Song link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n2BnbpjpRdoAm I crazy or is this song just... bad. I don't listen to or like any pop music but people were telling me to give this a shotIt's actually almost somehow impressive how off the "heavy guitar" chorus section sounds, like it is the aesthetics of rock with none of the anything-else of rock, it has no anything to it, it's completely emptyLike how does Daniel Nigro make it sound so not-good and so boring in this way. Can anyone explain the music theory or whatever behind what makes it so off. Is it just way too straight/non-syncopated. or something?She's good at singing of course but musically this is just not good, to me
>why does it sound goodbecause its written in the feel good scale with a no commitment harmony and a chorus in the dark and heavy scale with the same harmonylyrics that have only good timingpeak industrialization
>"this is very definition of X"Anyone who uses this phrase is 90iq. Equivocation is the sign of a midwit.
>>130492542Did an LLM reply to me. What.
>>130492633I am not sure that that is equivocation exactly
>>130492297pic you used gives the game awaytry again
>>130492741What the fuck are you talking about why is everyone replying to me so oddlyI am asking what, theoretically speaking, makes this song sound so not-good in this particular way. I am even arguing with people on that Twitter thread saying it just sounds like ordinary pop and is very much not punk or rock or punk-rock or even punk-popEveryone, including myself, is dunking on the stupid tweet
>>130492297This is better than I expected, thanks OP I'll check out more of her stuff
>>130492823She's a good singer but pop music is just so lame and so compositionally trite and bad
>>130492831and you are claiming 3 chord punk rock is better?
>>130492758>it just sounds like ordinary pop and is very much not punk or rock or punk-rock or even punk-popI mean you can dislike it all you want but this is just cope lmao
>>130492874I don't know. I exclusively listen to electronic music like Autechre and stuff. I don't really know what punk rock is. I have not listened to other genres. I just know this pop stuff is quite bad.>>130492917Dude it's mainstream cliche generic stale top 40 pop music with some heavy somewhat distorted guitars in the chorus, that's it. Compositionally it is mainstream pop music
>expecting normal replies with that woman in the OPlollmao even
>>130492932I don't use /mu/ much. Do people here have some kind of fixation with her
>>130492922Why are you commenting on whether something is or isn't rock/punk when you don't even listen to either?
>>130493071Because I'm pretentious.
No one ever called Blink-182 punk.
>>130492297Because it's very compressed, which makes the distorted guitar sound sound boring.
>>130493285Anon thank you for being the first to actually answer me
I WANNA SEE OLIVIA’s RODRIGO
>>130492297Ok, congrats you don't have the taste of a 12 year old girl OP!
>>130494780Actually that is a good question: who is an example of a genuinely good musician/band who both 12-year-old girls and elitist veteran /mu/ autists both like
>>130492297it's just kind of not anything
>>130492297It's Miley Cyrus Disney channel pop rock
Better luck next time, anon
