Artists saying what influenced them to make an album cripples the discussions about them.>oh radiohead said they were inspired by aphex twin making kid a, therefore it’s just a ripoff of aphex twinhow the fuck does this even sound like aphex twin in almost any way?
Radiohead solved IDM
>>132188213trueI can hear some Aphex Twin in Idioteque, but other than that I don’t hear him anywhere else on the album
>>132188213i hear a lot of U2 in this one as well. in general they remind me of U2 if they continued doing what they were doing in the 90s
>>132188213Went from one of the best bands to one of the most boring ones with this crap.
They also said charles mingus influenced which you can hear on the national anthem
>>132188213Unironically Nevermind. People use the comment Kurt made about lifting the dynamics from Pixies but seem to ignore that Nevermind has a lot more straightforward, radio friendly parts than something like Surfer Rosa, not to mention lyrics that are more vague and ironic instead of quirky and bizarre
>>132188251No they did not you fool. They solved post-rock
>>132188213I don't know how anyone can like and enjoy this album, it's pure garbage.
>>132193989Awful and pretentious (forced) taste.
>>132193989What part of it though? I could see people not liking the vocals or the lyrics. Other than that though, it's a generally easy to like album. I liked it immediately when I was a kid.
>>132194052ikr. It's literally pop music
only group i know who are blatantly based off aphex twin would be die antwoord.
>>132194052I used to love it, later on I realized it's not that good
>>132195029you were right before and became confused
>>132188213You are correct, it's just a rip off of U2
>>132188251by doing what? by combining middling indie rock and bad IDM?
>>132195720U2 could make Creep, but Radiohead could never make Where The Streets Have No Name
>>132191377>i hear a lot of U2 in this one as well. in general they remind me of U2 if they continued doing what they were doing in the 90sit's more about flood's production. that's the sound of 90s' u2 and depeche mode
I like to think that they were more influenced by autechre than apex twin but the song Kid A is a track that Yorke tried to replicate the drums he heard Aphex Twin play live once
>>132198072>tried to replicate the drums he heard Aphex Twin play live oncewhich are jungle beats with extra steps (and beats are dub on steroids) desu
>>132190558Aphex twin was what they were listening to. It doesn't sound like afx at all but that was the thing that got radiohead fucking w/ electronic shit enough to incorporate it that heavily. A lot of rockists didn't care about electronic shit back then so this was new for a lot of people. I mean they still don't but the crossover happened in the college rock/indie world when all the warp records shit was still relatively new
Radiohead have always and will always be pop musicians
>>132196155but U2 couldn't make anything post pablo honey
>>132188213>>132188213at that time thom yorke had a yamaha qy100 which he used to program a lot of the initial beats for kid a. while he might have been inspired by aphex twin to get into idm choppy and stuttery drums, the yamaha qy100 was more influential in the general direction for the kid a album due to the demo tracks and intiial ideas he produced while sitting in airports and in transport and in other places where he would program idm-style patterns on the yamaha qy100.the sound of kid a came from that yamaha qy100 because it produced repetitive very idm-styled patterns as that what is easiest to program into it. almost no one else in this thread will know about thom yorkes yamaha qy100 and so is just speculating.
>>132199789>the initial beats for kid a.beats as in actual drum beats, not "beats" as is used by african american hip hop producers. but the drum beats and some basic melodic parts he'd then develop outside of the yamaha qy100.
>>132199587>but U2 couldn't make anything post pablo honeylol, everything after pablo honey sounds like U2.
>>132198072Kid A title track is the beginning of ae's Acroyear2
>>132188213>therefore it’s just a ripoffthat logic actually applies to this record though
>>132199461>A lot of rockists didn't care about electronic shit back then so this was new for a lot of peoplereally? wasn't this an entirely a britpop issue as stated by thom himself? uk artists were very aware of electronic music thanks to synthpop acts and dub. even in the international scene, you have axl rose hang out with fucking depeche mode
>>132204971there's a few avenues that got rock fans into electronic stuff speaking generally, it could have been 70s rock bands rebranding to 80s pop, could have been something like new order etc, but axl rose and depeche mode serve a different demographic than young radiohead fans in 01. I don't think the divide between rock/electronic is really that separated, but you still see that attitude all the time of people who only care about rock. I don't wanna diminish the effects of Kid A by saying it's simply the first time some people had ever heard those two combined, radiohead def did it in a cool way, being influenced by something like aphex twin which is a lot headier than what rock fans mighta got with synth pop. It's a combo of a few things but I do think there were a lot of late 90s alt rock fans who'd never heard trippy electronics a la aphex twin, especially in america. The concept of "breaking america" was bigger back then and radiohead did it back with creep
>>132199461U2 did it before them, did you not listen to zooropa?
>>132207339Why would anyone listen to anything by U2? A bunch of phony balonies
>>132188213Fucking garbage
>>132207430>paranoid, depressing and scaryu wut? is this bait? if anything, the album fails at that
>>132207339I doubt u2 was inspired by aphex twin for zooropa. If you're just talking about rock + electronics then there's been plenty to do that before bothThere's a big difference between the type of electronic stuff happening pre warp shit and post warp shit
>>132188213Kid A is a great album but it's not a particularly interesting electronic album. In comparison to the work of the great IDM artists, it's sound is pretty basic and at times sounds amateur. I would actually say that Hail to the Thief and Amnesiac are more interesting in their use of the IDM inspired sound than Kid A.But Radiohead perfected their sound with In Rainbows and Thom made actually made an actually very good IDM record with Anima
>>132208015ISRAELI COPE.
>>132204044Why does the cover of this album look like a METAL album, but the contents are indie pop?
>>132211244idek what that means bro lol im j talking about aphex twin