[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/mlp/ - Pony

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
Flag
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: genius.png (207 KB, 926x498)
207 KB PNG
Come one and all to the meta-writefag and help raise the quality of MLP fanfiction! Featuring: Sunset Shimmer meets the pope!

ITT: Aging gracefully is an oxymoron, pimping Big Mac to Ponyvillians, swapping out a found family for nepotism, Iron Will's School of Self-Delusion, Print your fanfics and give them to strangers, my interests are cryptography and collecting global currencies, readers will never appreciate my greatness, eating rocks to own the blank flanks, Apple Bloom buys a shotgun, wait, is X still talking? No, that's narration, the most pornrific character imaginable, Total Shipper Death, an AI parody of that Don Bluth movie Anastasia, an overly complicated fattening fetish, never trust a woman, and calling Derpy bubble butt!

>/fimfic/ Secret Book Club
The two hundredth book is "Clean Slate":
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/71009/clean-slate
If (You) want to participate, read up to "Chapter 10: Jam" by Sunday, November 22nd.

>Recommended stories:
Tired of adventures that meander for a million words? Fed up with super special OCs? Well, we've compiled the best of the worst in order to bring you our absolute average!
New Starter Kit - http://mlpficreviews.org.uk/starter/
Old Starter Kit - http://i.imgur.com/vuTA7EN.png

>Common fic abbreviations used by the thread:
https://ponepaste.org/7317

>A list of reviews made by the Anons in this thread:
http://www.mlpficreviews.org.uk
Use the commands ">review <story link>" and ">discuss <story link>" to add reviews to a story.
Userscript for extra features: https://ponepaste.org/8619

>An in-depth writing guide for beginners:
https://eznguide.neocities.org/

>Additional material for authors:
Rhorse's Horse Behavioral Notes - https://ponepaste.org/932
Politics and the English Language - https://www.orwell.ru/library/essays/politics/english/e_polit/
Vhatug's tips for anatomically correct clop - https://poneb.in/g4VpEg4f
Purdue Online Writing resources: https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/index.html and https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/subject_specific_writing/creative_writing/writers/index.html

>Can you pre-read my story?
Post it on Google Docs or HackMD with comments enabled and give us a link.

>Various reviews and riffs:
Fillyanon's Bookshelf - https://ponepaste.org/5555
Notkickass222urmom's Reviews - https://pastebin.com/u/notkickass222urmom
IHeartShinzakura's Reviews - https://ponepaste.org/user/IHeartShinzakura
Appleanon reads fics - https://poneb.in/wmGX7FPm
Deluxe Big Master Review List - https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1z9Bz7UnEbxo-svlXa2tV49PJkP-yFuR7pRXiBUn-IeU
A Guide to Rational Fics - https://files.catbox.moe/3jzrfm.png

Previous Thread: >>43715443
>>
we safe?
>>
>>43715919
Nice, the thread bump. This one is good.
>>
>>43715924
Sacrifices have to be made sometimes.
>>
File: kiss in the gardens.jpg (559 KB, 2716x1894)
559 KB JPG
2+2th for best duo!
Enjoy this conveniently packaged Tuna: https://www.fimfiction.net/story/545440/singles-combat
>>
File: cheery moon.png (519 KB, 1310x1528)
519 KB PNG
>>43710368
Nah, you and your misogyny are stupid.
I'm pretty sure at this point that it was ED, and not Math Spook, that gave me the initial bounds for my script that used sklearn.gaussian_process.GaussianProcessRegressor to get it started finding 4MB video encode settings way more efficiently, and they have been working a treat ever since.
>>
File: IMG_4717.jpg (93 KB, 468x598)
93 KB JPG
>>43715493
>Sunlight would "fade" or "die" or "wane" or something.
No. The correct verb is “menopause,” as in,
>...waited as the dim, orange light of late sunset through the window boards menopaused.
>>
>>43716124
> I'm pretty sure at this point that it was ED, and not Math Spook
Kek, glad I can retain at least some of my anonymity.
>>
Futaloo get.

