[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/mlp/ - Pony

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
Flag
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1773638145375041.png (677 KB, 1209x1403)
677 KB PNG
Weird Mare Edition

Previous Edition: >>43641477

Fauster's Story Archive: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XiJRe1NWl_kIoWsHssZ27BMV7bZAe1jgX59-dWggYkA/
Uh-hmmm's Prompt Archives:
https://ponepaste.org/1046
Have a broken Pastebin link? Replace pastebin.com with poneb.in

Remember:
not to save anything of value on Pastebin
ignore all attempts at early new threads

Thread question: How would you want your wife to celebrate your anniversary? (assuming she remembers)
>>
>>43713425
new green list
>>43711967
>>
>>43713425
Any updates to the long and short of it and the sunburst green?
>>
>>43713500
Never ever, king
>>
>You are Spotless Peytral, a slightly-disgruntled Royal Guardsmare currently attending another Marks of Honor meeting.

>What is Marks of Honor? Well...
>Long story short, it's a club for mares with scars. Small ones, big ones, how you got 'em, doesn't matter, all are welcome.
>You gather with the gals to play some pool, drink some cider, and devour a cupcake or two. Maybe holler at the game on the crystal ball.
>Alright, alright, you couldn't lie to save your life, this is little more than a support group for literally-scarred mares.

>Other mares are often surprised by this particular revelation. To them, scars are cool, a permanent proof that you're a certified flank-kicker and mean business.

>Problem is, stallions dislike mares with scars.
>And 'dislike' is putting it very, very lightly.
>Celestia forbid it's a prominent one or happens to be on the muzzle! In fact, it's not uncommon for the members of the fairer sex to straight up bolt upon seeing a scarred mare, like they've seen a ghost.

>With your scar being right there, smack dab in the center of your nose, you've lost count of the amount of colts rapidly disappearing upon you entering any given room. It would be downright comical if it didn't hurt that much.
>Only ones remaining in place are either with their herds or are spoken-for. Which doesn't stop them from giving you a terrified side-eye every now and then, usually followed by generally trying to position their mares between you and them.

>And then there are, of course, the colts who don't bolt, but treat you with caustic disdain, often repeating the ever-painful saying, 'Scars are only found on mares dumb enough to get them'.

>You can't help but feel that you're getting screwed by the universe, and not in the fun way, either! You have spent many years protecting this country and these colts, and this is what you get? That's horseapples!

>You nurse your drink, watching as the liquid swirls inside the mug.

>Damn...

>Moondancer was right, you ARE all going to become marecels!..
>>
>>43713672

>You'd probably continue this unhappy train of thought, but it gets derailed by the entrance doors practically bursting open.

>The sheer volume of double doors slamming against the walls in unison makes mares jump, their gazes crossing at the entrance like searchlights.

>You have to squint to make out silhouettes against the bright sunlight, and they sure don't look like your normal visitors.

>Wait. It's those alien colts, the hyoomans!

>"The tip didn't lie, get 'em boys!"

>With that, all Tartarus broke loose.

>Sword and Board to your right got scooped up and was currently receiving rapid-fire kisses all over her muzzle in a wide-eyed daze.

>To your left, Tempest got cornered and called cute repeatedly. She's redder than a ripe tomato, and that's quite an achievement considering her coat color!
>Poor gal, her reputation is never going to recover from this...

>In the background, Heavy Halberd has laid one of the hyooman colts right across the pool table, holding him down with one hoof and pulling his tie taut with another. Judging by said hyooman's expression, which easily takes the cake as the raunchiest expression you've seen a colt conjure, he's quite into it.
>His hand bolts forward and takes... her hoof!

>L-Lewd!

>As if in a trance, you observe him planting a kiss on her hoof, which causes Halberd to lose it completely and start nuzzling the colt right then and there!

