>song generally deemed by the fanbase to be the band's worst song>listen to it>it's actually pretty goodWhy is this so common? Are it because normies are retarded?
Weird
>>130890597I think it's more hated by critics than the majority of the fanbase, and a lot of the critical bashing it has gotten over the years has seemed really performative and hyperbolic. It's almost like a rite of passage, you're not a true rock critic until you write your thesis on why Maxwell's Silver Hammer is the worst thing since cancer.
>>130890597>>130890623>>130890747>ZAYN, STOP MAKING US PLAY THAT'S WHAT MAKES YOU BEAUTIFUL>It's a drag innit? I'm a faggot!Wow, you guys are hilarious. Did you know old /mu/ hated this gay boyband? This thread would've led to some serious bullying.
Anyone else just hide his posts at this point?
Would the Beatles be viewed differently today if Paul had died in 2001 and George Harrison was still alive?
>>130890597I like it but it’s easily the weakest song on the album
It's a great song and I like it.
>>130890964not mean mr mustard? especially right after sun king?
>>130890898>>130890964>>130891328>>130891591>I'm a gay man in drag, cheers.Why would he say this? You guys actually listen to this? Lol
>>130890597I Want To Hold Your Hand is considerably worse than Maxwells Silver Hammer.
>>130890597I like this song. I loved the Steve Martin version when I was a kid.
>>130890597Its a catchy bouncy song and the "oh oh oh ohhhs" are buddy hollyish and infectious
>>130890597boybandslop
>>130890597it's the context that makes it bad
>>130891863>>130891885>>130891958>>130892177Completely agreed. My BF (we're both gay) actually sharted because he agreed with these posts about a boyband who made songs for teen girls with 3 chords. Get a hobby.
>>130892188Go back to fapping to Gone Troppo, you despicable georgefag
>>130890597you mean rev 9?
I remember in seventh grade English class the teacher played this song to teach us about ironic songwriting or some shit since it's upbeat and happy-sounding but is about murder.
A shame they put so much time into this track where they could have used that time to complete the tracks in the ending medley
>>130893535Kek
I like most of Paul's granny tunes. There, I said it.
>>130893535love paul
>>130890597It's competently made but the fact that they had Something, Here Comes the Sun, Come Together and the whole medley thing being worked on at the same time just makes it worse by association.
>Listen to the supposed worst Radiohead song>It's still better than some of the absolute shite on The King of Limbs https://youtu.be/TSah7g7g7R4
>>130890597actually think Paul's granny tunes might end up being the most enduring of the oeuvre.they are definitely the most challenging from a music theory perspective.i've been trying to learn old classic rock songs by ear and I have limited understanding of theory, but after a while you start to develop a sense of what the formulas of pop/rock songs are. Paul's granny songs tend to break the expected rules as much or more than any I've tried to learn.just totally unexpected chords that still sound right, and weird key changes, etc.
>>130890597It's not all that bad but it's not really up to the standard of the rest of the album. Also joke or novelty songs have decreased replay value. >>130890773Nah, I like watching him get more and more desperate. He posted the one direction sleeve in a completely unrelated thread earlier. He's gonna rope soon. KWAB.
>>130892253
>>130898474I just hide them because at this point, theres nothing to say to him that hasn't been said.
>>130896883It’s just a pity knowing he can go tier songs like fixing a hole
lol not one person has ever claimed it’s their worst song. rocky raccoon is closer to being the worst.
>>130890597Its got genuinely messed up lyrics that were way ahead of their time and predicted show trials, media trials, serial killers and that type of stuff and I think it was too "silly" because "who would do any of the weird shit in this song" and it aged extremely well and the lyrics are prophetically genius.
>>130900114Rocky raccoon is a better track. Fucking Paul broke up the band with Maxwells Silver Hammer. It's the track that broke the Beatles. Fruity!
>>130899990>>130900114>>130900251>>130900291completely agreed with all these posts about the beatles. i think that-WAIT, JOHN, NO!
>>130890597BANG BANG
>>130901491HERE WE COME HERE WE SLAMIT'S THE FUN FACTORY WITH THE BSB'S
>>130901567Get new material
>>130891591Mean Mr Mustard fucking slaps
>>130901762>slapsLIKE JOHN AND HIS WIFE! IT'S BEATDOWN TIME! (60s Harry Styles beat his wife, but only once and felt bad). I'M GAY!
>>130901762It really does
>>130901762A shame they didn't finish it