>review https://www.fimfiction.net/story/187820/verisimilitude

5/10. Daring and Dash retrieve a futa artifact and have hermaphrodite sex. I'm so desperate for a DaringDash fix, I'm reading futa now. It's the fanfic reading equivalent of shifting from OxyContin to heroin. Like virtually all of these pornfics, the story starts frustratingly well. Would have made a very nice DaringDash fic as Daring nearly kisses Dash when she rescues her. We get some of that shipping tension on the airship ride back, then the porn artifact pops up and the whole thing descends into one prolonged porn scene with all the nice shipping stuff thrown aside. What a waste.

Dash felt surprisingly in-character throughout the story but Daring was way off. She acted like a pornfic character right from the start, which, given the ending, should have been a hint. Speaking of, the ending's a curveball. The whole story's actually a doujin Scootaloo picked up at a con and she was sucked into the porn comic via the Power Ponies enchantment, meaning the entire fic is actually a horny pornfic Daring having futa sex with a filly. Literal fucking Futaloo, as my first futa fic, no less. I can't fucking believe it. I never would have thought I'd encounter the old thread meme when doing this. I guess that's my punishment for reading futa.

The twist completely recontextualizes the whole story and especially "Dash's" personality. She's incredibly naive throughout, which fits her character, but fits Scootaloo's far better. Dash's odd flight struggles during the opening adventure fight also make a lot more sense now. It is, to my seething displeasure, actually a really good twist as it accomplishes everything a curveball ending should do. I just wish it hadn't done it with Futaloo of all things.

>>43644827 here you go, anon, but don't consider me an expert. I can also confirm the AO3 tagfags won this round (though they've apparently lost the war with the hack). The word "blowjob" is never used in either the (short or long) description or in the story itself. You have to infer it from the futa warning. There's no other way of knowing unless you read it. The fic also receives an automatic one point deduction for tricking me into reading Futaloo foalcon.

>end
>>
>>43713845
>randomly deciding to shoehorn Celestia
It wasn't really random. The Celestia thing was intended to answer the question of "why doesn't Daring just go to Twilight/the alicorns for help?" It's to establish there is no magical solution to this she can call on. She either has to betray someone or she's stuck. The alicorns and all the magic of Equestria (and, by implication, the Elements as well, though you could argue they're already out of the equation anyway since it's post-canon) can't help her. It also gives the context for why the book's buried there in the first place.

Personally, I feel like the fic's biggest weakness remains the core premise of Daring going off on an adventure with Torch in the first place. Even after the ~9k of setup, I still don't feel like she would do it, especially with the context that this Daring already has experience with horror fic premises like the decapitation mind control artifact.

It's just brutal trying to get her in a betrayal thing. She's so removed from the rest of canon there's almost no one in the show she trusts. It's basically just the M6 and maybe Quibble if you want to stretch it and none of them really seem like they would put Daring in the plot position that's needed for the story so I was stuck with an OC.

>This sort of prose
Wasn't my favorite line, either. In a perfect world, I would have had time to edit things and polish it up a bit, but the deadline hit and it had to go out.
>>
>3 thread club
cursed
>>
File: glimmer wow loop.gif (508 KB, 290x290)
508 KB GIF
>>43716741
Wow! So much discussion that it filled over a full thread!
>>
>>43715493
One might argue that saying sunlight sputtered is meant to invoke a feeling of it being weak like a flame, a lantern going out.
It's definitely a stretch and would need sufficient justification for it. Like maybe in a horror fic where reality is being stretched, and the protagonist sees the sunlight sputter and die like a weak lantern out of fuel, leaving him in darkness. No idea if that fic's context fits that at all, if not then the author is indeed retarded.
>>
>>43716459
>Like virtually all of these pornfics, the story starts frustratingly well.
Fuck, I thought I was nuts but that is true. I was reading a fic once of a rare pair that I like that was decent and wasn't even [Sex] until 2/3 in. I was really enjoying the narration until the female lead got her guts rearranged.
>>
File: luna and tantabus.png (2.31 MB, 1920x1200)
2.31 MB PNG
>>
>>43716459
The crusaders getting sucked into an enchanted book and having to playing the role of their sisters actually sounds like a cute premise for a real fic.
>>
>>43717742
>playing the role of their sisters
So you’re saying it’s porn.
>>
>>43717941
Why is it always porn with you, bro.
>>
>>43717742
You had me at “the crusaders getting sucked”.
>>
>>43717945
The CMC were made for being groomed by their respective sisters/idols/mothers.
>>
I knew it you all hate me that's all. Good grammar and well executed storyline and it still gets 3 downvotes. I'm done. I'm going bananas now.
>>
>>43717962
>only 3
rookie numbers
>>
>>43717962
hey look out everynigga, he's going bananas
>>
>>43715493
I'll grab this rant about Grimm's predicates into the proper thread to not to lose it to the sands of time.

