[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/mlp/ - Pony


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: creaturequestria.jpg (279 KB, 1280x720)
279 KB JPG
>School of Friendship
Why did Hasbro do this to make S8-S9 awful?
>>
Why wasn't it the Castle of the Two Sisters?
It's been said a thousand times before and it'll be said a thousand times again but throwing the old, great sets that people already liked instead of milking them as much as possible (treebrary, canterlot, CoT2S) was such a fucking mistake and cost them so much goodwill as well.
>>
File: acting_cute.png (238 KB, 574x850)
238 KB PNG
she's the only good thing to come from S8
>>
>>43712398
>Hasbro
Unironically Hasjew is not the primary thing to blame for schoolshit. Yes they wanted *A* school added to the show, but the retarded staff are the ones who based the last two seasons around it instead of having it be a one off episode.
>>
anyone have a picture of the mane six's homes?
>>
>>43712424
>>
>>43712398
Hasbro only dictated School in s08 opener. The choice to make it creatureschool and having it featured in other episodes and having M6 as teachers instead of students is entirely on Haber.
>>
>>43712429
rip golden oak
>>
File: 1682200993081831.png (37 KB, 170x192)
37 KB PNG
>>43712429
thanks! comfy
>>
>>43712432
I'm still pissed that Amy Mebberson trolled us all by claiming that BOOM! Studios comics are gonna be set in s03 era.
>>
>>43712398
Most people in entertainment peaked in high school. They "write what they know", and so stick all characters into some Prussian-model education system, no matter how little sense it makes.

eg.: The student six are miserable and do not actually become friends until they escape the institution that supposedly is teaching them friendship.
>>
>>43712408
I think you meant:
>she is the only thing from S8 that I cum to
>>
>>43712453
Vogel is to blame. He even admitted it
>>
>>43712476
Why'd he do it?
>>
>>43712429
Based Dash, living in the fucking sky and looking down on everypony, she could probably take a piss outside and all the no wings would think its raining.
>>
>>43712398
I think that the school of friendship could've been great, if the writers were competent. It's hard to say that the school was the problem when every episode during that time without it was just as bad.
>>
File: kirin.png (1.2 MB, 1024x1024)
1.2 MB PNG
>>43712408
False
>>
>>43712658
>the school of friendship could've been great
The fucking concept of learning friendship from books and school is literal antithesis of the premise of the show.
>>
Something something as mentioned all hasbro asked was for silverstream and the friendship school to show up and the rest is the shows fault.
>>43712658
Its a very ass backwards concept, it can only work in the sense most ideas can. And even at its best, it doesn't make sense as the ongoing focus of your series.
And trying to tie it with a different races gimmick is only weighing it down further.
>>
File: ooglemarry.png (39 KB, 577x538)
39 KB PNG
>>43713450
AWOOOOOOOOOOGA SEX WITH KIRINS UNF UNF UNF PLAP PLAP PLAP!!!
>>
File: 2319360.jpg (797 KB, 3345x3093)
797 KB JPG
>>43712457
false we got fluttergoth from s8 too
>>
>>43712408
Literally who?
>>
>>43714040
Cozy Glow
>>
>>43712398
money
>>
I like the students a lot, I think they should have just been ambassadors from their homelands. School was dumb.
>>
>>43712398
Josh Haber Classic
>>
>>43712398
wasnt it supposed to be a spinoff
>>
>>43713680
>>43713700
Yeah, for it to work it would need to be very different. Less "Let's teach friendship with lectures!" and more "I was really alone when I was studying magic, I want to create a school that is better." And it would've needed to be scaled back dramatically to avoid the pitfall of making the show about Twilight and the secondary five. Treat it with the same gravity as Rarity's fashion business. It should be important to Twilight, not the center of the world.

Less could've been more with the creature slop too. Just like how making the school the whole season rather than a few focus episodes made it meaningless, making the foreign exchange students the whole season rather than something like 3 focus episodes for 2 characters made them meaningless too. Competent writers also would've realized that doing creature slop would've been much more interesting if we got to see more of their homelands rather than trying to make them just like ponies.
>>
What-if exercise: Let's say it's the end of Season 7 and you are in charge of the show's direction. You know the show is lasting for 2 more seasons, and you're stuck with the shitfuckery of the seasons that came before, but you can scrap the School idea.