>One of the amorous tall lugs seems to have zeroed in on you and a moment later you're locked in a tight hug.
>You look at his face, the rest of the world going mute and fading away. All you can see are small pink hearts in his eyes.
>Small, foalish, cutesy eyes...
>Your forehooves lock him into a hug of your own.

>In less than a minute, it was all over.
>The entirety of the club room is silent, with but a rare whisper.
>All attending mares are holding or are being held by their hyooman colts, in a way that only the greatest treasures can be reverently held.
>Many a mare has her hoof held by her corresponding hyooman.
>Very lewd!

>Tempest is still red in the face, but that doesn't stop her from aggressively rubbing up her colt with the most elated look you've seen her sport.

>And as for you? You're not complaining, wiggling tighter into your hyooman colt's warm embrace as he strokes your mane gently.

>"I, uh, am sorry for the mess. My pals tend to be quite a handful when excited."

>You just hum and shrug. Which mare cares about a little mess?
>Especially if it nets her a cute colt willing to look past the looks!
>>
>>43713673
>Wait... There is one hyooman without a mare. Making a quick headcount, you declare,
"Gals, I'm sorry to ruin the moment, but looks like we're a mare short."

>Sword and Board perks up,
>"Nightly Rounds is truant again! Let's go get her!"

>Five minutes later, you are at Nightly Rounds' doorstep, with the lone hyooman gently knocking and other hyoomans cheering him on.

>Nightly Rounds is surprised by the sheer commotion.
>The hyooman smiles at her,
>"I was told that a cool mare with scars lives here."

>Over the next several seconds, Rounds' mouth silently morphs into a small 'o'.
>She then smiles and proudly presents a scar on her flank that almost completely covers her left cutie-mark.

>She probably should've watched out for the hearts in the hyooman's eyes, 'cause much to her surprise and the shared mirth of mares she's scooped up and proclaimed beautiful.

>Turns out, alien colts dig scars!

>Somewhere far, far away, a certain pink princess rubs hooves with a cheesy smirk.
>All according to the plan...
>>
>>43713676

A short green I decided to polish up and finish.
Ponepaste: https://ponepaste.org/12247

To propeller:
I LIVED, BITCH!
>>
>>43713676
There goes those darn aliens abducting our mares. At this rate they're going to conquer the world!
>>
File: 1768735065697951.jpg (1.53 MB, 1440x1868)
1.53 MB JPG
>Meet evil alternate dimension version of Luna
>She respects stallions
>>
>>43714390
She’s happily married. Are we sure our Luna is ‘good’?
>>
>>43714390
>meet hot evil bitch
>she respects you
ick
>>
File: 1791578854411788.png (1.26 MB, 5000x6442)
1.26 MB PNG
>>43714830
Being evil doesn't mean you can't improve yourself. We must be better mares.
>>
>>43714830
Lunislam is right about stallions
>>
File: 1767222519038276.gif (20 KB, 500x500)
20 KB GIF
>>43713676
Wonderful. All mares deserve love.
>>
>>43714893
May all stallions be raped and murdered Alunamdulillah
>>
>>43714893
>>43715281
Get these s*ddle *rabians out of me sight
>>
>>43713500
Sunburst updated last thread. Unless you've read that one already, in which case, you're out of luck for the next 6 months. That's how you know that writefag is a colt, no work ethic.
>>
>>43713681
Fine green, though, this makes me think of the post from last thread. "Stallions don't like mares with scars," paints stallions as far too homogeneous, and plays into the biggest pitfall for RGRE.
Writers tend to simplify the world into absolutes. I'm sure there'd be plenty of stallions into mares with scars, and stallions who think they're gross. Probably plenty of stallions who like rough and tumble "bad fillies" and others who avoid those kinds.
You telling me Fancy Pants and Big Mac would have the same taste in mares?
There are some traits that might be universally disliked, or at least majorly, like being a complete unemployed loser mare, but for the most part, I'm sure there's a stallion out there for every mare.
Princess Cadence says so, anyway...
>>
>>43715942
>Writers tend to simplify the world into absolutes.
Not really, the stallions that don't mind scars are just very few and far between, and are likely already snagged into a herd.
In regular gender roles terms, there aren't many girls who'd date a cripple Veteran McMurderface. Why would you, if you had a ton of chads to pick from?
>>
Now I want a serious green where Anon and a scarred up mare who's seen a lot of combat end up bonding over scars.
Like the two start talking at the bar, she thinks she's being humored or someone put him up to it, until he mentions one of her scars looks like his.
He points to her side where she has a nasty-looking one, then lifts up the hem of his shirt to show one on his side that looks similar.
While he does, she sees other scars and feels a combination of interest and rightous anger.
Either Anon's a vet, a daredevil, a klutz, or just really accident prone.
Regardless, the mare decides to make it her duty to never let another scar mark this colt's skin.
>>
>>43715942
>Mono Giga-Stacy whos only advice is: "Just go up to stallions and talk to them"
Princess Cadence can go fuck herself
>>43715281
Would it be A-luna(m)-dulillah or Alhamdu-luna(h)?
>>
>>43713425
Is this image based off something?
>>
>>43716227
Second this, would be a neat interaction.
>>
>>43716227
>or just really accident prone.

