Why do people unfairly hate on SEED Destiny?
I like the first half.Problem is it turns around and sucks the 2nd half.That is probably why right there. That and niggas hate blood pumping music and fast action. They want EVA existential slow drip.
>>24079598>unfairly
>>24079759The best ending.
>>24079773It was better than Final Plus and everything that happened afterwards at least.
>>24079643>I like the first half>gay mc-whinefag "protagonist" that is so shit at being a sasuke he practically killed off the character archetype's popularity>absolute character assassination of everyone from SEED>Rips off zeta arcs but rapes them to deathThe second half is trite fanfiction writing to solve everything with deus ex faggot surviving a nuke and shooting everyone without killing anyone. It is bad. The first half was just as shit.Literally the only interesting or original things in Seed Destiny were Lunamaria's design (as tomboy Fa) and the Meer Campbell arc. Everything else was ripping things off badly down to doing a trio of crackhead jobbers arc again like SEED did, except worse because they also used that to ripoff Four Murasame's entire arc but so badly, with so much overacted screeching it made everyone hate it instead of feeling anything real.
>>24080928>so shit at being a sasuke he practically killed off the character archetype's popularitySasuke didn't go full edgelord till well after Destiny finished. He had only just started his becoming Naruto's enemy arc around the time Destiny was wrapping up. If anything Shinn emboldened the character type
>>24080928Why are Shinn haters always such faggots? Shinn is much less of a whiner than Amuro and Kamille, yet nobody calls them whinefags. Curious.
>>24080987because even if he whines less, ultimately it's formed 90% of his personality and motivation so it's present almost the entire time except for his showing in freedom moviethe others whine more but they have different personalities and change over time so it feels more like progressiongive it time and when more people incorporate freedom as part of shinn's character they'll associate him less with whining and see it as more development
>>24080928Don't forget retconning Mu's death and everything he did as Neo is instantly swept under the rug.
>>24080999Funny thing is plenty of people hate how Shinn is in Freedom with him going from wanting to kill Kira to worshipping him. Though, I guess Freedom Zero is meant to explain how he got to that point.
>>24080987>Shinn is much less of a whiner than Amuro and KamilleShinn shrieks like a bitch constantly and throws completely retarded tantrums. Amuro was forced to pilot the Gundam and did it to protect himself and his friends, and actually grew into a really respectable character. Shinn was a jingoistic soldier still acting like a retarded edgelord 15 year old, he has no excuse of being forced into anything. He has no moment of ever realizing "wait I'm acting like a retard", he never grows the fuck up, he continues blaming everyone else except the people actually responsible for everything that happens.Athrun at the start of SEED was a much better character than Shinn ever became. Shinn was a shitty fanfiction writing attempt at ripping off the zeta start of "sequel character is ANGRY boy" without any actual nuance or understanding of why it worked. Kamille started off rough but genuinely fought for good causes, was smart, and grew as a character.
>>24080987Shinn deserves it.
>>24079598It is quite fairly hated on because it is terribly written. Seed was no great piece of literature either and had a number of faults... but Destiny took all of Seeds faults, doubled down on them and then made it's own main character out to be a little bitch by having a main character from Seed in there part time also being a little bitch... And it turned out so bad that they brought back Seed's perfect main hero to take over full time from both of them. Jesus Yamato saves!
>>24081236They did that anyway. How much Kira's takeover was planned is up for debate but Kira was clearly planned to be a big character in the show immediately and anyone who thought otherwise because "Well ZZ had Amuro and Char in the opening just to be thematic" is doesn't realize that Fukuda doesn't have that kind of nuance and that Amuro and Char were gonna be in ZZ until CCA was greenlit during production.
>>24080928>the Meer Campbell arcMeer was an interesting idea but executed terribly. She was such an after thought that we didn't even get her backstory until after she was dead.
>>24081259Meer's not a real character. She exists to show why Lacus is great and anyone who isn't Lacus is bad.
>>24081243>How much Kira's takeover was planned is up for debate but Kira was clearly planned to be a big characterThe more I think about it, the more it seems Destiny was a project forced on the staff by the executives, who insisted on doing Zeta redux (timed to coincide with ANT):>new, angry protagonist>phantom pain as not-titans>athrun as quattro>et ceteraIt's very obvious with Shinn: even the slapdash writing makes it obvious that Fukuda did not want him around as the protagonist and any sequel for SEED was supposed to be more power fantasy with Kira on Freedom.The mecha design tells a story on itself: while Freedom is intended to look heroic and angelical (Fukuda's words), Destiny is clearly more "villainous", with sharper lines and that edgy "crying blood" faceplate.>>24081025>Athrun at the start of SEED was a much better character than Shinn ever became.Nah. Athrun was supposed to have had his whole thing solved during the first series. Why the fuck is he still hung on his father's words? Patrick almost destroyed the fucking planet.
