>Maneskin = any generic 70s band but shit>The Paradox = Blink-182 but meh>Geese = Strokes but shit>The Warning = Muse but meh + hot chicksWhy are zoomers so fuckin derivative and creatively bankrupt?
>>130405896It's a "meta" generation, they live vicariously through other people's past
maneskin and paradox are spiritually millennials.it's not possible to fuck with blink without being a millennial or being indocrinated into it
unironically the warning's albums were better when they wre like 12 year olds even though still corny asf. they used to have better songwriters
>>130405896Don't pretend most of the late 2000s and 2010s indie scene wasn't just the same derivative bullshit even if you can argue on quality. So it's magically okay when a Millennial band does "Midwest Emo Revival", "Garage Rock Revival" or "Dance-Punk Revival?". No it's the same derivative bullshit impulse. There were Millennial bands who made bank ripping off Cap n' Jazz but your criticisms aren't being applied to them. The endless Hardcore bands that played shows and released music on bandcamp throughout the 2000s, 2010s and the 2020s? Same derivative bullshit. Blackgaze was original in the modern scene but not much else. Also The Warning was outed by a Mexican anon as being a shill operation. Yes Geese were shilled by Chaotic Good along with many other artists. The Paradox are mediocre and I don't know the deal with Maneskin. Don't throw stones from a glass house. If you're a rap guy or an EDM guy i'd get it but since you're a rock guy you're a fucking hypocrite.
>>130406119slam
>>130406119>Also The Warning was outed by a Mexican anon as being a shill operationHow did they even find this shit out?
>>130406119bodied that freak
>>130406119What was tv on the radio reviving?
>>130406158He didn't have direct evidence but he studied them in conversation. Probably in the archives in the endless Warning threads that used to be in here.
>>13040623380s/90s Indie in general. A continuation of indie scenes.
>>130406260There's smth smiliar going on with Geese now but I can't prove
>>130406293https://www.wired.com/story/geese-chaotic-good-marketing-industry-plant/It's been proven for a couple of months now. They were found to be working with Chaotic Good Projects who astroturf with fake fan comments and fake fan accounts on social media.
>The Beatles but good
>>130406336These plastic boobies I can't LMAO
>>130406348>The Beatles but good
>>130405896They said >The kids of today should defend themselves against the 70shttps://youtu.be/UHfFJub5MsMin the 90s. With Eddie Vedder, of all people.You might be able to say that each round of the retro carousel produces results that are more lacklustre, more superficial, than the one before, but idk, sort of gets murky when you're trying to come to definitive conclusions.The 80s had Shakin' Stevens for cryin out loud.
>>130405896Im not defending any of these ''artists'' cause this shit is just slop, but they arent the problem. The problem is retards over the internet buying that bullshit cause they dont know enough music
>Strokes but shitBut The Strokes are already shit.
>>130407770Green Door was kino tbf, it reminds me of when you'd go to a car boot sale and there'd be stalls set up where they were selling (probably pirated) 50's Rock n' Roll CDs
>>130407798This.It's becoming increasingly obvious that scam awareness should be a school subject.Then again public schools are scams as well
>>130405973>songwritersoh so they outsource their songwriting to an outside party? Like some shitty pop act? Gee, I didn't need a reason to never listen to them again but thanks
>>130407862and already derivative lol
>>130406119They were just rich kids dicking around
>>130405896>OP = faggot but shit
>>130405896>>130405909All genres have been invented, fuckheads. We've just been through the hyperpop fad which was just "screw it, let's just sit on a piano".What the hell is left to innovate in music?
>>130409944>i am not innovative, imaginative nor creativeokay lol have fun crywanking yourself to sleep
>>130409998Invent a new genre now since you're so creative.
>>130410009The concept of 'new genres' is a bit weird nowadays as true forward movements in culture are usually brought on by technical advancements.The only current technical advancement that can move the culture forward is sadly AI. So let's just ask grok to make up a new genre and leave this convo behind so we can listen to actual music made by actual people and stop focusing on retarded hypotheticals
>>130409944Do you think all the previous genres were hypothesized in PKD novels before materializing in a lab?The whole point of innovation is we don't know what it is until it's concieved of.
>>130410419People R&Ding new technology used to work alongside artists to see what potential new tools had for that. Martin Hannet was given the worlds first digital delay circuit and used it to record Unknown Pleasures, Les Paul was an artist himself and was the first user of multi track recording, the prototypes for every modern guitar pedal were given to Jimi Hendrix to play with while he was in Britain. The Art Of Noise was a group formed around multiple people dicking around with what was essentially the first modern DAW.There is nothing like that happening in the tech world anymore. It's all jist marketing satanists trying to make kids into gambling addicts
>>130411140It's all changed now cause those incremental advancements you're talking about, while pivotal and forward pushing, are now maybe 1% of all possible things you can do with sound.I think we'll have to invent a new way of categorizing future music (at least the tiny fraction of it that wont be able to be called slop)
Are they good live? Do they enjoy what they do? Do people enjoy their music? Literally all that matters. You think someone wakes up one day and think "Hmm I need to write music pseuds on /mu/ will praise otherwise I am not a real musician". Get real faggots. I bet some of you fags listen to music you don't even enjoy because you want to look good.