>be a broken ex-guardsmare
>living in marital bliss to a wonderful creature called a hoomin
>finally, you found the only colt in the world who was able to look past your scars to see the mare underneath
>he's shown you love that you still feel like you don't deserve
>the night he showed you his own scars was the most beautiful night of your life
>you swore an oath to never let harm befall this damaged flower ever again
>however...
>"Ey honey, check out how fast I can chop this onion!"
>you really should've have learned how he got all those scars before you made that oath
>"That Dash chick was bragging about all her tricks again, so I got to thinking, how hard can it really be to do a triple backflip?"
>you love him deeply but watching making sure this dumbflank doesn't hurt himself is a tougher gig than the siege of Canterlot
>"Alright, I got the huge tub of ice for the brewskis, now I just need to carry it all the way past my homemade deep-fryer and all those Legos I left out on the floor."
>You're pretty sure that when they say marriage is difficult, this isn't what they mean

I might do a serious one in the future
>>
File: yes-sit.gif (1.07 MB, 220x174)
1.07 MB GIF
>>43716549
kek worthy green
>spoiler
>>
File: 1777206792436124.jpg (121 KB, 1195x750)
121 KB JPG
>>43716303
"You gave the weird girl a chance" was a normalfag meme, but the actual content of the image isn't based off of anything as far as I know.
>>43716549
>Anon decides to clean the house
>Guard wife's sixth sense for danger kicks in
>She has to stop him from mixing bleach and ammonia
>>
>>43716625
"I've only died twice this week!"
>"I want you to stop dying at all."
>>
>>43713425
>Thread question: How would you want your wife to celebrate your anniversary? (assuming she remembers)
how would anniversaries even work when polygamy is common?
It's not like herds get all their members simultaneously
>>
>>43716830
If it's polygamy than the stallion specifically still has an anniversary. But I don't that's what the prompt was talking about.
>>
>>43716833
>anniversary
anniversary of what? Getting with the first mare?
Doesnt sound fair for other herdmates
>>
>>43716834
You're assuming it's literally a harem (and a harem of the variety held by anime protagonists rather than a real harem which is generally inherited premade) because you're so baked into the idea of it being a male power fantasy, but there's literally no reason why a herd has to start between a single mare and a single stallion and indeed a lot of reasons to expect the stallion to only come into it after a significant part of the herd is established. If it's the standard family unit, then the expectation is that there's probably a communal place of residence owned mutually by a group of mares and they approach courtship as a group and bring a stallion in to their circumstances.
>>
>>43716867
you sound very, very angry at me asking a simple question
how exactly was I turning herds into harems when I propositioned that they are formed from a couple that gains other mares later?
>>
>>43716867
I think the 'mares court as a group' idea is particularly strong when you consider how they would of course attract stallions with a musical number. Only gigastacys and famous musicians and the like could dare try to court stallions without backing vocals and solid choreography. The professionalism of the number reflects how the mares trust each other and are able to cooperate as a family unit, as well as impressing whimsical stallions via catchy music and flashy costumes.