>>24081243>and that Amuro and Char were gonna be in ZZ until CCA was greenlit during production.Bullshit.https://gundamunofficial.com/production/gundamzz_animec.html>I don't yet know whether Amuro will actually appear in ZZ.>It's yet to be decided whether or not [Char] will appear, but if he does, he might get to the point where he feels he could run the Zabi family himself.
>>24081447That's not what I read 10 years ago
>>24081450>In his initial Gundam ZZ story outline, Tomino had proposed bringing Char back in mid-series on the enemy side, but by the time the broadcast began he seems to have cooled to the idea.https://tominostuff.tumblr.com/post/689166158551793664/my-anime-magazine-1986-may-edition>This is story-related, but will Char reappear after the third cour begins?>He probably will. But if ZZ can earn some support as it is, then it's also possible Char won't appear. In that case, maybe Char is dead in a ditch somewhere. (laughs) This time, ZZ's audience are mainly children, so Char may not show up.
>>24081453Damn it stop adding new info how am I supposed to be smug and all knowing if they keep changing things. Fuck
Should I just watch the movie instead of the showNormally I'd be all for content and wanting as many episodes as possible, but I'm really not feeling it for Seed Destiny
>>24081453>on the enemy sideeven though anyone who'd fight against Haman would probably be more of a friend than her (fuck Glemy)I really want to see the ZZ that would have had Char come back, or a ZZ that doesn't feel so rushed by the endDeserves a novelization or a movie series, and I hate recap movies
>>24081443I'd argue that Shinn being a Kira fanboy/lapdog in Seed Freedom isn't that out of character for him, but the fact he has nothing going for him beyond that continues the trend of Fukuda not caring about anyone that isn't propping up Kira and Lacus.
>>24081443>Athrun was supposed to have had his whole thing solved during the first seriesI said at the start of SEED. Destiny character assassinated every main cast member. Athrun gets brain damage, Cagalli becomes a cowardly little girl instead of a tomboy veteran, etc.But the best fight in all of SEED was the final fight between Strike and Aegis. That was the peak of that whole timeline.
>>24081443>The more I think about it, the more it seems Destiny was a project forced on the staff by the executives, who insisted on doing Zeta redux (timed to coincide with ANT):Rumor is that only the first 15-ish episodes were planned by the writers of Seed Destiny. It was supposed to be from Athrun's perspective (like how Season 1 was Kira's perspective). It was supposed to end with Athrun getting Saviour Gundam and flying to Earth. Then the story remains open ended. Which sort of makes sense since everything feels so self-contained during the first 15 episodes. 1. Athrun hesitant to fight.2. Gundam Hijack incident.3. Minerva sent to stop Break the World colony drop.4. Athrun sees his friends and decides to fight to protect everyone.5. Athrun gets Saviour Gundam and flies to Earth. End.Bandai wanted more and forced it to extend. Then the story goes off the rails. It's full of nonsense with Minerva pretty much wandering around Earth and doing nothing for 10 episodes. Then Kira comes back and hijacks the anime.
>>24080972Sasuke NEVER EVER went edgelord, Kishimoto is very, very attentive in keeping characters from crossing moral lines lightly or betraying what the believe in. The stories he writes have extremely strong aesops, such as Revenge is Bad. Notice how Sasuke never killed any civilians, just the guy who ordered his family killed. Even at the end, the most he wanted to do was kill the 5 Kages to start a revolution to bring peace.Whereas Shinn goes from wanting revenge on the EA and the Freedom for invading ORB and causing civilian casualties, to destroying ORB fleets himself and the ORB officer that rescued him, to attacking ORB territory, and then finally to attempting to blow up ORB and kill everyone with Requiem. Morosawa was big on petty, disproportionate, ultraviolent revenge, and it shows in her writing and IMO her personal character.
Is this the fart sniffing thread?
>>24081526Cagalli is a tomboy veteran. That’s her problem. That doesn’t fucking work in the role she’s now forced into. It’s been twenty years you can’t all be this fucking stupid. It’s solved.
I feel the Archangel vs. Minerva thing could have worked if they didn't make the Archangel always in the right and the Minerva mindless pawns for Durandal.