>>43715607
Good enough, Nonny.
Consider trying to read the next secret butt fun club selections, we'd benefit from an unabashed tl;dr approach.

>>43716459
What is your current top of Daring fanfiction?
The creme de la creme.
>>
File: Piempkin.jpg (638 KB, 4000x1770)
638 KB JPG
>>43715030
I agree with this for the most part, but I also think that your final questions are "wrong". The "correct" answer to all of them is:
>The exact details don't matter much, and whatever spoooooky thing you imagined is precisely the answer that the fic wanted you to have; the point of the mystery is setting the mood, not creating a scientific report.
More or less that.

>>43715033
>haven't been smart enough to figure the nature of the horror on my own
Maybe I'm jaded because I've seen it several times already, but knowing about black holes sort of made the fic mostly pointless for me, so perhaps being ignorant is the correct move if you want to enjoy it.

>>43715315
It's Monday night and I'm super tired, so I'll just say: Nuh, uh. You're wrong, and downbooping this fic should be a criminal offense.
Actually, if I had to pick a dream team of 5-10 Fimfiction authors of all time, he's 100% making it as my Horror specialist. A few others could play support for him because they have really high quality spikes, but between his lows being better than most writers' best, and his highs being among the best on the site, he's a pretty distant #1 for me, I think.

>>43715607
>read 1/5 (...) and stopped
>It was pretty interesting
That sounds kinda crazy to me! It's a oneshot! But yes, like twiflag said, the first part feels different than the rest.

>>43715550
>Spells that look at something and
No, black holes. The spell, cool as it is, is just a tool used by the writer to get to the "getting succ'd by a black hole, dude!" thing.
>Like every nigger man fic we've ever read?
>That said,
Yeah, thinking about it more, I believe you could be reductive in this way about virtually any fic ever written, so I don't know if this says anything at all about any story.
>not just being controlled by it
The struggle is good. That said, something I enjoy in the genre and you don't is a threat so cosmic in its size or scope that nothing about it can be done (or even attempted). That's kind of a defining trait of the cosmic horror genre that you so dislike, I think.
>to a far more mellow
Agreed, but adding it makes for a worse story because of that.

>>43715493
Point on a doll where a stylized prose hurt you in the past.

>>43717962
Seer?
The anons itt are kinda bloodthirsty, but I think you genuinely got, I don't know, unlucky somehow? It's very rare for a clubfic to be "brigaded" with a -3. For the record, I thought this fic was very weak (compared to your other work, too) but even stories far, far worse than this fic usually get -1, rarely -2. None of the last 10+ clubfics got more than -1, and on the other hand even Grimm got a -1 because an anon was being dumb. Though to be fair, a couple times an actual good fic would get -3 or -4 because anons were dumb. I mean, dumber than usual.
Or maybe our wholesome Twinkie enjoyer secretly runs an army of extra accounts to downvote fics he dislike into oblivion on his bad days.
>>
>>43717962
Remember the time the Squid totally beefed it?
>>
>>43717943
I can’t help that the show is so horny.
>>
>>43718141
Fics where the Scoots totally beefs it?
>>
>>43718124
I was planning to skip this week’s club to have more writing time, but after seeing the divided opinions on Door’s prose, I had to give it a look.

My sides! I almost burst into laughter at the very first paragraph. The other anon is right; the prose is awful. The problem is that it’s trying so, so very hard to be impressive. It thinks it’s vivid. It’s really convinced that it’s better than what the rest of us can write. It’s not; trying so hard makes it actually worse than average, worse than the more plain but also more appropriate prose that the rest of us write all the time.