>>130411612fuck off poptimist cvck, the problem with bands like these reaches way beyond 'hurr sound good''
>>130405896Geese sound nothing like The Strokes
He says, on the board with 10 KPop Threads and 10 Olivia Rodrigo threads up at all time.
>>130411852>this shit is shittier so this other shit is shit no morewhy not both anon
I don't know about those other bands but seeing Daniela Villareal having so much fun playing the guitar is what finally motivated me to pick up an instrument. And AFAIK they've received a lot of endorsements from famous artists so it's not like they're fraud. Mike Portnoy had their latest album on his top 10 of 2024 IIRC.
>>130412046>they've received a lot of endorsements from famous artistslike any other plant
>>130412104>Muh plantsBoomer retards can't fathom we aren't in the 70s anymore and shit goes viral. The Warning got Viral 10 years ago for their Metallica cover and they started from there. Angine de Poitrine recently blew up after the KEXP video blew up. Doesn't make them plants.
>>130412179Shut up cretin you're a failed shill
>>130412223I'm sorry your favored artists aren't more popular, maybe they're not as good as you think.
>>130411666This 100%. How on earth can you listen to this and say it sounds like the Strokes:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lt9P9CFZZpU
>>130405896The trick is not listening to those bands you compare them to, then it sounds new and fresh. Ultimately that's how it works for most people, virtually nobody listening to Rock or Metal or Pop listened to the precursors of the genre and its most famous and best contributors. In a lot of cases people find artists to listen to by chance or through acquaintances, even more the case nowadays since the youth doesn't listen to the radio anymore.
>>130412258no you disingenuous fuck, they didnt have a team of paid kike shills ''promoting'' their slop on social media, dipshit
>>130412337>>130412295>>130412258disgusting fucking shills fuck you, despicable wastes of skin cells
>>130412377>>130412363Uh oh melty
>>130412424as if there isnt a single person with a brain that could read this exchange and take your side
>>130409934which of those bands are you a fan of
only pedophile boomers and lesbians and troons care about the warning.only they/thems care about geese
>>130406353This is so fuckin humiliating. I think every tranny is going through a divine punishment
>>130406119>The Warning was outed by a Mexican anon as being a shill operation.>outedYou're giving that Mexican anon a lot of credit. I don't know when this "outing" happened, but it ws painfully obvious to me that the band was being astroturfed a few years ago when I kept seeing The Warning (Mexican Rock Band) threads here on /mu/ on a daily basis.
>>130412633this. man i really think scam awareness should be a school subject.then again, public schools are a scam tooand if you cant realize a shilled fucking inorganically grown band, you should be executed cause your IQ is clearly below 95 and we dont need people like that
>>130412642imagine if it was the chicanas themselves
>>130412653Im not gonna cause im not an incel simp (such an oxymoron but theres so many of you maggots)
>>130412633Why the fuck would anyone shill here of all places? 4chan's /mu/ is like 0.001% of the population of Reddit and an even smaller portion of TikTok, Youtube and Instagram. Even paying a singular person to shill here wouldn't be a good investment, especially considering the population of this board is older millenials with abnormal tastes. It's like those retards on /v/ who think every game is being shilled.
>>130412661This is what makes me scratch my head. It's not like 4chan's chuds are considerable people by mass normies
>>130412661Theres no ID requirement and it's supremely easy to astroturf anything, especially with the younger, ever dumber people finding the board through shitty youtube videos and them already being primed and susceptible to propaganda.But you already knew that.Fuck you
>>130405896IDC YOU'D NEED TO RIP THE FABRIC OF TIME AND SPACE TO TAKE MY TUNG OUTTA ALEJANDRA'S ASSHOLE
>>130412707Nah :/
>>130412661>Why the fuck would anyone shill here of all places?If someone is being paid to shill a band online, why not shill on 4chan alongside every other place you mentioned?
>>130412707You don't need ID to make accounts for Instagram or anything though? You think having to make an account is too big an hurdle so people will opt to shill here instead? What's next? Shilling on IRC channels? You have to be delusional as fuck to think /mu/ has any relevance to anyone since the mid 2000s. I swear "shillfags" are people who want to feel more important and relevant than they actually are (not at all).>>130412773Juice ain't worth the squeeze. There are no mechanisms on this website to bring visibility to a specific thread other than constant bumping and it's impossible to bump without being extremely obviously fake. One could argue that this thread is doing a better job at promoting the 4 bands at the OP than a bonafide shill could do making a dedicated thread for one of those bands.