>>24081526>>24081629Even in SEED, Cagalli was always a worthless character that the writing humiliates over and over. She's constantly crying, gets pushed around by other characters and acts stupid, making her very annoying to watch. From the top of my mind:>cries over her father betraying Orb's principles>gets shoved on an escape pod by Kira>gets slapped by Kira in the desert arc for being too impetuous>gets easily overpowered by Athrun during the island episode>gets slapped off-screen by her father for confronting him over his betrayal. Neither Kira nor Erica support her>crying and whining about Kira when Athrun gets captured>more worthless crying and whining during the fall of Orb; her father physically pushes her to the Kusanagi>this scene with Mwu>Rouge is customized with an additional support AI, because she's worthless>gets Rouge pushed out by Athrun during the attack on GENESIS; more crying>whines to Durandal about PLANT using Orb refugees to make weapons>cries to Athrun when Shinn rightfully calls her out on the Atthas' hypocrisy>does absolutely nothing to stop the Seirans from making a pact with the Atlantic Federation and just mumbles around in the meetings>gets herself overpowered by Yuna and goes along into marrying the creep>gets kidnapped by Kira>DARDANELLES>CRETE>more crying when the Murasame pilots get to the Archangel>more stupid hotheadedness: wants to go out on the Skygrasper to defend Orb>gets the Akatsuki, a one-off machine with nigh-impenetrable armor, damaged by Destiny in its very first deploymentI'm pretty sure people have an "idea" of Cagalli as a character that has no connection whatsoever with how the character actually is treated on the story itself. You can't "assassinate" a character this shitty.
>>24081794I mean Durandal wasn't even a bad guy for 95% of the anime. He only did something questionable at the end of the anime when he threatened Orb. And to be fair, Orb DID assist Logos and Djibril. They allowed Djibril to escape and fire Requiem which blew up several Plant colonies and kill tens of millions of Plant citizens. It's really hard to say that Djibril is a bad guy. It's more like everyone else has brain damage and suddenly wanted to protect Orb. The entire Earth should be furious at Orb for helping Djibril.
>>24081863Because aside from the Seirans the show treats Orb like it can do no wrong just like the Archangel. Plus, aside from Berlin they completely ignore LOGOs. I think someone said they think Lacus saying just because she doesn't support Durandal doesn't mean she supports Djibril was added to save face for the audience.
>>24081863>It's really hard to say that Djibril is a bad guy.You meant Durandal here, right?>The entire Earth should be furious at Orb for helping Djibril.They are. Even though they don't deploy any Windams, we see Earth Alliance cruisers next to ZAFT submarines during Operation Fury. The Archangel sinks a bunch of them later on (probably recycled footage from earlier).
>>24081863>It's really hard to say that Djibril is a bad guy.Based and Blue Earth pilled.
Did the anime just gloss over the fact that Logos destroyed several Zaft colonies? Millions died. I remember in Season 1 that destroying just a single Zaft colony was a MASSIVE deal and caused an entire war. But losing like 8 of them at once near the end of Season 2 is kinda just glossed over after a single episode and no one talks about it much.
>>24081899Stop being a meme-spewing imbecile, Duel.
>>24081902Just like how Freedom glossed over the fact that two major cities were completely wiped off the map.In many shows, this would be the most tragic event to happen in the story, but SEED just doesn't care that thousands of people died in a flash, and it doesn't have any repercussions either. The movie wastes more time about the Archangel's destruction or Lacus becoming missing than Ishtaria's complete destruction.
>>24081591>Whereas Shinn goes from wanting revenge on the EA and the Freedom for invading ORB and causing civilian casualties, to destroying ORB fleets himself and the ORB officer that rescued him, to attacking ORB territory, and then finally to attempting to blow up ORB and kill everyone with Requiem.Nothing wrong with any of this.
It was so bad the mecha genre never recovered from it.
>>24081443>The mecha design tells a story on itself: while Freedom is intended to look heroic and angelical (Fukuda's words), Destiny is clearly more "villainous", with sharper lines and that edgy "crying blood" faceplate.Compare the debut of Destiny vs Strike Freedom.Destiny (and Legend) first appears in the hangar cloaked in shadow and full of wires, emphasizing their machine-like nature. Shinn does puppy eyes to Durandal while Athrun is still mad about the Kira thing. Background music is the third ED, very melancholic with the string part.The first time they are used in combat is when Shinn and Rey go after Athrun, but nothing much is made about the fact that these are new machines: they could've used Impulse and a ZAKU and wouldn't have made a difference. Ditto with the "actual" debut in Ragnarok; even the takeoff animation cut is nothing special compared to the Splendor assembly. He gets to take out a bunch of Destroys (a sight that terrified Talia), but the story keeps cutting back to Athrun in bed being tended by Kira and Cagalli.Strike Freedom, on the other hand, gets a celestial chorus the first time it shows up onboard the Eternal. It goes through all the boot-up sequence, plus more cool cuts with the lights and shadows. Then it takes off, VESTIGE plays and repeats all the flashy moments Freedom had on the first series, plus the new gimmick of remote weapons.The whole fucking thing is the director screaming at the viewer "look at how cool and awesome Kira and Freedom are!"."Aura farming", as the zoomers call it
>>24081902It was treated like "Djbril did it and we killed him so the problem is solved". It helped that Durandal immediately started turning people to the Destiny Plan before they had time to think about it too hard
>>24081591Sasuke wanted to kill everyone in Konoha at one point he just never got into position to do so before he eventually got over himself. Just like how Shinn wanted to kill everyone in Orb but was stopped.