I made it up to when Dash and AJ arrived, but I feel no temptation to go further. If I want comedy, I’d rather read a fic where it’s intentional.
>>
This is the greatest reader feedback I’ve ever gotten:
>Part of me wants to scrub my eyes with steel wool.
I’ve peaked and can only go downhill from here.
>>
>>43718265
so you're saying it insists upon itself?
>>
>>43718124
>downbooping this fic should be a criminal offense.
>It's a crime to use the rating system to rate a fic how you think it ought to be rated
Note that you didn't say "disliking this fic", but literally clicking the dislike button.
>Point on a doll where a stylized prose hurt you in the past.
>No argument against specific examples of improper grammar
Concession accepted. Also, like >>43718265 says, the issue isn't that it's stylised. It's that it's stylised to such tasteless extremes. It's like saying that the Oval Office has been made statelier by the addition of gold trim.
>>
>>43718124
>The "correct" answer to all of them is
I don't feel this way.
The fic entity is the contrivance, the means for the wider story to exist.
For me the "correct" answer is not "it's just a story, don't mind it that much", but something like "what matters for that thing is intent; it can't enter without the permission given, and entering through the windows is highly unlikely to be permissible".
In a horror I want just enough rope to hang myself, thank you very much.

>being ignorant is the correct move if you want to enjoy it
I am not a clever pony.
>>
This is the kind of energy I need to put into my fanfics.
>>
>>43718733
NTA but I agree with this too. The useless locks on the door and the fact that the door only had a single deadbolt in rotten wood which the huge monster couldn't break and the way the monster was able to impersonate voices all indicated that it could only enter places if it were allowed inside or if the door were otherwise neglected.
>>
>get shitpost fic scene idea
>okay, I'll write it and then never open the doc again
>5.5k later i have to start thinking about what kind of cover art to use for a Candy Mare HFY Sci-fi shitpost oneshot
Damn it.

>review https://www.fimfiction.net/story/197775/daring-do-and-the-overdue-book

6/10. Daring must return an overdo library book to the local ancient temple library. By Rainbow Dash. This was another "Dash write a Daring fic" fic, but it didn't really feel much like one. Definitely another example of the author just kind of bolting the Dash ending to the end of the fic. The fic itself suffers that classic comedy fic problem of needing to jack things up more to be funnier.

>end

>review https://www.fimfiction.net/story/196369/forget-love

5/10. An OC with amnesia meets and ends up hooking up with Daring. This one was really bizarre. It's got an oddly bad vote ratio for 2014 and the whole thing feels like an AU. Daring is called "Caring" and is described as "A brown pegasus mare with a grayish mane and tail." I would never call her brown, and usually her mane's called "grayscale" or "black and gray" or "monochromatic", not "grayish" so I thought it was a totally different character, but the author confirmed it was actually her and for some unexplained reason she completely abandoned adventuring to run a homeless shelter. Wut?

The OC is apparently some gateway drug for the changelings. The timeline's completely fucked up. This seemingly takes place pre-ACW given there's a bunch of changelings running around replacing people and no one's the wiser, but Daring's retired so Daring Don't can't happen (or is this were the "I work alone" thing is supposed to come from?). And it was written well after Daring Don't aired. The changeling's plan also seemingly makes no sense. He's going to replace the OC, then abuse and rape Daring, which seems the exact opposite of how the changelings with their love eating are supposed to work. Just adds more confusion to an already bizarre plot. I'm seeing where all the downvotes came from.

>>43718011
Top seven so far. Haven't hit the longer multichapters yet:
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/387732/an-adventure-unknown
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/367630/historical-gaps
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/248204/daring-doesnt-need-a-special-somepony
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/138706/the-lantern
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/333504/the-riddle-of-the-sphinx
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/233491/my-little-danger-pony
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/367827/evil-is-easy-governing-is-harder

Favorite pornfic:
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/345685/author-and-adventurer
>>
>>43719279
>I would never call her brown
Yeah, her colonialism means she's obviously white-coded.
>>
>>43719279
I'll always be sad that Changing Views was abandoned, that was one of my favorite multichapter fics with Daring Do. Especially since the last canon update was on a cliffhanger. It was one of my first fics that I read so I'm probably viewing it with rose tinted glasses, but I thought the relationship between the mc and daring was pretty good throughout.

It's been a while since i read it, but I think "That Changeling's a Bad OC" was also decent, though it kinda got convoluted/weird at the end. Like, the worldbuilding stuff was interesting, but it didn't really feel like it meshed well with the first half. It's definitely doesn't go the direction you first think it will.

