The punk movement was successful, and it's no longer relevant.What the first wave of punks were really rebelling against was a short-lived problem, that from the late 60s to the mid 70s (maybe an 8 year stretch) it was hard for non-major acts to perform. After woodstock people realized they could make a lot of money off bands like Led Zeppelin and Pink Floyd, who wouldn't sing about very relatable things.Punk bands like the Ramones, the Sex Pistols, The Dictators, Richard Hell, etc. played simple, fun, down to earth music, which set the stage for alternative and new wave bands to find success without being bloated rockstars. Bands like Crass, MDC, and Fugazi wanted punk to make a broader social impact. They had minor successes - Fugazi inspired more people to be DIY, Crass helped the animal rights movement in the UK, but all that was secondary to the original purpose, which was just to solve an industry problem that no longer exists in the same way.Now industry plants like Die Spitz define modern punk, so it's no longer relevant. Even bands with their roots in hardcore are making pop albums, like Turnstile and Knocked Loose.
>>132202599yts are loser cucks
Supporting Trump is the most punk thing you can do in 2026 and Im tired of pretending otherwise.
>>132202599punk today is a space of self-marginalization. punks and their friends stay off in the corner, making redundant music that means little to anybody. at best, it's a fun hang at a show here or there.
>>132202677I basically agree. I think there were a lot of great punk bands in the past, especially in genres like post-punk and crust, but at this point anything that would've been interesting or experimental punk in the past is now considered either metal (like crust, which always crosses over with sludge and black metal now) or indie (like post-punk), so what's left is just these boring generic punk bands.
>>132202599thats stupid. bloated rock star music is the most utterly relatable music there is. its just fucking songs about beer and girls.
>>132202674fuck off double dick stroker pussy neck diaper wearing "Putin is my friend" pedo rapist cant fix a fucking pool mother fucker
>>132202741Not true. If you've ever listened to Zeppelin, a lot of it's about vikings and Lord of the Rings, and the love songs are mostly old blues tropes that don't speak to the modern condition. If you've ever listened to Pink Floyd, the lyrics are about life in the most abstract, broad way possible. I think those bands are both incredible, I love those bands, but it's a lot different from the Ramones singing about taking girls to burger king and doing heroin.
>fuck off double dick stroker pussy neck diaper wearing "Putin is my friend" pedo rapist cant fix a fucking pool mother fucker
>>132202761>a lot of itkek bro thats 1 band and just two damn songs, one of which (ramble on) is based on old ass blue lyrics (ie "rambling on") and on a book that had been turned into a goddamn british radio show, won an award, and had been printed as a mass market paperback.nobody's fault but mine may have started as a blues tune about the bible, but by the time zepplin did it, it may as well have been about heroin. bonham died from drinking for christ sakes. while some good punk is about stupid shit like watching tv, dunno, ops thesis is just an excuse for dumb cunts like this >>132202674 to post.Floyd? Gravy train jumpers is the modern condition, the eternal condition. Look at Trump's whitehouse. the wall may as well be about McDonalds and its definitely about drugs. QED op sux balls.
>>132202887no, you suck balls. Those were called examples, you illiterate moron.
>>132202906yes, and i demolished them by demonmstrating how they contradict your thesis.suck on.
>>132202674Taking it up the ass is the most punk thing you can do in 2026 and Im tired of pretending otherwise.
>>132202599>The punk movement was successfulindeed, its objective was selling clothes and they did
Punk rock is gay and lame.
>>132202599There is always a certain portion of the catalog of mu dedicated to some threads or others with an axe to grind against punk rockholy fuck stfu punk was punk, punk is punk, punk will always be punk
>>132203066Many prominent punks are conservative if you knew anything about the genre and weren’t a tourist you’d know your faggy Fantano quote is 100% bullshit
>>132203232true but all the punks that got promoted by the media and critics were the left-leaning ones
>>132203266that's true for everything, not just punk
>>132202599You're correct of course. Remember, this was the environment where the Modern Lovers debut LP couldn't be released and had to be shelved for 5 years.
>>132203984bro cant even get the dates correcthttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Modern_Lovers_(album)fuck off cunt
>>132202599>Die Spitzlol, Anthrax made them seethe so hard they had to name their band after their hatred.
The influence of misfits is underrated, probably the most copied band in terms of sound in punk
>>132206616midget elvis and the ghoulies were not punk
>>132202599>Now industry plants like Die Spitz define modern punkthere's a whole world of DIY punk still happening that's much better than Die Spitz, Turnstile, Knocked Loose etc. Move to a city and go to some DIY shows. It's always gonna feel a bit like a parody of shit that happened mad long ago but good punk is still happening
punk has become the hyper authoritarian, rules obsessed entity it used to rally against.punk after the age of 25 is lame.punk was 1975-1980.to be punk in the 21st century is lamer. subcultures like punk have been absorbed into capitalism and sold back to people as a uniform. punk was nihilistic and transgressive, in the modern day the left is allied with capital, capital has absorbed all sub cultures and sold it back to people, capital celebrates diversity and lgbt and womens rights. The left is no longer a threat to capital. Not that the right is any better, they just want to return to an older form of liberal capitalism, this is impossible.