>herd does a big musical number for Anon
>he doesn't get it, calls it gay
>dreams crushed

>Vinyl and Octavia started herding to court a stallion
>their attempts always comically fail because they can't cooperate musically
>>
File: 1793583874226063.jpg (730 KB, 2048x2048)
730 KB JPG
Behead all stallions
>>
>>43717889
I would be a good stallion that kiss the top upper lips and the crotch lower lips like a good stallion and make sure she eats before I do.
>>
>>43717889
I will now watch your show
>>
>>43717889
>Behead all demoralizationposters and femdomfags
Fixed that for you
>>
pre bed bump
>>
damn, it's been like 10 years since Cuddle Wings
>>
>>43717889
I miss AladdinAnon.
>>
>>43717889
I always wonder how humans would be made to dress in such hyper-maretriarchal societies.
Considering the whole "clothes are occasional/lewd" thing.
>>
>>43717889
>Middle East ponies
Are stallions forced to wear hibabs?
>>
>>43720259
>Klan Wizard gets noclip'd to Saddle Arabia
>nopony bats an eye even as the poor guy anxiously tries to figure out how to sail out to more familiar lands without interacting with the locals
>eventually arrives innaquestria after months stowed in a cargo hold
>mute as the horror of that one time he set out on land only to find zebras haunt him still
>>
>>43720349
Spontanuously combusts when setting eye on the school of friendship.
>>
>>43720395
>That's just a normal reaction to the school of friendship
>>
>>43720259
>>43720267
I've seen the idea tossed around, that ponies either think Anon covers up due to trauma or that his society is super anti-male and always expects them to be completely dressed up.
But I don't think any greens incorporated it.

Some also just think he's showing of in full suit because he want's to get oogled at.
>>
>>43720868
If I was in a monkey suit I would appreciate being appreciated.
>>
We need more young mares to die in the dragon war that the griffin kingdom started by trying to steal the dragon queen hoard.
Also the dragon queen husband but most Equestria news gloss over that part.
>>
>>43721517
Are you one of those stallions that hate mares?
>>
>>43721561
No but I have see my share of cowardly mares not defending a stallion from a zigger harassing him. I still feel rage when ever I remember that day, seeing all those mare walk past them as the zigger was sexually harassing that poor stallion.
>>
>>43721679
That stallion was begging for it, dressing like that in public
>>
>>43721679
I do my best to put those damn ziggers in their place but there's too many of them for me to take on alone. I harassed them back and slapped their flanks until my hands went numb but they wouldn't be deterred.
>>
Can we stop calling Zebras Ziggers? The polite term is Zegroes
>>
I'd fuck a zigger honestly.
>>
>>43722166
>Be Anon, and be familiar with the whole "blacked" thing from back home.
>Remember the "art" of taking white characters and editing the black spade thing on them.
>Thought it was funnier than anything else.
>Comes to mind when you start dating a zebra mare.
>Real nice lady, actually.
>She's a pretty serious business mare, and third generation immigrant.
>Never been to Zebrica and is a fully integrated Equestrian.
>The kind of person that, if she were black, other black people back home would call her a sellout or some stupid shit for being a productive member of society.
>Anyway, you found out there's an equivalent to "blacked" here when you heard some mare whisper you were "stripped" when you and your marefriend walked by.
>Looked it up and found out what it was, and decided to pull a little prank.
>You were meant to go to your marefriend's office today so the two of you could have lunch together during her break.
>You found a black marker and decided to give yourself some body art when you did.
>every head turns to see you in shorts and a tanktop, pale skin marked all over with black stripes.
>Mares are gaping, blushing, some fuming, others panting.
>And your marefriend looks aghast.
>She practically drags you out of the building to berate you for your stunt, though you hear one of the panting mares say that you were about to be "claimed" for zebra supremacy.
>God, ponies are almost as stupid as people.
>>
File: 1790574547188772.png (64 KB, 172x466)
64 KB PNG
>>43722196
>every head turns to see you in shorts and a tanktop, pale skin marked all over with black stripes.
I'm imagining some poor MLH fanfilly seeing that and becoming so fucking demoralized lmao
>>
>>43722203
You would act the same when you would see a mare with a black spade. "lmao"
>>
>>43722475
No I would simple >rape
>>
>>43722480
>impying you wouldn't be raped
>implying you wouldn't be gaped if the raping wasn't enough
>>
>>43722501
mares can't and don't gape.
>>
>>43721517
>We need more young mares to die
scum, mares should be at home beating their stallions for forgetting to cut the crust from their sandwiches, just as the Founding Sisters intended
>>
>>43721517
>"Just Cause" but it's the daughter of Daring Do sabotaging Griffonstone to topple the monarchy
>>
File: Rarity.gif (1.83 MB, 640x360)
1.83 MB GIF
Why is Rarity a disgusting, speciest rapist that lures innocent human men to her boutique only to force herself on them mercilessly for hours?
>>
>>43722778
>rapist
is she really a rapist when the "giving" side is perfectly fine with participating

