Come one and all to the meta-writefag and help raise the quality of MLP fanfiction! Featuring: Sunset Shimmer meets the pope!ITT: Aging gracefully is an oxymoron, pimping Big Mac to Ponyvillians, swapping out a found family for nepotism, My wife is so fucking cute bros, Luna likes kids (Not in a pedo way), meth really IS that effective, Iron Will's School of Self-Delusion, Print your fanfics and give them to strangers (it works for Mormons), my interests are cryptography and collecting global currencies, readers will never appreciate my greatness, eating rocks to own the blank flanks, Apple Bloom buys a shotgun, wait, is X still talking? No, that's narration, the most pornrific character imaginable, all Rarities are pedophiles, Total Shipper Death, an AI parody of that Don Bluth movie Anastasia, an overly complicated fattening fetish, never trust a woman, Calling Derpy bubble butt, and face the wall, commie!>/fimfic/ Secret Book ClubThe two hundredth book is "Clean Slate": https://www.fimfiction.net/story/71009/clean-slateIf (You) want to participate, read up to "Chapter 10: Jam" by Sunday, November 22nd.>Recommended stories:Tired of adventures that meander for a million words? Fed up with super special OCs? Well, we've compiled the best of the worst in order to bring you our absolute average!New Starter Kit - http://mlpficreviews.org.uk/starter/Old Starter Kit - http://i.imgur.com/vuTA7EN.png>Common fic abbreviations used by the thread:https://ponepaste.org/7317>A list of reviews made by the Anons in this thread:http://www.mlpficreviews.org.ukUse the commands ">review <story link>" and ">discuss <story link>" to add reviews to a story.Userscript for extra features: https://ponepaste.org/8619>An in-depth writing guide for beginners:https://eznguide.neocities.org/>Additional material for authors:Rhorse's Horse Behavioral Notes - https://ponepaste.org/932Politics and the English Language - https://www.orwell.ru/library/essays/politics/english/e_polit/Vhatug's tips for anatomically correct clop - https://poneb.in/g4VpEg4fPurdue Online Writing resources: https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/index.html and https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/subject_specific_writing/creative_writing/writers/index.html>Can you pre-read my story?Post it on Google Docs or HackMD with comments enabled and give us a link.>Various reviews and riffs:Fillyanon's Bookshelf - https://ponepaste.org/5555Notkickass222urmom's Reviews - https://pastebin.com/u/notkickass222urmomIHeartShinzakura's Reviews - https://ponepaste.org/user/IHeartShinzakuraAppleanon reads fics - https://poneb.in/wmGX7FPmDeluxe Big Master Review List - https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1z9Bz7UnEbxo-svlXa2tV49PJkP-yFuR7pRXiBUn-IeUA Guide to Rational Fics - https://files.catbox.moe/3jzrfm.pngPrevious Thread: >>43667207
First for best duo!Enjoy this conveniently packaged Tuna: https://www.fimfiction.net/story/545440/singles-combat
>>43715402Well OK, since you're treating my rant with more respect than it probably deserves. Here's an early example of "abusing sentence fragments":>Despite all the decay, the door to the cabin stood firm. Far firmer than the rest of it, the only sign of damage in the form of several long, deep, and jagged grooves carved into the wood.Another:>It had been waiting for years, drowned in stagnant silence, in dust and time. Every inch of it almost quivering in fervent anticipation. A drawn in breath that had never been released. Elastic pulled tight to the point of breaking, and then relentlessly and remorselessly held. Waiting.The first sentences have predicates as they should, but the following lines just leave their subjects incomplete.>Slipping under the doorframe, into the similarly decrepit interior.This one is just a participle with nothing else.Something I meant to mention was that he starts sentences with conjunctions too often. I'm fine with that in moderation, even though it's not strictly grammatically correct, but the fic has way too many instances of this, and they often appear quick succession.>And with such obvious desperation...>But now the door itself...>But now, as it lay open...>And it was that same impulse...>And seeing what was on the other side...All of these occur within a span of fewer than 350 words.The author will often cut out the last sentence in a paragraph into its own paragraph. I get that it's a horror story and he needs to manipulate tension, but it gets to the point of feeling gratuitous. This applies to some of the above examples, and furthermore:>It was too big.>Maybe. Applejack doubted it.>It knew.These three lines are three of four "paragraphs" in a row, and the one I left out starts with "And".This is an example of a more minor issue, but>...waited as the dim, orange light of late sunset through the window boards sputtered and died.Sunlight doesn't "sputter". A gas flame or a campfire sputters. Sunlight would "fade" or "die" or "wane" or something. It bothers me when people use words simply because they sound vaguely appropriate in similar contexts, without thinking about what words literally mean. The fic has other examples of misused verbs, but that's the main one I remember.Again, I could forgive the author for any of these "errors" if they were used sparingly and deliberately for style, but they've apparently become crutches.One thing I did give the author props for was ending quotes with periods instead of commas when the next verb wasn't a dialogue tag. It's a common mistake.
