page. 2/10
>>25663326>>25663348Of course these judgements are based only on the first page of every book, maybe it improves later. But I've never in my life seen a book that starts as a 2-4/10 and becomes good. Or even decent.
>>25659759>You have summoned the horde!
>>25663326>>25663348>I'm a 46 year old editor with 20 years of experience in the industry, a few published works under my beltMay or may not be true, but excellent, clear, concise, accurate critiques. What you said about the first two captured what I instinctively felt, but could not quantify as well. Enough so that I read the rest of them, after having previously written them off. Glad I did. The Chemical Divorse has my interest piqued.
>>25663586Also>inb4 the butthurt authors of 1, 2 and 6 try to say you're wrong about their dreck
>>25663348>>25663586More of The Chemical Divorce
>>25663629>>25663348Frank Zeist eating good today.
>>25663326you’re about to hear 1000 excuses from TB Johnson and Boor
>>25663643
>>25663326Sinner Sees author here. You claim to be an author, say there's no artistry in my work, and then fail to post your work. A frame of reference for what you consider beautiful sentences, intriguing thoughts, and interesting characters would give me actual insight into what you mean instead of just making me frown. And calling out a cliché in isolation means nothing to me. I don't believe in original ideas, only original combinations of ideas.Also, I really don't care about your industry experience since for all I know you're a nepo baby who bagged a sinecure.
>>25663713>get critique>everybody's fine>critique the critique>everybody loses their minds
>>256635881 here. No such thing as a wrong opinion but such a thing as lackluster critique.
>>25663643That anon praising Frank's overcooked mess gives me (TB) a little insight into why he didn't like mine
Reminder that this is the cover of my other book
>>25663348>has overseen 20 years of steady decline into tradpub's current gay diverse commie hellscapeDefinitely don't take this moron pedant's advice on "taste" lmao.
>>25663757Have the humility to accept criticism instead of lashing out you immature, untalented child. You don't want to remain forever as you are now, do you?
>>25663766You're not critiquing anything, you're whining and looking for (absurd) excuses.>I insert trite clichés in my garbage because I don't believe in originalityGuess you don't believe in good writing either.
>>25659505They've read less than a 100 books in their lives and think they can turn their hand to writing despite having no real reason to believe this.
>>25663890>this much sperging outPredictable but still hilarious. I guess those jeet genes won't be denied. "Saar! Why you no like my garbage saar?!?!">lackluster critiqueNot the case here. It was detailed and well motivated. Which is why you have zero counter arguments.>y-you haven't p-posted your own w-w-work!Irrelevant.Take the loss, TB. Walk away from the keyboard. Don't look even more stupid.
>>25663778TB I’m not trying to be a dick but this cover completely sucks. It’s amateur anime. It won’t even attract YA readers. It looks like a high schooler made it for a DIY graphic novel
>>25663897see>>25663766>>25663902My points in summary:>misguided views on originality >too vague to offer insight>failure to put money where mouth is by posting own work>>25663931That wasn't me, but that poster brings up a good point and it seems like you're trying to avoid it by insulting me. >>25664032I wonder if posters like this actually believe they speak for "readers" or if it's purely an attempt at trolling
>>25664042I am being whole heartedly honest. That cover is awful. I hope you didn’t pay for it
>>25663326Thanks. Too bad nobody to me this earlier
>>25659505None of these first pages tell me enough. I always give a book 1 chapter. But so far, all are shit.
>>25663903:( but I loved my collection of berenstein bears
NJB continues to mog all. Now he's even making tradpubbers seethe.
>>25664042Dude, you've had multiple posters give you the same feedback on your writing, especially the dialogue. Instead of doubling down on >no u recognize that people are actually giving you helpful criticism and use it to rework what you have. You're getting 10 times more than most excerpts that got posted too the old /wg/ threads. Take advantage of it.
>>25663326>>25663326My turn please.
>>25663326>The entire first paragraph is a thinly disguised infodump. We don't need to immediately know everything that passes through her mind and the implications of her frowning. They are obvious and should remain subtext, I don't need to read sentences like "if she held an unpleasant demeanor, frowned upon in such circles". Really? Being unpleasant is frowned upon in such circles? In which circles is it not? You're overexplaining things that are already obvious, which makes the reading a slog. You either can't distinguish between what should remain subtext and what should be explicated (a fatal flaw) or you're scared of losing the reader's attention or confusing him (also fatal). Write the story in the best possible way, not in the way that you think would be more palatable for the average reader, or you'll disappoint the intelligent ones and you will still be misunderstood by the dumb ones.Here the prose is less reddit-tier but still no intriguing or beautiful sentence. Don't really feel like reading hundreds of pages of this.4/10Funny, I actually got rid of that line in my final draft. I'm still not to sure of some other sentences, but it is what it is.
>>25664058I don't have it saved but this is where I'd post the point going over the head meme>>25664185I'm not Zesty Frank. I will not be adjusting my voice to appease every rando who takes issue with it. But I do welcome your critique. Even bad critique offers a good learning opportunity.