Come to think of it, would mares dare to "exploit" your rather "forward" way with female partners?
>>
>>43713425
I don't find her face attractive but that sweater vest makes me want to fuck her fluff.
>>
>>43722813
>>
I just really wanna rut that fluff and soak her sweater in my cum.
>>
File: IMG_4000.png (1.31 MB, 1000x1000)
1.31 MB PNG
this mare is here to steal your oats
>>
>>43722789
giving with massive quotations that is.
>>
I wonder if there are rituals for mares who don't have a coltfriend until 30 years old.
>>
>>43722789
Of course they would use you as an easy hookup.
>>
>>43722512
There blacked masters can and will gape you, though.
>>43722196
Playing into gender stereotypes or memes in public to embarrass your marefriend could be fun.
"Oh, heaven forbid I burn dinner... I wouldn't want to force my wife to hit me again. She hates it, but knows she has to if I'm to learn, isn't that right, dear?"
>Said mare is gaping in horror as a group of mares glare at her.
>One mare is nodding her head in agreement, and Anon makes sure to warn the fellas away from that one.
>>
>>43723973
That one example is outright mean
>>
>your plantation owning herd starts reading contemporary eugnics literature and getting funny ideas
>studs you with the ziggers "as an experiment"
>>
>>43723973
Playing with light hearted sterotypes is fun, but after that stunt your mare is gonna get ganked in an alley by the other mares
>>
>>43724344
What do they even hope the result will be? Nothing good is coming out of this.
>>
>>43725012
A zebra's brute strength, a pony's sheer ability to perform basic fucking tasks
Why, the mix would be unstoppable!
>note: zoolattos were a cursed experiment, containing the benefits of neither
>>
>>43722475
hot
>>
>>43725416
>t. NiggAnon
>>
>>43725440
honkey ass greens keeping a brotha down
>>
>>43725453
Leave it to the /PASTELED/ man to keep the /STRIPED/ man down
>>
>>43709574
>Either it's a total gender role flip and Rarity is viewed as coltish/gay
Was thinking about this (though I generally agree with the other anon, and also you're overselling how tomboyish Dash is); "coltish/gay" doesn't mean that she has to be literally like a dude and have the same interests for the same reasons (as gay might imply), and Rarity also is one of the most stallion-interested characters in canon. I think in a herding society this points to a pretty strong conclusion: Rarity is mono. She's obsessed with these 1:1 storybook romances, she cares about clothes which are associated with high society and with stallions (especially) peacocking - look at what % of stallions wear clothes daily compared to mares - and although she is quite the mare's mare when it comes down to throwing hooves (even among the M6, who are themselves much more rough and tumble than the average pony) she performs delicately outside of that.

