[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/mu/ - Music

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1724663832428961.jpg (344 KB, 915x1024)
344 KB JPG
>there are "people" in here criticizing music who don't even plan an instrument
>>
>>132184631
They also havent listened to the entire western canon. Fucking plebs need to lower their tone before baiting on my /mu/
>>
File: fact.jpg (120 KB, 1004x1011)
120 KB JPG
Only those with no ability to play an instrument can actually objectively evaluate music because they don't have any preconceived biases about how music should be written or played
>>
File: 1593265903150.png (601 KB, 900x935)
601 KB PNG
>>132184631
The critic is the music

Your brains (or lack thereof), the instrument

-Cuckgau Slopperoni Meloni
>>
>>132184636
So a staving child in africa will think any food is the best food ever and thats a good thing?
>>
I want to see an FPV drone strike on anthony fagtano
>>
That's why I don't criticize music I don't like. I just say it's not for my personal taste
>>
>>132184631
How do you plan an instrument?
>>
>>132185733
food and music aren't directly equatable. You can't starve from lack of music. Some people don't even like music and live just fine
>>
>>132184631
>you can't criticize movies unless you can make a movie
>you can't criticize video games unless you can program a game
>>
>>132184631
There are doctors who treat incurable diseases who haven't even died of them.
>>
>>132186069
correct
>>
>>132184636
>illiterate people have the best taste in books
>fat people are the most knowledgable nutritionists
>asexual people have the best sex life
And so on
>>
>>132186193
Most great musicians don't even know music theory
>>
>>132186200
name some examples
>>
>>132186233
Elton John
Louis Armstrong
David Bowie
Prince
Jimmy Hendrix
Beatles
>>
>>132186200
I guarantee that you're not a great musician, so you should probably learn theory
>>
>>132186246
>missing the point
>>
>>132186233
I dunno what you consider a "great" musician but the person that wrote this song stated they can't even read music and are entirely self taught, I think it's pretty good
https://soundcloud.com/fayt1/tears-of-an-ocean-4
>>
>>132186200
Knowing theory =/= being a good musician

In fact if Jacob Collier is anything to go by, it probably makes you worse.
>>
While doing an art definitely gives you deeper insight into and appreciation of the craft, this is a ridiculous sentiment and a cope for receiving negative criticism. It's literally the same as saying you can't judge a novel if you aren't a novelist, or you can't judge a film if you aren't a filmmaker, or you can't judge a painting if you aren't a painter. And, if it turns out the critic IS a musician, novelist, filmmaker, painter, etc. then the goalpost moves to you can't judge the piece of art if you aren't a better artist than the one you're criticizing.

It's a ridiculous standard because most artists don't make art specifically for other artists in their field. They make art for the public, to have an emotional or intellectual impact on them.

Case in point, most people enjoy the Ramones more than Yngwie Malmsteen. Anyone would acknowledge Malmsteen is a far better musician, but almost everyone prefers the Ramones because they wrote fun songs while Malmsteen was busy being a noodly bore.
>>
>>132186353
you're right but there are a lot of retards on /mu/ that will say you're wrong in an effort to sound smarter than you
>>
>>132186193
that's not what he argued
>>
>>132186353
Agreed, OP sounds like a buttmad musician. If all critics were musicians themselves it would be come a circlejerk of musician being deferent to each other because they're all in the in-group and 'understand' it better than the outsiders.
>>
Kek thats like people criticizing video games when they are not even a video game developer lmaooooooo they pretend to know what they are talking about when they just parrot it from an page on wikipedia
>>
Playing an instrument is a gay parlor trick, it's as cheezy as having big fake tits and lip fillers, it's a shortcut to easy sex with retards.
Try writing a compelling and outstanding song, a frightening impossibility for 99% of finger twiddling gear-head "musician" faggots
>>
>>132186549
>it's as cheezy as having big fake tits and lip fillers
>t. Thin lipped bitch with mosquito bite titties
;^)
>>
>>132186549
You’re so assmad that I have to assume you can neither play an instrument nor write songs
>>
>>132186599
They kinda have a point regardless of the wording. Pic related
>>
>>132186353
The Ramones suck too, retard.
>>
>>132184631
>order a steak at a restaurant
>its burnt to shit
>ask waiter to take it back
>"sir if you dont raise cattle then you cant have an opinion"
>>
>>132186599
Also a thin lipped woman that gets mad at the ladies with a nice rack lmao
>>
>>132186608
The fact that songwriting is hard doesn’t make playing an instrument easy, he is massively overstating it
>>
>>132186729
Well yeah obviously, that's why I said they "kinda" have a point "regardless of the wording"
>>
>>132186069
there are critical aspects of a medium which are invisible and therefore unconsiderable by critics who are themselves nescients non-practitioners; the inevitable oversights are delegitimizing of the end product that is the critique
>>
>>132186083
suffering from a disease is not a practice

treating them is
>>
>>132186241
you said great musicians
this list has not a one
>>
>>132186536
Being someone who can game develop carries similar weight to someone who has played a massive variety of relevant games, when it comes to right and worth of critique. And the same with one who cannot and has not.
>>
>>132186845
Lol no that is somebody that knows nothing about making video fames, they only play them lmaoooooooo retard
>>
>>132186827
OK retard
>>
>>132184631
Making music for musicians is great. But there's a reason that genres like jazz are niche.
>>
>>132184631
>>132186069
>>132186193
>you can't tell if food tastes good unless you're a professional chef
>you can't know if your clothes are comfortable unless you're a tailor
>you can't criticize the performance of your car unless you own a factory and have worked at every step of the production line
>you shouldn't be allowed to vote or have any opinion regarding politics unless you've previously been an elected politician
>>
File: IMG_0897.gif (7 KB, 220x229)
7 KB GIF
>>132186998
>>
>>132186998
correct
>>
>>132187065
>>132187105
There is only one constant in music: a hit and not a hit.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.