>>25664365>muh voicengmi
>>25663757>fail to post your workStop making up hoops to jump through. I am not going to dox myself here and it's not necessary to give poignant critique, which I've already done.If you were more humble you could learn from what I tried to teach you and improve. You'll never be great, you need to be born with talent for that, but you could become decent, were you humble enough to take criticism from your betters. But you aren't, so you won't.>i don't believe in original ideasThis excuse is very common with your kind (talentless and arrogant, I've seen thousands of you and none has ever amounted to anything). But it's a valid argument only when it pertains to premises. You can start from a cliché premise (boy meets girl, despot controls a country) but then you need a non-cliché execution. And this is where you fail. There is no possible justification for a dialogue like "forget this" / "forget what?" / "exactly". It's unjustifable. Stop grasping at straws, you won't convince anyone and will only look like the petulant, arrogant child you are.>>25663773Now you're even insulting your colleague. Show some dignity, if you can't show talent.>>25663890>pedantThere was nothing pedantic about my criticism. It was all very basic stuff that any decent writer already knows.And I'm not one of those editors that have caused the decline (otherwise I'd have praised the reddit quality of your prose), I'm one of those that fought and still fight against it.>>25664042>too vagueNot for people with at least a shred of talent.
>>25664365You don't have a voice worth protecting, arrogant little shit. You sound like every reddit tryhard """aspiring writer""" who has ever existed. Nobody would distinguish your shit from theirs in a blind test.
>>25664032The commonly accepted theory is that he's trying to fuck the """artist""". Nothing else can explain his insistence on that dogshit cover.
>>25664560the other covers are more dogshit.
>>25664257The passage has a rather overwrought, melodramatic style, and its prose often seems more interested in sounding poetic than in conveying a clear image or emotion. The descriptions are saturated with clichés, awkward metaphors, and unnecessarily ornate phrasing. Expressions such as “emerald waters,” “golden spire,” “graceful lady,” and “starry night” pile familiar romantic imagery on top of one another without making the scene feel particularly vivid or original.Additionally, there's a deluge of loaded words, which, like we've said, should be avoided because they are lazy and not effective in communicating clear images.The scene also suffers from clumsy sentence construction and a lack of natural rhythm. Phrases like “Her hair flowed behind her and her body glided through the emerald waters” and “Cackles and boasts did Wellgunde laugh” feel awkward, while the dialogue is excessively theatrical even by the standards of mythological fantasy. The characters speak in a succession of grandiose declarations, but their personalities remain indistinguishable.There is also a tendency to explain emotions rather than dramatize them, and the imagery occasionally becomes unintentionally ridiculous (“your duty is to watch the sleeping gold, but you play like a bird as the snake consumes its eggs”). Overall, it reads like an attempt at lyrical fantasy that mistakes verbosity for elegance and archaic diction for literary sophistication. There is an essay by LeGuin where she speaks of the difference between the two ("From Elfland to Poughkeepsie").
>>25664491You did your best, but give it up brother. He doesn't want help. Sometimes people can't see the opportunities they're given.
>>25659505Selection bias. There are plenty of writers who post here but the better ones have the good sense to not associate themselves with fucking 4chan. What we have as "/lit/ writers" are the people too stupid, desperate, or lacking in ambition to know or care that associating themselves with this place is a terrible career move.
>>25664595Coward.
>>25663353The first page, first paragraph, first sentence are one of the most important parts of any book and if people can't make them excellent then they're certainly not going to do it later.
>>25664585Thanks! I was hoping to make it grandiose and hoping it sounded like a overwrought melodramatic opera.
>>25664595Yay for the desperate and stupid!
>>25664599Sometimes people refuse to do a thing because because of a lack of stupidity rather than a lack of bravery. You have nothing to gain and much to lose by attaching your name to a website infamous as the cesspool of the internet, home to pedophiles and school shooters and nazis. If you want anything resembling conventional success, you should have the common sense to realize that being labelled as a "4chan writer" is something to be avoided at all costs. Or do you aspire to have your name and writing listed alongside such luminaries as these >>25659505?My point, assuming that OP's implication was>Why are /lit/ writers all such shit?was that the good writers who post here are intelligent enough to not doxx themselves on 4chan.
>>25664622you are wise and i must detach myself from this cesspit. Is it too late?
>>25664608I'm not complaining, I like a lolcow as much as anyone, but that's very different than wanting to become one.
>>25664625I'm not saying that there's something inherently wrong with posting here; I'm saying that if you want anything resembling conventional success then you need to have your work accepted by editors and publishers and the general public and you need to be realistic about how normies perceive this place.
>>25664595I wrote It’s all Forgotten Now. Broadly speaking I think you’re right. If you somehow manage to land that big 5 or other major publishing moonshot and they found out your work was posted around here first, you’re definitely screwed. With that being said, I have no chance of that happening. A major publisher is probably never going to touch my work. I don’t have an in and the type of writers who do get that break write very specific genres/themes that I’m not particularly interested in. I’m not saying I’m any great talent, but many major writers published in trash mags/politically fringe outfits because it was the only place they could get traction. In the short term, yeah, this place is poison. With time it will lose its sting. It’s turning into a ghost town. Check out the rest of the collection if you’re interested. I think The Laundromat Clown is the best one. >>25660986
>>25664032I like but I think it'd be A LOT better if he got a 3D foid to sport that look for the cover. it'd make it easier to crank hog.
How do I know if I have gotten better if nobody gives me any criticism?
>>25664685I read The Buzzer last night (story that the first page is from, for those that don't follow the link). It's not very subtle. If that's what you were going for, you accomplished it well. But you don't give the reader much room to think.
>>25664714Too many people don't understand that.
>>25664732Fair enough. Thanks for giving it a read. I was basically trying to say that our system is a ghost running on inertia. The systems we’ve set up don’t have anyone at the helm anymore and that when there’s no organizing principles beyond forgotten bureaucracy you just get spiteful violence. Was that what you felt was too on the nose? I usually try for the whole show don’t tell mantra but sometimes it doesn’t always work.
>>25664742Yes. It was very literal.
>>25664747Gotcha. Thanks for the feedback