I wouldn't be surprised if in a herd RGRE the stereotype for fashion designer was not "gay man" but rather "mono mare". This is a mare that cares very deeply about how a stallion looks and how she herself looks and being seen, not a mare that intends to fade into a crowd. She wants to stand out and she wants to help others stand out. She's pursuing a stallion-like lifestyle (her by herself monopolizing all romantic attention from her parmour) while still being a mare and doing mare things. And of course, even though fashion is more stallion associated, it's still ultimately mares that dominate the industry just due to the forces that have put them in most other positions of influence.

I'm not a herdfag personally, but the thought is interesting
>>
>>43725628
Interesting headcanon desu, you've got any idea what "preference" other M6 might have on "herd/mono" scale?
>>
File: 2526750~2.jpg (83 KB, 960x540)
83 KB JPG
>>43712415
So the limit is 39%...
>>
File: 1792488935290180.jpg (114 KB, 238x600)
114 KB JPG
>>43725700
They'd all be herders, but Fluttershy would be more than average while Pinkie and Twilight would be less set on it than average, but still ultimately end up in the standard arrangement most likely.

>Fluttershy
Opposite side of the coin to Rarity. Has traditional feminine skills but doesn't like showing off. Doesn't wear clothes even though she appreciates them, is good at needlework, etc.. Would help dress her stallion up and would e.g. fix his suit when it frays and things like that but when about the town would want a group to blend into and hide behind.
Reclusive hard herder, you wouldn't even see her until the other mares had vetted you and made initial overtures. Probably ends up the ultimate authority at home, since Fluttershy's herd are going to have to be animal-compatible mares so it's probably her personal friend group like Treehugger and Dr Fauna.

>Dash
Gigastacy normie, so she'd fall into herding just because it's the normal thing to do. Would be sympathetic towards janefilly stallions and appreciate having shared interests, and also likes being the best and IS the best, so most likely has a herd built out of pegasi that she's often in charge of because they're near-peers with similar pursuits: other Wonderbolts, other Ponyville weather team pegasi, that sort of thing. Probably ends up with a herd that is like Cloud CHaster, Flitter etc. and a stallion that's either a retired performer/hero like Soarin, or an up and coming one from her generation like Thunderlane.

>Applejack
It's implied that Granny Smith probably contributes a lot to matchmaking and AJ tends to value things by their use in an agricultural context, so the farming ponies probably have mixers and get-togethers where this sort of thing gets organized and courtship happens. Most likely her co-wives are going to be various cousins and the like. Most likely would be seperate from the Manehattan side of the family for the most part, but you'd expect that side to be just as normal only more chic and urban. Normie like Dash, so herder by default - and like Dash it's just logistically sensible since she's a landowner and the herd are probably her core team. Probably the most lowkey sexist of the M6, with some expectation that a good stallion will quietly let the mares make the decisions when it comes down to it, with Fluttershy having a longer leash but similar views/preferences when it comes down to it.
>>
>Twilight
There's a big question mark hanging over Twilight which is how you're handling Cadance in this AU. I tend to take Candy as kind of "out and proud" like a popular rocker type, and Twilight is very likely very accepting and open minded. She's not mono, though. With her extremely strong personal bonds and unwillingness to just let a relationship lie, Twilight probably ends up in a defacto lesbian polycule with some of her friends that just picks up a stallion one day and naturally segues into a fairly idealized herd scenario.
Or you just lean into Princess Twilight being foreveralone lmao.