>>130412797Same fucking pattern shills on /pol/ and /x / use lmao rope fast
>>130412797Sowing seeds of distrust towards things you see online is only healthy
>>130412812>Shills on /x/Okay now you're just joking
>>130412824Theres disgusting shills on /x/ looking for damaged individuals to invite to their discord servers and make them their victims
>>130412824>deflecting by using a single aspect of the postEpic playbook move bro real organic
>/mu/fags mad because some bands they never have to listen to ever are finding some successIt's not like there's a limit to how many bands of a genre that can exist at once. The existence of those derivative bands is not preventing the birth of le epic unique band you crave.
>>130412721This but with Paulina.
>>130409944Millennials had no problem coming up with new sounds even if it resulted in Brostep
>>130405896WHAT? BANDS SOUND SIMILAR? NO WAY THIS HAS NEVER HAPPENED BEFORE IN THE HISTORY OF MUSIC!
>>130412914>shills keep seething about being outed and keep up the poorest damage control possibleMunted retard, the problem isnt fame or infamy, the problem is these shells of music bands are being pushed just for some people to earn money.There is NO passion and love for music, just a quick buck and boring tired rock riffs
>>130412928This but with bothIf you prefer Paulina prolly your a manlet but that's okay asf
Great the indian coomers joined the chat, thread dead
>>130412971would the warning even be a thing now without coomers?
>>130412956Pretty sure passionless and loveless bands suck ass live. Smashing Pumpkins are a good example of such a band of talentless hacks.
>>130413010Another tactic of retarded shills.Bring a completely new talkimg point to a discussion to move the convo away from the main point.Fuck you
>>130413045you niggas just paranoid adis point
>>130413061Fuck off esl monkey
>>130413061Nigga probably some Mexican from Monterrey who got shot down by Alejandra in middle school and can't cope.
I hope you're at least getting paid for this, you despicable scum
>>130413073If I were a nigga chicano I would have raped her, thank (?) God I'm not
>>130412797>Juice ain't worth the squeezeI don't know about that. When I saw Rick Beato mention The Warning in that one video he posted the other day, my first thought was "Hey, I know that band!" So I guess the shilling succeeded in getting people like me to remember their name. >There are no mechanisms on this website to bring visibility to a specific thread other than constant bumping and it's impossible to bump without being extremely obviously fake.Fake or not, the person shilling athe Warning was doing so by posting pictures conventionally attractive women doing stuff that generally looks kind of cool to people. This place being an imageboard people can use freely without having to make an account means there is very little friction to posting pictures of these attractive women looking cool. Also, somebody probably saw the constant threads on the front page full of people obsessing over female singers and thought this would be a good place to do the same for The Warning. I doubt anyone was wasting too much time posting pictures of the band here while also making their rounds on other platforms. I'm willing to bet that a Hayley Williams stan probably checked out The Warning after seeing those threads every day for weeks in end.Never underestimate the value of a free billboard.
>>130414414>Never underestimate the value of a free billboard./\Anons also underestimate the size and influence of 4chan in general
>>130414508I agree with both of you but it's not 'anons'Look at the convos they had.They are clearly the same shills we are talking about trying to obfuscate their work
>>130414508While the influence is undeniable, it's getting most people to agree on something to push something that's from the last decade to greater consciousness is the problem.
>>130412633You're actually right I forgot it was nearly daily. I don't think it was a proper outing I think that Mexican anon was claiming to have psyched the shills out.
>>130414598The age of organic board meme culture is deadBack to your doom anon
>>130414628it was dead by 2010
>>130414661Not denying that, not nostalgic for it, most of the people here are and always were genuine morons
>>130414628>>130414661Have hope dudes holy shit
>>130414740lol you havent been here for more than 2 months huh
>>130414740i think of all boards /mu/ may be the one that decayed the most
>>130414628>"anon"Great work anon, calling the non-anon an anon.
>>130414855My purpose was to dehumanize, anon.I dont believe in your misconstrued idea of identity
>>130414870ok anon
>>130414748I've been here for 8 years
>>130406119The Oh Sees may have been retro but there was no band you could directly say they rip off. Same with Ty Segall. You can fault them for not being innovative but they injected plenty of their own personality and style into what they did and I think the same can be said about a lot of the other indie bands from that time too. Geese is the only band of the 4 mentioned that even somewhat add their own sense of personality into their music and Foreskin is unapologetically just royalty-free pastiche.
>>13041515213 here, it was past dead when you came
>>130415257I've come to realise that fairly recently
>>130415231Fair enough>>130415152
>>130415388Shit didn't mean to quote the second one
>>130415231i love how the paradox isn't ever even recalled to be mentioned lol. op is drowning in instagram algorithms and bitching about it
>>130406260What is the difference between an actual paid shill and just some autistic anon latching onto something and turning it into an obsession? There's one on /v/ for that stupid Disney racing game and I refuse it's someone paid for it.
>>130414761
>>130414761Decayed or been outgrown by you? You can't expect the music board from 2026 to talk about the same artists and the same genres as the 2006 board.
>>130415791decayed. categorically
The Warning's latest MV has a lot of tummy and abs so I'm all in.
>>130417078>tummy AND abslol