What would you occupy the last 2 seasons with?
>>
>>43714650
And you know what, I'll add a little more flexibility: You can change the premise of the Movie if it's going to have an effect on the show.
>>
>>43714662
the movie never happens
the end
>>
>>43714650
School is removed. All School-related episodes are removed. I still might like to see Smolder as a transfer student or something
I would still have Spike gaining wings. Either that, or Spike gaining magic. Just remove retarded deafness plot.
LyraBon scene stays.
Scootaloo's lesbian "aunts" are outright removed, parents are unmentioned, The Cakes are not her guardians.
Remove Daring Do episodes.
Twilight does not move away from Ponyville.
Discord is not Grogar
Villain episodes stay, just make sure to not show them being close to reformation (so that even retards would understand).
Do not reform all the villains.
Do not attack disarmed villains (i.e. obliterate them with the rainbow on the first try)
Do not make Discord perform petrification
Do not make Fluttershy starve predators.
Still have an epilogue, just with younger M6 (no eyebags, no gray hair). Still have canon couples. More kids of M6. AJ have a lot of kids. Remove Fluttercord.
Have a comfy fluff episode with Celestia and Luna going to brief vacation. No arguing, but still some conflict/drama, just not between them. Philomena exists.
Replace "Horse Play" with Twilight and Celestia episode.
Mean Six actually do something
Remove "The End in Friend", replace with another Rarity and Rainbow Dash episode (like Rarity Investigates!, only about something else, not detective).
Remove self-referential humor.
Leave "Going to Seed" in, but make it less... preschool-ley.
Obviously still include "Sounds of Silence"
Erase "Yakity-Sax" from existence, it never existed.
Make Lightning Dust less unhinged in "The Washouts", make her give bad advice, but not maliciously, don't sabotage Scootaloo. LD still gets rejected, but does not get blasted off.
Remove "A Rockhoof and a Hard Place" or make it less retarded.
>>
>>43714650
>you are in charge of the show's direction
Declare thateverything past season 2 is no longer canon. Season 8 will be rebranded as season 3 and we go from there.
>>
>>43714761
Also maybe make an episode out of "Sunny Skies All Day Long" fanfic. Not a direct adaptation, just take a premise.
>>
>>43714650
>>43714662
I'll take hard mode without touching the movie. What I would really like to change is the season 6 finale, but I can accept the bad situation.

Season 7 begins with Chrysalis causing problems, establishing that even in exile she's dangerous, and the bulk of the season deals with trying to track her and clean up problems that she leaves everywhere she goes, which conveniently gives lots of reasons to travel to far away places since Chrysalis won't head for the center of equestria while on the run. And to give it a bit more direction, Chrysalis is searching for Starswirl's lost research, which comes to a culmination in the season 7 finale. I'm not canonizing the other pillars or bring Starswirl to the present though, and Starswirl is getting completely different characterization.

The moral of the finale is that even if someone is redeemable, sometimes it's not your place, and trying to help them just makes it worse. This is shown with chrysalis entering into a truce with the mane 6, and predictably backstabbing them once the lost research is completed. It ends with chrysalis getting exiled from the equestria mainland like a manipulative ex or mother. It's slightly hopeful with signs that chrysalis can redeem herself but highlights that nobody can make the decision for her, and trying to help won't be good for her.

Season 8's opening has the princesses in crisis, not because of some kind of monster attack, though. Celestia has simply gotten sick, and needs Twilight's help with royal duties until she recovers. Twilight always felt like the odd one among the princesses, so season 8 will focus on fixing that. Most of the season will be calm without monsters, focused on establishing the post ending status quo and showing everyone getting their hero's rewards. There's lots of indulgent fan service. The finale has no time skip, and is about Pinkie inviting everyone to a party celebrating Twilight's anniversary for arriving in Ponyville.
>>
>>43714797
Just some bullet points of what I would like to squeeze in.
>A chance to meet Luna's bat pony guard, and establish bat pony capabilities.
>All four princesses meet to exchange and practice spells for an episode.
>Twilight establishes her own guard for her castle.
>Also Twilight's castle gets renovated, actually establishing what is in it, and making it stop looking like a giant middle finger.
>A couple of Moondancer episodes.
>Episodes on Rarity's business empire.
>Better fluttershy x discord fuel.
>Flutterbat returns
>An episode on sweet apple acre's finances, where Twilight and/or Rarity tries to help out only to find out Applejack is loaded since the farm has been successful for so long. Moral against excessive splurging with another "Applejack was right all along" ending.

And if I can fudge for an extra EQG movie too
>Make Flash Sentry an actual character so there's at least one more stallion for shipping.
>EQG mane 6 + sunset shimmer visit equestria
>Human sunset shimmer revealed.

And if I can push my luck
>Glimmy fucking dies
>Trottingham and any mares within are canonized.
>>
>>43714864
>All four princesses meet to exchange and practice spells for an episode.
How would it even work? It's only enough content for a cold open.
>>
File: 1524892.jpg (1.76 MB, 2560x1920)
1.76 MB JPG
>>43714864
> and making it stop looking like a giant middle finger.
Already done in the movie/RR.
>>
>>43714896
Start with revealing a weakness that Celestia has, and twilight knows the answer but is too nervous to give advice until Celestia asks directly. When the get together proper starts, Twilight expects to learn and be tested only, and that gets in her way until she realizes that she really is in the same league as the princesses now, and they invited her because they wanted her help and expertise. The obstacle that brings that out could be magical mishap that Twilight assumes the other three have under control as it increasingly becomes evident that they do not. Or something else like that. Maybe she assumes they're sandbagging on purpose while failing to solve something, and she intentionally botches her spells to fit in.
>>
>>43714905
incredible how one change can make it look nicer, still out of place though.
>>
>>43712398
Why does one need a school for friendship???
>>
>>43715266
The ponies are retarded
>>
>>43714905
the left its a jagged sharp piece of shit faust said she avoided when designing mlp in the right its just trying to soften up a still clearly out of place jagged bullshit
>>
>>43715266
Friendship is power
>>
>>43714905
Still looks like shit
>>
>>43714905
Still looks good
>>
>>43712398
I'd love to visit. Looks comfy.
>>
>>43714905
still awful



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.