>>24081443>while Freedom is intended to look heroic and angelical (Fukuda's words), Destiny is clearly more "villainous", with sharper lines and that edgy "crying blood" faceplate.>>24081974That was certainly the intention by the time it debuted, but there is one issue with this being preplanned though, one of the "tells" of the Destiny being evil is that it had a light grayish paint rather than white like the Impulse, Strike and Freedom. But this wasn't actually visible in some of the earliest Destiny official art from before its tv show debut. Which suggests there were behind the scenes changes going on until fairly late.Still, the logo of SEED Destiny changed to featuring the Strike Freedom with its 3rd opening, so by that point they certainly intended to position Shinn as an antagonist already, months before the story played out on the show.Oddly though, Shinn's VA was still credited in the number 1 spot every episode where he was featured until the late 30s. It's only in the 40s where he's officially removed from the protagonist position in the credits of the original run of SEED Destiny.
>>24082040Kira's group only really officially take over as the protagonists after Athrun rejoins them. That's when Shinn stops getting any meaningful focus outside of fight scenes
>>24082044I think there are some who consider Athrun the true protagonist because of it. I think even the recap moves and The Edge manga do this too. Surprisingly I think the Edge manga actually shows Shinn scoring some hits in the final battle as opposed to the anime where Athrun destroyed him in seconds.
>>24082066The recap makes Athrun the protag because it's the only way to have a consistent narrative using the footage they already had to work with.
>>24081591Larger alert larger alert! Sasuke did go full edge mode dumbass he wanted to kill the whole village and slime out his old friends.
>>24081967Based and fuck it pilled, at that point Orb was just in the way causing more problems by showing up trying to stop the fighting like a female screaming at two guys
>>24082014>Just like how Shinn wanted to kill everyone in OrbStop with the bullshit. Shinn just hated Orb's government and the Atthas for being hypocrites. He wasn't a psychopath that would murder every single civilian in the island.
>>24081591>and the ORB officer that rescued himHe had no choice, Todaka was working for Djibril and Neo.
>>24082113In the finale he was supporting Orb being destroyed by Requiem so yes he was.
>>24082114>>24081591See, this shit annoys me from a storytelling point of view. If they really wanted to make Shinn a tragic character, he should've learned that he was the one who killed the one person in Orb that helped him and make him spiral further down.Instead, it's a non-event in the story, only useful to make Cagalli cry even more. Even a worthless character like Tolle got more repeats of his death than Todaka's. For fuck's sake, they even repeated Rau's death in Freedom's "supercut of tragic deaths".
>>24082124And doesn't Athrun have a flashback to people who died in the last war and one of them is Flay whom he never even met let alone wasn't even there when it happened?
>>24081523I hate Kira and Lacus, in Seed Destiny and Freedom they come off as like creepy dolls, “we’ll protect you, It’s okay” etc bullshit. Kira is also a bum ass pilot, he is told to be the ultimate coordinator, but only wins in fights when his mech is objectively better than the enemy, in Destiny, Freedom gets clapped by Impulse and Shin, in the movie he gets clapped by the White and Black knight, until he gets the special backpack upgrade. His ass trash just like Char, farming W’s on NPC’s, disgusting work
>>24081259Show unironically just killed her off to tie up loose ends, there was no reason for them to attempt to kill the real Lacus, Durandal didn’t even sign off on it, they just wanted to kill her fr, the ending episodes of Seed Destiny were so bad.
>>24082134I'm almost surprised they didn't kill off Shinn either.
>>24082127>>24082111>>24082103Get the fuck out of my board, spammer.
>>24082145My guess is that Fukuda would've killed Shinn off, but the execs wouldn't let him.
>>24082150That's what I thought too.
>destiny is just a worse perfect strike
>>24082134Why would they not want to try to kill Lacus again? Meer was useless to them at that point because they'd been exposed
>>24082179For a second I thought you were talking about the writers because yeah, once she was exposed, she served her purpose, so they killed her.
>>24082200I mean the writers yes, but even in universe once Meer had been exposed the only use for her left was to try to trap for another attempt to get the real Lacus right before the Destiny Plan rolled out
>>24082124>>24081591>>24082114Shinn didn't even know the guy who rescued him was on the ship. It's supposed to be ironic. Morosawa isn't some genius writer but she did okay here.