Can't think of any other longfics with Daring that i've read off the top of my head.
>>
File: priestess moon.png (363 KB, 1200x1200)
363 KB PNG
>>
>>43716459
The prose becomes a bit turgid once the kissing starts in earnest, but it mostly recovers. Having Scootaloo be the perspective character helps a lot there, I imagine, in terms of keeping narration simple. Not perfect, you have lines like
>holding onto Rainbow’s cutie marks as she choked the load down
and you think 'hey, that's pretty good' but then it does still gild the lily with
>, nary a drop escaping the seal of her lips.
Whereas most of the "how is our character feeling about this moment" narration is a lot more too the point, if colored by emotion that tells us how the characters are feeling about the scene.
>A.N. Though, for what it's worth, it's not meant to be foalcon (in any fetishistic sense).
lmao
This is real nigger foalcon like true pedoshit grooming. We're literally watching an adult character from a porno seduce a child, and it feels like the !Daring figures out what she's working with halfway through and adjusts her approach.

This was genuinely a pretty good story. Of course every 'character' is out of character, but that's because they're explictly not those characters and the story really makes a point of hammering this home. 7/10
For any reasons wondering, it's pure futa-on-female, they swap who is wearing the amulet but there's only ever one dick at a time.

>The twist completely recontextualizes the whole story and especially "Dash's" personality.
Daring's personality even more, in my opinion. It's not Daring either, it's a doujin character that only needs to be Daring in name and drive the plot (porn), and she certainly drives the porn. You can feel where she goes for something and it doesn't work out, so she fixes her approach. You can see how she gives a lot of latitude and rolls with anything Scootaloo does because she wants to encourage and escalate and follow through on the smut. She acts like a character out of a hentai because she is one.
>have hermaphrodite sex
I feel like phrasing it this way gives the wrong impression, for those who haven't read it. If you don't like futa x futa then you really don't have to worry here.
>>
>>43715960
>>
File: 1794184643364.gif (2.08 MB, 507x415)
2.08 MB GIF
Does this gesture have a name? Or is writing "excited hoof taps/stomps" easier enough to understand without a visual?
>>
>>43716461
>It wasn't really random. The Celestia thing was intended to answer the question of "why doesn't Daring just go to Twilight/the alicorns for help?" It's to establish there is no magical solution to this she can call on.
Oh no, I understand the author's motivation. The reason you decided to make it an edgefest AU is because the plot you wrote doesn't fit into FiM and you decided to slippily force it in by taking a chainsaw to the setting and characters rather than either
>think about where and how you could run a similar plot that fits in with what you've been given
>acknowledge how different the world you're presenting is and make it a proper AU
>adapt to the source material and write something more in line with the spirit of the world and respectful to the characters in it
That doesn't change the fact that Celestia wouldn't do that and that yes, there are magical solutions they can call on.

>The alicorns and all the magic of Equestria (and, by implication, the Elements as well, though you could argue they're already out of the equation anyway since it's post-canon) can't help her.
You've decided to set this post-canon for some reason, which means that the elements/rainbow lasers are in play, so no, they can help her. That's just how it works. If you can't write "and then the rainbow got rid of the evil and everypony was friends" [paraphrased] then it's not FiM. Heck it's not MLP, this is true G1 protoplasm. This is the foundational axiom of the setting, if you want to argue with it you can't, you have to either avoid the confrontation or accept that you're writing an AU and think about the consequences of your actions. e.g. Celestia never apologises because she's always in the right in these sorts of interactions, so if you change her to have actually TRAPPED and BETRAYED somepony to make a plot work then it recontextualizes her interactions with Princess Luna and Sunset Shimmer. The reason it reads like a 2/10 FFN/SB/QQ powertrip fic at that point is that it basically is one, the author's pet is making characters act out of sorts in order to fund their tragic backstory or show how great they are.
>It also gives the context for why the book's buried there in the first place.
See, this is one of the things that worked. FiM has a thousand year span where there is pony society as we know it but no Elements as far as we're ever shown. Celestia sticking evil in a box because a good solution isn't available is a thing that happens even when C+L have the lelements. So it's not like you can't have the book and it's not like you can't have had Celestia seal it away without having solved the issue. You can consider this as "the book is Discord". Discord isn't a truly solved problem, he's just in a rock, and Celestia can't solve the issue. But she's not presented as being complicit in all his crimes in early-Equestria.
>>
The problem with the fic is that
>you make Celestia explicitly malicious, rather than leaving any problems from her time as mistakes or things which happened before ponies understood what was going on or etc.
>you introduce post-FiM Dash, specifically to a plot that drags in your friends as well, which implictly brings in the rainbow laser of friendship
Specifically because of the combination, and the Celestia character assassination is the root of it all. You can bring in Dash, and not say what happens (which is what the fic does), and the astute reader is going to reason that it'll be a problem for the M6 and they'll solve it. I disagree with any critics who claim that Daring would never get broken, Daring is just a pony, she can succumb to pressure it's fine. Where it becomes a problem is the claim that Celestia directly contributed to the evil and then never turned around and fixed things.
The problem is now coming to light, so it's going to get solved because we're in the era where millennia old problems are getting solved (FiM, RoH, Shadow Play. Heck, Inspiration Manifestation is pretty much 1:1 with this fic and guess what fucking happens in that?) which is obviously a problem if you want to imply that it'll continue to be a problem and also use the era. Either set it in the time period where Luna is on the moon or accept that the ending is going to be hopeful because the problem is not going to escalate much further than it does in the fic, but either way don't fuck with Celestia's personal history unless you're willing to bear out the consequences that change would have on the rest of the world.