>Pinkie
Pinkie's family probably do sister-herds where the stallion marries a group of mares that are all close relatives and any who've been absorbed into the lifestyle. They have the choosing stone, so they can be a lot more direct and efficient about this kind of thing than the Apple family are.
Pinkie herself, being the pink sheep of the family, is very possibly outside of that kind of setup. Similar to Twilight, Pinkie just has extremely close friends that would naturally cross some sort of invisible romantic line one day and Pinkie would just suggest that they should become a herd and they would. Pinkie fits in very well with a lot of the more silly ponies in Canterlot and the like, so I see two strong layups:
>All four Pie sisters marry Cheese Sandwich.
>Pinkie and Twilight and Minuette etc. marry a pretty harmless stallion like Cheese Sandwich or Flash Sentry

Bonus rounds:
>Starlight Glimmer
Closet mono. Way too controlling to want to actually share, but unlike Can Dance she doesn't have her feelings sorted out and flip-flops between wanting what she actually wants and feeling guilty over it. Collects autistic and narcissistic ponies like Trixie and Maud as a beard. There's a good chance that Sunburst ends up 'married' to a herd but only actually being more than friends with Starlight.

>Sunset Shimmer
Avoided romance when she was chasing princesshood, ever since she ran off it has unleashed a sexual titan of biblical (literally, antidiluvian) proportions. Has hammered the EqG girls (Pinkie/Dash/Twilight in particular) into a defacto harem/herd, but unlike good ponies they don't stick with a given partner and go through stallions/mares as it pleases them.
>>
>>43725881
>co-wives
I think we use "herdmates" here

Would it make any sense for RD and FS to herd together? They've known each othrr since foalhood and RD is certainly a mare that can help Flutters enjoy "the shadow"
>>43725883
>Pinkie's family probably do sister-herds where the stallion marries a group of mares that are all close relatives and any who've been absorbed into the lifestyle.
>Pinkie herself, being the pink sheep of the family, is very possibly outside of that kind of setup.
I had an idea that she might rather be an "absent" wife that, despite being part of the herd, only participates in its activities when she visits the farm
perhaps they have this arrangement to not make it "unfair" for her? Or keep the tradition more "consistent"?
>There's a good chance that Sunburst ends up 'married' to a herd but only actually being more than friends with Starlight.
wonder how common fraudulent herds might actually be
I mean, somepony might only be a part of one to support their friend, right?
>>
File: Clipboard Image.jpg (605 KB, 3000x2000)
605 KB JPG
>>43725931
>I think we use "herdmates" here
I was searching for a gendered term, though I suppose "herdmares" works better there.
>Would it make any sense for RD and FS to herd together? They've known each othrr since foalhood and RD is certainly a mare that can help Flutters enjoy "the shadow"
Yes. This is where I was going with it initially in my thoughts, they're pretty compatible in the sense that Rainbow is a good peacock and Fluttershy is a good homemaker and they do end up being pretty solid friends. The thing that made me lean away from it is just Fluttershy's animals. I can't imagine her living without them, Dash very likely would not want to live with them, it'd create other issues for the herd, and of course I can't imagine Dash not living in a cloud home which raises further issues with keeping the animals there.
>[pinkie]
>I had an idea that she might rather be an "absent" wife that, despite being part of the herd, only participates in its activities when she visits the farm
Yeah, she'd be a commuter wife in that scenario. It's not really surprising, Pinkie is a good social front, so you can think of her like a traveling salesman husband in that scenario. Maud also travels, so it's more that Limestone is the head of the household and Marble is her #2 who stays at home (most likely Marble and the stallion have major roles in foal-rearing).
>wonder how common fraudulent herds might actually be
>I mean, somepony might only be a part of one to support their friend, right?
Depends where your AU lies on the magic<->3dpd spectrum, I guess. "Realistically", yes, that feels like it'd happen all the time. At least individual members of herds might just be there because of her connection to the other mares and have a fairly cool relationship with the stallion pretty often, a true mono fake-herd feels like it'd be pretty rare and you'd need an exceptional pony that's able to carry the weight of an entire household on her own withers like Starlight to make it work (whether that's the mono or one of her supporters).
I tend to prefer more whimsical and 'just-so' stories though, so I'd say that many relationships start out that way but they end up finding things to connect over and it blooms into real authentic love.
>>
>>43726025
>Limestone and Marble
Herding is for mentally ill faggots so I'll stay at home with Limestone and give her as many foals as she demands of me!
>>
>>43726025
>The thing that made me lean away from it is just Fluttershy's animals. I can't imagine her living without them, Dash very likely would not want to live with them, it'd create other issues for the herd, and of course I can't imagine Dash not living in a cloud home which raises further issues with keeping the animals there.
Can't Dashie just... Move the cloudhouse to Flutters' backyard or something?
>>
>>43726032
>and give her as many foals as she demands of me!
are you sure that the alphamare is gonna prioritize pregnancies for herself? She certainly has other prioritizing in the pony family unit

