>2026>no MLP Stardew Valley clone where you move into the Apple Family farm and try to run Flim and Flam out of business>no MLP open world RPG >the only MLP video game since gen 2 is a 3 hour adventure that costs $60 and apparently features Sprout's redemption arcA-at least Them's Fightin' Herds came out...
There is a game but it's mobile gachaslop
...?>>43722872
>>43730115>less users joining the board>hard to coordinate anons with specific skills>hard to keep anons working on a single project without quittingdamn, if only there was some sort of technology that could speed up the process of making a game and filling the open rolls on a small team of anons without having a bunch of anons screeching that they dont like the thing but are not going to learn a skill to help the thing.
>>43730137That doesn't count because uuuuhhhh...
>>43730137>>43730218>>43730239I was more making a thread about Hasbro wasting opportunities. I know Them's Fightin' Herds is a fan game and it's also the only fan game I was aware of outside of that weird Russian game where you torture baby ponies in diapers for some reason.
>>43730246iirc Hasbro is really bad at making contracts, and so all the rights to make a MLP:FiM game went to that Gameloft game.On the bright side, they seem to be more lax on C&Ding fan games now, like on Steam.https://store.steampowered.com/app/2688410/Tales_From_the_Herd/(This is also from /create/ general)
>>43730115I wouldn't say those ideas feel very pony. Nor would they appeal to little girls. Remember, the people ponies are made for?
>>43730115check this out:farmville FIMcityville EQG
>>43730658>cityville EQGHe said MLP, not barbieslop.
>>43730115>Stardew Valley cloneYikes>open world RPG YIKES>since gen 2Gen 3 had a few games I think>A-at least Them's Fightin' Herds came out...Didn't the story mode get abandoned?
I want a collectathon platform game where you start playing as Twilight exploring levels in Ponyville or the Everfree forest, and you slowly unlock the rest of the Mane 6, each have her own abilities and stuff to find unlockables (like different skins and costumes for the girls, concept art, music, etc...)I guess Spike could be the character that sells you upgrades and stuff in exchange for gems.
>>43730115Just play Ponyvania.
>>43730647Both farming games and RPGs are actually pretty popular among girl demographics?>>43730675Gen 3 had the most of any pony gen in fact, having around 4 games. The bar ain't very high since its competing with 2(literally only 1 game) and 5(which has a total of 2).>Didn't the story mode get abandoned?Yep. The people running it deleted the dev team after one content wave all the way back in 2023.
>>43730661any questions?
>>43730703They are?Well anyway it's still not very pony you know what I mean? Ponyville isn't a peaceful place. Everypony there is crazy and it's just constant chaos every day. Ponies do work hard but like that's only ever a small part of the show. Take away all the fun and just keep the farming? Not really fim.As for open world rpg, I don't fucking believe you that little girls could like those. Pretty much every single one of those so far is rated M and has a ton of killing. But say you were going to make it different. How do you make it feel like pony? How do you simulate cartoony but sincere friendship in a computer simulation and how does the open world and the rpg aspect fit into it?
>>43730762This. Saying barbies aren't pony is an insane and disingenuous take.
>>43730775Hasjew opinion discarded.
>>43730778NO YOU TAKE MY OPINION OUT OF THE TRASH RIGHT NOW! PLEEASE ANON PLEEEAAASSSEEEE!!!!!!! I'M LITERALLY CRYING!1!is that how I'm supposed to react?
>>43730770Most farming sims have non farming activities as a thing you do on the side. And interacting with random characters in town is usually a large part of them; which of course comes with random big things happening in the town.They aren't games where you sit on a farm and nothing else.Even FiM ain't just about friendship, a general "adventure" angle being most of the game ain't weird in the slightest. In fact trying to blindly tie everything to that concept is how you don't make FiM.They aren't all M and the one obvious example to point at(Infinity Nikki) just decides to focus more on platforming and puzzles, and customization elements obviously(but the more combat focused ones don't actually see that much a decrease).Friendship in the context of games is generally just going to be cutscenes for doing something for an NPC, something this game type is already consistently doing anyway.
>>43730775>Saying barbies aren't ponyAnon, I...
>>43730273lulthis does look really good though
>>43730818>farming games have sode activitiesHow do you know that? You playing farming games? Lmao. We got a rake and hoe gamer here. Anyway alright maybe it would work but it would be more of an Applejack game than a whole ass FIM game. And even then idk. Still a little too cozy. Like, you're not actually doing the work. Some game genres are just stupid.>infinity nikki is obviousNever heard of it but thanks for telling me about it, it sounds cool. Also lmao what are you, an anime girls and gambling gamer? Lol.>Even FiM ain't just about friendship, a general "adventure" angle being most of the game ain't weird in the slightest.It's like 98% about friendship at least and JUST adapting the adventure episodes is totally a weird thing to do. Then it's not really a full adaptation of the show. Also what are you, a potion and sword gamer?>Friendship in the context of games is generally just going to be cutscenes for doing something for an NPC, something this game type is already consistently doing anyway.Fake shit. Not good enough for an adaptation of FIM. Innovate or die. Stop being lazy and trying to just do what everyone else has done. What are you, a copy and paste developer?
>>43730893Nta but if he was going to copy and paste anything and he was going for a cartoony friendship simulator, just use Dispatch as a template. All you gotta do is take out the swears and blood, and replace the romance choice with like best friend type shit.
>>43730115>Apple Family farm and try to run Flim and Flam out of businessWhy are rariniggers so spiteful?
>>43730115G4 has a city simulator and a bubble shooter. But I don’t know why it took until G5 for adventure games to come out.
>>43730678It would be cool to have something akin to Psychonauts. Ponyville could serve the same purpose as the camp in that game, being a comfy hub where you hang around, meet ponies, finish grounded low-stake quests, and find secrets. The main story could take the player to different parts of Equestria and have some higher-stake conflicts.