>>43715493The only one of these I agree with is the last one. I remember getting kicked out by least one more nonsensical metaphor, but I can't be assed to find it right now.The first two are good. The sentence starting with "Slipping" was odd, but I liked how it evoked motion from the narrating perspective moving to the door, flying through the gap it and coming out into the cabin. The other one is just repetition for effect with periods instead of commas.
>>43715402I read the first 1/5 of Don't Open The Door, then I got bored and stopped. It was pretty interesting though.- Don't open the door seems like it has a dark horror theme to it- I like how you can tell the overall vibe to the environment just by the word choice, even without interpreting it into something specific. - It's ominous and lonely. The word choice's good.- There's different sentence lengths- It seems like the cabin is alive, And I'm not sure if that is intentional.- The dialogue seems fine. The story has an interesting hook with the cabins description and that part of all that being alive.- This is more realistic.- Applejack has a broken bone, and her and Rainbow Dash have entered into the cabin- I don't like the part on the blood because the way it's written makes it seems like the writer doesn't know how much blood can be lost.- Now I'm curious, what is going to happen? I think the word choice "Death sentence" was on the nose. But I don't think that necessarily bad, because it increases the curiosity for what will happen next. I wonder what will happen to this pony.- I really liked the description so the part where the knife wrote in "don't open the door."
>>43715032>Kind of forced kino, imo. It was a very Hollywood'y line.the kino was how unbelievably hard Celestia was coping>And not!Princess Luna isn't?I agree her not being princess of the night is garbo, but this is when she and Twi barely know each other. And she does try to persuade Twilight into not looking again but just sort of can't manage it and has to settle with "at least talk to Celestia who knows how to talk to you properly.">I swear I've seen this exact premise in like 5 different afternoon Science Channel shows 10+ years ago.Spells that look at something and immediately compile every known thing about it from all written works on the planet?>but it's just means to an end for this fic. I can guarantee that it started with the author going, "but what about Twilight unwittingly passing the event horizon?" and building around that.Like every nigger man fic we've ever read? What if Twilight found a funny artifact? What if she gave it to Rarity after? What if the only thing niggerman let you do of your own free will was write in your journal?That said, "but what about Twilight unwittingly passing the event horizon?" does pretty much sum up the level of manifest destiny Twilight had in the fic about jumping into it for no reason>Rarity also didn't want that, she had much more serious moments of losing control and clawing it back, etc. Here, we're just reading a lucid journal that goes, "and anyway, here I went insane for three hours" like three timesMy problem with the Rarity fic is that I don't see that. I see Rarity say "And then I'm gonna send the letter to Celestia!" 7 times and I realize, wait a second, Rarity doesn't achieve a single thing she sets out to do. She writes in the journal how scared she is and her next plan and the moment she puts the pen down she does niggerman's bidding until he lets her write again. Twilight is at least actually doing plenty and then recounting it. Regardless, Fluttershy's journal was the best. She's fucking schizo in the very start and it actually seems like she would keep a journal to just pretend she's talking to her friends that she abandoned, rather than just writing a story in her journal>I think the protagonist being pulled by whatever unearthly force they're faced with is a big part of the appeal.this is the exact thing I don't like lol. They should be reacting to it and the situation, not just being controlled by it. And "it" really did just take the form of a black hole for that fic, complete with Twilight's entire world revolving around it and making horrible decisions to kill herself in it>but also a good "bad end" horror fic leaves you with a bit of a sinking feeling in your stomachTrue I think he had that when Twilight was the last one, but I think the SCP thing was like explicitly walking away from that to a far more mellow, "Yeah, no one on that world made it and the egg thing took off after the whole world burned