Come to think of it, how would herds even manage pregnancies collectively? It's obvious that (1) it's better for the whole herd to have at least one foal per mare to "tie" all of them together, and (2) putting all eggs (seeds?) in one basket mkght produce terrible results (jealousy over "my husband's daughter"s...), but I'm not sure if three's anything that might be done beyond that
>>
>>43726058
>prioritizing
*other things to do
>>
>>43726034
>Can't Dashie just... Move the cloudhouse to Flutters' backyard or something?
Well sure but I feel like this is asking for compromises that Dash doesn't have any particular reason to make. If she ended up marrying an earth pony or something, sure. But that would definitely be settling for living conditions that work with the circumstances rather than having things how she'd want them. She has such stereotypical Cloudsdale interests that I don't really get why she'd maintain a detached relationship and be further away from most of the things she cares about if she ends up with a group that shares her values, you know what I mean?
Like it's less about having a cloud home and more about being up in the sky.
>>
>>43726117
>but I feel like this is asking for compromises that Dash doesn't have any particular reason to make.
desu "loyalty" to thr skies or her friends is a bit weird when you think about it
Return of Harmony made it look like she's supposed to value friends more than her hometown and her way of life, perhaps Dash is indeed supposed to herd with her childhood friend over nice mares that share her interests?
>>
>>43726025
>The thing that made me lean away from it is just Fluttershy's animals. I can't imagine her living without them, Dash very likely would not want to live with them, it'd create other issues for the herd, and of course I can't imagine Dash not living in a cloud home which raises further issues with keeping the animals there.
funnily enough my own headcanon sort of solves this for me cause I can't imagine herds, where the mares, before joining the herd, had houses of their own, abandoning those homes. So I'd assume there'd be a sort of rotation of ensuring upkeep of property. Fluttershy sort of "moving in" with Rainbow Dash, but still owning her cottage, and sort of renovating it to ensure the animals can be even more self-sufficient than they already are, with the availability of it allowing her to visit daily
>>
File: 3163496.jpg (150 KB, 1280x1108)
150 KB JPG
>>43726032
>I'll stay at home with Limestone and give her as many foals as she demands of me!
but what if Limestone demands you give her nieces and nephews via her socially awkward and relationship deficient autistic sisters?
>>
>>43726189
I'll refuse and make it up to her by giving her even MORE foals!
>>
>>43726189
>but what if Limestone demands you give her nieces and nephews via her socially awkward and relationship deficient autistic sisters?
letting the shyest member enjoy well-deserved attention must be nice imo
feels like a weird form of cuckoldry on Limestone's part desu
>>
File: 1785391473265205.png (1 MB, 1464x1576)
1 MB PNG
>tfw no human husbando to beat up
>>
>>43726779
She wouldn't do that



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.