Like I'm biased in this discussion because you're being a petulant bitch and I was biased when reading the fic because the prose is dogshit, but this isn't a problem that you can just wave of. It's fundamental badness. When your response to "why is [giant plot hole that clashes with the setting and existing characters to exist] in this" is
>otherwise the plot wouldn't happen
It means the narrative is bad. This is far from the worst thing I've ever read but I don't think that the people who've written worse were both trying their hardest and actually adults with three digit IQs.
>>
>>43720326
Prancing in place. Tippy taps.
>>
>>43720353
Thanks, those both work better.
>>
>>43718265
>My sides! I almost burst into laughter at the very first paragraph
Years of arid prose have legitimately given you brain damage. Go read Dickens right now.
>>
File: little luna glare.jpg (1.35 MB, 2200x2200)
1.35 MB JPG
>>43719580
>That Changeling's a Bad OC
Is a terrible story and made me believe Raguos was entirely a hack before I read his older, much better stories. It's a series of shitposts organized into prose and the first half can't be said to mesh even with itself.
The worldbuilding is terrible: changelings are established to be well integrated with Equestria while in disguise, and also have 17 additional powers because canon changelings somehow don't give nearly enough storytelling material to work with on their own. The characterization of Daring is also terrible. She gets two of those extra powers used on her and is entirely unbothered to have been mind controlled and drugged to sleep "because it was restful."
And, of course, the title is true.
>>
>>43720579
This isn't the one set in the same universe as the one with Chrysalis' inbred retarded daughter is it?
>>
File: 645367658134.png (525 KB, 1280x777)
525 KB PNG
>>43720597
Don't be mean to Pupa
>>
>>43720604
I'm not trying to be mean to Pupa but that story pissed me off since by the end it doubled down on the greater problems that caused all her issues in the first place. She deserves better.
>>
oof
>>
File: ye olde throne room.png (1.82 MB, 1920x1080)
1.82 MB PNG
>>
>>43720664
Write for yourself, not for others.
>>
>>43720346
>Either set it in the time period where Luna is on the moon
>on the moon
i'd expect you of all people to not get thing wrong, pinkieflag.
>>
File: sunset horse.png (827 KB, 640x1136)
827 KB PNG
>>
>>43720489
You’re comparing him to Dickens???
I’m not the one with brain damage.
>>
>>43721251
I can't tell if you're making an esoteric quibble about her actually being "in" the moon or just being retarded for no reason, but the alicorns are still visible from Equestria painted on the surface of the moon when they're banished there (both Luna and Celestia) so I'm not going to worry too much about the specifics between in/on/to in casual reference.
I assume it's just asset reuse but I do think it's kind of lame that the Mare in the Moon looks the same for both Celestia and Nightmare Moon
>>
>>43721752
No, but I can see why your complete lack of reading comprehension would make you believe as much.
>>
>>43721771
Pinkflaggot, I...
>>
>>43721959
Ah, so just trolling then. Carry on
>>
>>43721973
>The flaggot runs away in terror
Typical.
>>
>>43721973
>everything we see in the show is 100% undeniable canon that you aren't allowed to contest, no matter how many hoops you have to jump through to explain all the obvious contradictions this causes.
>except that thing that the show is 100% consistent about for its entire run, with absolutely no evidence whatsoever of the contrary, and that contradicts literally nothing. you're obviously just trolling if you believe that.
>>
>>43721990
Do you actually have a point or are you just vagueposting and throwing random insinuations that people said the exact opposite of what they just posted like an hour ago with no real endgame? I genuinely don't even know what you think you're saying
>except that thing
What thing nigga?
>>
>>43721955
>You should read a writer who is so great that he makes gorgeous prose sound simple and easy. Only then will you appreciate the work of a try-hard incompetent.
Do you hear what you're saying?
>>
5 on koth_ponyville_revamped
>>
Its okay that you aren't the best writer in fimfiction.
Its okay that you will never get the feedback you want.
Its okay that you are a failure writer.
Accept that and live your life.
>>
>>43722149
wrong thread. disregard.
>>
>>43721994
>What thing nigga?
luna was in the moon, not on the moon. this is a real distinction, and one that the show is perfectly consistent about.
you should have been able to surmise that this is what i was talking about based on context clues.
>>
>>43722199
Hey retard did you not see the entire post >>43721771 saying exactly that?
>you should have been able to surmise that this is what i was talking about based on context clues.
Continuing to go on after I already said that in a post which asked if that's what >>43721251 was about is pretty strong context that that's not what you were asking about, faglord
>>
>>43720604
>>43720644
That fic went to shit when Pupa went into a coma for the whole middle half of it. She's the whole point of the story and she gets sidelined by sunbutt trying to kiss her mom.
>>
>tfw the Pinkiefag gives your fic a 2/10 but the Futaloo foalcon a 7/10

