https://poal.me/i23yqk
miles is better but I don't find either terribly interesting
>>131518072Miles. Coltrane is great but he had no restraint when playing with Miles. Too damn many notes, and that just makes me appreciate Miles' playing all the more.
>>131518072Trane was a real nigga, Miles was a trustfund kid.
too intense, man...https://youtu.be/8iTLJnVd5uE
>>131518072the only moment coltrane was ever interesting is when mac miller rapped over a sample of his
>>131518072Coltrane because saxophone is objectively a better-sounding instrument than trumpet.
>>131518072Coltrane?
is /mu/ a sharkey bonanno, a wingy manone, or a muggsy spanier board?
>>131518072its a Coltrane board but Alice
>>131518072Miles because trumpet is objectively a better-sounding instrument than saxophone.
>>131518423It's not
>>131518072I don't listen to 60s Drake or 60s Kendrick Lamar
>>131518490oh not this shit again
Evans, Jamal, P. Johnson, Kelly type of guy
/mu/ is a Drizzy board
>>131518072Why choose when we can have both at the same time?https://youtu.be/-Hpczb5quhk?si=8y0yjhWZy4AIotZS
>>131519417miles and trane played together?? holy shit
>>131519439>he doesn't know about the First QuintetGet an education, boy: https://youtu.be/Ys9wiGNDCvA?si=NFlsK9s-ZMvOXWiI
>>131519540sorry, forgot the /s, reddit!
>>131518072One made In a Silent Way. I think that makes it pretty obvious who was the better musician.
>>131518072Trane was alright, for a trumpet nigga I'd pick Don Cherry over Miles
>>131519439They played together on Kind of Blue, stupid
>>131520036Sam Rivers > Coltrane for sax
>>131519708>mfw I get clowned on /mu/ of all places
>>131519937>I think that makes it pretty obvious who was the better musicianYeah, the one who didn't.
>>131519937Fusion Miles is mogged by Soft Machine and Zappa.
>>131518072trane is the better musician, miles is the better bandleaderas for their discographies I think trane has higher highs whereas miles has a ton of great records (and even more bad ones)
>miles of shit davis>john cumstainPass
>>131520711Such wit
>>131518072Aren't you forgetting someone?
>>131518072Trane, by far.
>>131522011Oh right op forgot "another guy playing unrelated instrument"
>>131522035Well, I could have posted "another guy fucking your mom", of which there are plentiful examples, but I abstained.
>>131522067My mom is a virgin. Nice try though.
>>131522067Cool projection negro w/ white parents
Miles music actually had soul. Coltrane was all about techniquefaggotry and going up and down scales super fast
>>131522483You only think that way because Miles made normalfaggot music
>>131518072Evans (Bill)>>131522011Correct.
>>131518072Trane has a stronger discography and didn't subject the public to 40 fusion albums>>131518367Zoomers were a mistake
>>131522011>>131522738you can't include Bill Evans in the question or else there's no contestalso they're more frequently mentioned together and were kind of a generation before him
>>131522011>>131522738Bill Evans couldn't compose worth shit and some of his best performances were Davis compositions
>>131522796>h-he can't composeyou mean like 90% of jazz artists?
>>131522777>and were kind of a generation before himthey (as you know) played together, so not sure this is really a fair argument. >>131522796>Bill Evans couldn't compose worth shitSo What? Jazz has always recycled standards.
Neither...It's Eric Dolphy or nothing.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u1lWpLFGhjE
>>131518072John Coltrane. Miles Davis put me to sleep, even his super out there shit
>>131522856>So What? Jazz has always recycled standards.Davis and Coltrane were more talented composers than Evans. They were also both better at improvising over standards than Bill. I respect Bill Evans quite a bit, but he's got the Larry Byrd syndrome of being extremely overrated, ranked among the greatest of all time, simply for being White
