Have any of you taken a course on this? What was it like?
Yes and it was awesome. We skipped Oxen of the Sun too kek.
>>25659597Why was it awesome
>>25659635Great teacher teaching a great book. I was also studying philosophy so a lot of the harder chapters like Proteus managed to come off very kino
>>25659589Yes, my first semester of graduate school I took a course on Ulysses. I got an A in the class and on the final paper. Later I talked with my professor, and he told me that he liked my ideas that I developed in the paper a great deal. He said he thought I hadn't done as good a job as I should developing them, but that the ideas were so good he gave me an A anyway. He encouraged me to keep developing them further.
>>25659643What made him a great teacher?
>>25659707That's based. What chapter was your essay on? Or was it about the book as a whole?
>>25659707What were your insights? Generally speaking
>>25659737She was a she, and she ruled because you could tell she had read the book multiple times and had a personal passion for it, not just the usual intellectual curiosity and trivia. She helped us understand the book as a peculiar love letter to Ireland and art and life, not just an autistic hodgepodge of references, though we definitely discussed those as they're pretty important at times. The key to understanding the book lies in the allusions, sure, but the key to ENJOYING the book is in realizing what makes each chapter unique, in terms of the applied writing style, why Joyce chose it for that chapter and for the corresponding characters, etc. I could tell we were only discussing like 10 percent of the book, and even then it was more mystifying than 100 percent of most other books I've read. It's kino and it's a masterpiece imo.
>>25659761Oh and she also helped us understand the humor of the book as well. Ulysses is extremely funny if you know what to look out for. The Cyclops chapter in particular is an incredible display of satire.
>>25659738The essay was about the book as a whole. However, at my professor's encouragement, I took the ideas up again when it was time to write my master's thesis. The professor from my Ulysses class became my thesis advisor, and he helped me complete my thesis and get my MA.Over time, I gradually focused in on Eumaeus and Ithaca as the main subjects of my ideas.>>25659740Well, my biggest idea in the original paper is that the book, Ulysses, is hostile to its protagonists, at least past a certain point. In the master's thesis I started to draw on certain legendary Joyce scholars and their ideas, like Hugh Kenner's Uncle Charles Principle and David Hayman's Arranger. What I basically assert is that, within the meta-framework of the book, the shifts in style past a certain point aren't just experiments on Joyce's part, they're Ulysses trying to conquer and control both Stephen and Bloom, especially Bloom.
>>25659769>I gradually focused in on Eumaeus and IthacaYou love to see it. Ithaca is one of my favorite chapters in the book.>the shifts in style past a certain point aren't just experiments on Joyce's part, they're Ulysses trying to conquer and control both Stephen and Bloom, especially Bloom.That's interesting, I'd love to hear more. Which chapter would you say is when the book starts to control Bloom and Stephen?
>>25659774Starts TRYING to control, at least.As for where it starts, I'd argue it's at least vaguely present from the beginning, but where it REALLY begins to take hold is Aeolus. Go back and look at that chapter, with those headlines in all caps constantly interrupting the action. They're not the normal narrative voice, and they don't belong to either Stephen or Bloom's free indirect discourse. They're a fourth force, a fourth voice, that has entered the book.
>>25659779You know, I had a feeling it might have been Aeolus, since that's the first chapter where they "meet" each other, sorta. It makes sense too, Joyce briefly working as a journalist and him making fun of newspapers for their loud-mouthed headlines trying to compete for attention and whatnot. Good shit.
>>25659784Also, notice how ironic and undermining all the headlines are. They spend most of the chapter basically mocking Stephen, and Bloom, too. It's a clue that the book's intentions are not friendly.
>>25659589>useless coursesyes USA education has been overrun by leftists
>>25659761>>25659766This is an outstandingly immature post. I'm wowed. Are you a sophomore in uni? Sheesh.
>>25659769Yeah Stephen is a clown and Bloom is a clown. By design. How far did you take it? Your idea I mean.
>>25659905Yeah, I'm interested in how far they're missing the mark. Are the students bright enough to know they're being defrauded? Are they getting sucked in with a false understanding of "10% of the book"? Are they being taught the book properly so they aren't mystified when it's not Stephen King?
>>25659814>It's a clue that the book's intentions are not friendly.Thanks for the heads up, I'll keep it in mind the next time I reread it.
>25659939>25659944>25659949
Stop replying to this thread. An anime tourist who has no intention of reading this is just looking for talking points to download so he can pretend to be smart on some manchild board.