>review https://www.fimfiction.net/story/159228/temporary-hiatus

6.5/10. After successfully killing Daring in a very anti-climatic way, Ahuizotl naval gazes at her corpse. I think this was the point of origin for a few of the earlier ones I read--It's Just You and Me, which has an identical setup except its Ahuizotl who gets the arrow to the chest and Daring who does the waxing; and Fallen Foes, which has Ahuizotl wax over "Ms Do"'s dead body. The story was fine but i liked Fallen Foes setup way more. It does the same emotional sad thing but then throws a curveball at the end as a bonus whereas this one just has the "villain in mourning" thing going on.

There's also a second AU chapter where the opposite happens. Daring dodges the arrow, wins the prize, and Ahuizotl gets crushed to death by the collapsing temple. She handles it way better than he did. Can't say it's as good as the first chapter. It's much more of a "normal" story than a POV introspective monologue thing, so the author can't even really do a direct comparison of their reactions, which is, I assume, the only reason to do the chapter.

>end

>review https://www.fimfiction.net/story/169778/better-luck-next-time

6.7/10. While being successfully killed by Ahuizotl in a very anti-climatic way, Daring naval gazes as her body starts cooling. Figured I'd complete the set and read the fan prequel to the above. I think I like this one a bit more. It has a bit more sad punch to it given its from the POV of the one dying. There's just something about reading someone's "dying moments" that strikes me harder than a villain in mourning thing does.