>>43715032>No, not at all.>Twilight makes a spell that helps you look at things and then she looks at something weirdTo me, makes a lot more sense than:>Twilight goes to a different world and gets her head caved in with a hammer by a lighthouse operator while she's sleeping>Luna got infected by niggerman when she was banished and anything niggerman does makes sense because he can do anythingWhat I mean is we see the world before the """horror""" element is introduced and it is then introduced/discovered in a way that could happen. Twilight creates a new spell (that is explicitly NOT some stupid spell that accidently gets everyone killed) and simply uses it is sooo much better than le cosmic horror decided to show up rn and your all fucked for real.>but "look how silly this is" is generally bad.Yeah but I generally think journals are bad so the potential satire was funny to me, and especially her considering the whole event might have happened because she started a journal>>43715033>elderly in Fortnitekek>Not satisfied. Smells of modern SCP if I'm being uncharitableironically the cabin that shows up to lost ponies and sp00ks them made me think of SCP more than any other fics (until the obvious SCP part of susurrations)>And this something takes the life of a bright young protagonist in an unusually cruel and uncaring manner, leaving everypony else to pick up the shards.Yeah I did like that as well tying into my dislike of cosmic horror. It's a lot less 'this entire world is going to die now for no reason other than niggerauth woke up' and more one pony (that was a national treasure) did something bad and something horrible happened to them. Kind of similar to the berry punch train story. The train didn't wake up and destroy equestria, it just fucked with people that got on and then was quickly cancelled as a failure anyways so it didn't have a lasting impact on anyone except those who directly interacted with it. >>43715060>I think the analogy hinges on Celestia being "marked" by that primordial church.Yeah I mean I definitely see it now that we've discussed it. And the moment I should've noticed is when one alicorn looked at the circle they controlled and said "wait a minute, something isn't right..." lolThat said, we don't get the same kino we did in circle when Luna causes an eclipse just to create a really big circle kek>>43715315fucking kek, welcome to /fsbc/I will add though, the profanity is especially bad with this level of prose. None of the other horror fics that had much less in terms of prose ever went as low as characters just saying fuck and bitch a bunch
>>43715607>I read the first 1/5 of Don't Open The Door, then I got bored and stopped.Pretty much exactly the first 20% is Applejack suffering immensely from a completely broken hind leg. This part had a very different feel for me from the rest of the fic and I think it executed that feel better although that feel definitely wasn't horror. >got bored and stopped. It was pretty interesting though.huh? seemed like you liked it well enough and it doesn't exactly take a long time to read it all
>>43715443READ!
>>43715674oh OP has a word that's autosaged
>>43715679>oh OP has a word that's autosagedFuck fuck dammit fuck I can't do anything right.Which word is it?
>>43715679God dammit
>>43715688Maybe pedo / pedophile?
What if Rainbow Dash was inside of Guitar Hero
>>43715898>>43715898>>43715898Please tell me I got it right this time.
>>43715906Looks fine to me. "Tulpa" is also a banned word, I've lost an OP or two to it before.
>>43715952I browsed the archive to play it extra safe. Based on older OPs, phrases and words I'll now avoid are:cute + funnytuplapedo(phile)age of consent
>>43715493>Sunlight would "fade" or "die" or "wane" or something.No. The correct verb is “menopause,” as in,>...waited as the dim, orange light of late sunset through the window boards menopaused.
It's over.
>>43716536We're so back.