>>25659966>this is MY kinda girl, lit!
>>25659589No, but my mother did back when she was in university (not USA). They divided the class into groups and each one got a chapter to focus on.
>>25659944>How far did you take it? Your idea I mean.Well, I wound up developing my ideas into a scholarly essay and a proposal for a conference presentation. I submitted the essay to a couple of Joycean journals and the proposal to a major conference. The essay was rejected, but the proposal was accepted, so this summer I gave a talk at the conference.I got some pushback on my ideas, and a lot of the Joyce scholars I talk to think they need additional development, and more thorough engagement with other critics, particularly the more recent ones like the Joycean postmodernists and poststructuralists.I could in theory do all of this on my own, but if I can get paid to study and refine my ideas, why not? So I'm currently preparing to apply to a couple of PhD programs in English Literature. Hopefully I get into one and am able to really push my research and theories as far as they'll go.
>>25659939saying this while posting that image is definitely something
>>25660280How did that turn out?
>>25660280can you ask her what chapter she got
>>25660281What happens at a conference like that? Do you give a powerpoint or do you literally read your essay out loud to an auditorium? Are Joycean scholars irl as bad as they are on paper? I'm surprised you were rejected from journals. The Joyce industry is SCREAMING garbage. At their best the essays / "papers" say nothing. At least you have the right take on the novel. And worse, your "take" isn't new, it's the truth, it's inside the novel, it's where ppl should start from when thinking about the book. It couldn't be much more clear.
you dont read and you're not fitting in
>>25660516this this this this this!!
>>25659949science is also being attacked by leftists
>>25660398>And worse, your "take" isn't new, it's the truth, it's inside the novel, it's where ppl should start from when thinking about the book.Yeah, to be honest I'm kind of dreading getting forced to deal with the poststructuralists, postmodernists, postcolonialists, feminists, and other such critics if I get into a PhD program. I know I'll have to to be taken seriously, but I don't take THEM seriously from the start. My master's thesis advisor doesn't take them seriously either, he told me I didn't need to bother with them for the thesis. The only critics whose secondary literature I engaged with were classics: Hugh Kenner, Richard Ellmann, Stanley Sultan, and David Hayman.
>>25660900underage tourist, we know
>>25661254Ellmann bc the bio?
>>25661254You'll have to take them seriously meaning you'll have to a) understand Saussure (easy) and b) dismantle their essays (easy)—the good news is these dipshits almost exclusively feed off Nestor bc it's the shortest chapter, it has teaching and history in it, and has all sorts of things for them to complain about coming from Deasy. Idk how to deal with the postcolonialists—haven't seen anything from them.
>>25659974this!!!!!!
>and he's a phonepoasternauseating.
>>25661497Actually, this is the book I used for the thesis. People forget that Ellmann wrote quite a lot.
>>25662212You mean they're trying to forget. Though I think he's been pretty well washed away without artificial propping up. Kenner will win out. And that will bring in Davenport. And there will be a renaissance, partially due to copyrights ending.
>>25662312I actually used Kenner heavily, too. I might actually consider my own ideas to be a development from Kenner's. Like I've taken several key ideas from Kenner, and then taken one additional step forward, one additional step into new territory.
>>25660900What's the deal with these images? How are they being made?
>>25662201this so much this!
>>25659761>>25659766Was she pretty?
>>25662585No, butt she had one of those fat swishing asses that short circuits the beholder's brain.
>>25660281I'm an assistant professor and did my PhD in anglophone modernismsYou should pursue your ideas as far as you'd like to, but I'd advise that you only do so in academia if you end up in a fully funded program (5 years of funding guaranteed) and are perfectly OK not getting an academic TT job. >>25661254FWIW, at the level you're currently at, you likely don't understand poststructuralism, poco theorists, or even the postmodernist critical theorists beyond a very cursory level. There are many PhD programs with an emphasis on critical theory, and after years of coursework, research, and dissertation writing, the candidates don't have any mastery over "all theory." When I was applying to PhD programs I thought I was firmly in the "no theory" camp (just liked X, Y, and Z critics) and I ended up a poststructural narratologist.
>>25663086>You should pursue your ideas as far as you'd like to, but I'd advise that you only do so in academia if you end up in a fully funded program (5 years of funding guaranteed) and are perfectly OK not getting an academic TT job.Oh, I know all that. I'm only applying to fully-funded programs. I know better than to do the contrary.