>end

>review https://www.fimfiction.net/story/174228/excavation-site-55

3.5/10. Daring and her archeology team unearth a treasure from the ancient past. Man, what a disappointment. I think the worst fics I've read are the ones that have a really good concept the author just completely botches. It's a variant of Yucca Mountain. Daring unearths an iPhone (no, really) and Celestia has to cover it up, but, as I'm sure you can tell, it's just not a good story. Spelling and grammar issues abound. The narrator really struggles to paint a good mental picture. Buried under all that, there was a chance to have almost a horror kind of thing go on--the dig team is frustrated and fed up with Daring, then they unearth the human artifact and shit hits the fan, but it never even comes close to delivering on any of the ideas--horror, government conspiracy, etc. Nothing. What a waste.
>>
>>43722204
It's dumb because it establishes that the rampant changeling incest is a bad thing and that Pupa being babied and her education neglected.
So at the end they're going to marry her off to her cousin and treat her even more like a baby. And this is somehow a happy ending.
>>
>>43722696
When I read it, I took it as a half-tragic resolution, where Chrysalis's hooves are tied and she basically isn't allowed to discipline Pupa anymore. She's in a place emotionally and politically where she needs to overcompensate by showering her daughter with gifts and love, long-term consequences be damned. Even the author treats it as kind of a superficial resolution because he points out how Pupa stops getting educated and essentially regresses in maturity due to her trauma. The royal family is left literally in their walled garden trying to find some small amount of joy in how the future of their nation lies with two retard babies. What bothered me is how Chrysalis's sweeping political reforms are presented as daunting but necessary for modernization, when really they're doing the opposite. (She's giving more power to the petty nobles? Bringing back feudalism?? Hello???)
>>
>>43722696
>>
>>43722784
See you could argue that all this was some sort of commentary on Imperial Japan's fading power but I just don't think the author was clever enough for that.
>>
>>43722488
>tfw the Pinkiefag gives your fic a 2/10 but the Futaloo foalcon a 7/10
I gave your fic a 3/10 >>43672810, but Verisimilitude is actually a good example of a fic which works where DD and the ToT fails. Both of them are an attempt to pervert FiM into genre it's not in order to tell a story of that genre using it's world. In about half as many words, Verisimilitude goes through the same plot points, actually places itself in the world successfully, and even goes a narrative beat further. Plus, you know, it's just better written; far less embellishment in the prose, exposition is integrated a fair amount more even if it's not perfect, no cringey references that don't land and so end up detracting from the atmosphere, and of course it respects it's characters and their world in a way which makes it less jarring.

It sort of goes back to the discussion about Rain Party; the twist ending brings Verisimilitude all together. Without the ending it'd be making many of the mistakes that DDatToT does (though it would still be a far superior text on a technical level). If it didn't land the ending, it'd be stupid. If it didn't attempt the ending at all, it'd be stupid and insulting. If it was worse written, it'd be boring as well as everything else. DDatToT is boring and stupid and insulting because it doesn't attempt to marry the ending into the setting at all. It's a story which is missing a resolution even though it's 13k words and wastes a huge amount of the reader's time on things which are only unpleasant (like the nuclear warning sign, or the overly expanded exposition dump, or half the character descriptions. Heck the entire intro could be cut down to the first four lines + 1 paragraph and you'd lose nothing) and while it has a good payoff (the dissolving scene is quite nice) it's wrapped in a shit sandwich with six layers of bread just to make you work for that little glimmer of enjoyment and topped with a real whopper of a non-finale which brings together all the things that could have worked and confirms that indeed, they do not.

Unironically I think you should go back to the futaloo story and have a look at how it tells a porn story inside FiM and take that as an example of how you could tell a horror story instead. Based on a lot of your reviews I do think you have terminally shit taste, and I don't know how the fuck you gave verisimilitude only a 5/10 when it's so much better than most of the things you read and you acknowledge such, but it has practically the same setup (MC-Scootadash is seduced by a pornographic magical construct -> MC-Daring is betrayed by an edgelord magical construct) only it's twist resolves the story's apparent narrative/character failings instead of doubling down on them so you could easily use it's structure as a template for a better approach than your own work.
>>
File: faceoff.jpg (185 KB, 912x1200)
185 KB JPG
How's that writing going, guys?
>>
>>43715919
>>43719299
>>
>>43723102
Writing?
>>
File: star rain card.png (630 KB, 1193x1318)
630 KB PNG
>>
File: comic vector glare.png (1.24 MB, 3000x5438)
1.24 MB PNG
>>
>>43723102
I wrote eight words yesterday!
>>
>>43723102
I'm about 20k words deep into a horror thing and I'm at the stage where I hate all of it.
>>
>>43723102
I used to reply to these with my technical writing but ever since AI took over all I'm doing is technical reading (and it makes me want to rope). The only things I write nowadays are prooompts
>>
>>43723102
oh yeah, who even has control of the corpse right now?
>>
File: purpluna fall castle_s.png (3.83 MB, 2320x3053)
3.83 MB PNG
>>
>>43723862
Sleepy
>>
>>43724199
Then go take a nap, dammit.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.